razeri_plugin_contract/

renderer.rs

// Copyright (C) 2026 Gabriel Shea <gshea@ideapivot.com> - All Rights Reserved

//! Layered rendering traits for SQL generation.
//!
//! The hierarchy is designed so that implementing [`SqlRenderer`] (4 methods)
//! gives you ANSI-standard defaults for all higher-level traits.

use crate::DataType;
use crate::constraint_enforcement::ConstraintEnforcement;
use crate::routine_form::{ProcedureForm, ScalarFunctionForm, TableFunctionForm};
use crate::sid_spelling::{SidSpelling, UNSPELLED_SID};

/// **Where the aggregated expression goes** in a form returned by
/// [`SqlRenderer::median_aggregate_form`].
///
/// The form is a template rather than finished SQL so that *which function*
/// and *how a column is written* stay in different hands — the dialect answers
/// the first, the query renderer the second. A form must carry this token
/// exactly once.
pub const AGGREGATE_ARGUMENT: &str = "{argument}";

/// **What kind of value an aggregate would have to collapse** — the axis
/// [`SqlRenderer::render_single_row_aggregate`] varies on, held to three arms
/// because three is what the measurements distinguish.
///
/// Not the full type lattice: `MAX` behaves identically across every numeric,
/// textual and temporal type on every platform razeri reaches, and splitting
/// them would invite per-type arms nothing has measured.
#[derive(Debug, Clone, Copy, PartialEq, Eq)]
pub enum AggregableKind {
    /// Numeric, textual and temporal — every platform orders these and every
    /// platform has `MAX` for them.
    Orderable,
    /// A truth value. `PostgreSQL` and SQL Server have no `MAX` for it and each
    /// spells the collapse differently.
    Boolean,
    /// `uuid`, JSON, binary, interval, array, map — the families with no
    /// ordering to borrow. Availability is per platform and is measured, never
    /// assumed.
    Opaque,
}

/// **A clock bound once for a whole load script** — what
/// [`SqlRenderer::render_inline_clock_binding`] answers on an engine whose
/// loads ship as flat statement lists rather than procedure bodies.
///
/// The `statements` run first and capture the engine's current moment under
/// one name; `reference` is the expression every later statement of the same
/// run reads it back by. One binding, many readers, is what makes a version's
/// close and its successor's open the same instant by construction.
#[derive(Debug, Clone, PartialEq, Eq)]
pub struct InlineClockBinding {
    /// The statement(s) that bind the moment, in run order, each terminated.
    pub statements: Vec<String>,
    /// The expression that reads the bound moment back.
    pub reference: String,
}

/// Level 1 — Core SQL rendering. REQUIRED: every dialect must implement these 4 methods.
///
/// These methods define the absolute minimum surface for rendering SQL:
/// data types, identifier quoting, qualified names, and timestamps.
pub trait SqlRenderer: Send + Sync {
    /// Render a [`DataType`] as platform-specific SQL.
    fn render_data_type(&self, dt: &DataType) -> String;

    /// **The type text for a column that ADMITS NULL** — the whole type, not a
    /// modifier appended to one.
    ///
    /// Nine of razeri's ten platforms spell nullability by SILENCE: a column
    /// declared without `NOT NULL` admits one, and its type text is the same
    /// text a required column carries. That is the default here, and for those
    /// nine this hook is [`SqlRenderer::render_data_type`] under another name.
    ///
    /// **`ClickHouse` is the exception, and it is the reason this hook exists.**
    /// There a bare type is NOT NULL — nullability is a property OF the type,
    /// spelled `Nullable(T)` — so a renderer that expresses *nullable* by
    /// omitting a keyword expresses nothing at all. `render_field` used to carry
    /// a comment saying the wrapper was *"handled in data type"*; it was handled
    /// nowhere, and every `nullable:` a design declared was discarded on that
    /// one engine (`Nullable(` appeared ZERO times in any rendered
    /// `schema.sql`).
    ///
    /// # What the discard actually cost, measured rather than assumed
    ///
    /// Not a loud refusal. `insert_null_as_default` **defaults to `1`** on
    /// `ClickHouse` (24.10.2, server default, `changed = 0`), so
    /// `INSERT … SELECT NULL` into a bare column does not raise — it writes the
    /// TYPE'S DEFAULT, silently: `''` for `String`, `0` for `Int64`,
    /// `1900-01-01` for `Date32` (which is razeri's own unknown-member date, so
    /// an unknown attribute came back indistinguishable from a deliberately
    /// seeded one). Only with `insert_null_as_default = 0` does the engine
    /// answer `Code: 70 … Cannot convert NULL to a non-nullable type`. **A
    /// design's own data was being fabricated on one engine and honest on the
    /// other nine**, and the DDL is where that is fixed.
    ///
    /// # A dialect overriding this owes a measurement
    ///
    /// Not every type can be wrapped. `ClickHouse` refuses
    /// `Nullable(Array(…))`, `Nullable(Map(…))` and `Nullable(JSON)` outright,
    /// so its override declines those and says so in its own rustdoc. A
    /// wrapper that cannot be applied must be DECLINED by name, never applied
    /// and hoped for: an unwrappable type rendered `Nullable(…)` turns a silent
    /// wrong value into a `CREATE TABLE` that does not run.
    fn render_nullable_data_type(&self, dt: &DataType) -> String {
        self.render_data_type(dt)
    }

    /// Quote an identifier using platform conventions.
    ///
    /// `PostgreSQL`: `"name"`, `MySQL`: `` `name` ``, SQL Server: `[name]`
    fn quote_identifier(&self, name: &str) -> String;

    /// Render a fully qualified name (optional schema + name).
    fn qualify_name(&self, schema: Option<&str>, name: &str) -> String;

    /// Whether this dialect uses schemas in qualified names.
    ///
    /// `ClickHouse` uses only `database.object` (no schema level).
    /// Default: `true` (most platforms use `catalog.schema.object`).
    fn uses_schema_in_qualified_names(&self) -> bool {
        true
    }

    /// Whether this dialect is the "agnostic" pseudo-dialect.
    ///
    /// Agnostic rendering produces unquoted, platform-neutral DDL.
    /// Real dialect implementations should not override this.
    fn is_agnostic_dialect(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether this dialect supports `SECURE VIEW` (Snowflake).
    fn supports_secure_view(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether this dialect supports `GLOBAL TEMPORARY VIEW` (Databricks).
    fn supports_global_temporary_view(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Render the platform's `CURRENT_TIMESTAMP` expression.
    fn render_current_timestamp(&self) -> String;

    /// Return a stable string identifier for this dialect.
    ///
    /// Used for dispatch when trait-based rendering is not yet available for
    /// a domain concept, and as a human-readable label in diagnostics and
    /// error messages.  This method works for **all dialects** registered
    /// in the `PlatformRegistry` (e.g. `"postgresql"`, `"sqlite"`,
    /// `"cockroachdb"`).
    ///
    /// Convention: lowercase, hyphen-separated (e.g. `"postgresql"`,
    /// `"sql-server"`, `"snowflake"`, `"sqlite"`).
    ///
    /// The default returns `"ansi"`.
    fn dialect_name(&self) -> &'static str {
        "ansi"
    }

    /// **How this engine spells a surrogate key.**
    ///
    /// Razeri derives every key one way — normalize each part, join them, hash
    /// the result, guard NULLs with a sentinel — and composes that derivation
    /// in exactly one place. What a dialect decides is the *vocabulary*: what
    /// this engine calls `LOWER` and `TRIM`, how it joins strings, how it casts
    /// a value to text, and how it spells a 64-bit hash.
    ///
    /// The default is [`UNSPELLED_SID`] — ANSI's vocabulary under a name that
    /// says it is a guess. **A dialect that leaves it there is telling Razeri it
    /// has not decided**, and the emitted SQL will call an `xxhash64` its engine
    /// very likely does not have. Override it.
    ///
    /// If your engine has no portable 64-bit hash, say so rather than reaching
    /// for the nearest-looking function: a hash that is deterministic within one
    /// warehouse and equal to nothing outside it is the lock-in a portable key
    /// exists to end. Name an artifact your dialect's prerequisites install, or
    /// refuse the key and orient the reader.
    fn sid_spelling(&self) -> SidSpelling {
        UNSPELLED_SID
    }

    /// **The `CAST` target spelling for a [`DataType`] on this engine.**
    ///
    /// A column declaration and a `CAST` target are two grammars on most
    /// engines, so this is a separate answer from
    /// [`render_data_type`](Self::render_data_type) and not a synonym for it.
    /// `MySQL` takes `SIGNED` where it declares `BIGINT`; T-SQL takes
    /// `NVARCHAR(MAX)` where ANSI says `TEXT`.
    ///
    /// Where the two *are* the same on your engine — which is the common case
    /// on engines with one type vocabulary — say so by delegating:
    ///
    /// ```ignore
    /// fn render_cast_type(&self, dt: &DataType) -> String {
    ///     self.render_data_type(dt)
    /// }
    /// ```
    ///
    /// The default is ANSI's cast vocabulary. Razeri's generated load opens
    /// with a CTE that casts every source column to its declared type, so a
    /// wrong name here fails the load on its first statement.
    fn render_cast_type(&self, dt: &DataType) -> String {
        crate::agnostic::render_cast_type_ansi(dt)
    }

    /// **Which stored-procedure grammar this engine speaks.**
    ///
    /// Razeri composes the procedure — its parameters, its steps, its comment —
    /// and spells it in the form this returns. The default is
    /// [`ProcedureForm::Agnostic`], which parses on no engine: it is the honest
    /// answer for a dialect that has not said, and it is what an unlisted
    /// platform has always been handed.
    ///
    /// It lives on `SqlRenderer` rather than on
    /// [`ProcedureRenderer`] because the composer
    /// holds the renderer as a [`DdlRenderer`], and a decision reachable only
    /// through a trait the caller does not hold is a decision the caller makes
    /// instead.
    fn procedure_form(&self) -> ProcedureForm {
        ProcedureForm::Agnostic
    }

    /// **Which scalar-function grammar this engine speaks.**
    ///
    /// The default is [`ScalarFunctionForm::PostgreSql`] — what an unlisted
    /// dialect has always been handed, and a dangerous inheritance on a near
    /// neighbour: `LANGUAGE SQL IMMUTABLE PARALLEL SAFE` is a *"syntax error at
    /// or near `PARALLEL`"* on an engine that descends from `PostgreSQL` and
    /// reports itself as one.
    fn scalar_function_form(&self) -> ScalarFunctionForm {
        ScalarFunctionForm::PostgreSql
    }

    /// **Which table-valued-function grammar this engine speaks, and — where it
    /// has none — the words it refuses in.**
    ///
    /// The default is [`TableFunctionForm::PostgreSql`], what an unlisted
    /// dialect has always been handed. If your engine has no routine a query
    /// selects `FROM`, answer [`TableFunctionForm::Unsupported`] with your own
    /// sentence: Razeri then declines to build the routine at all and prints
    /// **your** words rather than another engine's. A refusal written once per
    /// artifact kind tells every author about whichever engine happened to need
    /// it first, and the near form an author will otherwise find on their own
    /// is exactly what costs them a day.
    fn table_function_form(&self) -> TableFunctionForm {
        TableFunctionForm::PostgreSql
    }

    // ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
    // Expression rendering extensions (Phase 1 debt removal)
    // ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════

    /// Platform's `CURRENT_DATE` expression.
    ///
    /// `SqlServer`: `CAST(GETDATE() AS DATE)`, `ClickHouse`: `today()`, others: `CURRENT_DATE`
    fn render_current_date(&self) -> String {
        "CURRENT_DATE".to_string()
    }

    /// Render a boolean literal.
    ///
    /// SqlServer/ClickHouse: `1`/`0`, others: `TRUE`/`FALSE`
    fn render_boolean_literal(&self, value: bool) -> String {
        if value { "TRUE".to_string() } else { "FALSE".to_string() }
    }

    /// **Collapse a subquery that selects AT MOST ONE ROW into an aggregate**,
    /// for the engines that will not accept an unaggregated correlated scalar.
    ///
    /// Razeri's SCD-2 and SCD-1 re-opens assign `col = (SELECT … WHERE
    /// {correlation})`. Databricks refuses that shape by name
    /// (`MUST_AGGREGATE_CORRELATED_SCALAR_SUBQUERY`) and Snowflake stopped
    /// unnesting it the day the guard beside it became uncorrelated, so the
    /// emission wraps the projection in an aggregate. **Which** aggregate is a
    /// dialect fact and **whether one exists at all** is a dialect × type fact,
    /// which is why this hook takes the kind and may answer `None`:
    ///
    /// - `MAX` is the obvious choice and is wrong for a BOOLEAN on two of the
    ///   platforms razeri reaches. Measured on the running
    ///   containers: `PostgreSQL` and Citus raise
    ///   *"function max(boolean) does not exist"*, SQL Server raises
    ///   *"Msg 8117: Operand data type bit is invalid for max operator"*, while
    ///   `MariaDB` (`MAX(TRUE)` → `1`) and `ClickHouse` (`max(true)` → `true`)
    ///   answer it happily;
    /// - `PostgreSQL` has no `max()` for `uuid`, `jsonb` or `bytea` either
    ///   (measured, same run), and SQL Server has one for both
    ///   `uniqueidentifier` and `varbinary` (measured).
    ///
    /// **`None` means *this dialect cannot aggregate this kind* and is not a
    /// failure.** The caller then emits the bare correlated scalar — the
    /// prior shape, measured green on the whole
    /// `PostgreSQL` family — and says so on the output, because that shape is
    /// the one Databricks refuses.
    ///
    /// **Correctness does not come from the aggregate's meaning.** The subquery
    /// is under a guard that is false for the entire load if any member
    /// disagrees with itself, so it selects one row; `MAX`, `BOOL_OR` and
    /// `BOOLOR_AGG` of one value are all that value. The choice between them is
    /// availability, not semantics.
    fn render_single_row_aggregate(
        &self,
        expression: &str,
        kind: AggregableKind,
    ) -> Option<String> {
        let _ = kind;
        Some(format!("MAX({expression})"))
    }

    /// **The AGGREGATE median this engine has for `expression`, or `None` when
    /// it has none.**
    ///
    /// Aggregate is the load-bearing word, and it is why this cannot be
    /// answered from a function-name table. Four spellings are in the wild:
    ///
    /// - a plain `median(x)` aggregate — `duckdb`, `clickhouse`, `snowflake`;
    /// - the SQL ordered-set aggregate
    ///   `PERCENTILE_CONT(0.5) WITHIN GROUP (ORDER BY x)` — `postgres` and its
    ///   family (measured on a running instance: it groups);
    /// - a two-argument `PERCENTILE(x, 0.5)` — `databricks`;
    /// - and a WINDOW function wearing one of those names, which is **not**
    ///   this. `mariadb` has `MEDIAN(x) OVER (…)` and `sqlserver` has
    ///   `PERCENTILE_CONT(…) OVER (…)`, and both are a syntax error in a
    ///   `GROUP BY` select list (measured: `MariaDB` raises `ERROR 1064` and
    ///   SQL Server raises *"Msg 10753: The function `PERCENTILE_CONT` must
    ///   have an OVER clause"*). A window function returns one value per ROW,
    ///   not one per group, so it is a different answer and not a fallback.
    ///
    /// **The default declines**, so a dialect that has never been asked the
    /// question is never assumed to have the answer, and a dialect added
    /// tomorrow opts in deliberately with a form somebody measured. The caller
    /// turns `None` into a build-time refusal naming the column and the target
    /// — razeri does not emit SQL its target cannot run.
    ///
    /// # Why a TEMPLATE rather than finished SQL
    ///
    /// The aggregated expression is a column reference, and how a column
    /// reference is spelled — quoted, bracketed, upper-cased — belongs to the
    /// renderer that lays out the query, not to this answer. Handing back a
    /// form with [`AGGREGATE_ARGUMENT`] where the expression goes keeps the
    /// two apart: this trait owns *which function*, the query renderer owns
    /// *how the column is written*, and neither has to reimplement the other.
    fn median_aggregate_form(&self) -> Option<&'static str> {
        None
    }

    /// Render a date literal.
    ///
    /// `ClickHouse`: `toDate('2024-01-15')`, others: `DATE '2024-01-15'`
    fn render_date_literal(&self, date: &str) -> String {
        format!("DATE '{date}'")
    }

    /// Render a timestamp literal.
    ///
    /// `ClickHouse`: `toDateTime('...')`, others: `TIMESTAMP '...'`
    fn render_timestamp_literal(&self, ts: &str) -> String {
        format!("TIMESTAMP '{ts}'")
    }

    /// Render an interval literal.
    ///
    /// `SqlServer`: `'P1Y2M3D'`, `ClickHouse`: `INTERVAL 1 YEAR`, others: `INTERVAL '1 year'`
    fn render_interval_literal(&self, interval: &str) -> String {
        format!("INTERVAL '{interval}'")
    }

    /// Render the string concatenation operator.
    ///
    /// `SqlServer`: `+`, others: `||`
    fn concat_operator(&self) -> &'static str {
        "||"
    }

    /// Render a NaN literal for a floating-point type.
    ///
    /// `PostgreSQL`: `'NaN'::float`, others: `NULL`
    fn render_nan_literal(&self, _dt: &DataType) -> String {
        "NULL".to_string()
    }

    /// Render an infinity literal for a floating-point type.
    ///
    /// `PostgreSQL`: `'Infinity'::float` / `'-Infinity'::float`, others: `NULL`
    fn render_infinity_literal(&self, _positive: bool, _dt: &DataType) -> String {
        "NULL".to_string()
    }

    /// Render the NULL-coalescing function name.
    ///
    /// `SqlServer`: `ISNULL`, `ClickHouse`: `ifNull`, others: `COALESCE`
    fn ifnull_function_name(&self) -> &'static str {
        "COALESCE"
    }

    /// Render an IIF expression (or CASE WHEN equivalent).
    ///
    /// `SqlServer`: `IIF(cond, then, else)`, others: `CASE WHEN cond THEN then ELSE else END`
    fn render_iif(&self, cond: &str, then_val: &str, else_val: &str) -> String {
        format!("CASE WHEN {cond} THEN {then_val} ELSE {else_val} END")
    }

    /// Render a `DATE_TRUNC` expression.
    ///
    /// `SqlServer`: `DATETRUNC(field, expr)`, `ClickHouse`: `toStartOfMonth(expr)`, others: `DATE_TRUNC('field', expr)`
    fn render_date_trunc(&self, field: &str, expr: &str) -> String {
        format!("DATE_TRUNC('{field}', {expr})")
    }

    /// Render a date field extraction expression.
    ///
    /// `SqlServer`: `DATEPART(field, column)`, `ClickHouse`: `toYear(col)/toMonth(col)`, others: `EXTRACT(field FROM column)`
    fn render_date_extract(&self, field: &str, column: &str) -> String {
        format!("EXTRACT({field} FROM {column})")
    }

    /// Render a `TRY_CAST` expression.
    ///
    /// `ClickHouse`: `accurateCastOrNull(expr, 'Type')`, others: `TRY_CAST(expr AS Type)`
    fn render_try_cast(&self, expr: &str, target: &DataType) -> String {
        format!("TRY_CAST({} AS {})", expr, self.render_data_type(target))
    }

    /// Render a positional parameter placeholder.
    ///
    /// `PostgreSQL`: `$1`, `SqlServer`: `@p1`, Databricks: `{param1}`, others: `?`
    fn render_parameter_placeholder(&self, index: usize) -> String {
        format!("${index}")
    }

    /// Render a named parameter placeholder.
    ///
    /// `SqlServer`: `@name`, `PostgreSQL`: `:name`, Databricks: `{name}`
    fn render_named_parameter(&self, name: &str) -> String {
        format!(":{name}")
    }

    /// Keyword emitted for MERGE NOT MATCHED branch.
    ///
    /// SqlServer/Databricks: `WHEN NOT MATCHED BY TARGET`, others: `WHEN NOT MATCHED`.
    fn merge_not_matched_keyword(&self) -> &'static str {
        "WHEN NOT MATCHED"
    }

    /// Whether MERGE supports `WHEN NOT MATCHED BY SOURCE`.
    fn supports_merge_not_matched_by_source(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether this platform supports MERGE statements.
    fn merge_supported(&self) -> bool {
        true
    }

    /// Whether `WITH SCHEMA EVOLUTION` is supported for MERGE.
    fn merge_supports_schema_evolution_keyword(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether table hints are supported in MERGE target.
    fn merge_supports_table_hints(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether OUTPUT clause should be used for MERGE result projection.
    fn merge_uses_output_clause(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether RETURNING clause is supported for MERGE.
    fn merge_supports_returning_clause(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// The schema separator for qualified names.
    ///
    /// Almost always `.`, but could differ for some platforms.
    fn schema_separator(&self) -> &'static str {
        "."
    }

    /// The statement separator for scripts.
    ///
    /// Almost all platforms: `;\n`, `SqlServer`: `;\nGO\n`
    fn statement_separator(&self) -> &'static str {
        ";\n"
    }

    // ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
    // UPDATE behavior hooks (Phase 4.3 debt removal)
    // ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════

    /// Whether the platform supports compound assignment operators (e.g., `col += value`).
    ///
    /// `SqlServer`: `true`, others: `false`.
    fn supports_compound_assignment(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether UPDATE supports FROM clause for join-based updates.
    ///
    /// `PostgreSQL`, `SqlServer`, Snowflake, `CitusDB`: `true`, others: `false`.
    fn supports_update_from(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether the platform uses ALTER TABLE ... UPDATE syntax (`ClickHouse` mutations).
    fn uses_alter_table_update(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// **Whether a mutation on this platform can read only the row it is
    /// mutating.**
    ///
    /// `uses_alter_table_update` above says how the mutation is SPELLED; this
    /// says what the mutation may LOOK AT, and the two are independent facts
    /// that happen to be true of the same engine today. A platform answering
    /// `true` here cannot express *assign this column from another relation*
    /// at all: neither the `SET` list nor the `WHERE` may correlate out to a
    /// second table, so no re-spelling of a correlated `UPDATE` compiles —
    /// what is available instead is `INSERT … SELECT` over a join and a
    /// mutation whose predicate is an uncorrelated `IN`.
    ///
    /// **Measured, and it is the reason the seam exists.** `ClickHouse`
    /// 24.10.2 (2026-08-23) answered razeri's emitted re-open with
    /// `Code: 47 … UNKNOWN_IDENTIFIER` while resolving the assignment's own
    /// subquery — after the statement PARSED, which is what made the
    /// distinction visible: the syntax was right and the reach was not.
    ///
    /// It sits here on [`SqlRenderer`] and **only** here. The house already
    /// carries one capability with two definitions —
    /// `uses_alter_table_update` is declared on this trait and again on
    /// `DialectCapabilities`, which is a named defect with a ring of its own —
    /// and a second duplicated flag would make it two. `SqlRenderer` is the
    /// trait razeri's generators call, so this is the definition that decides.
    ///
    /// Default `false`: every engine razeri reaches except `ClickHouse` lets a
    /// mutation correlate, and the ANSI correlated `UPDATE` those nine compile
    /// is unchanged by this flag existing.
    fn mutation_reads_only_its_own_rows(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// **The spelling a SQL statement inside a generated procedure body reads
    /// a declared local variable by** (the one-clock law, owner 2026-09-01:
    /// *"no daylight between the close of one version and the open of a
    /// next"*).
    ///
    /// A versioning load binds its clock ONCE — a `Declare` step at the top of
    /// the procedure — and every close and every open reads the variable
    /// instead of the engine's clock. The DECLARATION is the procedure
    /// renderer's business (`razeri-sql`'s per-platform strategies each spell
    /// `Declare` correctly already); what the LOAD GENERATORS need is the
    /// reference spelling to embed in the raw statements they compose, and
    /// that differs by procedure language:
    ///
    /// - bare `name` — PL/pgSQL, MySQL/MariaDB, and the default;
    /// - `@name` — T-SQL;
    /// - `:name` — Snowflake Scripting's bind syntax inside SQL statements;
    /// - `$name` — the agnostic format's marker.
    ///
    /// It mirrors the `Expression::Variable` arm of each procedure renderer in
    /// `razeri-sql` — the two must agree, and each override says so beside the
    /// spelling.
    fn render_procedure_variable_reference(&self, name: &str) -> String {
        name.to_owned()
    }

    /// **The statement a generated load asks a scalar question with and throws
    /// the answer away.**
    ///
    /// A load's guard evaluates one scalar and reads nothing back: it either
    /// passes silently or stops the load on the engine's own error. What
    /// differs between engines is not the question but the STATEMENT that may
    /// carry it, and the difference is a procedure-language rule rather than a
    /// SQL one:
    ///
    /// - a bare `SELECT` is a legal script statement everywhere, and is legal
    ///   inside the procedure bodies `MySQL`, `MariaDB` and T-SQL accept, where it
    ///   simply hands the caller a result set nobody reads — so that is the
    ///   default;
    /// - **PL/pgSQL refuses it.** A `SELECT` with no destination inside a
    ///   procedure body is `query has no destination for result data`, raised
    ///   the moment the procedure is called. PL/pgSQL's own discard form is
    ///   `PERFORM`, and the Postgres family overrides this to spell it.
    ///
    /// The engines that ship no stored procedure inline the same statement into
    /// a script, where the default is the only form that runs — and every such
    /// engine takes the default, so one answer per dialect is unambiguous.
    ///
    /// `alias` names the answered column for the forms that answer one; a
    /// discard form that answers nothing ignores it.
    fn render_discarded_scalar(&self, expression: &str, alias: &str) -> String {
        format!("SELECT {expression} AS {alias};")
    }

    /// **How a script with no stored procedures binds the load's clock once**
    /// — same law as [`Self::render_procedure_variable_reference`], on the
    /// engines where a load ships as a flat statement list rather than a
    /// procedure body.
    ///
    /// The statements run FIRST and bind the engine's current moment to
    /// `name`; the reference is the expression every close and open in the
    /// same run then reads, so a version's `record_end_timestamp` and its
    /// successor's `record_start_timestamp` are one value by construction.
    /// Every spelling must be RE-RUNNABLE in one session — a second load in
    /// the same session rebinds rather than failing — because a load script is
    /// run whole and run again.
    ///
    /// The default is the one shape every engine can carry: a one-row
    /// temporary table capturing [`Self::render_current_timestamp`], read back
    /// through a scalar subquery. Engines with a native variable idiom
    /// override it (`DuckDB`'s `SET VARIABLE`, Databricks' session variables);
    /// `ClickHouse` overrides only the temporary-table spelling its own DDL
    /// requires.
    fn render_inline_clock_binding(&self, name: &str) -> InlineClockBinding {
        InlineClockBinding {
            statements: vec![
                format!("DROP TABLE IF EXISTS {name};"),
                format!(
                    "CREATE TEMPORARY TABLE {name} AS SELECT {} AS load_clock;",
                    self.render_current_timestamp()
                ),
            ],
            reference: format!("(SELECT load_clock FROM {name})"),
        }
    }

    /// Whether UPDATE supports TOP(n) clause (`SqlServer`).
    fn update_supports_top_clause(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether UPDATE supports table hints (e.g., `WITH (NOLOCK)`) (`SqlServer`).
    fn update_supports_table_hints(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether UPDATE uses OUTPUT clause positioned before FROM (`SqlServer`).
    ///
    /// When `true`, RETURNING/OUTPUT is rendered between SET and FROM.
    /// When `false`, RETURNING is rendered at the end of the statement.
    fn update_uses_output_clause(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether UPDATE supports a RETURNING clause at the end of the statement.
    ///
    /// `PostgreSQL`, `CitusDB`: `true`. Others: `false`.
    fn update_supports_returning(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    // ========================================================================
    // INSERT behavior hooks
    // ========================================================================

    /// Whether INSERT uses OUTPUT clause positioned before VALUES/SELECT (`SqlServer`).
    ///
    /// When `true`, RETURNING/OUTPUT is rendered between column list and source.
    /// When `false`, RETURNING is rendered at the end of the statement.
    fn insert_uses_output_clause(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether INSERT supports RETURNING at the end (`PostgreSQL`, `CitusDB`).
    fn insert_supports_returning(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether INSERT supports table hints (e.g., `WITH (TABLOCK)`) (`SqlServer`).
    fn insert_supports_table_hints(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether INSERT OVERWRITE is supported (Snowflake, Databricks).
    fn supports_insert_overwrite(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether INSERT ... ON CONFLICT is supported (`PostgreSQL`, `CitusDB`).
    fn supports_on_conflict(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether OVERRIDING SYSTEM/USER VALUE clause is supported (`PostgreSQL`).
    fn supports_overriding_clause(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// The keyword for returning data from DML: "OUTPUT" (`SqlServer`) or "RETURNING" (others).
    fn returning_clause_keyword(&self) -> &'static str {
        "RETURNING"
    }

    /// Whether OUTPUT ... INTO is supported (`SqlServer`).
    fn supports_returning_into(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether multi-table INSERT (INSERT ALL) is supported (Snowflake).
    fn supports_multi_table_insert(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    // ========================================================================
    // Function/procedure parameter behavior hooks
    // ========================================================================

    /// Render the security mode clause for function/procedure definitions.
    ///
    /// Standard SQL: `SECURITY INVOKER`/`SECURITY DEFINER`.
    /// T-SQL: `EXECUTE AS CALLER`/`EXECUTE AS OWNER`.
    fn render_security_mode(&self, is_definer: bool) -> &'static str {
        if is_definer { "SECURITY DEFINER" } else { "SECURITY INVOKER" }
    }

    /// Render a function parameter name.
    ///
    /// Standard SQL uses the bare name. T-SQL prefixes with `@`.
    fn render_function_parameter_name(&self, name: &str) -> String {
        name.to_string()
    }

    /// Render explicit nullability for a function parameter, if the platform requires it.
    ///
    /// Most platforms omit nullability in parameter lists. T-SQL native
    /// compilation requires explicit `NULL`/`NOT NULL`.
    fn render_function_parameter_nullable(&self, _nullable: bool) -> Option<&'static str> {
        None
    }

    /// Render the default-value clause for a function parameter.
    ///
    /// Standard SQL: `DEFAULT value`. T-SQL: `= value`.
    fn render_function_parameter_default(&self, value: &str) -> String {
        format!("DEFAULT {value}")
    }

    /// Render a column name inside a table-valued function definition.
    ///
    /// Standard SQL uses the bare name. T-SQL uses bracket quoting `[name]`.
    fn render_function_column_name(&self, name: &str) -> String {
        name.to_string()
    }

    // ========================================================================
    // Partition & generated column rendering hooks
    // ========================================================================

    /// Render a time partition expression for a column and granularity.
    ///
    /// Granularity values: `"hourly"`, `"daily"`, `"weekly"`, `"monthly"`,
    /// `"quarterly"`, `"yearly"`.
    ///
    /// Default: `date_trunc('unit', column)` (ANSI / `PostgreSQL` style),
    /// mapping granularity names to `date_trunc` units.
    fn render_time_partition_expr(&self, column: &str, granularity: &str) -> String {
        let unit = match granularity {
            "hourly" => "hour",
            "daily" => "day",
            "weekly" => "week",
            "monthly" => "month",
            "quarterly" => "quarter",
            "yearly" => "year",
            other => other,
        };
        format!("date_trunc('{unit}', {column})")
    }

    /// Render a DDL partition clause wrapping the expression list.
    ///
    /// Default: `PARTITION BY (expr)`. Snowflake: `CLUSTER BY (expr)`,
    /// Databricks: `PARTITIONED BY (expr)`, `ClickHouse`: `PARTITION BY expr` (no parens).
    fn render_partition_clause(&self, expr: &str) -> String {
        format!("PARTITION BY ({expr})")
    }

    /// Render a generated column declaration.
    ///
    /// Default: `name GENERATED ALWAYS AS (expr) STORED` (`PostgreSQL` style).
    fn render_generated_column(&self, name: &str, expr: &str) -> String {
        format!("{name} GENERATED ALWAYS AS ({expr}) STORED")
    }

    // ========================================================================
    // Window function capability hooks
    // ========================================================================

    /// Whether the platform supports the EXCLUDE clause in window frame specifications.
    ///
    /// `PostgreSQL`, Snowflake, Databricks: `true`. Others: `false`.
    fn supports_window_frame_exclude(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether the platform supports the GROUPS frame mode in window functions.
    ///
    /// `PostgreSQL`, Databricks: `true`. Others: `false`.
    fn supports_window_frame_groups(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether the platform supports named windows (WINDOW clause).
    ///
    /// Most platforms: `true`. `ClickHouse`, `DuckDB`, `MariaDB`: `false`.
    fn supports_named_windows(&self) -> bool {
        true
    }

    // ========================================================================
    // DDL table-scope capability hooks
    // ========================================================================

    /// Whether the platform uses a `#` prefix for session-scoped temporary table names.
    ///
    /// SQL Server: `true`. Others: `false`.
    fn uses_hash_temp_table_prefix(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether the platform supports `DECLARE @name TABLE (...)` table variables.
    ///
    /// SQL Server: `true`. Others: `false`.
    fn supports_table_variables(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// The full CREATE keyword for session-scoped temporary tables.
    ///
    /// Default: `"CREATE TEMPORARY"`.
    /// SQL Server: `"CREATE"` (uses `#name` instead of TEMPORARY keyword).
    /// Databricks: `"CREATE OR REPLACE TEMPORARY"`.
    fn render_create_temp_table_keyword(&self) -> &'static str {
        "CREATE TEMPORARY"
    }

    /// Whether the platform supports transient tables (e.g. `CREATE TRANSIENT TABLE`).
    ///
    /// Snowflake: `true`. Others: `false`.
    fn supports_transient_tables(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether the platform supports `ON COMMIT DROP` for transaction-scoped temp tables.
    ///
    /// `PostgreSQL`, `CitusDB`: `true`. Others: `false`.
    fn supports_on_commit_drop(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether the platform requires an `ENGINE = ...` clause on CREATE TABLE.
    ///
    /// `ClickHouse`: `true`. Others: `false`.
    ///
    /// A platform that answers `true` owns its whole engine suffix in ONE place:
    /// the `CREATE TABLE` composer emits the engine, then the sorting key, then
    /// whatever the resolved storage plan contributes. A storage renderer for
    /// such a platform must therefore contribute NEITHER an engine clause nor a
    /// sorting key — two engine clauses is `Code: 62 … Syntax error`, and a
    /// sorting key that disagrees with the inline `PRIMARY KEY` is
    /// `Code: 36 … Primary key must be a prefix of the sorting key` (both
    /// measured on `ClickHouse` 24.10.2).
    fn requires_table_engine(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether this platform's table sorting key refuses nullable columns.
    ///
    /// `ClickHouse`: `true` — a `MergeTree` sorting key containing a
    /// `Nullable(…)` column answers `Code: 44 … Sorting key contains nullable
    /// columns, but merge tree setting allow_nullable_key is disabled`, measured
    /// on 24.10.2 against the control (the same key over a non-nullable column
    /// of the same type is accepted). Others: `false`.
    ///
    /// The materializer asks this before it lets a design's clustering columns
    /// into a sorting key, so the answer is a refusal the author can act on
    /// rather than a deployment failure they cannot.
    fn sorting_key_refuses_nullable_columns(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether the platform requires a primary key on every table.
    ///
    /// `ClickHouse` (MergeTree): `true`. Others: `false`.
    fn requires_primary_key_in_create_table(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Create a boxed [`FormulaRenderer`](crate::FormulaRenderer) for this dialect.
    ///
    /// Real dialect implementations override this to return `Box::new(Self)`.
    /// The default returns an ANSI dialect with standard function names.
    fn to_formula_renderer(&self) -> Box<dyn crate::FormulaRenderer> {
        Box::new(crate::AnsiDialect)
    }
}

/// Level 2 — Expression rendering with ANSI SQL defaults.
pub trait ExpressionRenderer: SqlRenderer {
    /// Render a CAST expression.
    fn render_cast(&self, expr: &str, target: &DataType) -> String {
        format!("CAST({} AS {})", expr, self.render_data_type(target))
    }

    /// Render string concatenation.
    fn render_concat(&self, parts: &[String]) -> String {
        format!("CONCAT({})", parts.join(", "))
    }

    /// Render a COALESCE expression.
    fn render_coalesce(&self, parts: &[String]) -> String {
        format!("COALESCE({})", parts.join(", "))
    }

    /// Render a string aggregation function.
    fn render_string_agg(&self, expr: &str, separator: &str) -> String {
        format!("STRING_AGG({expr}, '{separator}')")
    }
}

/// A foreign key's referential action — SQL's own five words, no synonyms.
///
/// Lives here (rather than in the table model) so a dialect can answer
/// [`DdlRenderer::supports_foreign_key_action`] about a specific action
/// without depending on the modeling crate.
#[derive(Debug, Clone, Copy, PartialEq, Eq, Hash)]
pub enum ReferentialAction {
    /// Also delete or update the referencing rows
    Cascade,
    /// Set the referencing columns to NULL
    SetNull,
    /// Reject the delete or update; some engines defer the check
    Restrict,
    /// Reject the delete or update (the SQL default)
    NoAction,
    /// Set the referencing columns to their default values
    SetDefault,
}

impl ReferentialAction {
    /// Parses the SQL words, case-insensitively; underscores read as spaces
    /// so `set_null` and `SET NULL` both land.
    ///
    /// # Errors
    /// Returns a plain message listing the valid words when the input is not
    /// one of them.
    pub fn from_sql_word(word: &str) -> Result<Self, String> {
        match word.trim().replace('_', " ").to_uppercase().as_str() {
            "CASCADE" => Ok(Self::Cascade),
            "SET NULL" => Ok(Self::SetNull),
            "RESTRICT" => Ok(Self::Restrict),
            "NO ACTION" => Ok(Self::NoAction),
            "SET DEFAULT" => Ok(Self::SetDefault),
            _ => Err(format!(
                "'{word}' is not a referential action. Use one of: CASCADE, SET NULL, \
                 RESTRICT, NO ACTION, SET DEFAULT."
            )),
        }
    }
}

impl std::fmt::Display for ReferentialAction {
    fn fmt(&self, f: &mut std::fmt::Formatter<'_>) -> std::fmt::Result {
        match self {
            Self::Cascade => write!(f, "CASCADE"),
            Self::SetNull => write!(f, "SET NULL"),
            Self::Restrict => write!(f, "RESTRICT"),
            Self::NoAction => write!(f, "NO ACTION"),
            Self::SetDefault => write!(f, "SET DEFAULT"),
        }
    }
}

/// Level 3 — DDL rendering with reasonable defaults.
pub trait DdlRenderer: SqlRenderer {
    /// Prefix for CREATE TABLE statements.
    fn render_create_table_prefix(&self) -> &'static str {
        "CREATE TABLE"
    }

    /// Whether this engine carries the given foreign-key referential action
    /// (`ON DELETE …` / `ON UPDATE …`) in `CREATE TABLE` DDL.
    ///
    /// The ANSI default says yes to all five words. A dialect answers `false`
    /// for an action its engine rejects or silently never enforces; the
    /// renderer then keeps the author's declaration visible as a plain
    /// comment instead of emitting a clause the engine would refuse — a
    /// declared action never vanishes without a trace.
    fn supports_foreign_key_action(&self, action: ReferentialAction) -> bool {
        let _ = action;
        true
    }

    /// Prefix for CREATE VIEW statements.
    fn render_create_view_prefix(&self) -> &'static str {
        "CREATE OR REPLACE VIEW"
    }

    /// Render a column definition (name, type, nullability).
    fn render_column_definition(&self, name: &str, dt: &DataType, nullable: bool) -> String {
        let quoted = self.quote_identifier(name);
        let (type_str, null_str) = if nullable {
            (self.render_nullable_data_type(dt), "")
        } else {
            (self.render_data_type(dt), " NOT NULL")
        };
        format!("{quoted} {type_str}{null_str}")
    }

    /// Render the surrogate identity column — a plain, ungenerated `BIGINT NOT
    /// NULL` on **every** dialect.
    ///
    /// **razeri's surrogate keys are logical and DETERMINATE, never
    /// engine-generated.** The identity value is a hash
    /// derived from the entity's identity grain, WRITTEN BY THE LOAD
    /// (`materialize_core`, `sid_expression`), so the same design loaded with the
    /// same data converges to the same key on `Postgres`, `Snowflake`, `MariaDB`,
    /// `ClickHouse` — every target. A database-assigned `AUTO_INCREMENT` /
    /// `IDENTITY(1,1)` / `GENERATED ALWAYS AS IDENTITY` would be sequential,
    /// load-order-dependent and **non-portable** — a different key per database
    /// for the same row — which is the one thing a portable key may not be. So no
    /// dialect emits a generator here; every one renders a plain column and the
    /// load fills it.
    ///
    /// `SQLite` narrows the type to `INTEGER` and `ClickHouse`/`DuckDB` carry
    /// their own overrides only to document the same plain shape; no override
    /// re-introduces a generator.
    ///
    /// The `_data_type` argument is reserved for future use (e.g., dialect-aware
    /// width selection); current dialects always emit `BIGINT` / `INTEGER`.
    fn render_identity_column(&self, name: &str, _data_type: &DataType) -> String {
        let quoted = self.quote_identifier(name);
        format!("{quoted} BIGINT NOT NULL")
    }

    /// Whether this platform's engine actually **assigns** an identity column's
    /// value, rather than merely tolerating the declaration.
    ///
    /// **This is a dialect fact, not a field fact, and the difference is a
    /// deploy-time failure.** `Field::identity` says razeri intends the engine
    /// to generate the value; whether it does depends entirely on the target.
    /// `render_identity_column`'s own table above records that `DuckDB`,
    /// `SQLite` and `ClickHouse` have **no native identity** — there the column
    /// comes out as a plain `NOT NULL` and **the writer must supply it.**
    ///
    /// The default is `false` because the default `render_identity_column`
    /// emits no generation clause: a dialect that overrides the rendering to
    /// generate values must override this too, and
    /// `the_identity_capability_matches_what_each_dialect_renders` holds the two
    /// in step so they cannot drift.
    ///
    /// Read by the deploy bundle's write contract: a column
    /// the engine does not generate is a column a hand-written `INSERT` owes.
    fn generates_identity_values(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// **The latest instant this platform can hold EXACTLY in the column it
    /// renders for `data_type`** — the ceiling the refuse-by-name rule compares
    /// against, or `None` for *no declared ceiling*.
    ///
    /// Spelled `YYYY-MM-DD HH:MM:SS`, which is how razeri writes a timestamp
    /// literal (`razeri_materialize::convert::OPEN_INTERVAL_SENTINEL`), so the
    /// comparison is a string comparison over a format that sorts
    /// chronologically. A ceiling and a value in the same spelling cannot be
    /// compared wrongly by a parser neither of them goes through.
    ///
    /// # What the refusal contract asks of this
    ///
    /// > A value razeri cannot store exactly on a target platform is a
    /// > deploy-time refusal naming the value, the column, the platform and the
    /// > ceiling — never a truncation, never a saturated write.
    ///
    /// The *refusal* lives in `razeri_materialize::bundle`, which is the one
    /// place it is built — the function is `refuse_unrepresentable_values`, and
    /// it is reached from `generate_bundle` before a single file is rendered.
    /// This is only where a platform declares the number.
    ///
    /// # A stated variance from the decision's original wording
    ///
    /// The refusal was decided as a *deploy-time* act, homed in the
    /// prerequisites step. Razeri refuses **earlier**: at bundle
    /// generation, by declining to emit the bundle at all. That is strictly
    /// ahead of deploy time and cannot be skipped by an operator who never runs
    /// the script — a deliberate strengthening, recorded rather
    /// than glossed. The consequence worth knowing: a *hand-assembled* bundle,
    /// or one from an older razeri, is not re-checked at deploy time by
    /// anything. **The default is `None`, which
    /// means "razeri has no measured ceiling for this platform and type" and not
    /// "this platform holds everything"** — an unmeasured platform gets no
    /// refusal rather than an invented one.
    ///
    /// # The ceiling is a property of the TYPE, not of the platform
    ///
    /// That is the half a platform-flat capability would get wrong, and it is
    /// measured rather than assumed (reading the renderers):
    ///
    /// | platform | `Timestamp(p)` renders | ceiling | `TimestampTz(p)` renders | ceiling |
    /// |---|---|---|---|---|
    /// | `MySQL`, `MariaDB` | `DATETIME(p)` | `None` — the end of the four-digit calendar is not a constraint | `TIMESTAMP(p)` | **`2038-01-19 03:14:07`** |
    /// | `ClickHouse` | `DateTime64(p)` | `2299-12-31 23:59:59` at p ≤ 6, **`2262-04-11 23:47:16`** at p ≥ 7 | `DateTime64(p,'UTC')` | the same |
    /// | everything else | — | not measured → `None` | — | `None` |
    ///
    /// On `MySQL` the two razeri type variants land on *different engine types*
    /// and get different answers: `Timestamp` renders as the
    /// non-converting `DATETIME` — the type whose semantics match the declared
    /// non-tz timestamp — which runs to the end of the calendar and so
    /// declares no ceiling at all, while `TimestampTz` keeps `TIMESTAMP` and its
    /// 32-bit epoch boundary. A check keyed on the platform alone would either
    /// miss the real ceiling or refuse a column that is fine. On `ClickHouse`
    /// the ceiling moves with the **declared precision** of one type:
    /// `DateTime64(9)` is int64 nanoseconds from the epoch and stops at
    /// 2262-04-11, while `DateTime64(6)` reaches 2299.
    ///
    /// Parameters:
    /// - `data_type`: the column's declared type, as the design carries it —
    ///   not the rendered string, because the precision is what moves the answer
    ///   and re-parsing it back out of `DateTime64(9)` would be a second reading
    ///   of what the dialect already knows.
    fn representable_timestamp_ceiling(&self, data_type: &DataType) -> Option<&'static str> {
        let _ = data_type;
        None
    }

    /// Whether the platform requires every auto-increment / identity column to
    /// be the leading column of an index (PK or KEY).
    ///
    /// `MySQL` / `MariaDB`: `true` (otherwise error 1075). Others: `false`.
    ///
    /// When this is `true` and an identity column is not already the leading
    /// column of the primary key, the DDL renderer must emit an additional
    /// `KEY (identity_col)` clause on the table.
    fn auto_increment_requires_key(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Prefix for DROP TABLE statements.
    fn render_drop_table_prefix(&self, if_exists: bool) -> String {
        if if_exists { "DROP TABLE IF EXISTS".to_string() } else { "DROP TABLE".to_string() }
    }

    /// Prefix for DROP VIEW statements.
    fn render_drop_view_prefix(&self, if_exists: bool) -> String {
        if if_exists { "DROP VIEW IF EXISTS".to_string() } else { "DROP VIEW".to_string() }
    }

    /// Prefix for CREATE SCHEMA / CREATE NAMESPACE.
    fn render_create_schema_prefix(&self, if_not_exists: bool) -> String {
        if if_not_exists {
            "CREATE SCHEMA IF NOT EXISTS".to_string()
        } else {
            "CREATE SCHEMA".to_string()
        }
    }

    /// Render a complete CREATE SCHEMA statement.
    ///
    /// Dialects that need fundamentally different syntax (e.g. T-SQL wrapping
    /// in `IF SCHEMA_ID(...) IS NULL EXEC(...)`) should override this method.
    /// The default concatenates [`Self::render_create_schema_prefix`] with the name.
    fn render_create_schema_statement(&self, name: &str, if_not_exists: bool) -> String {
        let prefix = self.render_create_schema_prefix(if_not_exists);
        format!("{prefix} {name}")
    }

    /// Render a table comment (platform-specific syntax).
    ///
    /// Like [`Self::render_column_comment`], nothing in the tree calls this and
    /// no dialect overrides it — **and unlike its sibling it has not been
    /// measured.** Read that method's table before wiring either: the ANSI
    /// spelling is a hard syntax error on five of the ten platforms razeri
    /// renders for at the column level, and this form was not probed.
    fn render_table_comment(&self, table: &str, comment: &str) -> Option<String> {
        Some(format!("COMMENT ON TABLE {table} IS '{comment}'"))
    }

    /// Render a column comment — **not wired to anything, and measured**.
    ///
    /// # Nothing calls this
    ///
    /// No caller in the tree, no dialect override, and, until measured, no
    /// execution against a live engine — the exact state the column `DEFAULT`
    /// clause was in when it turned out to be refused outright on four platforms
    /// of ten and silently wrong on a fifth. Moving the open
    /// interval's meaning here was proposed **on the condition that it be measured first**,
    /// because *"a comment that fails to compile is a worse outcome than the
    /// clause it replaced"*.
    ///
    /// # It was measured, on ten platforms, and this ANSI form is right on five
    ///
    /// Executed against six containers, in-process `DuckDB` and
    /// `SQLite`, and both live cloud accounts:
    ///
    /// | platform | this `COMMENT ON COLUMN` | inline `COMMENT` in `CREATE TABLE` | what it does take |
    /// |---|---|---|---|
    /// | `PostgreSQL`, Citus | ✅ | ❌ syntax error | this, as a separate statement |
    /// | `DuckDB` | ✅ | ❌ syntax error | this, as a separate statement |
    /// | Snowflake, Databricks | ✅ | ✅ | either |
    /// | `ClickHouse` | ❌ `SYNTAX_ERROR` (code 62) | ✅ | inline, or `ALTER TABLE … COMMENT COLUMN c '…'` |
    /// | `MySQL`, `MariaDB` | ❌ `ERROR 1064` | ✅ | inline, or `ALTER TABLE … MODIFY <whole column definition> COMMENT '…'` |
    /// | SQL Server | ❌ `Msg 156, Incorrect syntax near the keyword 'ON'` | ❌ `Msg 102` | `EXEC sp_addextendedproperty …` — a stored procedure, not DDL |
    /// | `SQLite` | ❌ syntax error | ❌ syntax error | **nothing at all** |
    ///
    /// Four mechanisms for ten platforms, and two of them carry a hazard the
    /// `DEFAULT` clause never had:
    ///
    /// - `MySQL`'s and `MariaDB`'s only `ALTER` route **redefines the column**.
    ///   Measured: a `MODIFY` that did not restate `NOT NULL` left
    ///   `is_nullable = YES` behind it. A documentation mechanism that can
    ///   silently de-constrain a column is strictly worse than the clause it
    ///   replaces.
    /// - SQL Server's `sp_addextendedproperty` **is not idempotent**:
    ///   `Msg 15233 — Property 'MS_Description' already exists`. Razeri emits
    ///   `CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS` so a deploy bundle can be re-applied; a
    ///   comment mechanism that fails on the second run takes that away.
    ///
    /// # So the escape hatch was taken
    ///
    /// Q1's answer included its own fall-back — *"if the measurement comes back
    /// ugly, take the simpler answer: no comment, and the bundle README carries
    /// the contract"* — and the measurement is ugly. **Razeri emits no column
    /// comment.** The open interval's meaning ships instead in the deploy
    /// bundle's generated *write contract*
    /// (`razeri_materialize::bundle::write_contract`, Q5), which is prose an
    /// operator reads, is right on all ten platforms because no engine parses
    /// it, and is owed regardless of how this measurement came out.
    ///
    /// The hook stays, unchanged and unwired, for the same reason
    /// `render_column_default` stays: a dialect that genuinely wants to emit one
    /// has somewhere to say so. **A dialect that overrides this owes a
    /// measurement first** — the ANSI spelling below is a hard syntax error on
    /// five of the ten platforms razeri renders for.
    fn render_column_comment(&self, table: &str, column: &str, comment: &str) -> Option<String> {
        Some(format!("COMMENT ON COLUMN {table}.{column} IS '{comment}'"))
    }

    /// Whether to render IF NOT EXISTS on CREATE TABLE.
    fn supports_if_not_exists(&self) -> bool {
        true
    }

    /// Render a column's `DEFAULT` clause — **keyword included** — or decline it.
    ///
    /// `None` means *this dialect renders no default clause for this value*, and
    /// [`render_field`](../../razeri_sql/domain/ddl/fn.render_field.html) omits
    /// the whole clause. The ANSI default returns `None` for every value, which
    /// is the write-contract rule expressed where the renderer can see it:
    /// **razeri emits no
    /// column `DEFAULT` clause in rendered DDL, on any platform, for any value —
    /// a value the generated load owns is written by the load, never by the
    /// schema.**
    ///
    /// *Read that qualifier deliberately.* The sentence is about the DDL an engine
    /// executes. The `.raz.sql` **agnostic interchange** form —
    /// `Table::to_ddl()`, which `Table::from_ddl()` parses back — still
    /// serializes `Field::default_value` as `DEFAULT <value>`, because that is
    /// where a design's declared default survives a save and a load.
    ///
    /// **That exception is a serializer, not a platform, and the word "agnostic"
    /// names both.** `to_ddl()` renders through a free function and consults no
    /// dialect; you reach it by calling it, never by choosing a target.
    /// `SchemaObject::render_ddl` short-circuits to it only for a renderer whose
    /// [`SqlRenderer::is_agnostic_dialect`] answers `true` — which defaults to
    /// `false` here and is overridden by exactly one type in the tree,
    /// `AnsiDialect`, which no registration hands out. The platform the registry
    /// publishes under the name `agnostic` is `AgnosticDialect`; it does **not**
    /// override the method, so it declines the clause like every other target.
    /// The rule therefore holds on all eleven registered platforms, `agnostic`
    /// included, on every rendering path — pinned by
    /// `the_registered_agnostic_platform_is_not_the_interchange_form` in
    /// `crates/razeri-sql/tests/portable_column_defaults_census.rs`.
    ///
    /// # Why the keyword lives in here
    ///
    /// It used to be concatenated by the caller — `parts.push(format!("DEFAULT
    /// {rendered}"))` — so the hook could rewrite a value and **could not decline
    /// a clause**: a dialect returning `""` emitted a bare dangling `DEFAULT`.
    /// This is the same correction made for
    /// statement boundaries: *the emission declares the boundary; a consumer
    /// never infers it.*
    ///
    /// # Why the hook survives the decision
    ///
    /// `Field::default_value` stays on the struct, so the design
    /// still knows what a column's intended default is, and a future dialect that
    /// genuinely wants to emit one has somewhere to say so. The distinction being
    /// bought is between **what razeri knows** and **what razeri emits**.
    ///
    /// A dialect that overrides this owes the whole clause, keyword and all —
    /// `Some(format!("DEFAULT {value}"))` — because there is nowhere else it is
    /// added.
    fn render_column_default(&self, value: &str) -> Option<String> {
        let _ = value;
        None
    }

    /// **Spell an author's OWN declared default in this engine's words.**
    ///
    /// This is the other sense of "default", and the seam a dialect had no way
    /// to reach. [`render_column_default`](Self::render_column_default) governs
    /// the tables Razeri's generated load owns, and it declines everywhere by
    /// design. A `tile: base` table is the ruled exception: the author owns
    /// every column, no generated statement writes into it, and the declared
    /// default is an engine constraint they asked for — so it is rendered, on
    /// every platform, and it used to be rendered **verbatim**.
    ///
    /// Verbatim is a portability hole with the design's own words in it. A
    /// design declaring `default: CURRENT_TIMESTAMP` is asking for *the current
    /// moment*, not for those eighteen characters; on `BigQuery` those
    /// characters name the zone-aware type, the column Razeri builds is
    /// `DATETIME`, and the `CREATE TABLE` is refused outright — *"Column
    /// default expression has type TIMESTAMP which cannot be assigned to column
    /// type DATETIME"*. The design was right and had nowhere to be translated.
    ///
    /// The default returns the value unchanged, which is exactly today's
    /// behaviour on every platform, so a dialect that says nothing renders what
    /// it always did.
    ///
    /// # A dialect overriding this owes a measurement, and owes restraint
    ///
    /// Translate an expression whose *meaning* your engine spells differently.
    /// Do not rewrite an author's literal, do not widen a type, and do not
    /// silently drop a default you cannot express — an author who declared one
    /// and got none has a column that fills with NULL and a document that says
    /// otherwise. Where the engine has no equivalent at all, leave the value
    /// alone and let the engine refuse it: a loud failure belongs to the value
    /// the author wrote, and a quiet substitution belongs to nobody.
    ///
    /// Parameters:
    /// - `value`: the default exactly as the design declares it.
    /// - `column_type`: the type of the column it is being assigned to —
    ///   load-bearing, because the same expression is legal against one type
    ///   and refused against another on the same engine.
    fn render_declared_column_default(&self, value: &str, column_type: &DataType) -> String {
        let _ = column_type;
        value.to_owned()
    }

    // ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
    // DDL Extensions (Phase 1 debt removal)
    // ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════

    /// Render a BEGIN transaction statement.
    ///
    /// `PostgreSQL`: `BEGIN`, `SqlServer`: `BEGIN TRANSACTION`, `ClickHouse`: empty (no DDL transactions)
    fn render_begin_transaction(&self) -> &'static str {
        "BEGIN"
    }

    /// Render a COMMIT transaction statement.
    fn render_commit(&self) -> &'static str {
        "COMMIT"
    }

    /// Whether the platform supports DDL transactions.
    fn supports_ddl_transactions(&self) -> bool {
        true
    }

    /// Render a DROP FUNCTION statement with optional parameter types for overloaded functions.
    fn render_drop_function(&self, name: &str, param_types: &[&str], if_exists: bool) -> String {
        let exists = if if_exists { " IF EXISTS" } else { "" };
        if param_types.is_empty() {
            format!("DROP FUNCTION{exists} {name}")
        } else {
            format!("DROP FUNCTION{exists} {name}({})", param_types.join(", "))
        }
    }

    /// Render the drop keyword for a SQL object type.
    fn render_drop_object_keyword(&self, obj_type: &str) -> String {
        obj_type.to_uppercase()
    }

    /// Render the CREATE VIEW keyword/prefix with `secure/global_temp` modifiers.
    fn render_create_view_keyword(&self, secure: bool, global_temp: bool) -> String {
        let mut parts = vec!["CREATE OR REPLACE"];
        if secure {
            parts.push("SECURE");
        }
        if global_temp {
            parts.push("GLOBAL TEMPORARY");
        }
        parts.push("VIEW");
        parts.join(" ")
    }

    /// Render an IF EXISTS clause for ALTER TABLE DROP COLUMN/CONSTRAINT.
    ///
    /// Some platforms (`SqlServer`, Databricks, `MariaDB`) don't support IF EXISTS in ALTER DROP.
    fn supports_alter_drop_if_exists(&self) -> bool {
        true
    }

    // ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
    // Drop Behavior Hooks (Phase 4.1 debt removal)
    // ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════

    /// Whether DROP INDEX uses ON syntax: `DROP INDEX idx ON table` (`SqlServer`).
    fn drop_index_uses_on_syntax(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// **Whether this engine checks the constraints it accepts.**
    ///
    /// The default is [`ConstraintEnforcement::Enforced`] — eight of Razeri's
    /// registered platforms, and the safe assumption for a dialect that has not
    /// said, because *"this engine guarantees nothing"* is the unusual claim.
    ///
    /// Answer [`ConstraintEnforcement::DeclaredOnly`] where a `PRIMARY KEY`,
    /// `FOREIGN KEY` or `UNIQUE` is accepted and never checked. Two engines are
    /// that, in two different ways, and the type carries both:
    ///
    /// - `BigQuery` has the words. `NOT ENFORCED` is the only legal spelling,
    ///   so the keyword goes on the constraint line and the engine makes the
    ///   declaration honest by itself.
    /// - `Redshift` has no words. It takes all three constraints, checks none,
    ///   and renders DDL a reader cannot tell from `PostgreSQL`'s — so the note
    ///   is written above the constraint list instead, and it is the only place
    ///   that DDL says what it means.
    ///
    /// [`key_constraint_suffix`](Self::key_constraint_suffix) reads this, so
    /// stating enforcement states the suffix too.
    fn constraint_enforcement(&self) -> ConstraintEnforcement {
        ConstraintEnforcement::Enforced
    }

    /// **The words a key constraint must carry to be accepted at all.**
    ///
    /// Appended to a table-level `PRIMARY KEY (…)` and to a
    /// `FOREIGN KEY (…) REFERENCES …`. Empty on every engine that enforces its
    /// keys, and empty on a declaring engine that has no keyword for it.
    ///
    /// The default reads
    /// [`constraint_enforcement`](Self::constraint_enforcement), so the two are
    /// one fact rather than two that must be kept in step. Override this only
    /// for a keyword a key constraint needs for some *other* reason than
    /// enforcement — there is no such engine in Razeri's set today.
    fn key_constraint_suffix(&self) -> &'static str {
        self.constraint_enforcement().keyword()
    }

    /// Whether a table-level `UNIQUE (…)` constraint is part of the grammar.
    ///
    /// `false` on an engine that has no such constraint at all, where the
    /// declaration is left out of the `CREATE TABLE` and named in a comment
    /// beside it rather than emitted and refused.
    fn supports_unique_constraint(&self) -> bool {
        true
    }

    /// Whether a table-level `CHECK (…)` constraint is part of the grammar.
    ///
    /// `false` on an engine that has none, with the same treatment as
    /// [`supports_unique_constraint`](Self::supports_unique_constraint): named
    /// in a comment, never written as SQL the engine will reject.
    fn supports_check_constraint(&self) -> bool {
        true
    }

    /// Whether the platform supports CASCADE/RESTRICT in DROP statements.
    ///
    /// True for `PostgreSQL`, `CitusDB`, `DuckDB`, Snowflake, Agnostic.
    /// False for `SqlServer`, `ClickHouse`, Databricks, `MySQL`, `MariaDB`.
    fn supports_cascade_drop(&self) -> bool {
        true
    }

    /// Whether `COMMENT ON PROCEDURE` is part of the grammar.
    ///
    /// `true` almost everywhere, and **false on `Redshift`**, where
    /// `COMMENT ON FUNCTION`, `COMMENT ON VIEW` and `COMMENT ON COLUMN` all
    /// exist and the procedure form alone does not: *"syntax error at or near
    /// `PROCEDURE`"*, measured on a live workgroup. A description is worth
    /// having and is not worth a statement that stops the script, so a
    /// declining engine simply carries no description on its procedures.
    fn supports_procedure_comment(&self) -> bool {
        true
    }

    /// Whether the platform supports function argument types in DROP FUNCTION.
    ///
    /// False for `ClickHouse` (no overloaded functions).
    fn supports_drop_function_arg_types(&self) -> bool {
        true
    }

    /// Whether the platform supports SYNC option for DROP (`ClickHouse`).
    fn supports_sync_drop(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether the platform supports FORCE option for DROP (Databricks).
    fn supports_force_drop(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }

    /// Whether the platform supports CASCADE in ALTER TABLE DROP.
    ///
    /// Only `PostgreSQL`, `CitusDB`, `DuckDB` support CASCADE in ALTER TABLE DROP.
    fn supports_alter_drop_cascade(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }
}

/// **One row, written once** — the pieces of an INSERT that must do nothing
/// when a row already carries the same key.
///
/// The key value is not a field of its own: it is whichever `values` entry sits
/// at the same index as the key column in `columns`. Two fields that must agree
/// are two fields free to disagree, and the one they would disagree about here
/// is the one that decides whether a second write is a duplicate.
#[derive(Debug, Clone, Copy)]
pub struct InsertIfAbsent<'a> {
    /// The target table, already spelled the way the caller wants it written —
    /// schema-qualified or bare.
    pub table: &'a str,
    /// The columns being written, in the order `values` supplies them.
    pub columns: &'a [&'a str],
    /// One value expression per column.
    pub values: &'a [String],
    /// The columns whose equality means *this row is already here*.
    pub key_columns: &'a [&'a str],
}

impl InsertIfAbsent<'_> {
    /// The value expression written into `column`, if it is being written.
    #[must_use]
    pub fn value_of(&self, column: &str) -> Option<&str> {
        let at = self.columns.iter().position(|name| *name == column)?;
        self.values.get(at).map(String::as_str)
    }

    /// `key = value AND …` — the test for *already here*, in terms of the
    /// values this INSERT would have written.
    ///
    /// `qualifier` prefixes the column side, which the guarded form needs so
    /// the probe's own row is named unambiguously.
    ///
    /// # Panics
    ///
    /// When a key column is not among the columns being written. A key the
    /// INSERT does not supply cannot be tested for, and silently dropping it
    /// from the predicate would make the guard match everything.
    #[must_use]
    pub fn key_predicate(&self, qualifier: &str) -> String {
        self.key_columns
            .iter()
            .map(|column| {
                let value = self
                    .value_of(column)
                    .unwrap_or_else(|| panic!("{column} is a key column and must be written"));
                format!("{qualifier}{column} = {value}")
            })
            .collect::<Vec<_>>()
            .join(" AND ")
    }

    /// **`ON CONFLICT (key) DO NOTHING`** — for the platforms that let the
    /// engine decide, which is every platform that has the clause.
    ///
    /// The engine tests the key as it writes, so two sessions registering one
    /// file at the same moment settle on one row rather than on whichever of
    /// them looked first.
    #[must_use]
    pub fn on_conflict_do_nothing(&self) -> String {
        format!(
            "{}\n{}\nON CONFLICT ({}) DO NOTHING;",
            self.target(),
            self.values_clause(),
            self.key_columns.join(", ")
        )
    }

    /// **`ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE key = key`** — the `MySQL` family's no-op.
    ///
    /// `INSERT IGNORE` would be shorter and it is not the same request: it
    /// downgrades *every* error on the statement to a warning — a truncated
    /// value, a bad date — so a row that should have been refused arrives
    /// mangled and silent. Assigning the key to itself touches only the
    /// collision this is about, and leaves everything else to complain
    /// normally.
    #[must_use]
    pub fn on_duplicate_key_no_op(&self) -> String {
        let held = self
            .key_columns
            .iter()
            .map(|column| format!("{column} = {column}"))
            .collect::<Vec<_>>()
            .join(", ");
        format!("{}\n{}\nON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE {held};", self.target(), self.values_clause())
    }

    /// **The guarded form over an explicit one-row source** — the same
    /// `INSERT … SELECT … WHERE NOT EXISTS` the portable default writes, with a
    /// `FROM` clause under it.
    ///
    /// `GoogleSQL` refuses a `WHERE` on a query that selects from nothing —
    /// *"Query without FROM clause cannot have a WHERE clause"*, measured on the
    /// live service on every generated `register_file` procedure — while
    /// `PostgreSQL` and its cousins accept the bare form. `(SELECT 1)` is a
    /// one-row table that changes no result: the guard still decides whether
    /// the row is written, and the values are still the caller's.
    ///
    /// It stays a separate form rather than becoming the default because the
    /// engines that need no `FROM` read better without one, and a clause every
    /// platform carries for one platform's sake is how a rendering stops saying
    /// what it means.
    #[must_use]
    pub fn guarded_over_one_row(&self) -> String {
        format!(
            "{}\nSELECT {}\nFROM (SELECT 1)\nWHERE NOT EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM {} WHERE {});",
            self.target(),
            self.values.join(", "),
            self.table,
            self.key_predicate("")
        )
    }

    /// `INSERT INTO t (a, b)` — shared by every form below.
    fn target(&self) -> String {
        format!("INSERT INTO {} ({})", self.table, self.columns.join(", "))
    }

    /// `VALUES (…)`.
    fn values_clause(&self) -> String {
        format!("VALUES ({})", self.values.join(", "))
    }
}

/// Level 4 — DML rendering with reasonable defaults.
pub trait DmlRenderer: SqlRenderer {
    /// Prefix for INSERT statements.
    fn render_insert_prefix(&self) -> &'static str {
        "INSERT INTO"
    }

    /// **Write one row, and do nothing if its key is already there.**
    ///
    /// Every platform can express this and they do not agree on how, so the
    /// spelling belongs to the dialect and not to the caller. The default is
    /// the portable one — an `INSERT … SELECT` guarded by `WHERE NOT EXISTS` —
    /// which needs no upsert syntax at all and is therefore the right answer
    /// for a platform nobody has written an arm for. Platforms with a native
    /// idiom override it: `ON CONFLICT … DO NOTHING` where that exists,
    /// `ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE` on the `MySQL` family.
    ///
    /// **No dialect is left without an idempotent form.** The guarded form is
    /// weaker than the native ones under concurrency — two sessions can both
    /// find the row absent and both insert — which is why a platform that can
    /// let the engine decide should, and why this one leans on the key's own
    /// uniqueness constraint to catch the race rather than pretending it cannot
    /// happen. On an engine that enforces no key at all the guard is the whole
    /// of what there is, and it is worth saying so rather than implying more.
    fn render_insert_if_absent(&self, insert: &InsertIfAbsent<'_>) -> String {
        format!(
            "{}\nSELECT {}\nWHERE NOT EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM {} WHERE {});",
            insert.target(),
            insert.values.join(", "),
            insert.table,
            insert.key_predicate("")
        )
    }

    /// Prefix for MERGE statements.
    fn render_merge_prefix(&self) -> &'static str {
        "MERGE INTO"
    }

    /// Render the platform's upsert strategy keyword.
    ///
    /// Returns `None` if platform doesn't support upsert natively.
    fn render_upsert_strategy(&self) -> Option<&str> {
        None
    }

    /// Render RETURNING / OUTPUT clause for INSERT/UPDATE.
    fn render_returning_clause(&self, _columns: &[&str]) -> Option<String> {
        None
    }

    /// Render a LIMIT clause.
    fn render_limit_clause(&self, n: usize) -> String {
        format!("LIMIT {n}")
    }

    /// Render a temporary table prefix or keyword.
    fn render_temp_table_prefix(&self) -> &'static str {
        "TEMPORARY"
    }
}

/// Level 5 — Stored procedure / function rendering with defaults.
pub trait ProcedureRenderer: SqlRenderer {
    /// Prefix for CREATE PROCEDURE.
    fn render_create_procedure_prefix(&self) -> &'static str {
        "CREATE OR REPLACE PROCEDURE"
    }

    /// Prefix for CREATE FUNCTION.
    fn render_create_function_prefix(&self) -> &'static str {
        "CREATE OR REPLACE FUNCTION"
    }

    /// Render a variable declaration inside a procedure body.
    fn render_variable_declaration(&self, name: &str, dt: &DataType) -> String {
        format!("DECLARE {} {};", name, self.render_data_type(dt))
    }

    /// Render BEGIN/END block delimiters.
    fn render_begin_end(&self, body: &str) -> String {
        format!("BEGIN\n{body}\nEND;")
    }

    /// Whether procedures use a language clause (e.g., Snowflake JavaScript).
    fn requires_language_clause(&self) -> bool {
        false
    }
}

#[cfg(test)]
mod tests {
    use super::*;
    use crate::DialectCapabilities;

    /// A test dialect that implements only the required `SqlRenderer` methods.
    /// All other traits use defaults.
    struct TestDialect;

    impl SqlRenderer for TestDialect {
        fn render_data_type(&self, dt: &DataType) -> String {
            match dt {
                DataType::Boolean(_) => "BOOLEAN".to_string(),
                DataType::Integer(_) => "INTEGER".to_string(),
                _ => "TEXT".to_string(),
            }
        }
        fn quote_identifier(&self, name: &str) -> String {
            format!("\"{name}\"")
        }
        fn qualify_name(&self, schema: Option<&str>, name: &str) -> String {
            match schema {
                Some(s) => format!("{}.{}", self.quote_identifier(s), self.quote_identifier(name)),
                None => self.quote_identifier(name),
            }
        }
        fn render_current_timestamp(&self) -> String {
            "CURRENT_TIMESTAMP".to_string()
        }
    }

    impl ExpressionRenderer for TestDialect {}
    impl DdlRenderer for TestDialect {}
    impl DmlRenderer for TestDialect {}
    impl ProcedureRenderer for TestDialect {}
    impl DialectCapabilities for TestDialect {}

    #[test]
    fn sql_renderer_core_methods_work() {
        let d = TestDialect;
        assert_eq!(d.render_data_type(&DataType::boolean()), "BOOLEAN");
        assert_eq!(d.quote_identifier("users"), "\"users\"");
        assert_eq!(d.qualify_name(Some("public"), "users"), "\"public\".\"users\"");
        assert_eq!(d.render_current_timestamp(), "CURRENT_TIMESTAMP");
    }

    #[test]
    fn dialect_name_returns_ansi_by_default() {
        let d = TestDialect;
        assert_eq!(d.dialect_name(), "ansi");
    }

    #[test]
    fn expression_renderer_defaults_produce_ansi_sql() {
        let d = TestDialect;
        assert_eq!(d.render_cast("age", &DataType::int()), "CAST(age AS INTEGER)");
        assert_eq!(d.render_concat(&["a".into(), "b".into()]), "CONCAT(a, b)");
        assert_eq!(d.render_coalesce(&["x".into(), "y".into()]), "COALESCE(x, y)");
    }

    #[test]
    fn ddl_renderer_defaults_produce_ansi_sql() {
        let d = TestDialect;
        assert_eq!(d.render_create_table_prefix(), "CREATE TABLE");
        assert_eq!(d.render_create_view_prefix(), "CREATE OR REPLACE VIEW");
        assert_eq!(
            d.render_column_definition("name", &DataType::boolean(), false),
            "\"name\" BOOLEAN NOT NULL"
        );
        assert_eq!(d.render_column_definition("age", &DataType::int(), true), "\"age\" INTEGER");
    }

    #[test]
    fn dml_renderer_defaults_produce_ansi_sql() {
        let d = TestDialect;
        assert_eq!(d.render_insert_prefix(), "INSERT INTO");
        assert_eq!(d.render_merge_prefix(), "MERGE INTO");
        assert_eq!(d.render_limit_clause(10), "LIMIT 10");
        assert!(d.render_upsert_strategy().is_none());
        assert!(d.render_returning_clause(&["id"]).is_none());
    }

    #[test]
    fn procedure_renderer_defaults_produce_ansi_sql() {
        let d = TestDialect;
        assert_eq!(d.render_create_procedure_prefix(), "CREATE OR REPLACE PROCEDURE");
        assert_eq!(
            d.render_variable_declaration("v_count", &DataType::int()),
            "DECLARE v_count INTEGER;"
        );
        assert!(!d.requires_language_clause());
    }

    #[test]
    fn trait_hierarchy_allows_selective_override() {
        struct MySqlLike;
        impl SqlRenderer for MySqlLike {
            fn render_data_type(&self, _: &DataType) -> String {
                "INT".into()
            }
            fn quote_identifier(&self, name: &str) -> String {
                format!("`{name}`")
            }
            fn qualify_name(&self, schema: Option<&str>, name: &str) -> String {
                match schema {
                    Some(s) => format!("`{s}`.`{name}`"),
                    None => format!("`{name}`"),
                }
            }
            fn render_current_timestamp(&self) -> String {
                "NOW()".into()
            }
        }
        impl ExpressionRenderer for MySqlLike {
            fn render_concat(&self, parts: &[String]) -> String {
                format!("CONCAT({})", parts.join(", "))
            }
        }
        impl DdlRenderer for MySqlLike {}
        impl DmlRenderer for MySqlLike {}
        impl ProcedureRenderer for MySqlLike {}
        impl DialectCapabilities for MySqlLike {}

        let d = MySqlLike;
        assert_eq!(d.quote_identifier("users"), "`users`");
        assert_eq!(d.render_current_timestamp(), "NOW()");
        // DDL defaults still work even though we only overrode expressions
        assert_eq!(d.render_create_table_prefix(), "CREATE TABLE");
    }

    #[test]
    fn sql_renderer_expression_extensions_produce_ansi_defaults() {
        let d = TestDialect;
        assert_sql_renderer_literal_defaults(&d);
        assert_sql_renderer_parameter_and_merge_defaults(&d);
        assert_sql_renderer_update_insert_defaults(&d);
        assert_sql_renderer_partition_and_window_defaults(&d);
    }

    /// Assert ANSI defaults for literal, date/time, and basic expression hooks.
    /// Parameters:
    /// - dialect: Renderer under test.
    fn assert_sql_renderer_literal_defaults(dialect: &TestDialect) {
        assert_eq!(dialect.render_boolean_literal(true), "TRUE");
        assert_eq!(dialect.render_boolean_literal(false), "FALSE");
        assert_eq!(dialect.render_date_literal("2024-01-15"), "DATE '2024-01-15'");
        assert_eq!(
            dialect.render_timestamp_literal("2024-01-15 12:00:00"),
            "TIMESTAMP '2024-01-15 12:00:00'"
        );
        assert_eq!(dialect.render_interval_literal("1 year"), "INTERVAL '1 year'");
        assert_eq!(dialect.render_current_date(), "CURRENT_DATE");
        assert_eq!(dialect.concat_operator(), "||");
        assert_eq!(dialect.render_nan_literal(&DataType::float()), "NULL");
        assert_eq!(dialect.render_infinity_literal(true, &DataType::float()), "NULL");
        assert_eq!(dialect.ifnull_function_name(), "COALESCE");
        assert_eq!(
            dialect.render_iif("x > 0", "pos", "neg"),
            "CASE WHEN x > 0 THEN pos ELSE neg END"
        );
        assert_eq!(
            dialect.render_date_trunc("month", "created_at"),
            "DATE_TRUNC('month', created_at)"
        );
        assert_eq!(
            dialect.render_date_extract("year", "created_at"),
            "EXTRACT(year FROM created_at)"
        );
        assert_eq!(dialect.render_try_cast("age", &DataType::int()), "TRY_CAST(age AS INTEGER)");
    }

    /// Assert ANSI defaults for parameter and merge-related extension hooks.
    /// Parameters:
    /// - dialect: Renderer under test.
    fn assert_sql_renderer_parameter_and_merge_defaults(dialect: &TestDialect) {
        assert_eq!(dialect.render_parameter_placeholder(1), "$1");
        assert_eq!(dialect.render_named_parameter("user_id"), ":user_id");
        assert_eq!(SqlRenderer::merge_not_matched_keyword(dialect), "WHEN NOT MATCHED");
        assert!(!SqlRenderer::supports_merge_not_matched_by_source(dialect));
        assert!(SqlRenderer::merge_supported(dialect));
        assert!(!SqlRenderer::merge_supports_schema_evolution_keyword(dialect));
        assert!(!SqlRenderer::merge_supports_table_hints(dialect));
        assert!(!SqlRenderer::merge_uses_output_clause(dialect));
        assert!(!SqlRenderer::merge_supports_returning_clause(dialect));
        assert_eq!(dialect.schema_separator(), ".");
        assert_eq!(dialect.statement_separator(), ";\n");
    }

    /// Assert ANSI defaults for update and insert behavior extension hooks.
    /// Parameters:
    /// - dialect: Renderer under test.
    fn assert_sql_renderer_update_insert_defaults(dialect: &TestDialect) {
        assert!(!SqlRenderer::supports_compound_assignment(dialect));
        assert!(!SqlRenderer::supports_update_from(dialect));
        assert!(!SqlRenderer::uses_alter_table_update(dialect));
        // How a mutation is SPELLED and what it may LOOK AT are
        // two facts, and the ANSI default is that a mutation may correlate.
        assert!(!SqlRenderer::mutation_reads_only_its_own_rows(dialect));
        assert!(!dialect.update_supports_top_clause());
        assert!(!dialect.update_supports_table_hints());
        assert!(!dialect.update_uses_output_clause());
        assert!(!dialect.update_supports_returning());
        assert!(!dialect.insert_uses_output_clause());
        assert!(!dialect.insert_supports_returning());
        assert!(!dialect.insert_supports_table_hints());
        assert!(!SqlRenderer::supports_insert_overwrite(dialect));
        assert!(!SqlRenderer::supports_on_conflict(dialect));
        assert!(!dialect.supports_overriding_clause());
        assert_eq!(dialect.returning_clause_keyword(), "RETURNING");
        assert!(!SqlRenderer::supports_returning_into(dialect));
        assert!(!SqlRenderer::supports_multi_table_insert(dialect));
    }

    /// Assert ANSI defaults for partitioning, generated columns, and window hooks.
    /// Parameters:
    /// - dialect: Renderer under test.
    fn assert_sql_renderer_partition_and_window_defaults(dialect: &TestDialect) {
        assert_eq!(
            dialect.render_time_partition_expr("event_ts", "monthly"),
            "date_trunc('month', event_ts)"
        );
        assert_eq!(dialect.render_partition_clause("event_ts"), "PARTITION BY (event_ts)");
        assert_eq!(
            dialect.render_generated_column("event_month", "DATE_TRUNC('month', event_ts)"),
            "event_month GENERATED ALWAYS AS (DATE_TRUNC('month', event_ts)) STORED"
        );
        assert!(!SqlRenderer::supports_window_frame_exclude(dialect));
        assert!(!SqlRenderer::supports_window_frame_groups(dialect));
        assert!(SqlRenderer::supports_named_windows(dialect));
    }

    #[test]
    fn ddl_renderer_extensions_produce_ansi_defaults() {
        let d = TestDialect;
        assert_ddl_renderer_transaction_and_view_defaults(&d);
        assert_ddl_renderer_drop_defaults(&d);
    }

    /// Assert ANSI DDL defaults for transaction and view keyword hooks.
    /// Parameters:
    /// - dialect: Renderer under test.
    fn assert_ddl_renderer_transaction_and_view_defaults(dialect: &TestDialect) {
        assert_eq!(dialect.render_begin_transaction(), "BEGIN");
        assert_eq!(dialect.render_commit(), "COMMIT");
        assert!(dialect.supports_ddl_transactions());
        assert_eq!(dialect.render_create_view_keyword(false, false), "CREATE OR REPLACE VIEW");
        assert_eq!(
            dialect.render_create_view_keyword(true, false),
            "CREATE OR REPLACE SECURE VIEW"
        );
        assert!(dialect.supports_alter_drop_if_exists());
    }

    /// Assert ANSI DDL defaults for drop-related behavior hooks.
    /// Parameters:
    /// - dialect: Renderer under test.
    fn assert_ddl_renderer_drop_defaults(dialect: &TestDialect) {
        assert_eq!(dialect.render_drop_object_keyword("table"), "TABLE");
        assert_eq!(
            dialect.render_drop_function("my_func", &[], true),
            "DROP FUNCTION IF EXISTS my_func"
        );
        assert!(!dialect.drop_index_uses_on_syntax());
        assert!(DdlRenderer::supports_cascade_drop(dialect));
        assert!(dialect.supports_drop_function_arg_types());
        assert!(!DdlRenderer::supports_sync_drop(dialect));
        assert!(!DdlRenderer::supports_force_drop(dialect));
        assert!(!dialect.supports_alter_drop_cascade());
    }
}