derive_generic_visitor 0.2.0

Boilerplate for building visitors, inspired by derive-visitor.

Driving a visitor

The premise of this crate is that to visit a type means to call a function on each of its fields. The Visit[Mut] and Drive[Mut] traits of this module provide the simplest interface for this: a type that implements a Visit<...> for a bunch of types is like a bundle of FnMut closures, and drive_inner on a type T calls <V as Visit<FieldTy>>::visit on each field of T.

The Drive/DriveMut derive macros implement these types automatically for a type. With that boilerplate out of the way, it becomes easy to define flexible visitors.

The output of the derive macros looks like:

#[derive(Drive)]
enum MyList {
    Empty,
    Cons(String, Box<MyList>),
}

impl<'s, V> Drive<'s, V> for MyList
where
    V: Visitor,
    V: Visit<'s, String>,
    V: Visit<'s, Box<MyList>>,
{
    fn drive_inner(&'s self, v: &mut V) -> ControlFlow<V::Break> {
        match self {
            Self::Empty => {}
            Self::Cons(x, y) => {
                v.visit(x)?;
                v.visit(y)?;
            }
        }
        ControlFlow::Continue(())
    }
}

As you can see, this is not recursive in any way: x.drive_inner(v) simply calls v.visit() on each field of x; it is up to the visitor to recurse into nested structures if it wishes.

Defining useful visitors

A visitor is a type that implements Visit<T>/VisitMut<T> for a set of types T. An implementation of Visit[Mut] typically involves calling x.drive_inner(self) to recurse into the type's contents, with some work done before or after that call. The Visit and VisitMut derive macros make such usage straightforward.

#[derive(Drive)]
enum MyList {
    Empty,
    Cons(MyNode),
}
#[derive(Drive)]
struct MyNode {
    val: String,
    next: Box<MyList>
}

#[derive(Default, Visitor, Visit)]
#[visit(drive(MyList))] // recurse without custom behavior
#[visit(drive(for<T> Box<T>))] // recurse without custom behavior
#[visit(enter(MyNode))] // call `self.enter_my_node` before recursing
#[visit(skip(String))] // do nothing on a string
struct ConcatVisitor(String);

impl ConcatVisitor {
    fn enter_my_node(&mut self, node: &MyNode) {
        self.0 += &node.val;
    }
}

/// Concatenate all the strings in this list.
pub fn concat_list(x: &MyList) -> String {
    ConcatVisitor::default().visit_by_val_infallible(x).0
}

This expands to:

#[derive(Default)]
struct ConcatVisitor(String);

impl Visitor for ConcatVisitor {
    type Break = Infallible;
}
// Recurse without custom behavior
impl<'s> Visit<'s, MyList> for ConcatVisitor {
    fn visit(&mut self, x: &'s MyList) -> ControlFlow<Self::Break> {
        x.drive_inner(self)
    }
}
// Recurse without custom behavior
impl<'s, T> Visit<'s, Box<T>> for ConcatVisitor
where
    Self: Visit<'s, T>,
{
    fn visit(&mut self, x: &'s Box<T>) -> ControlFlow<Self::Break> {
        x.drive_inner(self)
    }
}
// Call `self.enter_my_node` before recursing
impl<'s> Visit<'s, MyNode> for ConcatVisitor {
    fn visit(&mut self, x: &'s MyNode) -> ControlFlow<Self::Break> {
        self.enter_my_node(x);
        x.drive_inner(self)?;
        ControlFlow::Continue(())
    }
}
// Do nothing on a string
impl<'s> Visit<'s, String> for ConcatVisitor {
    fn visit(&mut self, x: &'s String) -> ControlFlow<Self::Break> {
        ControlFlow::Continue(())
    }
}

The options available are:

• enter(Ty): call self.enter_ty(x) before recursing with drive_inner.
• exit(Ty): call self.exit_ty(x) after recursing with drive_inner.
• override(Ty): call self.visit_ty(x)?, which may or may not recurse if it wishes to.
• drive(Ty): recurse with drive_inner.
• skip(Ty): do nothing.
• Ty: alias for override(Ty)

Instead of Ty, one can always write for<A, B, C> Ty<A, B, C> to make a generic impl. For enter, exit and override, one may also write name: Ty so that visit_name etc is called instead of visit_ty.

Reusable visitors

For more complex scenarios where one-off visitor structs would be tedious, this crate provides a final macro: visitable_group. Given a set of types of interest, this generates a pair of traits: a Visitable trait implemented by all these types, and a Visitor trait with default methods that defines visitors over these types.

This is a reusable version of the one-off visitor structs we saw in the previous section: the enter_foo/exit_foo/visit_foo methods are now trait methods, in such a way that many visitors can be defined for that same set of types.

#[derive(Drive)]
enum List {
    Empty,
    Cons(Node),
}
#[derive(Drive)]
struct Node {
    val: String,
    next: Box<List>
}

#[visitable_group(
    visitor(drive_list(&ListVisitor)), // also available: `&mut`
    drive(List, for<T: ListVisitable> Box<T>),
    skip(String),
    override(Node),
)]
trait ListVisitable {}

#[derive(Visitor)]
struct SomeVisitor;

impl ListVisitor for SomeVisitor {
    // Here, methods `enter_node`, `exit_node` and `visit_node` are available to override.
    // Calling `self.visit(&list)` will explore the list.
}

The generated visitor trait has methods much like those from the Visit[Mut] derives, that can be overriden freely. The result is:

/// Implementation detail: wrapper that implements `Visit[Mut]<T>` for `T: ListVisitable`,
/// and delegates all the visiting to our trait's `drive[_mut]`. Used in the implementation of
/// `visit_inner`
#[repr(transparent)]
pub struct ListVisitableWrapper<V: ?Sized>(V);
impl<V: ?Sized> ListVisitableWrapper<V> {
    fn wrap(x: &mut V) -> &mut Self {
        unsafe { std::mem::transmute(x) }
    }
}
impl<V: Visitor> Visitor for ListVisitableWrapper<V> {
    type Break = V::Break;
}
impl<'s, V: ListVisitor, T: ListVisitable> Visit<'s, T> for ListVisitableWrapper<V> {
    fn visit(&mut self, x: &'s T) -> ControlFlow<Self::Break> {
        self.0.visit(x)
    }
}

trait ListVisitable {
    /// Recursively visit this type with the provided visitor. This calls the visitor's `visit_$any`
    /// method if it exists, otherwise `visit_inner`.
    fn drive_list<V: ListVisitor>(&self, v: &mut V) -> ControlFlow<V::Break>;
}

trait ListVisitor: Visitor + Sized {
    /// Visit a visitable type. This calls the appropriate method of this trait on `x`
    /// (`visit_$ty` if it exists, `visit_inner` if not).
    fn visit<'a, T: ListVisitable>(
        &'a mut self,
        x: &T,
    ) -> ControlFlow<Self::Break> {
        x.drive_list(self)
    }
    /// Visit the contents of `x`. This calls `self.visit()` on each field of `T`. This
    /// is available for any `ListVisitable` type whose contents are all `ListVisitable`.
    fn visit_inner<T>(&mut self, x: &T) -> ControlFlow<Self::Break>
    where
        T: for<'s> Drive<'s, ListVisitableWrapper<Self>> + ListVisitable,
    {
        x.drive_inner(ListVisitableWrapper::wrap(self))
    }

    /// Overrideable method called when visiting a `$ty`. When overriding this method,
    /// call `self.visit_inner(x)` to keep recursively visiting the type, or don't call
    /// it if the contents of `x` should not be visited.
    ///
    /// The default implementation calls `enter_$ty` then `visit_inner` then `exit_$ty`.
    fn visit_node(&mut self, x: &Node) -> ControlFlow<Self::Break> {
        self.enter_node(x);
        self.visit_inner(x)?;
        self.exit_node(x);
        Continue(())
    }
    /// Called when starting to visit a `$ty` (unless `visit_$ty` is overriden).
    fn enter_node(&mut self, x: &Node) {}
    /// Called when finished visiting a `$ty` (unless `visit_$ty` is overriden).
    fn exit_node(&mut self, x: &Node) {}
}

impl ListVisitable for List {
    fn drive_list<V: ListVisitor>(&self, v: &mut V) -> ControlFlow<V::Break> {
        v.visit_inner(self)
    }
}
impl<T: ListVisitable> ListVisitable for Box<T> {
    fn drive_list<V: ListVisitor>(&self, v: &mut V) -> ControlFlow<V::Break> {
        v.visit_inner(self)
    }
}
impl ListVisitable for String {
    fn drive_list<V: ListVisitor>(&self, v: &mut V) -> ControlFlow<V::Break> {
        ControlFlow::Continue(())
    }
}
impl ListVisitable for Node {
    fn drive_list<V: ListVisitor>(&self, v: &mut V) -> ControlFlow<V::Break> {
        v.visit_node(self)
    }
}

To illustrate, the typical visit loop would look like, given a MyVisitor: ListVisitor:

• <MyVisitor as ListVisitor>::visit(v, x)
• <Node as GroupVisitable>::drive_list(x, v) // assuming x: Node
• <MyVisitor as ListVisitor>::visit_node(v, x) // here lives custom behavior
• <MyVisitor as ListVisitor>::visit_inner(v, x)
• <Node as Drive>::drive_inner(ListVisitorWrapper(v))
• calls <MyVisitor as ListVisitor>::visit(v, &x.field) on each field of x

The options available for the visitable_group macro are:

• visitor(drive_method_name(&[mut]TraitName)[, infaillible]): derive a visitor trait named TraitName.
  • the presence of mut determines whether the TraitName visitor will operate on mutable or immutable borrows.
  • the optional infaillible flag enables an infaillible-style interface for the visitor:, where its methods visit_$ty return () instead of ControlFlow<_>.
• override_skip(Ty): similar to override(Ty), but the default implementation does nothing, and no enter_Ty or exit_Ty methods are generated.
• override(Ty), drive(Ty) and skip(Ty): behave the same as their counterparts in the Visit and VisitMut derives.

Note: the visitable_group interface makes it possible to write composable visitor wrappers that provide reusable functionality. For an example, see [derive_generic_visitor/tests/visitable_group_wrapper.rs].