{
"counts": {
"Open": 1,
"OpenHigh": 0,
"OpenMedium": 0,
"OpenLow": 1,
"Resolved": 1,
"Dismissed": 0,
"Stale": 1
},
"findings": [
{
"id": "01M65ECBREMZRY2QJEYDHEDYBA",
"trailId": "01M659Z3PQVF861CZ28PMK8KC5",
"repositoryId": "01KWHDK2EKTJT9BA4KSDQCWRA5",
"reviewId": "01M65ECBQXTY1N5Q6XNXK8723D",
"codeVersionId": "01M65EB9T396F210Q8S0PR95XH",
"actorId": "agent:trail-review",
"title": null,
"body": "`deleted_paths_under` counts any path ever deleted in history, even if a later commit saved it again. If the user deletes a tracked file, saves, then recreates the file, `live_matches_saved` sees it as an addition that is in `deleted` and returns false. The entry is then treated as held, so the recreated file is probably not captured or published until a pull releases it. Consider only counting deletions that are not followed by a re-add, or deletions that did not originate from this machine's own checkpoints.",
"severity": "low",
"confidence": 0.4,
"status": "open",
"statusReason": null,
"staleOutcome": "current",
"staleCheckedAt": null,
"staleCheckedCodeVersionId": null,
"clientId": "4878cbc5895afe371edd82c6a3437019",
"clientIdHash": "e6b8c8b1132cd5bc6f13e8db50446edcfccb283d61c2537e18f83bae176e3ec5",
"createdAt": "2026-10-30T03:41:43.564Z",
"updatedAt": "2026-10-30T03:41:43.564Z",
"location": {
"id": "01M65ECBRE5071RCEWMA4GB238",
"reviewCommentId": "01M65ECBREMZRY2QJEYDHEDYBA",
"codeVersionId": "01M65EB9T396F210Q8S0PR95XH",
"granularity": "line",
"filePath": "crates/mise-system/src/history/shadow.rs",
"startLine": 2116,
"startColumn": null,
"endLine": null,
"endColumn": null,
"selectedText": " let literal = format!(\":(literal){stream}\");",
"nearbyText": null,
"language": null
},
"discussionId": "01M65ECBRE89VCCTJVYWDN7J6M"
},
{
"id": "01M65A0ACHHRSZQWTGF0H1SYJ9",
"trailId": "01M659Z3PQVF861CZ28PMK8KC5",
"repositoryId": "01KWHDK2EKTJT9BA4KSDQCWRA5",
"reviewId": "01M65A0ACDWWAQ4N7DJSTXVS69",
"codeVersionId": "01M65A0ACBX9Q06Q5F93K2RN1Q",
"actorId": "agent:trail-review",
"title": null,
"body": "live_matches_saved now returns true whenever every saved file is live and unchanged, ignoring live files with no saved version. That also covers a file another machine deleted and pulled into the saved version but not yet applied locally. The stream is then treated as held, and the next capture re-saves the file, silently reverting the remote deletion. Before this change the live/saved set mismatch made the stream unheld, so the capture carried the pulled version and the deletion was applied. The check needs a way to tell a widened-entry addition from a remotely deleted file, for example by only ignoring live files that no previous narrower stream covered, or files not present in the upstream history.",
"severity": "medium",
"confidence": 0.6,
"status": "resolved",
"statusReason": "Fixed in 58b789e5d2: extra live files only count as additions when no stream held here covered them; e2e test_dotfiles_profile_remote_deletion reproduces the scenario.",
"staleOutcome": "stale",
"staleCheckedAt": "2026-10-30T03:05:43.851Z",
"staleCheckedCodeVersionId": "01M65CAEM0CS3VKQNWMAPVBB4J",
"clientId": "aa22b06b46d10779cb9b7053c12929a5",
"clientIdHash": "86cf7f8aa385177176d20ea09b84881b1a81357e35e4389774e67615f747fe31",
"createdAt": "2026-10-30T02:25:14.64Z",
"updatedAt": "2026-10-30T03:05:52.814Z",
"location": {
"id": "01M65A0ACHHR4AC0H5WC963YGD",
"reviewCommentId": "01M65A0ACHHRSZQWTGF0H1SYJ9",
"codeVersionId": "01M65A0ACBX9Q06Q5F93K2RN1Q",
"granularity": "line",
"filePath": "crates/mise-system/src/history/held.rs",
"startLine": 253,
"startColumn": null,
"endLine": null,
"endColumn": null,
"selectedText": " Ok(true)",
"nearbyText": null,
"language": null
},
"discussionId": "01M65A0ACHNT0M5NR1ZRC7K18F"
}
],
"has_more": false,
"trail": {
"id": "01M659Z3PQVF861CZ28PMK8KC5",
"number": 1159,
"url": "https://entire.com/gh/jdx/mise/trails/1159",
"branch": "",
"originalBranch": "claude/github-issue-discussion-e01ea6",
"base": "main",
"title": "fix(dotfiles): keep saving a directory tracked in place of narrower paths",
"status": "merged",
"author": {
"id": "01KVXJKTKXPZN75VHNT4D041RQ",
"login": "jdx"
},
"assignees": [
"jdx"
],
"createdAt": "2026-10-30T02:24:35.031Z",
"updatedAt": "2026-10-30T11:36:24.507Z",
"mergedAt": "2026-10-30T11:35:41Z",
"unresolvedCount": 1,
"bodyDocument": {
"textSnapshot": "",
"etag": "W/\"2026-10-30T02:24:35.060254Z\""
}
}
}