gam_gpu/numerics_host.rs
1//! Host-side scalar special functions shared by the CPU parity references of
2//! the GPU backends.
3//!
4//! The CUDA kernels emit their own NVRTC-visible numerics (see
5//! [`crate::numerics_device`]); this module is the matching **host** side
6//! used by the CPU parity oracles (`bms_flex_row`'s test oracle) and the
7//! CPU reference path (`pirls_row`'s probit CDF). Keeping a single definition
8//! here means the host `erfc` cannot drift between backends.
9
10/// Complementary error function `erfc(x) = 1 − erf(x)` evaluated on the host.
11///
12/// Routes to `libm::erfc`, the SunOS msun double-precision implementation
13/// (accurate to within ~1 ulp across the entire real line). The CUDA kernel
14/// side calls device `erfc`, which is itself msun-derived, so the host CPU
15/// reference matches the device path to within a ULP. The previous
16/// branchless Cody 1969 Chebyshev rational here was only ~1.2e-7 accurate
17/// in relative terms; that ate seven digits of every probit `Mills =
18/// φ/Φ = pdf / (½·erfc(-x/√2))` evaluation and made any sufficiently
19/// tight finite-difference probe of `∂neglog/∂e = -w·s·Mills` (which the
20/// analytic side computes from this same `cdf`, while the FD side
21/// differences `log cdf` and cancels the erfc bias) break against itself
22/// at the ~2e-7 floor instead of the genuine 5-point-stencil truncation
23/// floor near 1e-12.
24pub fn erfc(x: f64) -> f64 {
25 libm::erfc(x)
26}
27
28// ── Host oracle for the shared device probit numerics (issue #1175) ──────────
29//
30// The functions below are the CPU-side, device-free mirror of the CUDA source
31// in [`crate::numerics_device::PROBIT_NUMERICS_CU`]. They are written
32// LINE-FOR-LINE against that kernel source — the SAME branch structure, the
33// SAME asymptotic `erfcx` polynomial, and the SAME constants — differing only
34// in that they call the host `libm`
35// transcendentals (`erfc`/`exp`/`log`) where the kernel calls the device
36// `erfc`/`exp`/`log`. Both sides are the SunOS *msun* double-precision
37// implementations, so the host oracle matches the device to within ~1 ULP per
38// transcendental (issue #1175 items 4–5). This mirrors the #1017
39// `emulate_certified_encode_row` pattern: a CPU emulator that is BOTH the
40// fallback and the exactness oracle a device launch is pinned to.
41//
42// Correctness *without a GPU* (CPU-verifiable): the test harness below asserts
43// (a) these constants are bit-identical to the literals in the kernel source
44// (the "constants cannot drift" lock, #1175 item 4), (b) the kernel source uses
45// only msun transcendentals and no fast-math intrinsics (transcendental-parity
46// intent), and (c) the host oracle satisfies the defining probit identities to
47// a stated ULP bound. Confirming a *device launch* reproduces this oracle to
48// round-off still needs CUDA hardware.
49
50/// `1/√(2π)`, matching `INV_SQRT_2PI` in the kernel source bit-for-bit.
51pub const INV_SQRT_2PI: f64 = 0.3989422804014327;
52/// `√2`, matching `SQRT_2` in the kernel source bit-for-bit.
53pub const SQRT_2: f64 = 1.4142135623730951;
54/// `ln(2)`, matching `LN_2` in the kernel source bit-for-bit.
55pub const LN_2: f64 = 0.6931471805599453;
56/// `1/√π`, matching `inv_sqrt_pi` in the kernel source bit-for-bit.
57pub const INV_SQRT_PI: f64 = 0.5641895835477563;
58/// `√(2/π)`, matching `sqrt_2_over_pi` in the kernel source bit-for-bit.
59pub const SQRT_2_OVER_PI: f64 = 0.7978845608028654;
60
61/// Scaled complementary error function `erfcx(x) = exp(x²)·erfc(x)` for `x ≥ 0`,
62/// the host oracle for the device `erfcx_nonnegative`. Returns `0.0` at `+∞`;
63/// negative inputs and `NaN` return `NaN` because they violate the restricted
64/// domain. For `0 ≤ x < 26` evaluates `exp(x²)·erfc(x)` directly; beyond that
65/// it switches to the same six-correction asymptotic expansion as the kernel.
66///
67/// The direct branch carries `x²` exactly. Rounding the square perturbs it by
68/// a relative `ε/2`, and `exp` converts a relative perturbation of its ARGUMENT
69/// into `x²` times that in its RESULT — `5.7e-14` at the top of the branch,
70/// against the `3e-16` the asymptotic branch already delivers, so the seam at
71/// `26` was a 190x step DOWN in error into the interval every probit consumer
72/// lives in. `mul_add` is the IEEE fused operation, matching the kernel's
73/// explicit `fma` call, which `--fmad=false` does not touch (it disables
74/// CONTRACTION of a separate `a*b+c`). See `gam_math::probability` for the
75/// measurements; this branch is its line-for-line device-side twin.
76pub fn erfcx_nonnegative(x: f64) -> f64 {
77 if x.is_nan() || x < 0.0 {
78 return f64::NAN;
79 }
80 if x == f64::INFINITY {
81 return 0.0;
82 }
83 if x < 26.0 {
84 let hi = x * x;
85 let lo = x.mul_add(x, -hi);
86 let head = libm::exp(hi) * erfc(x);
87 return head.mul_add(lo, head);
88 }
89 let inv = 1.0 / x;
90 let inv2 = inv * inv;
91 let poly = 1.0
92 + inv2
93 * (-0.5
94 + inv2
95 * (0.75
96 + inv2
97 * (-1.875 + inv2 * (6.5625 + inv2 * (-29.53125 + inv2 * 162.421875)))));
98 inv * poly * INV_SQRT_PI
99}
100
101/// `log Φ(x)` for the standard normal CDF, the host oracle for the device
102/// `log_ndtr`. For `x < 0` uses the `erfcx` representation
103/// `log Φ(x) = −u² + log(½·erfcx(u))`, `u = −x/√2`, keeping digits into the
104/// deep left tail; for `x ≥ 0` uses `log1p(−½·erfc(x/√2))`, retaining the
105/// negative tail after the CDF rounds to one. Propagates `±∞`/`NaN` exactly as
106/// the device path does.
107pub fn log_ndtr(x: f64) -> f64 {
108 if x == f64::INFINITY {
109 return 0.0;
110 }
111 if x == f64::NEG_INFINITY {
112 return f64::NEG_INFINITY;
113 }
114 if x.is_nan() {
115 return x;
116 }
117 if x < 0.0 {
118 let u = -x / SQRT_2;
119 let ex = erfcx_nonnegative(u);
120 -u * u + libm::log(ex) - LN_2
121 } else {
122 let upper_tail = 0.5 * erfc(x / SQRT_2);
123 libm::log1p(-upper_tail)
124 }
125}
126
127/// Joint `(log Φ(x), Mills ratio φ(x)/Φ(x))`, the host oracle for the device
128/// `log_ndtr_and_mills`. The `x < 0` branch computes the Mills ratio as
129/// `√(2/π)/erfcx(u)`, which stays finite even when `Φ(x)` underflows; the
130/// `x ≥ 0` branch forms `pdf/cdf` directly. Boundary values mirror the kernel:
131/// `(+0, +0)` at `+∞`, `(−∞, +∞)` at `−∞`, `(NaN, NaN)` at `NaN`.
132pub fn log_ndtr_and_mills(x: f64) -> (f64, f64) {
133 if x == f64::INFINITY {
134 return (0.0, 0.0);
135 }
136 if x == f64::NEG_INFINITY {
137 return (f64::NEG_INFINITY, f64::INFINITY);
138 }
139 if x.is_nan() {
140 return (x, x);
141 }
142 if x < 0.0 {
143 let u = -x / SQRT_2;
144 let ex = erfcx_nonnegative(u);
145 let log_cdf = -u * u + libm::log(ex) - LN_2;
146 let lambda = SQRT_2_OVER_PI / ex;
147 (log_cdf, lambda)
148 } else {
149 let upper_tail = 0.5 * erfc(x / SQRT_2);
150 let cdf = 1.0 - upper_tail;
151 // Same exact-square correction as `erfcx_nonnegative`. `x` is finite
152 // and non-negative here, so the residual is always a finite number.
153 let xx = x * x;
154 let pdf = INV_SQRT_2PI * libm::exp(-0.5 * xx);
155 let pdf = pdf.mul_add(-0.5 * x.mul_add(x, -xx), pdf);
156 let log_cdf = libm::log1p(-upper_tail);
157 let lambda = pdf / cdf;
158 (log_cdf, lambda)
159 }
160}
161
162/// Joint `(log Φ(x), φ(x)/Φ(x), −d²log Φ(x)/dx²)` host oracle.
163///
164/// The curvature's deep-left branch differentiates the same 32-level Laplace
165/// continued fraction as the CPU model kernel, retaining its unit limit without
166/// subtracting the nearly equal `x` and Mills ratio. The CUDA source mirrors
167/// this operation order; host/device transcendental channels are ULP-close,
168/// while the rational curvature branch is operation-for-operation identical
169/// when device FMA contraction is disabled.
170pub fn log_ndtr_mills_curvature(x: f64) -> (f64, f64, f64) {
171 let (log_cdf, lambda) = log_ndtr_and_mills(x);
172 if x.is_nan() {
173 return (log_cdf, lambda, x);
174 }
175 if x.is_infinite() {
176 return (
177 log_cdf,
178 lambda,
179 if x.is_sign_positive() { 0.0 } else { 1.0 },
180 );
181 }
182 let curvature = if x <= -4.0 {
183 let t = -x;
184 let mut q = 0.0;
185 let mut q_first = 0.0;
186 for n in (1..=32).rev() {
187 let denominator = t + q;
188 let value = f64::from(n) / denominator;
189 q_first = -value * (1.0 + q_first) / denominator;
190 q = value;
191 }
192 1.0 + q_first
193 } else {
194 lambda * (x + lambda)
195 };
196 (log_cdf, lambda, curvature)
197}
198
199#[cfg(test)]
200mod probit_parity_tests {
201 //! CPU-verifiable floating-point-order & transcendental parity harness for
202 //! the shared probit numerics (issue #1175). Everything here runs without a
203 //! GPU: it pins the host oracle constants to the kernel-source literals,
204 //! audits the kernel source for msun-only transcendentals (no fast-math),
205 //! and checks the host oracle against the defining probit identities within
206 //! stated ULP bounds. A *device* reproducing this oracle to round-off still
207 //! requires CUDA hardware and is asserted by the on-device parity gates.
208 use super::*;
209 use crate::numerics_device::PROBIT_NUMERICS_CU;
210
211 const EPS: f64 = f64::EPSILON; // 2.220446049250313e-16
212
213 /// Relative error of `got` vs `want`, expressed in ULP of `want`.
214 fn ulp(got: f64, want: f64) -> f64 {
215 if want == 0.0 {
216 (got - want).abs() / EPS
217 } else {
218 (got - want).abs() / (EPS * want.abs())
219 }
220 }
221
222 /// Extract the first f64 literal appearing after `needle` in `src`.
223 fn literal_after(src: &str, needle: &str) -> f64 {
224 let start = src
225 .find(needle)
226 .unwrap_or_else(|| panic!("kernel source is missing marker {needle:?}"))
227 + needle.len();
228 let tail = &src[start..];
229 // Skip separators between the marker and the number ('=', whitespace).
230 let num_start = tail
231 .find(|c: char| c == '-' || c == '.' || c.is_ascii_digit())
232 .unwrap_or_else(|| panic!("no numeric literal follows {needle:?}"));
233 let rest = &tail[num_start..];
234 let end = rest
235 .find(|c: char| !(c.is_ascii_digit() || matches!(c, '.' | 'e' | 'E' | '+' | '-')))
236 .unwrap_or(rest.len());
237 rest[..end]
238 .parse::<f64>()
239 .unwrap_or_else(|e| panic!("failed to parse literal after {needle:?}: {e}"))
240 }
241
242 /// #1175 item 4 pattern ("constants cannot drift"): every constant the host
243 /// oracle uses is bit-identical to the literal baked into the kernel source.
244 /// A one-bit edit on either side fails this immediately.
245 #[test]
246 fn host_constants_match_kernel_source_bit_for_bit() {
247 for (needle, host) in [
248 ("#define INV_SQRT_2PI", INV_SQRT_2PI),
249 ("#define SQRT_2", SQRT_2),
250 ("#define LN_2", LN_2),
251 ("inv_sqrt_pi =", INV_SQRT_PI),
252 ("sqrt_2_over_pi =", SQRT_2_OVER_PI),
253 ] {
254 let device = literal_after(PROBIT_NUMERICS_CU, needle);
255 assert_eq!(
256 device.to_bits(),
257 host.to_bits(),
258 "constant {needle:?} drifted: kernel={device:?} host={host:?}"
259 );
260 }
261 }
262
263 /// Transcendental-parity intent: the kernel evaluates its transcendentals
264 /// through the msun `erfc`/`exp`/`log` (which the host `libm` mirrors) and
265 /// contains NO fast-math intrinsic or single-precision variant. FMA
266 /// contraction is separately disabled at compile time via
267 /// `device_cache`'s `--fmad=false`; this guards the source itself.
268 #[test]
269 fn kernel_source_uses_msun_transcendentals_only() {
270 for good in ["erfc(", "exp(", "log(", "log1p("] {
271 assert!(
272 PROBIT_NUMERICS_CU.contains(good),
273 "kernel source should call msun `{good}`"
274 );
275 }
276 for bad in [
277 "__expf",
278 "__logf",
279 "expf(",
280 "logf(",
281 "erfcf(",
282 "__fdividef",
283 "__frcp",
284 "use_fast_math",
285 "ffast-math",
286 "__dmul_",
287 "__dadd_",
288 "__fmaf",
289 ] {
290 assert!(
291 !PROBIT_NUMERICS_CU.contains(bad),
292 "kernel source must not use fast-math / single-precision `{bad}`"
293 );
294 }
295 }
296
297 /// `erfc` boundary + symmetry: `erfc(0)=1` exactly and
298 /// `erfc(-x) = 2 - erfc(x)` to ≤ 2 ULP across a moderate grid.
299 #[test]
300 fn erfc_boundary_and_symmetry() {
301 assert_eq!(erfc(0.0), 1.0);
302 let mut worst = 0.0_f64;
303 for i in 0..300 {
304 let x = i as f64 * 0.01;
305 worst = worst.max(ulp(erfc(-x), 2.0 - erfc(x)));
306 }
307 assert!(worst <= 2.0, "erfc symmetry drift {worst:.3} ULP > 2");
308 }
309
310 /// Defining identity `erfcx(x)·exp(-x²) = erfc(x)` to ≤ 4 ULP for
311 /// `0 < x < 26` (the direct branch of the host oracle).
312 ///
313 /// The inverse factor has to undo the square the SAME way the branch built
314 /// it, or the identity cannot resolve anything finer than the error it is
315 /// supposed to be measuring. `exp(-fl(x*x))` is off by `x²·ε/2` — up to
316 /// `250` ULP at the top of this range — in the opposite direction from
317 /// `exp(fl(x*x))`, so writing the identity with a rounded square on both
318 /// sides makes the two errors CANCEL and the check passes identically well
319 /// whether or not the branch corrects for them. That is why this test, and
320 /// the ULP-tight one it looks like, said nothing about a 190x defect.
321 #[test]
322 fn erfcx_matches_definition() {
323 assert_eq!(erfcx_nonnegative(0.0), 1.0);
324 assert!(erfcx_nonnegative(-3.0).is_nan());
325 assert!(erfcx_nonnegative(f64::NEG_INFINITY).is_nan());
326 assert!(erfcx_nonnegative(f64::NAN).is_nan());
327 assert_eq!(erfcx_nonnegative(f64::INFINITY), 0.0);
328 let mut worst = 0.0_f64;
329 let mut x = 0.1_f64;
330 while x < 25.0 {
331 let hi = x * x;
332 let lo = x.mul_add(x, -hi);
333 let inverse_exp = libm::exp(-hi);
334 let inverse_exp = inverse_exp.mul_add(-lo, inverse_exp);
335 worst = worst.max(ulp(erfcx_nonnegative(x) * inverse_exp, erfc(x)));
336 x += 0.1;
337 }
338 assert!(worst <= 4.0, "erfcx definition drift {worst:.3} ULP > 4");
339 }
340
341 /// The identity above is self-consistent by construction; this is the
342 /// accuracy pin. References are `mpmath` at `dps=60`, on arguments whose
343 /// squares are NOT representable in `f64` — the only ones where the
344 /// rounded-square error is non-zero, and precisely the ones the shared
345 /// erfcx grid (`0.1`, `0.2`, … stepping by `0.1`) mostly misses, since a
346 /// tenth-spaced grid lands on many exactly-squaring values and the identity
347 /// check cancels the defect at the rest.
348 ///
349 /// `1.5e-15` matches the bound the CPU kernel holds itself to in
350 /// `gam_math::probability::erfcx_matches_high_precision_reference`; the two
351 /// implementations are line-for-line twins and must not drift in accuracy
352 /// any more than they may drift in constants.
353 #[test]
354 fn erfcx_matches_high_precision_reference() {
355 const TOLERANCE: f64 = 1.5e-15;
356 let refs: &[(f64, f64)] = &[
357 (0.1, 0.8964569799691267),
358 (10.5, 0.05349189974656412),
359 (14.3, 0.0393580473372741),
360 (19.7, 0.028602309402825203),
361 (23.9, 0.023585649371803793),
362 (25.9999, 0.021683668126369115),
363 ];
364 for &(x, reference) in refs {
365 let got = erfcx_nonnegative(x);
366 let rel = (got - reference).abs() / reference.abs();
367 assert!(
368 rel < TOLERANCE,
369 "erfcx({x}) = {got:.17e}, reference {reference:.17e}, rel {rel:.3e}"
370 );
371 }
372 }
373
374 #[test]
375 fn erfcx_asymptotic_switch_and_subnormal_contract_match_device_source() {
376 // `26² = 676` is exactly representable, so the plain direct form has no
377 // square residual to lose and is a legitimate oracle AT THIS ARGUMENT
378 // (and, note, only here — which is why this check never saw the
379 // rounded-square defect the accuracy pin above catches).
380 let switch = 26.0_f64;
381 assert_eq!(switch.mul_add(switch, -(switch * switch)), 0.0);
382 let direct = libm::exp(switch * switch) * erfc(switch);
383 assert!(
384 (erfcx_nonnegative(switch) / direct - 1.0).abs() < 1.0e-15,
385 "erfcx switch disagrees with direct finite identity"
386 );
387 let tail = erfcx_nonnegative(f64::MAX);
388 assert!(tail > 0.0 && tail.is_subnormal(), "erfcx(MAX)={tail:e}");
389
390 for required in [
391 "isnan(x) || x < 0.0",
392 "inv2 * 162.421875",
393 "log1p(-upper_tail)",
394 "log_ndtr_mills_curvature",
395 // The exact-square correction, on both the erfcx branch and the
396 // `log_ndtr_and_mills` pdf, must survive in the device source or
397 // the two sides stop describing one function.
398 "double lo = fma(x, x, -hi);",
399 "fma(pdf, -0.5 * fma(x, x, -xx), pdf)",
400 ] {
401 assert!(
402 PROBIT_NUMERICS_CU.contains(required),
403 "device source lost shared tail contract `{required}`"
404 );
405 }
406 for forbidden in ["1e-300", "if (xx > 700.0)", "if (cdf > 1.0)", "1.0 / 0.0"] {
407 assert!(
408 !PROBIT_NUMERICS_CU.contains(forbidden),
409 "device source reintroduced numerical projection `{forbidden}`"
410 );
411 }
412 }
413
414 /// `log_ndtr` boundary + stable bulk Gaussian identity to ≤ 2 ULP for
415 /// `|x| ≤ 3`, and `Φ(x)+Φ(-x)=1` to ≤ 4e-16.
416 #[test]
417 fn log_ndtr_matches_log_cdf_and_reflects() {
418 assert_eq!(log_ndtr(0.0), libm::log(0.5));
419 assert_eq!(log_ndtr(f64::INFINITY), 0.0);
420 assert_eq!(log_ndtr(f64::NEG_INFINITY), f64::NEG_INFINITY);
421 assert!(log_ndtr(f64::NAN).is_nan());
422 assert!(log_ndtr(10.0) < 0.0);
423
424 let mut worst_bulk = 0.0_f64;
425 for i in -30..=30 {
426 let x = i as f64 * 0.1;
427 let expected = if x < 0.0 {
428 libm::log(0.5 * erfc(-x / SQRT_2))
429 } else {
430 libm::log1p(-0.5 * erfc(x / SQRT_2))
431 };
432 worst_bulk = worst_bulk.max(ulp(log_ndtr(x), expected));
433 }
434 assert!(
435 worst_bulk <= 2.0,
436 "log_ndtr vs log-cdf drift {worst_bulk:.3} ULP > 2"
437 );
438
439 let mut worst_refl = 0.0_f64;
440 for i in 0..60 {
441 let x = i as f64 * 0.1;
442 let s = libm::exp(log_ndtr(x)) + libm::exp(log_ndtr(-x));
443 worst_refl = worst_refl.max((s - 1.0).abs());
444 }
445 assert!(
446 worst_refl <= 4e-16,
447 "Φ(x)+Φ(-x) reflection drift {worst_refl:e} > 4e-16"
448 );
449 }
450
451 /// `log_ndtr_and_mills` agrees with `log_ndtr` on the log-CDF channel and
452 /// satisfies the Mills identity `λ(x)·Φ(x) = φ(x)` to ≤ 32 ULP for
453 /// `|x| ≤ 5`; the deep left tail stays finite (no `-∞`/`NaN`).
454 #[test]
455 fn log_ndtr_and_mills_identity_and_deep_tail() {
456 for i in -50..=50 {
457 let x = i as f64 * 0.1;
458 let (log_cdf, lambda) = log_ndtr_and_mills(x);
459 assert_eq!(
460 log_cdf.to_bits(),
461 log_ndtr(x).to_bits(),
462 "joint log-CDF channel diverged from log_ndtr at x={x}"
463 );
464 let phi = libm::exp(log_cdf);
465 let pdf = INV_SQRT_2PI * libm::exp(-0.5 * x * x);
466 assert!(
467 ulp(lambda * phi, pdf) <= 32.0,
468 "Mills identity drift {:.3} ULP > 32 at x={x}",
469 ulp(lambda * phi, pdf)
470 );
471 }
472 for &x in &[-10.0, -20.0, -30.0, -38.0] {
473 let (log_cdf, lambda) = log_ndtr_and_mills(x);
474 assert!(
475 log_cdf.is_finite() && log_cdf < 0.0,
476 "deep-tail log Φ({x}) not finite-negative: {log_cdf}"
477 );
478 assert!(
479 lambda.is_finite() && lambda > x.abs() * 0.9,
480 "deep-tail Mills({x}) should track |x|: {lambda}"
481 );
482 }
483 assert_eq!(log_ndtr_and_mills(f64::INFINITY), (0.0, 0.0));
484 assert_eq!(
485 log_ndtr_and_mills(f64::NEG_INFINITY),
486 (f64::NEG_INFINITY, f64::INFINITY)
487 );
488 }
489
490 #[test]
491 fn log_ndtr_curvature_keeps_unit_left_tail_and_matches_mills_derivative() {
492 let (_, lambda, curvature) = log_ndtr_mills_curvature(-1.0e100);
493 // Deep-left Mills tracks |x| to rounding: the value is assembled from
494 // a short transcendental chain (x/sqrt2, erfcx, reciprocal), so exact
495 // bit equality with 1e100 is one spurious ulp away on some hosts
496 // (a real A10 box measured 1.0000000000000002e100). The contract is
497 // "λ(-1e100) = 1e100 up to a few ulps", not a bit pattern.
498 let ulp = 1.0e100_f64.next_up() - 1.0e100;
499 assert!(
500 (lambda - 1.0e100).abs() <= 4.0 * ulp,
501 "deep-left Mills must track |x| to rounding: lambda={lambda:e}"
502 );
503 assert_eq!(curvature, 1.0);
504 assert_eq!(log_ndtr_mills_curvature(f64::INFINITY), (0.0, 0.0, 0.0));
505 assert_eq!(
506 log_ndtr_mills_curvature(f64::NEG_INFINITY),
507 (f64::NEG_INFINITY, f64::INFINITY, 1.0)
508 );
509 let (nan_log, nan_mills, nan_curv) = log_ndtr_mills_curvature(f64::NAN);
510 assert!(nan_log.is_nan() && nan_mills.is_nan() && nan_curv.is_nan());
511
512 let h = 1.0e-5;
513 for x in [-8.0_f64, -4.0, -2.0, 0.0, 3.0] {
514 let (_, _, analytic) = log_ndtr_mills_curvature(x);
515 let (_, left) = log_ndtr_and_mills(x - h);
516 let (_, right) = log_ndtr_and_mills(x + h);
517 let finite_difference = -(right - left) / (2.0 * h);
518 let relative = (finite_difference - analytic).abs() / analytic.abs().max(1.0e-300);
519 assert!(
520 relative < 2.0e-8,
521 "curvature fd mismatch x={x}: analytic={analytic:e}, fd={finite_difference:e}, rel={relative:e}"
522 );
523 }
524 }
525}