stuffr-core 0.9.0

//! Format detection and pipeline resolution.
//!
//! Streams have no filename, so extensions are a hint and never the decision.
//!
//! [`resolve_chain`] is the single-layer resolution: outer format only, with
//! the inner layer decided from the path's remaining extensions when one is
//! given ([`inner_from_path`]) and [`Chain::Raw`] otherwise. [`resolve_chain_deep`]
//! closes that gap: whenever the outer layer is a codec and the inner layer
//! is still [`Chain::Raw`] — no path at all (stdin), or a path whose
//! extensions ran out — it decodes that layer, peeks [`PROBE_LEN`] of the
//! *decoded* bytes, and resolves again — recursively, bounded by
//! [`MAX_CHAIN_DEPTH`] on both routes, so that neither a piped stream nor a
//! misleadingly-named file can turn re-probing a decoded stream into an
//! unbounded decompression-nesting attack. Either way the source it returns
//! is already decoded through every codec layer named in the resolved
//! `Chain`, so a caller never has to guess which route produced it.

use std::path::Path;

use crate::archive::DecodeOpts;
use crate::error::{Error, Result};
use crate::format::{FormatId, FormatKind};
use crate::registry::Registry;
use crate::source::{DecodeSideSource, PeekSource, Source};

/// The detection window, per the spec.
pub const PROBE_LEN: usize = 4096;

/// Maximum layers when re-probing a decoded stream.
///
/// Four, chosen against real shapes: `.tar.gz` is depth 2 and `.tar.gz.gz` at
/// depth 3 is already pathological, so this leaves headroom without admitting
/// a decompression-nesting bomb. `Chain` is recursive, so the bound lives at
/// the resolution site rather than in the type.
pub const MAX_CHAIN_DEPTH: usize = 4;

/// Reads a bounded prefix without consuming it.
///
/// A seekable source is rewound; a pipe is wrapped in a [`PeekSource`] that
/// replays the prefix. Either way the caller still sees byte zero.
pub fn probe(mut src: Box<dyn Source>) -> Result<(Vec<u8>, Box<dyn Source>)> {
    if src.caps().seekable {
        let mut prefix = vec![0u8; PROBE_LEN];
        // `caps().seekable` is the `Source`'s own claim; `as_seek()` is a
        // second, independent method on the same trait, and `Source` is
        // public — a third-party codec (Phase 2+) can implement one without
        // honouring the other. Trusting the claim with `.expect(..)` turned a
        // buggy-but-foreign `Source` impl into a panic reachable through this
        // crate's own public `probe`; surfacing it as a typed error instead
        // lets a caller match on it same as any other seek failure. There is
        // no format to name yet at this stage of detection, so the sentinel
        // id below is a placeholder, not a registered format.
        let Some(seek) = src.as_seek() else {
            return Err(Error::NotSeekable {
                format: FormatId::new("<probe>"),
            });
        };
        let mut filled = 0;
        while filled < PROBE_LEN {
            match std::io::Read::read(seek, &mut prefix[filled..])? {
                0 => break,
                n => filled += n,
            }
        }
        prefix.truncate(filled);
        std::io::Seek::seek(seek, std::io::SeekFrom::Start(0))?;
        return Ok((prefix, src));
    }

    let peek = PeekSource::fill(src, PROBE_LEN)?;
    let prefix = peek.prefix().to_vec();
    Ok((prefix, Box::new(peek)))
}

/// A resolved decode pipeline.
#[non_exhaustive]
#[derive(Clone, PartialEq, Eq, Debug)]
pub enum Chain {
    /// A codec wrapping something else. Decode order: this codec, then `inner`.
    Codec { codec: FormatId, inner: Box<Chain> },
    /// A container of entries.
    Container { container: FormatId },
    /// Opaque bytes. The terminal case for a bare compressed file.
    Raw,
}

impl Chain {
    /// The container this chain resolves to, if any, at ANY depth.
    ///
    /// `Some(tar)` for `tar over gzip` as well as for a bare `tar`: however
    /// many codec layers sit above it, the entries live in a container, and a
    /// caller that has not OPENED that container cannot speak for its
    /// fidelity. That is the whole use — `ops::inspect` identifies a stream
    /// WITHOUT decoding it, so it never opens the container and must not
    /// report a fidelity conclusion it did not reach. See
    /// `ops::Inspection::fidelity_evaluated`.
    ///
    /// The `_` arm covers [`Chain::Raw`] and anything added later: `Chain` is
    /// `#[non_exhaustive]`, and "no container" is the right answer for a
    /// shape this method does not recognise, since the caller's only use of
    /// `Some` is to withhold a claim.
    pub fn container(&self) -> Option<FormatId> {
        match self {
            Chain::Container { container } => Some(*container),
            Chain::Codec { inner, .. } => inner.container(),
            _ => None,
        }
    }

    /// The outermost codec, if any — the layer a writer must create FIRST,
    /// because the container writes into it.
    ///
    /// Deliberately only the outermost, and deliberately NOT recursive the
    /// way [`Chain::container`] is: a write-side chain is at most one codec
    /// deep. `MAX_CHAIN_DEPTH` bounds the READ side, where deeper nesting is
    /// a hostile-input concern rather than a shape stuffr emits, and a
    /// recursive answer here would let a caller silently write only the
    /// innermost of several codecs.
    pub fn outermost_codec(&self) -> Option<FormatId> {
        match self {
            Chain::Codec { codec, .. } => Some(*codec),
            _ => None,
        }
    }

    /// Human-readable form, innermost first: `"tar over gzip"`.
    pub fn describe(&self) -> String {
        match self {
            Chain::Raw => "raw".to_string(),
            Chain::Container { container } => container.to_string(),
            Chain::Codec { codec, inner } => match inner.as_ref() {
                Chain::Raw => codec.to_string(),
                other => format!("{} over {}", other.describe(), codec),
            },
        }
    }
}

fn hex_prefix(bytes: &[u8]) -> String {
    if bytes.is_empty() {
        return "empty input".to_string();
    }
    bytes
        .iter()
        .take(8)
        .map(|b| format!("{b:02x}"))
        .collect::<Vec<_>>()
        .join(" ")
}

/// Lowercase extension components of a path, outermost last.
/// `"out.tar.gz"` → `["tar", "gz"]`.
fn extensions(path: &Path) -> Vec<String> {
    let name = path
        .file_name()
        .and_then(|s| s.to_str())
        .unwrap_or_default();
    name.split('.')
        .skip(1)
        .map(|s| s.to_ascii_lowercase())
        .collect()
}

/// Resolves the inner layer beneath an outer codec, using the path's remaining
/// extensions. `.tar.gz` → tar; `.tgz` → tar; `.gz` or no path → Raw.
fn inner_from_path(reg: &Registry, path: Option<&Path>, outer: FormatId) -> Chain {
    let Some(path) = path else {
        return Chain::Raw;
    };
    let exts = extensions(path);

    // `.tgz` and friends: one extension meaning "tar inside <codec>", spelled
    // as "t" + the codec's own extension. Resolved through the SAME
    // [`compound_alias`] the write side uses, never a second copy of the strip
    // rule — the copy is how `.tbz` came to mean tar-over-bzip2 when reading
    // and a bare gzip when writing, which is the exact defect class
    // `chain_for_new_path` shares this function to prevent.
    if let Some(last) = exts.last()
        && compound_alias(reg, last) == Some(outer)
        && let Some(id) = reg.by_extension("tar")
        && reg.container(id).is_some()
    {
        return Chain::Container { container: id };
    }

    // Otherwise look one extension inwards.
    if exts.len() >= 2
        && let Some(id) = reg.by_extension(&exts[exts.len() - 2])
        && reg.container(id).is_some()
    {
        return Chain::Container { container: id };
    }
    Chain::Raw
}

/// The codec a `.tgz`-style compound extension names — "t" + the codec's own
/// extension, meaning "tar inside <codec>".
///
/// Needed only on the write side. The read side takes the outer codec from
/// the magic bytes and never has to parse `tgz` at all; a file being created
/// has no magic, so the name is the only evidence there is. No codec
/// registers its own compound alias and none should — `tar::meta` spells out
/// why registering `tgz` on tar would make a `.tgz` resolve to a bare tar —
/// so the suffix is stripped here instead, and `inner_from_path` calls this
/// same function when deciding what is inside.
///
/// # `.tlz` means tar-over-**lzip** here, and that is a decision
///
/// The strip rule sends `.tlz` to `lz`, which lzip registers, so stuffr reads
/// and writes `.tlz` as `tar.lz` — lzip. **GNU tar and libarchive both read
/// `.tlz` as `tar.lzma`** (LZMA1, the `.lzma` alone-format), so an archive
/// stuffr writes as `.tlz` will not open in GNU tar, and one GNU tar wrote
/// will not open here.
///
/// It is left as it is, deliberately and for now: `lzip` is the format
/// actually worth writing of the two (it carries a CRC and a recognised
/// magic, where `.lzma` has neither), the spelling is genuinely contested
/// rather than settled — `.tlz` predates lzip and both readings are in the
/// wild — and changing it would silently reinterpret existing files. What is
/// NOT acceptable is that the answer was an accident of which extension
/// happened to be registered; it is written down here so the next change to
/// it is a decision rather than a side effect. If it is ever revisited, the
/// honest options are to refuse `.tlz` outright as ambiguous, or to add it to
/// [`COMPOUND_SPELLINGS`] pointing at `lzma`.
fn compound_alias(reg: &Registry, ext: &str) -> Option<FormatId> {
    let stripped = ext.strip_prefix(['t', 'T'])?;
    if stripped.is_empty() {
        return None;
    }
    let stripped = stripped.to_ascii_lowercase();
    let spelling = COMPOUND_SPELLINGS
        .iter()
        .find(|(alias, _)| *alias == stripped)
        .map_or(stripped.as_str(), |(_, real)| *real);
    let id = reg.by_extension(spelling)?;
    // A container never sits inside itself: `.tar` is resolved by the direct
    // lookup above, and anything reached through the alias must be a codec.
    reg.container(id).is_none().then_some(id)
}

/// The compound spellings whose remainder after the `t` is NOT the codec's
/// own registered extension, and what it really means.
///
/// Without this table the strip rule simply fails to find a codec and the
/// whole name resolves to [`Chain::Raw`] — which on the write side is not a
/// refusal but a silent fallback to `default_format()`, so **`stuffr pack
/// notes.txt -o f.tbz` wrote a gzip stream, with no tar inside it, at exit
/// 0.** A name promising one thing and bytes that are another, reported as
/// success, is the defect class the write-side chain resolution exists to
/// close, and `.tbz` was its last surviving member.
///
/// The table lives here rather than in the registry ON PURPOSE. Registering
/// `bz` as an extension of bzip2 would fix `.tbz` and simultaneously make a
/// plain `.bz` writable — and `.bz` is **bzip1**, a different, obsolete
/// format this build cannot produce. The alias is only ever consulted in the
/// `t`-prefixed compound position, so `stuffr pack notes.txt -o f.bz` still
/// finds no format for `bz` and behaves exactly as it did.
///
/// GNU tar and libarchive both read `.tbz` as `tar.bz2`; `.tbz2` needs no
/// entry, because stripping its `t` already yields bzip2's registered `bz2`.
const COMPOUND_SPELLINGS: &[(&str, &str)] = &[("bz", "bz2")];

/// The chain an OUTPUT path names, from its extensions alone.
///
/// The write-side twin of [`resolve_chain`], which cannot serve here: that one
/// sniffs magic bytes, and a file about to be created has none. Shares
/// `inner_from_path` with the read side deliberately — a second, write-side
/// extension table would drift, and `.tar.gz` resolving one way for reading
/// and another for writing is the whole class of bug this exists to prevent.
///
/// Never fails: an unknown or absent extension is [`Chain::Raw`], which every
/// caller already has to handle.
pub fn chain_for_new_path(reg: &Registry, path: &Path) -> Chain {
    let Some(ext) = path.extension().and_then(|e| e.to_str()) else {
        return Chain::Raw;
    };
    let Some(outer) = reg.by_extension(ext).or_else(|| compound_alias(reg, ext)) else {
        return Chain::Raw;
    };
    // `x.tar` — a container with nothing above it.
    if reg.container(outer).is_some() {
        return Chain::Container { container: outer };
    }
    // `outer` is a codec. `x.tar.gz` and `x.tgz` both name a container inside
    // it; `x.gz` names nothing, and resolves to a bare codec over Raw.
    let inner = inner_from_path(reg, Some(path), outer);
    Chain::Codec {
        codec: outer,
        inner: Box::new(inner),
    }
}

/// Turns a path and/or a probed prefix into a concrete pipeline.
///
/// The extension is consulted first, against the full magic-hit set; priority
/// decides only when the path is silent or names a format whose magic did not
/// match. Failure names the bytes actually seen so a misdetection is
/// debuggable without library prints.
pub fn resolve_chain(reg: &Registry, path: Option<&Path>, prefix: &[u8]) -> Result<Chain> {
    let mut candidates = reg.match_magic(prefix);

    if candidates.len() > 1 {
        // The extension is consulted FIRST, and against every magic hit — a
        // path saying `.apk` must reach apk even though zip outranks it. That
        // is the spec's own worked example, and ranking cannot be allowed to
        // pre-empt an explicit filename. Priority decides only when the path
        // is silent, or names a format whose magic never matched.
        let by_ext =
            path.and_then(|p| extensions(p).iter().rev().find_map(|e| reg.by_extension(e)));
        match by_ext.filter(|id| candidates.contains(id)) {
            Some(id) => candidates = vec![id],
            None => {
                let top = reg.priority_of(candidates[0]);
                let tied: Vec<FormatId> = candidates
                    .iter()
                    .copied()
                    .filter(|id| reg.priority_of(*id) == top)
                    .collect();
                if tied.len() == 1 {
                    candidates = tied;
                } else {
                    let names: Vec<&str> = tied.iter().map(|id| id.as_str()).collect();
                    return Err(Error::AmbiguousFormat {
                        candidates: names.join(", "),
                    });
                }
            }
        }
    }

    let outer = candidates.first().copied().or_else(|| {
        path.and_then(|p| extensions(p).iter().rev().find_map(|e| reg.by_extension(e)))
    });

    let Some(outer) = outer else {
        return Err(Error::UnknownFormat {
            seen: hex_prefix(prefix),
        });
    };

    let kind = if reg.container(outer).is_some() {
        FormatKind::Container
    } else if reg.codec(outer).is_some() {
        FormatKind::Codec
    } else {
        return Err(Error::FormatNotEnabled(outer));
    };

    Ok(match kind {
        FormatKind::Container => Chain::Container { container: outer },
        FormatKind::Codec => Chain::Codec {
            codec: outer,
            inner: Box::new(inner_from_path(reg, path, outer)),
        },
    })
}

/// Builds `innermost` back up under each codec in `layers`, outermost last so
/// the final fold produces the correct nesting order.
fn wrap_layers(layers: &[FormatId], innermost: Chain) -> Chain {
    layers
        .iter()
        .rev()
        .fold(innermost, |inner, codec| Chain::Codec {
            codec: *codec,
            inner: Box::new(inner),
        })
}

/// Decodes `src` through every [`Chain::Codec`] layer named in `chain`,
/// outermost first, so the returned source is positioned exactly where
/// `chain`'s innermost entry (a [`Chain::Container`] or [`Chain::Raw`])
/// begins. A chain with no codec layers at all (a bare container) hands
/// `src` back untouched.
/// Builds one codec layer's decoder and marks its output as decode-side.
///
/// The ONE place in this crate that turns a [`Source`] into a decoded one, so
/// it is also the one place that has to remember the marking — see
/// [`crate::source::decode_side`] for why the marking exists at all, and for
/// the four downstream `?`s it retroactively makes correct.
///
/// Two things happen here, and they cover the two moments a codec can fail:
///
/// * **Construction.** A codec that validates its header eagerly can fail
///   inside `decoder()` itself, reading the source that is about to become
///   decode-side but is not yet wrapped. That error is folded through
///   [`Error::from_decode_io`] here. No registered codec takes this branch
///   today (`CLAUDE.md`'s Phase 3c backlog records the same gap against
///   `conformance.rs:393`), which is exactly why it is worth closing before
///   one does: an unreached branch that is wrong by default is how this class
///   keeps recurring.
/// * **Reading.** Every later `read` is marked by [`DecodeSideSource`].
///
/// Wrapping is idempotent, so a three-layer chain pays one tag allocation per
/// error rather than three.
fn build_decoder(
    reg: &Registry,
    codec: FormatId,
    src: Box<dyn Source>,
    opts: &DecodeOpts,
) -> Result<Box<dyn Source>> {
    let decoded = reg
        .require_codec(codec)?
        .decoder(src, opts)
        .map_err(|e| match e {
            Error::Io(io_err) => Error::from_decode_io(io_err),
            other => other,
        })?;
    Ok(DecodeSideSource::wrap(decoded))
}

fn decode_through_chain(
    reg: &Registry,
    chain: &Chain,
    src: Box<dyn Source>,
    opts: &DecodeOpts,
) -> Result<Box<dyn Source>> {
    match chain {
        Chain::Codec { codec, inner } => {
            let decoded = build_decoder(reg, *codec, src, opts)?;
            decode_through_chain(reg, inner, decoded, opts)
        }
        Chain::Container { .. } | Chain::Raw => Ok(src),
    }
}

/// [`resolve_chain`], but when the outer layer is a codec whose inner the
/// path left as [`Chain::Raw`] — whether because there was no path at all,
/// or because the path's own extensions ran out before naming a container —
/// keeps going: decodes that layer, peeks [`PROBE_LEN`] of the *decoded*
/// bytes, and resolves again from the decoded bytes' own magic. Closes the
/// Phase 0 limitation where a codec on stdin always bottomed out at Raw
/// purely for lack of an extension.
///
/// The path still gets first say: `resolve_chain` runs once with it, and if
/// that alone already resolves the full chain (a bare container, or a codec
/// whose inner the extensions named directly — `.tar.gz`), peeking never
/// happens. Peeking is what runs when the path is silent, or was not enough.
///
/// Bounded by [`MAX_CHAIN_DEPTH`] on **both** routes, because re-probing a
/// *decoded* stream is exactly what makes unbounded nesting attackable: each
/// layer is cheap to produce and expensive to expand. A path is a name, not
/// a proof — `a.gz.gz.gz.gz.gz` is refused the same way piped bytes with the
/// identical shape are, and exceeding the bound is a typed
/// [`Error::ChainTooDeep`], never a panic and never a silent stop.
///
/// Returns the resolved [`Chain`] alongside a [`Source`] **already decoded
/// through every codec layer named in that `Chain`** — positioned exactly
/// where the chain's innermost entry begins, ready to hand straight to a
/// container or to read as raw bytes. This holds on both routes: a path
/// that resolves in one step (no peeking needed) still gets its codec
/// layers decoded before the source comes back, so a caller never has to
/// ask whether the source it received happens to be raw or already decoded.
pub fn resolve_chain_deep(
    reg: &Registry,
    path: Option<&Path>,
    src: Box<dyn Source>,
) -> Result<(Chain, Box<dyn Source>)> {
    resolve_chain_deep_with(reg, path, src, &DecodeOpts::default())
}

/// [`resolve_chain_deep`], but with the [`DecodeOpts`] every codec layer's
/// decoder is built from spelled out by the caller instead of defaulted.
///
/// This exists because [`DecodeOpts::memory_limit`] is the ONLY guard that
/// can see a pure codec's pre-output dictionary allocation — the one sized
/// from a value the file declares in its own header, before a single decoded
/// byte exists. `--max-ratio` counts decoded output bytes and so cannot see
/// it at all. Resolving a chain builds a decoder per codec layer, so a
/// resolver that defaults its opts leaves every entry-aware verb (`list`,
/// `test`, `cat`, `unpack -C`) unbounded against a crafted `.tar.lz` whose
/// header declares a 512 MiB dictionary, while the single-stream path
/// refuses the same bytes at exit 6.
///
/// `resolve_chain_deep` remains as the "library default" spelling —
/// unbounded, matching `DecodeOpts::default()` everywhere else — but no CLI
/// path should use it: the CLI always has a resolved limit to pass.
pub fn resolve_chain_deep_with(
    reg: &Registry,
    path: Option<&Path>,
    src: Box<dyn Source>,
    opts: &DecodeOpts,
) -> Result<(Chain, Box<dyn Source>)> {
    let (prefix, src) = probe(src)?;
    let chain = resolve_chain(reg, path, &prefix)?;

    // Either a bare container, or a codec whose inner the path already named
    // (e.g. `.tar.gz`) — the path (if any) is done contributing. Decode
    // through whatever codec layers `chain` names and stop; there is nothing
    // left to peek.
    if !matches!(&chain, Chain::Codec { inner, .. } if matches!(inner.as_ref(), Chain::Raw)) {
        let decoded = decode_through_chain(reg, &chain, src, opts)?;
        return Ok((chain, decoded));
    }

    // The chain bottoms out at Raw. From here, only the decoded bytes' own
    // magic decides — the path, if there was one, already had its say above
    // and found nothing further.
    let Chain::Codec { codec, .. } = chain else {
        unreachable!("guarded above: chain is Chain::Codec with a Raw inner")
    };
    let mut layers: Vec<FormatId> = vec![codec];
    let mut current_codec = codec;
    let mut src = src;
    let mut depth = 1usize;

    loop {
        if depth >= MAX_CHAIN_DEPTH {
            return Err(Error::ChainTooDeep {
                depth: MAX_CHAIN_DEPTH,
            });
        }

        let decoded = build_decoder(reg, current_codec, src, opts)?;
        // This `probe` reads through a DECODER — unlike the one at the top
        // of this function, and unlike `resolve_chain_deep_with`'s own
        // `probe(src)` two calls up, both of which read the RAW,
        // undecoded source. An `io::Error` here means the bytes this codec
        // just produced are malformed, not that the raw source or the
        // environment failed, so it is reclassified via
        // `Error::from_decode_io` exactly like every other decoder-side
        // read in this crate (`ops.rs`, `entries.rs`, `conformance.rs`).
        //
        // Left as a bare `?` (as it was until Task 4b), a truncated `.zz`
        // or an empty `.lz` — a codec stream with no container above it, so
        // resolution bottoms out in this very loop re-probing the decoded
        // bytes — surfaced as `Error::Io`: exit 1, "stuffr failed", for
        // input that is simply corrupt. `ops::decompress` decodes the
        // identical bytes through a call already wired to
        // `Error::from_decode_io`, so `cat` and `list` disagreed on the
        // exit code for the same input; see `error.rs`'s doc comment on
        // `from_decode_io` for the convention this leans on, and
        // `Error::exit_code`'s comment for this wildcard's history.
        //
        // Do NOT widen this to `probe(src)` above (raw source) or to
        // `probe`/`PeekSource::fill` themselves — either would reclassify a
        // genuine i/o failure on the raw source (a real disk error, a
        // permission failure, a broken pipe) as `Corrupt`, which is a new
        // lie in the opposite direction.
        //
        // As of the decode-side marker (see `crate::source::decode_side`),
        // `build_decoder` has already tagged this source, so `probe`'s own
        // internal `?` would classify it anyway and this `map_err` sees an
        // `Error::Corrupt` and passes it through. Kept rather than deleted:
        // it is the site Task 4b's regression tests name, and a belt that
        // does not depend on the marker being applied one call up.
        let (next_prefix, next_src) = probe(decoded).map_err(|e| match e {
            Error::Io(io_err) => Error::from_decode_io(io_err),
            other => other,
        })?;
        depth += 1;

        let next_chain = match resolve_chain(reg, None, &next_prefix) {
            Ok(chain) => chain,
            Err(Error::UnknownFormat { .. }) => {
                return Ok((wrap_layers(&layers, Chain::Raw), next_src));
            }
            Err(e) => return Err(e),
        };

        let Chain::Codec { codec: nested, .. } = next_chain else {
            return Ok((wrap_layers(&layers, next_chain), next_src));
        };

        layers.push(nested);
        current_codec = nested;
        src = next_src;
    }
}

#[cfg(test)]
mod tests {
    use super::*;
    use crate::archive::{Codec, DecodeOpts, EncodeOpts, Sink};
    use crate::format::{CodecCaps, FormatId, FormatMeta, MagicRule};
    use crate::registry::Registry;
    use crate::source::{ReaderSource, Source, StreamOnly};
    use crate::testing::{
        MOCK_CODEC, MOCK_CONTAINER, MockCodec, MockContainer, SharedBuf, mock_archive_bytes,
    };
    use std::io;
    use std::io::{Read, Write};
    use std::path::Path;
    use std::sync::Arc;

    const GZIP: FormatId = FormatId::new("gzip");
    const TAR: FormatId = FormatId::new("tar");

    const GZIP_MAGIC: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
        offset: 0,
        bytes: &[0x1f, 0x8b],
        format: GZIP,
    }];
    const TAR_MAGIC: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
        offset: 257,
        bytes: b"ustar",
        format: TAR,
    }];

    fn registry() -> Registry {
        let mut r = Registry::new();
        r.register_codec(
            Arc::new(MockCodec),
            FormatMeta::codec(GZIP, &["gz", "tgz"], GZIP_MAGIC),
        );
        r.register_container(
            Arc::new(MockContainer),
            FormatMeta::container(TAR, &["tar"], TAR_MAGIC),
        );
        r
    }

    /// `registry()` above registers the mock codec under BOTH `gz` and `tgz`,
    /// and the mock container under `tar` — exactly the shape the compound
    /// alias needs, so no new fixture is required here.
    #[test]
    fn an_output_path_resolves_to_the_chain_its_name_promises() {
        let reg = registry();
        let c = |p: &str| chain_for_new_path(&reg, Path::new(p)).describe();
        assert_eq!(c("x.tar"), "tar");
        assert_eq!(c("x.gz"), "gzip");
        assert_eq!(c("x.tar.gz"), "tar over gzip");
        assert_eq!(
            c("x.tgz"),
            "tar over gzip",
            "the compound alias must resolve too"
        );
        assert_eq!(c("x.TAR.GZ"), "tar over gzip", "extensions are caseless");
        assert_eq!(c("x.txt"), "raw");
        assert_eq!(c("x"), "raw");
    }

    /// Finding 4 of the Phase 2c final review. `bzip2` registers `bz2` and
    /// nothing else, so stripping `.tbz`'s `t` looked up `bz`, found no
    /// format, and resolved the whole name to [`Chain::Raw`] — which on the
    /// write side is not a refusal but a silent fall back to the default
    /// codec, so `-o f.tbz` wrote a gzip with no tar inside it at exit 0.
    ///
    /// The registry is deliberately the one place NOT fixed: `.bz` is bzip1.
    #[test]
    fn tbz_means_tar_over_bzip2_without_making_plain_bz_writable() {
        const BZIP2: FormatId = FormatId::new("bzip2");
        const BZIP2_MAGIC: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
            offset: 0,
            bytes: b"BZh",
            format: BZIP2,
        }];
        let mut reg = Registry::new();
        // `bz2` ONLY — the real bzip2 codec's whole extension list.
        reg.register_codec(
            Arc::new(MockCodec),
            FormatMeta::codec(BZIP2, &["bz2"], BZIP2_MAGIC),
        );
        reg.register_container(
            Arc::new(MockContainer),
            FormatMeta::container(TAR, &["tar"], TAR_MAGIC),
        );

        let c = |p: &str| chain_for_new_path(&reg, Path::new(p)).describe();
        assert_eq!(
            c("f.tbz"),
            "tar over bzip2",
            "GNU tar and libarchive both read .tbz as tar.bz2"
        );
        assert_eq!(c("f.TBZ"), "tar over bzip2", "and extensions are caseless");
        assert_eq!(
            c("f.tbz2"),
            "tar over bzip2",
            "the spelling that always worked must keep working"
        );
        assert_eq!(
            c("f.tar.bz2"),
            "tar over bzip2",
            "and so must the long form"
        );

        // The half that says WHERE the fix lives. `bz` is bzip1, a different
        // and obsolete format: registering it on bzip2 would have fixed
        // `.tbz` and simultaneously made `-o f.bz` write a bzip2 stream under
        // a name that promises bzip1.
        assert_eq!(
            c("f.bz"),
            "raw",
            "`bz` must resolve to nothing outside the t-prefixed compound form"
        );

        // The READ side resolves the same name through the same function —
        // that sharing is the point, and a second write-side table is what
        // would let `.tbz` mean one thing to `pack` and another to `list`.
        let chain = resolve_chain(&reg, Some(Path::new("f.tbz")), b"BZh\0").unwrap();
        assert_eq!(
            chain.describe(),
            "tar over bzip2",
            "reading a .tbz must agree with writing one"
        );
    }

    /// The pair a writer actually consumes: the container to create, and the
    /// codec to create FIRST because the container writes into it.
    #[test]
    fn the_outermost_codec_is_the_layer_a_writer_creates_first() {
        let reg = registry();
        let pair = |p: &str| {
            let c = chain_for_new_path(&reg, Path::new(p));
            (c.container(), c.outermost_codec())
        };
        assert_eq!(pair("x.tar"), (Some(TAR), None));
        assert_eq!(pair("x.gz"), (None, Some(GZIP)));
        assert_eq!(pair("x.tar.gz"), (Some(TAR), Some(GZIP)));
        assert_eq!(pair("x.tgz"), (Some(TAR), Some(GZIP)));
        assert_eq!(pair("x.txt"), (None, None));
    }

    #[test]
    fn probe_does_not_consume_the_stream() {
        let src: Box<dyn Source> = Box::new(ReaderSource::new(std::io::Cursor::new(
            b"HEADERbody".to_vec(),
        )));
        let (prefix, mut rest) = probe(src).unwrap();
        assert_eq!(&prefix[..6], b"HEADER");

        let mut all = Vec::new();
        rest.read_to_end(&mut all).unwrap();
        assert_eq!(all, b"HEADERbody", "the consumer must still see byte zero");
    }

    #[test]
    fn probe_reads_at_most_the_window() {
        let big = vec![b'x'; PROBE_LEN * 3];
        let src: Box<dyn Source> = Box::new(ReaderSource::new(std::io::Cursor::new(big)));
        let (prefix, _) = probe(src).unwrap();
        assert_eq!(prefix.len(), PROBE_LEN);
    }

    #[test]
    fn magic_identifies_a_bare_codec_stream() {
        let r = registry();
        let chain = resolve_chain(&r, Some(Path::new("blob.gz")), &[0x1f, 0x8b, 0x08]).unwrap();
        assert_eq!(
            chain,
            Chain::Codec {
                codec: GZIP,
                inner: Box::new(Chain::Raw)
            }
        );
        assert_eq!(chain.describe(), "gzip");
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_double_extension_nests_the_container_inside_the_codec() {
        let r = registry();
        let chain = resolve_chain(&r, Some(Path::new("out.tar.gz")), &[0x1f, 0x8b, 0x08]).unwrap();
        assert_eq!(
            chain,
            Chain::Codec {
                codec: GZIP,
                inner: Box::new(Chain::Container { container: TAR })
            }
        );
        assert_eq!(chain.describe(), "tar over gzip");
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_codec_on_stdin_resolves_to_raw_inner() {
        // No path means no extension hint. Phase 2 refines this by peeking
        // after the first decoded block; until then Raw is the honest answer.
        let r = registry();
        let chain = resolve_chain(&r, None, &[0x1f, 0x8b, 0x08]).unwrap();
        assert_eq!(
            chain,
            Chain::Codec {
                codec: GZIP,
                inner: Box::new(Chain::Raw)
            }
        );
    }

    #[test]
    fn container_magic_resolves_directly() {
        let r = registry();
        let mut prefix = vec![0u8; 512];
        prefix[257..262].copy_from_slice(b"ustar");
        let chain = resolve_chain(&r, Some(Path::new("x.tar")), &prefix).unwrap();
        assert_eq!(chain, Chain::Container { container: TAR });
        assert_eq!(chain.describe(), "tar");
    }

    #[test]
    fn extension_is_the_fallback_when_magic_says_nothing() {
        let r = registry();
        let chain = resolve_chain(&r, Some(Path::new("mystery.tar")), b"no magic here").unwrap();
        assert_eq!(chain, Chain::Container { container: TAR });
    }

    /// `Chain::container` must see THROUGH codec layers, not only name a
    /// bare container. `ops::inspect` uses it to decide whether it may report
    /// a fidelity conclusion, and `backup.tar.gz` has a container it has not
    /// opened just as surely as `backup.tar` does — a non-recursive version
    /// would quietly re-introduce the false negative for every `.tar.gz`.
    #[test]
    fn chain_container_sees_through_codec_layers() {
        let tar = FormatId::new("tar");
        assert_eq!(Chain::Container { container: tar }.container(), Some(tar));
        assert_eq!(
            Chain::Codec {
                codec: GZIP,
                inner: Box::new(Chain::Container { container: tar }),
            }
            .container(),
            Some(tar),
            "tar over gzip still has a container nobody has opened"
        );
        assert_eq!(
            Chain::Codec {
                codec: GZIP,
                inner: Box::new(Chain::Raw),
            }
            .container(),
            None,
            "a bare codec stream has no container, so an empty warning list is a real finding"
        );
        assert_eq!(Chain::Raw.container(), None);
    }

    #[test]
    fn tgz_single_extension_still_nests_tar_inside_gzip() {
        let r = registry();
        let chain = resolve_chain(&r, Some(Path::new("a.tgz")), &[0x1f, 0x8b]).unwrap();
        assert_eq!(
            chain,
            Chain::Codec {
                codec: GZIP,
                inner: Box::new(Chain::Container { container: TAR })
            }
        );
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_compound_extension_resolves_without_a_registered_compound_alias() {
        // `.tgz` means "t" + gzip's own extension. Resolving it must not depend
        // on gzip having separately registered "tgz" itself: a codec that
        // forgets that alias would otherwise silently yield Raw instead of
        // tar-over-<codec>, with no error raised.
        let mut r = Registry::new();
        r.register_codec(
            Arc::new(MockCodec),
            FormatMeta::codec(GZIP, &["gz"], GZIP_MAGIC), // deliberately NO "tgz" alias
        );
        r.register_container(
            Arc::new(MockContainer),
            FormatMeta::container(TAR, &["tar"], TAR_MAGIC),
        );

        let chain = resolve_chain(&r, Some(Path::new("a.tgz")), &[0x1f, 0x8b]).unwrap();
        assert_eq!(
            chain,
            Chain::Codec {
                codec: GZIP,
                inner: Box::new(Chain::Container { container: TAR })
            }
        );
    }

    #[test]
    fn probe_does_not_consume_a_seekable_stream_either() {
        // Non-consumption has two implementations — rewind for a seekable
        // source, replay for a pipe. Only the pipe path was covered.
        let mut f = tempfile::NamedTempFile::new().unwrap();
        std::io::Write::write_all(&mut f, b"HEADERbody").unwrap();
        let (_, path) = f.keep().unwrap();
        let src: Box<dyn Source> = Box::new(crate::source::FileSource::open(&path).unwrap());

        let (prefix, mut rest) = probe(src).unwrap();
        assert_eq!(&prefix[..6], b"HEADER");

        let mut all = Vec::new();
        rest.read_to_end(&mut all).unwrap();
        assert_eq!(
            all, b"HEADERbody",
            "a seekable source must be rewound to byte zero"
        );
    }

    #[test]
    fn probe_bounds_the_window_on_a_seekable_stream_too() {
        let big = vec![b'x'; PROBE_LEN * 3];
        let mut f = tempfile::NamedTempFile::new().unwrap();
        std::io::Write::write_all(&mut f, &big).unwrap();
        let (_, path) = f.keep().unwrap();
        let src: Box<dyn Source> = Box::new(crate::source::FileSource::open(&path).unwrap());

        let (prefix, _) = probe(src).unwrap();
        assert_eq!(prefix.len(), PROBE_LEN);
    }

    #[test]
    fn unknown_input_names_the_bytes_it_actually_saw() {
        // Debugging a misdetection must not require adding prints to the library.
        let r = registry();
        let err = resolve_chain(&r, None, &[0xde, 0xad, 0xbe, 0xef]).unwrap_err();
        let msg = err.to_string();
        assert!(msg.contains("de ad be ef"), "message was: {msg}");
        assert!(matches!(err, crate::Error::UnknownFormat { .. }));
    }

    #[test]
    fn unknown_empty_input_still_produces_a_usable_message() {
        let r = registry();
        let err = resolve_chain(&r, None, b"").unwrap_err();
        assert!(err.to_string().contains("empty"));
    }

    #[test]
    fn equally_ranked_candidates_with_no_extension_are_an_error_not_a_guess() {
        // A piped stream has no path to disambiguate with. Guessing silently is
        // how a zip becomes an apk.
        const A: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
            offset: 0,
            bytes: b"PK",
            format: FormatId::new("alpha"),
        }];
        const B: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
            offset: 0,
            bytes: b"PK",
            format: FormatId::new("beta"),
        }];
        let mut r = Registry::new();
        r.register_container(
            Arc::new(MockContainer),
            FormatMeta::container(FormatId::new("alpha"), &["alpha"], A),
        );
        r.register_container(
            Arc::new(MockContainer),
            FormatMeta::container(FormatId::new("beta"), &["beta"], B),
        );

        let err = resolve_chain(&r, None, b"PKrest").unwrap_err();
        assert!(matches!(err, crate::Error::AmbiguousFormat { .. }));
        let msg = err.to_string();
        assert!(
            msg.contains("alpha") && msg.contains("beta"),
            "must name the candidates: {msg}"
        );
        // Exit 2, not 1. The message says "Pass `--format` to choose" —
        // actionable advice, so this is the caller pointing stuffr at
        // something it cannot resolve alone, the same class as
        // `UnknownFormat` and `NotAnArchive`. It fell through
        // `exit_code`'s wildcard to 1 (an internal failure) until the
        // Phase 2 final review; see `error.rs`'s
        // `pointing_a_verb_at_the_wrong_file_is_always_exit_two`.
        assert_eq!(err.exit_code(), 2);
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_higher_priority_candidate_resolves_without_an_extension() {
        const A: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
            offset: 0,
            bytes: b"PK",
            format: FormatId::new("alpha"),
        }];
        const B: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
            offset: 0,
            bytes: b"PK",
            format: FormatId::new("beta"),
        }];
        let mut r = Registry::new();
        r.register_container(
            Arc::new(MockContainer),
            FormatMeta::container(FormatId::new("alpha"), &["alpha"], A).with_priority(-5),
        );
        r.register_container(
            Arc::new(MockContainer),
            FormatMeta::container(FormatId::new("beta"), &["beta"], B),
        );

        let chain = resolve_chain(&r, None, b"PKrest").unwrap();
        assert_eq!(
            chain,
            Chain::Container {
                container: FormatId::new("beta")
            }
        );
    }

    #[test]
    fn an_extension_still_disambiguates_equal_candidates() {
        const A: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
            offset: 0,
            bytes: b"PK",
            format: FormatId::new("alpha"),
        }];
        const B: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
            offset: 0,
            bytes: b"PK",
            format: FormatId::new("beta"),
        }];
        let mut r = Registry::new();
        r.register_container(
            Arc::new(MockContainer),
            FormatMeta::container(FormatId::new("alpha"), &["alpha"], A),
        );
        r.register_container(
            Arc::new(MockContainer),
            FormatMeta::container(FormatId::new("beta"), &["beta"], B),
        );

        let chain = resolve_chain(&r, Some(Path::new("x.beta")), b"PKrest").unwrap();
        assert_eq!(
            chain,
            Chain::Container {
                container: FormatId::new("beta")
            }
        );
    }

    #[test]
    fn an_extension_outside_the_tied_set_does_not_break_the_tie() {
        // A tie between two formats sharing a magic, with a path whose
        // extension names a THIRD format that does not share it. The extension
        // must not select a format whose magic never matched, and the error
        // must name the genuinely tied candidates rather than the irrelevant
        // one.
        const A: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
            offset: 0,
            bytes: b"PK",
            format: FormatId::new("alpha"),
        }];
        const B: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
            offset: 0,
            bytes: b"PK",
            format: FormatId::new("beta"),
        }];
        const C: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
            offset: 0,
            bytes: b"GZ",
            format: FormatId::new("gamma"),
        }];
        let mut r = Registry::new();
        r.register_container(
            Arc::new(MockContainer),
            FormatMeta::container(FormatId::new("alpha"), &["alpha"], A),
        );
        r.register_container(
            Arc::new(MockContainer),
            FormatMeta::container(FormatId::new("beta"), &["beta"], B),
        );
        r.register_container(
            Arc::new(MockContainer),
            FormatMeta::container(FormatId::new("gamma"), &["gamma"], C),
        );

        let err = resolve_chain(&r, Some(Path::new("x.gamma")), b"PKrest").unwrap_err();
        assert!(matches!(err, crate::Error::AmbiguousFormat { .. }));
        let msg = err.to_string();
        assert!(
            msg.contains("alpha") && msg.contains("beta"),
            "must name the tied candidates: {msg}"
        );
        assert!(
            !msg.contains("gamma"),
            "must not name the irrelevant extension: {msg}"
        );
    }

    #[test]
    fn an_extension_reaches_a_lower_priority_format_that_shares_the_magic() {
        // The spec's worked example: zip outranks apk on a bare stream, but a
        // path saying `.apk` must still reach apk. Ranking must not override an
        // explicit filename.
        const ZIP_MAGIC: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
            offset: 0,
            bytes: b"PK",
            format: FormatId::new("zip"),
        }];
        const APK_MAGIC: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
            offset: 0,
            bytes: b"PK",
            format: FormatId::new("apk"),
        }];
        let mut r = Registry::new();
        r.register_container(
            Arc::new(MockContainer),
            FormatMeta::container(FormatId::new("zip"), &["zip"], ZIP_MAGIC),
        );
        r.register_container(
            Arc::new(MockContainer),
            FormatMeta::container(FormatId::new("apk"), &["apk"], APK_MAGIC).with_priority(-5),
        );

        // With no path, the higher-priority zip wins on the bare magic hit.
        let chain = resolve_chain(&r, None, b"PKrest").unwrap();
        assert_eq!(
            chain,
            Chain::Container {
                container: FormatId::new("zip")
            }
        );

        // Same bytes, but the path names apk — the lower-ranked candidate must
        // still be reached; ranking cannot pre-empt an explicit filename.
        let chain = resolve_chain(&r, Some(Path::new("archive.apk")), b"PKrest").unwrap();
        assert_eq!(
            chain,
            Chain::Container {
                container: FormatId::new("apk")
            }
        );
    }

    /// A `Source` that lies: it claims `seekable: true` but `as_seek()`
    /// always returns `None`. Nothing in this crate can implement `Source`
    /// this way today, but the trait is public and a third-party codec could
    /// — the point of this test is that `probe` must survive that instead of
    /// panicking.
    struct LiesAboutSeekability(std::io::Cursor<Vec<u8>>);

    impl Read for LiesAboutSeekability {
        fn read(&mut self, buf: &mut [u8]) -> std::io::Result<usize> {
            std::io::Read::read(&mut self.0, buf)
        }
    }

    impl Source for LiesAboutSeekability {
        fn caps(&self) -> crate::source::SourceCaps {
            crate::source::SourceCaps {
                seekable: true,
                len: Some(self.0.get_ref().len() as u64),
            }
        }

        fn as_seek(&mut self) -> Option<&mut dyn crate::source::SeekRead> {
            None
        }
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_source_that_claims_seekable_but_has_no_seek_view_errors_instead_of_panicking() {
        let src: Box<dyn Source> = Box::new(LiesAboutSeekability(std::io::Cursor::new(
            b"payload".to_vec(),
        )));
        // Not `.unwrap_err()`: the `Ok` side is `(Vec<u8>, Box<dyn Source>)`,
        // and `Source` is not `Debug`, so `Result::unwrap_err`'s `T: Debug`
        // bound can't be satisfied here.
        match probe(src) {
            Err(err) => assert!(
                matches!(err, crate::Error::NotSeekable { .. }),
                "must be NotSeekable, not a panic: {err:?}"
            ),
            Ok(_) => panic!("expected NotSeekable, got Ok"),
        }
    }

    // --- Peek-based inner resolution (Task 4) -----------------------------
    //
    // `testing::MockCodec`'s bitwise-NOT transform is its own inverse:
    // encoding through it an EVEN number of times reproduces the original
    // bytes exactly, which would make a nesting-depth test silently
    // degenerate (the "6-deep" stream would collapse back to the bare
    // container and never exercise the bound at all). `PrefixedMockCodec`
    // instead prepends a fixed magic and passes the payload through
    // unchanged, so decoding always strips exactly one layer no matter how
    // many are stacked.
    const NESTED_MAGIC: &[u8] = b"MOCK";

    struct PrefixedMockCodec;

    impl Codec for PrefixedMockCodec {
        fn id(&self) -> FormatId {
            MOCK_CODEC
        }

        fn caps(&self) -> CodecCaps {
            CodecCaps {
                encode: true,
                decode: true,
                ..Default::default()
            }
        }

        fn decoder(&self, mut src: Box<dyn Source>, _o: &DecodeOpts) -> Result<Box<dyn Source>> {
            let mut discard = vec![0u8; NESTED_MAGIC.len()];
            src.read_exact(&mut discard)?;
            Ok(Box::new(StreamOnly::new(src)))
        }

        fn encoder(
            &self,
            mut dst: Box<dyn Write + Send>,
            _o: &EncodeOpts,
        ) -> Result<Box<dyn Sink>> {
            dst.write_all(NESTED_MAGIC)?;
            Ok(Box::new(PassthroughSink(dst)))
        }
    }

    struct PassthroughSink(Box<dyn Write + Send>);

    impl Write for PassthroughSink {
        fn write(&mut self, buf: &[u8]) -> std::io::Result<usize> {
            self.0.write(buf)
        }
        fn flush(&mut self) -> std::io::Result<()> {
            self.0.flush()
        }
    }

    impl Sink for PassthroughSink {
        fn finish(mut self: Box<Self>) -> Result<()> {
            self.0.flush()?;
            Ok(())
        }
    }

    fn mock_registry_with_codec_and_container() -> Registry {
        const CODEC_MAGIC: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
            offset: 0,
            bytes: NESTED_MAGIC,
            format: MOCK_CODEC,
        }];
        const CONTAINER_MAGIC: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
            offset: 0,
            bytes: b"ME",
            format: MOCK_CONTAINER,
        }];
        let mut r = Registry::new();
        r.register_codec(
            Arc::new(PrefixedMockCodec),
            FormatMeta::codec(MOCK_CODEC, &["mock"], CODEC_MAGIC),
        );
        r.register_container(
            Arc::new(MockContainer),
            FormatMeta::container(MOCK_CONTAINER, &["mar"], CONTAINER_MAGIC),
        );
        r
    }

    /// Wraps `payload` in one `PrefixedMockCodec` layer, via the codec's own
    /// `encoder` rather than hand-building the bytes, so the fixture is
    /// provably decodable by the exact codec `resolve_chain_deep` will call.
    fn mock_codec_encode(payload: &[u8]) -> Vec<u8> {
        let sink = SharedBuf::new();
        let mut s = PrefixedMockCodec
            .encoder(Box::new(sink.clone()), &EncodeOpts::default())
            .unwrap();
        s.write_all(payload).unwrap();
        s.finish().unwrap();
        sink.contents()
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_container_inside_a_codec_resolves_from_the_stream_with_no_path() {
        let reg = mock_registry_with_codec_and_container();
        let inner = mock_archive_bytes(&[("a.txt", b"alpha")]);
        let outer = mock_codec_encode(&inner);

        let (chain, _src) = resolve_chain_deep(
            &reg,
            None,
            Box::new(ReaderSource::new(io::Cursor::new(outer))),
        )
        .expect("resolve");

        // Before this task the inner layer was Chain::Raw, because no path meant
        // no extension to consult. The prefix of the DECODED stream now decides.
        assert_eq!(
            chain,
            Chain::Codec {
                codec: MOCK_CODEC,
                inner: Box::new(Chain::Container {
                    container: MOCK_CONTAINER
                }),
            },
            "a container nested inside a codec must be found by peeking the decoded stream"
        );
    }

    #[test]
    fn nesting_beyond_the_depth_bound_is_a_typed_error_naming_the_depth() {
        let reg = mock_registry_with_codec_and_container();
        let mut bytes = mock_archive_bytes(&[("a.txt", b"alpha")]);
        for _ in 0..MAX_CHAIN_DEPTH + 2 {
            bytes = mock_codec_encode(&bytes);
        }

        // Not `.expect_err(..)`: the `Ok` side is `(Chain, Box<dyn Source>)`,
        // and `Source` is not `Debug`, so `Result::expect_err`'s `T: Debug`
        // bound can't be satisfied here — same reason as
        // `a_source_that_claims_seekable_but_has_no_seek_view_errors_instead_of_panicking`
        // above.
        match resolve_chain_deep(
            &reg,
            None,
            Box::new(ReaderSource::new(io::Cursor::new(bytes))),
        ) {
            Err(Error::ChainTooDeep { depth }) => assert_eq!(depth, MAX_CHAIN_DEPTH),
            Err(other) => panic!("expected ChainTooDeep, got {other:?}"),
            Ok(_) => panic!("nesting past the bound must be refused"),
        }
    }

    #[test]
    fn nesting_beyond_the_depth_bound_is_refused_via_the_path_route_too() {
        // A path is a name, not a proof: `a.gz.gz.gz.gz.gz` must be refused
        // exactly like the identical bytes arriving with no path at all.
        // `mock_registry_with_codec_and_container` only ever exposes a
        // single extension per format ("mock"), so a path naming it gives
        // `inner_from_path` nothing to find a container with — the chain
        // still bottoms out at Raw, and peeking (and the bound) must engage
        // all the same.
        let reg = mock_registry_with_codec_and_container();
        let mut bytes = mock_archive_bytes(&[("a.txt", b"alpha")]);
        for _ in 0..MAX_CHAIN_DEPTH + 2 {
            bytes = mock_codec_encode(&bytes);
        }

        match resolve_chain_deep(
            &reg,
            Some(Path::new("nested.mock")),
            Box::new(ReaderSource::new(io::Cursor::new(bytes))),
        ) {
            Err(Error::ChainTooDeep { depth }) => assert_eq!(depth, MAX_CHAIN_DEPTH),
            Err(other) => panic!("expected ChainTooDeep, got {other:?}"),
            Ok(_) => panic!("nesting past the bound must be refused, path or no path"),
        }
    }

    // --- Task 4b: a decoder-side io::Error must reclassify; a raw-source
    // one must not -------------------------------------------------------

    /// A `Source` whose every read raises `InvalidData` — used two ways
    /// below: wrapped as the return of a codec's own `decoder()` (so the
    /// failure looks exactly like a corrupt payload discovered only once
    /// something reads the decoded bytes), and handed directly to
    /// `resolve_chain_deep` as the RAW top-level source (so the identical
    /// error kind arises before any codec is even involved). The two tests
    /// using it must disagree on the resulting `Error` variant — that
    /// disagreement is the whole point of Task 4b's fix.
    struct AlwaysInvalidData;

    impl Read for AlwaysInvalidData {
        fn read(&mut self, _buf: &mut [u8]) -> std::io::Result<usize> {
            Err(std::io::Error::new(
                std::io::ErrorKind::InvalidData,
                "decoded bytes are malformed",
            ))
        }
    }

    impl Source for AlwaysInvalidData {
        fn caps(&self) -> crate::source::SourceCaps {
            crate::source::SourceCaps {
                seekable: false,
                len: None,
            }
        }

        fn as_seek(&mut self) -> Option<&mut dyn crate::source::SeekRead> {
            None
        }
    }

    /// A codec whose `decoder()` construction always succeeds but whose FIRST
    /// read fails with `InvalidData`, standing in for a corrupt payload behind
    /// an intact-looking header.
    ///
    /// `zlib.rs` is the lazy shape this models. Do NOT read it as "every real
    /// codec constructs lazily" — `xz_pure.rs` and `lzip.rs` both read at
    /// construction (`fill_buf()`), and reach the same place only because they
    /// end in `.unwrap_or(&[])`, which swallows the failure and defers it to
    /// the re-probe read this module classifies. An earlier version of this
    /// comment named `lzip.rs` as an example of the convention it contradicts.
    struct FailingDecodeCodec;

    impl Codec for FailingDecodeCodec {
        fn id(&self) -> FormatId {
            FormatId::new("always-fails-to-decode")
        }

        fn caps(&self) -> CodecCaps {
            CodecCaps {
                encode: false,
                decode: true,
                ..Default::default()
            }
        }

        fn decoder(&self, _src: Box<dyn Source>, _o: &DecodeOpts) -> Result<Box<dyn Source>> {
            Ok(Box::new(AlwaysInvalidData))
        }

        fn encoder(&self, _dst: Box<dyn Write + Send>, _o: &EncodeOpts) -> Result<Box<dyn Sink>> {
            unimplemented!("this test never encodes")
        }
    }

    /// The fix itself: a codec stream with no container above it (so
    /// resolution bottoms out at `Chain::Raw` and re-probes the decoded
    /// bytes, per `resolve_chain_deep_with`'s own doc comment) whose decoded
    /// bytes turn out to be malformed must report `Error::Corrupt` — exit 5
    /// — not `Error::Io`. Before Task 4b's fix this was `Err(Error::Io(_))`,
    /// the identical bug `list_reports_a_truncated_codec_stream_as_corrupt_
    /// not_as_an_io_failure` and `list_reports_an_empty_lzip_stream_as_
    /// corrupt_not_as_an_io_failure` pin at the CLI level with the real
    /// zlib and lzip codecs.
    #[test]
    fn a_decoder_side_io_error_while_re_probing_becomes_corrupt() {
        let mut reg = Registry::new();
        const FAILING: FormatId = FormatId::new("always-fails-to-decode");
        const FAILING_MAGIC: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
            offset: 0,
            bytes: &[0xab, 0xcd],
            format: FAILING,
        }];
        reg.register_codec(
            Arc::new(FailingDecodeCodec),
            FormatMeta::codec(FAILING, &["fail"], FAILING_MAGIC),
        );

        // Real, readable bytes for the RAW top-level probe to sniff magic
        // from — only the DECODED stream (`AlwaysInvalidData`) ever fails.
        let bytes = vec![0xab, 0xcd, 0x00, 0x00];
        match resolve_chain_deep(
            &reg,
            None,
            Box::new(ReaderSource::new(io::Cursor::new(bytes))),
        ) {
            Err(Error::Corrupt(msg)) => assert!(
                msg.contains("malformed"),
                "must carry the decoder's own message via Error::from_decode_io: {msg}"
            ),
            Err(other) => panic!("expected Corrupt (a decoder-side read failed), got {other:?}"),
            Ok(_) => panic!("a decoder that always fails to read cannot resolve successfully"),
        }
    }

    /// A codec that validates its header inside `decoder()` and REFUSES
    /// there — before a single decoded byte exists, so before
    /// [`crate::source::DecodeSideSource`] can mark anything — must still
    /// report `Error::Corrupt`.
    ///
    /// No registered codec takes this branch today; `.Z` parses its header
    /// lazily and every other decoder here is a `Read` adapter built without
    /// touching the source. It is pinned anyway, and `build_decoder` folds it
    /// anyway, because "unreached and wrong by default" is precisely the
    /// shape this class keeps recurring in: Task 4b closed the re-probe call,
    /// the ladder's spool was still open, and the enumeration that found the
    /// spool found this too. `CLAUDE.md`'s Phase 3c backlog records the same
    /// gap from the other side, against `conformance.rs:393`.
    #[test]
    fn a_decoder_that_refuses_at_construction_is_corrupt_not_an_io_failure() {
        struct RefusesToBuild;

        impl Codec for RefusesToBuild {
            fn id(&self) -> FormatId {
                FormatId::new("refuses-to-build")
            }

            fn caps(&self) -> CodecCaps {
                CodecCaps {
                    encode: false,
                    decode: true,
                    ..Default::default()
                }
            }

            fn decoder(&self, _src: Box<dyn Source>, _o: &DecodeOpts) -> Result<Box<dyn Source>> {
                Err(Error::Io(io::Error::new(
                    io::ErrorKind::InvalidData,
                    "the header is malformed and I will not build a decoder for it",
                )))
            }

            fn encoder(
                &self,
                _dst: Box<dyn Write + Send>,
                _o: &EncodeOpts,
            ) -> Result<Box<dyn Sink>> {
                unimplemented!("this test never encodes")
            }
        }

        const REFUSES: FormatId = FormatId::new("refuses-to-build");
        const REFUSES_MAGIC: &[MagicRule] = &[MagicRule {
            offset: 0,
            bytes: &[0xab, 0xcd],
            format: REFUSES,
        }];

        let mut reg = Registry::new();
        reg.register_codec(
            Arc::new(RefusesToBuild),
            FormatMeta::codec(REFUSES, &["refuse"], REFUSES_MAGIC),
        );

        // Both routes through `resolve_chain_deep_with` build a decoder — the
        // path route via `decode_through_chain`, the pathless one via the
        // re-probe loop — so both are checked, and both go through
        // `build_decoder`.
        for path in [None, Some(Path::new("thing.refuse"))] {
            let bytes = vec![0xab, 0xcd, 0x00, 0x00];
            match resolve_chain_deep(
                &reg,
                path,
                Box::new(ReaderSource::new(io::Cursor::new(bytes))),
            ) {
                Err(Error::Corrupt(msg)) => assert!(
                    msg.contains("malformed"),
                    "must carry the codec's own message: {msg}"
                ),
                Err(other) => panic!("expected Corrupt for path {path:?}, got {other:?}"),
                Ok(_) => panic!("a codec that refuses to build cannot resolve successfully"),
            }
        }
    }

    /// The hazard side: the SAME `InvalidData` error kind, but raised by the
    /// RAW source before any codec is even chosen, must stay `Error::Io` —
    /// exit 1 — never `Error::Corrupt`. This is what a fix that reclassified
    /// too broadly (inside `probe`/`PeekSource::fill` themselves, or at
    /// `resolve_chain_deep_with`'s own top-level `probe(src)` call) would
    /// get wrong: it has nothing to do with the error's `ErrorKind`, only
    /// with WHICH read produced it, so this guard cannot be satisfied by
    /// checking the kind alone the way the CLI-level directory test does.
    #[test]
    fn a_raw_source_io_error_of_the_identical_kind_stays_io_not_corrupt() {
        let reg = mock_registry_with_codec_and_container();
        match resolve_chain_deep(&reg, None, Box::new(AlwaysInvalidData)) {
            Err(Error::Io(io_err)) => assert_eq!(
                io_err.kind(),
                std::io::ErrorKind::InvalidData,
                "sanity: this must be the same error kind the test above reclassifies, so the \
                 two tests differ only in WHERE the read happened"
            ),
            Err(other) => panic!(
                "a raw-source failure must stay Io, not become {other:?} — reclassifying it \
                 would be a lie in the opposite direction from Task 4b's bug"
            ),
            Ok(_) => panic!("a raw source that always errors cannot resolve successfully"),
        }
    }

    #[test]
    fn the_returned_source_is_decoded_through_every_codec_layer_on_both_routes() {
        // The defect this pins: the path route used to return the PRISTINE,
        // undecoded source (resolve_chain alone tells you the shape, nothing
        // decodes anything), while the no-path route returned the source
        // already peeled past every codec layer. A caller of
        // `resolve_chain_deep` cannot be expected to inspect `path.is_some()`
        // itself to know which kind of source it was just handed — both
        // routes must leave the source in the identical state: decoded
        // through every codec layer named in the returned `Chain`, ready to
        // hand straight to the container.
        //
        // "thing.mar.mock" mirrors `.tar.gz`: `inner_from_path` finds the
        // container ("mar") one extension in from the codec ("mock"), so
        // this path resolves the FULL chain in one `resolve_chain` call,
        // with no peeking at all — the route this test must prove decodes
        // its codec layer exactly as the peeling route does.
        let reg = mock_registry_with_codec_and_container();
        let inner = mock_archive_bytes(&[("a.txt", b"alpha")]);
        let outer = mock_codec_encode(&inner);

        let (chain_with_path, mut src_with_path) = resolve_chain_deep(
            &reg,
            Some(Path::new("thing.mar.mock")),
            Box::new(ReaderSource::new(io::Cursor::new(outer.clone()))),
        )
        .expect("resolve with path");
        let (chain_no_path, mut src_no_path) = resolve_chain_deep(
            &reg,
            None,
            Box::new(ReaderSource::new(io::Cursor::new(outer))),
        )
        .expect("resolve without path");

        let expected_chain = Chain::Codec {
            codec: MOCK_CODEC,
            inner: Box::new(Chain::Container {
                container: MOCK_CONTAINER,
            }),
        };
        assert_eq!(chain_with_path, expected_chain);
        assert_eq!(chain_no_path, expected_chain);

        let mut bytes_with_path = Vec::new();
        src_with_path.read_to_end(&mut bytes_with_path).unwrap();
        let mut bytes_no_path = Vec::new();
        src_no_path.read_to_end(&mut bytes_no_path).unwrap();

        assert_eq!(
            bytes_with_path, inner,
            "the path route must decode through the codec layer, not return raw bytes"
        );
        assert_eq!(
            bytes_with_path, bytes_no_path,
            "both routes must leave the source in the identical, already-decoded state"
        );
    }
}