{
"item_type": "subsection",
"chapter_id": "environment",
"subsection_id": "common-patterns",
"subsection_title": "Common Patterns",
"subsection_file": "book/src/environment/common-patterns.md",
"feature_mappings": [],
"drift_detected": true,
"severity": "high",
"quality_assessment": "Documentation shows extensive patterns that are NOT IMPLEMENTED in current codebase. Many features shown in examples do not exist in actual implementation.",
"issues": [
{
"type": "missing_feature_implementation",
"severity": "high",
"section": "Multi-Environment Deployment Pattern",
"description": "Documentation shows 'secrets' with provider-based configuration (provider: vault), but SecretValue enum only supports Simple(String) and Provider formats. The example syntax 'secrets: { DATABASE_PASSWORD: { provider: vault, key: ... } }' is valid but NOT demonstrated in any working examples or tests.",
"current_content": "secrets:\n DATABASE_PASSWORD:\n provider: vault\n key: secret/data/db/${PROFILE}",
"should_be": "The pattern is technically correct per SecretValue enum definition, but needs clarification that secret providers are DESIGNED but not yet FUNCTIONAL. No vault/AWS integration exists.",
"fix_suggestion": "Add prominent note: 'Secret providers (vault, aws) are planned features. Currently only Simple string secrets are fully supported. Use environment variables for secrets: DATABASE_PASSWORD: \"${DATABASE_PASSWORD}\"'",
"source_reference": "src/cook/environment/config.rs:86-112 (SecretProvider enum defined but no provider implementation exists)"
},
{
"type": "missing_feature_implementation",
"severity": "high",
"section": "Secrets Management Pattern",
"description": "Shows AWS and Vault secret providers as working examples, implying they are functional. No actual provider implementation exists in codebase.",
"current_content": "AWS_ACCESS_KEY:\n provider: aws\n key: prod/aws-credentials/access_key",
"should_be": "Remove or clearly mark as 'Future Feature' examples",
"fix_suggestion": "Replace AWS/Vault examples with working pattern using environment variables. Add 'Coming Soon' section for planned provider support.",
"source_reference": "src/cook/environment/ - no provider implementation files exist"
},
{
"type": "missing_feature_implementation",
"severity": "high",
"section": "Environment Variable Composition Pattern",
"description": "Shows layered env_files loading with ${ENVIRONMENT} variable interpolation in file paths, but no evidence this interpolation works in env_files field",
"current_content": "env_files:\n - .env\n - .env.${ENVIRONMENT}\n - .env.local",
"should_be": "Verify if env_files supports variable interpolation or use static file lists",
"fix_suggestion": "Test and document whether env_files field supports ${VAR} interpolation. If not supported, show static file pattern or conditional loading approach.",
"source_reference": "src/config/workflow.rs:29 (env_files: Option<Vec<PathBuf>> - no interpolation logic shown)"
},
{
"type": "outdated_information",
"severity": "medium",
"section": "CI/CD Integration Pattern",
"description": "Shows 'when' conditional syntax that may not be implemented for shell commands in standard workflows",
"current_content": "- shell: \"cargo build --release\"\n when: \"${CI_MODE} == 'true'\"",
"should_be": "Verify 'when' clause support in WorkflowCommand or use alternative conditional approach",
"fix_suggestion": "Confirm 'when' clause is implemented for shell commands. If not, show alternative pattern using goal_seek or separate workflow profiles.",
"source_reference": "src/config/command.rs - need to verify 'when' field exists in shell command config"
},
{
"type": "incomplete_explanation",
"severity": "medium",
"section": "Template Parameterization Pattern",
"description": "Shows capture_output and capture_format features that may not be documented elsewhere",
"current_content": "capture_output: coverage_result\n capture_format: json",
"should_be": "Cross-reference to documentation explaining capture feature",
"fix_suggestion": "Add link to variable capture documentation or inline explanation of how captured variables are used",
"source_reference": "src/config/command.rs - verify these fields exist"
},
{
"type": "missing_content",
"severity": "low",
"section": "All Patterns",
"description": "No examples show env_files actually being loaded or how dotenv format files are processed",
"fix_suggestion": "Add example showing .env file contents and how values are loaded into workflow",
"source_reference": "src/config/workflow.rs:29"
},
{
"type": "broken_links",
"severity": "medium",
"section": "Cross-References",
"description": "Found 4 broken internal link(s) - referenced files do not exist",
"broken_links": [
{
"link_text": "Best Practices",
"original_target": "best-practices.md",
"current_file": "book/src/environment/common-patterns.md",
"expected_path": "book/src/environment/best-practices.md",
"exists": false,
"suggestion": "File does not exist. Create best-practices.md subsection or link to different location."
},
{
"link_text": "Environment Profiles",
"original_target": "environment-profiles.md",
"current_file": "book/src/environment/common-patterns.md",
"expected_path": "book/src/environment/environment-profiles.md",
"exists": false,
"suggestion": "File does not exist. Create environment-profiles.md subsection or update link."
},
{
"link_text": "Secrets Management",
"original_target": "secrets-management.md",
"current_file": "book/src/environment/common-patterns.md",
"expected_path": "book/src/environment/secrets-management.md",
"exists": false,
"suggestion": "File does not exist. Create secrets-management.md subsection or update link."
},
{
"link_text": "MapReduce Environment Variables",
"original_target": "mapreduce-environment-variables.md",
"current_file": "book/src/environment/common-patterns.md",
"expected_path": "book/src/environment/mapreduce-environment-variables.md",
"exists": false,
"suggestion": "File does not exist. May need to link to mapreduce chapter instead: ../mapreduce/environment-variables.md"
}
],
"fix_suggestion": "Update links to point to existing files or create the referenced subsections. Consider linking to parent chapter index pages if subsections don't exist yet."
}
],
"positive_aspects": [
"Comprehensive real-world patterns covering many use cases",
"Clear YAML examples with inline comments",
"Good progression from simple to complex patterns",
"Practical CI/CD and deployment examples",
"Feature flag pattern is useful and well-explained"
],
"improvement_suggestions": [
"Clearly distinguish between implemented features and planned/future features",
"Add 'Implementation Status' badges or notes to each pattern",
"Include working examples that can be copy-pasted and run immediately",
"Show both the ideal pattern and the current workaround where features are incomplete",
"Add troubleshooting section for common pattern issues",
"Link to actual test files demonstrating working patterns",
"Provide minimal working example before showing complex patterns"
],
"cross_references": [],
"metadata": {
"analyzed_at": "2025-01-11T00:00:00Z",
"feature_inventory": ".prodigy/book-analysis/features.json",
"topics_covered": [
"Multi-Environment Deployment",
"Secrets Management",
"Profile-Based Configuration",
"Environment Variable Composition",
"CI/CD Integration",
"Local Development",
"Template Parameterization",
"Regional Configuration",
"Feature Flags"
],
"validation_focus": "Check common patterns documentation matches implementation",
"implementation_gaps": [
"Secret provider integration (vault, aws) - DESIGNED but NOT IMPLEMENTED",
"env_files variable interpolation - UNCLEAR if supported",
"when clause for shell commands - NEEDS VERIFICATION",
"capture_output and capture_format - EXISTS but needs cross-reference"
]
}
}