# Glass v7 & DaemonicError Implementation Roadmap
**Session:** Ada v8.5 + Meph collaborative session
**Date:** May 2026
**Status:** Implementation planning
---
## Core Discovery This Session
**Glass<GLASS> IS a general-purpose pattern matching engine.**
Every Glass implementation is a template. Every observation through Glass is a match
operation. Every match result is a new template. The system generates its own matching
patterns through operation. The severity spectrum is a match quality spectrum.
This changes nothing about implementation (it was already built correctly) but changes
everything about documentation and how new features are framed.
---
## TIER 0: Already Done (this session)
- [x] `?Sized` comment block → proper doc comment
- [x] `lock_frame` stub → real signature with `&mut self` + `locker_position`
- [x] `into_result` → `Box<dyn DaemonicError>` return type + Cracked-to-Ok policy
- [x] Severity docs → all 11 variants documented as match quality indicators
- [x] `Unknown` fidelity action → changed from `Warn` to `Attend`
- [x] 13 axioms formalized and stress-tested
- [x] Four documents drafted (axiom paper v3, observations v1.1, Ada observations v1, instantiation v8.5)
---
## TIER 1: Glass Module Additions (immediate, unblocks everything else)
### 1a. ObservationTier enum (NEW)
```rust
pub(crate) enum ObservationTier {
/// Symbols that cannot be broken down further.
/// Finite, fully enumerable state space. 0-9 in base 10.
Absolute,
/// Conceptually atomic but substrate-decomposable.
/// u8, i32, bool, char.
Primitive,
/// Structures composed from primitives.
/// Structs, enums, containers, most application types.
Composed,
/// Symbols that carry their own instruction logic.
/// Glass states, DaemonicErrors, repair enclosures.
GlyphicExecutable,
}
```
Add `fn tier(&self) -> ObservationTier` to Glass trait, defaulted to `Composed`.
### 1b. FidelityAction::Drop (NEW)
```rust
pub(crate) enum FidelityAction {
Continue,
Attend,
Warn,
Halt,
Abort,
/// Emergency containment. Destroy the Glass to prevent
/// corrupted content from being observed by others.
/// Requires justification signature (Axiom 1 compliance).
/// Triggers TemporalStackUnwind from the Glass's position.
Drop,
}
```
Add `Drop` to fidelity_action match — triggered by temporal corruption detection.
### 1c. Boundary Protocol (Glass ↔ Result/Option)
```rust
// Result → Glass (information-adding)
impl<T, E: std::error::Error> From<Result<T, E>> for Observation<T> {
fn from(result: Result<T, E>) -> Self {
match result {
Ok(value) => Observation::ok(value, pos!()),
Err(e) => Observation::shattered(pos!())
.with_note(e.to_string()),
}
}
}
// Option → Glass (None = Unknown, not error)
impl<T> From<Option<T>> for Observation<T> {
fn from(opt: Option<T>) -> Self {
match opt {
Some(value) => Observation::ok(value, pos!()),
None => Observation::unknown(pos!()),
}
}
}
```
### 1d. glass!() macro
```rust
/// Glass equivalent of Rust's `?` operator.
/// Extracts payload from Stable/Cracked Glass.
/// Early-returns on all other severities.
/// Configurable threshold via `allow:` syntax.
macro_rules! glass {
($expr:expr) => { /* Stable only */ };
($expr:expr, allow: $($state:pat),+) => { /* Stable + listed */ };
}
```
---
## TIER 2: DaemonicError Fixes (requires Tier 1)
### 2a. DaemonicError dyn-compatibility split
Split into dyn-compatible core + static extension:
**Core (dyn-compatible):**
- `position(&self) -> &Position`
- `context(&self) -> &dyn ErrorContext`
- `severity(&self) -> Severity`
- `is_recoverable(&self) -> bool`
- `source_position(&self) -> Option<&Position>`
- `emit_generic(&self) -> Box<dyn Glass<GenericError>>`
- `emit_symbolic(&self) -> Box<dyn Glass<SymbolicError>>`
- `emit_daemonic(&self) -> Box<dyn Glass<Daemonic>>`
**Extension (static only):**
- `emit_diagnostic<D: Diagnostic>(&self) -> D`
- `emit_subdiagnostic<S: Subdiagnostic>(&self) -> S`
### 2b. Debug/Display as Glass operations
DaemonicDebug and DaemonicDisplay return Glass, not strings.
Debug observes through Glass → produces Glass observations about the target.
Display renders Glass → produces Glass observations about presentation.
Neither depends on DaemonicError directly. Both depend on Glass.
```
Glass (foundation)
├── DaemonicError (content of dark Glass states)
│ Error is a Glass PAYLOAD, not a peer of Glass
├── DaemonicDebug (Mirror that observes Glass → produces Glass)
│ Debug depends on Glass, not on Error
└── DaemonicDisplay (Mirror that renders Glass → produces Glass)
Display depends on Glass, not on Error
```
### 2c. Timestamp struct fixes
- `check_zero` → returns `Result<(), BrokenSword>` not impl block
- BrokenSword error type for "time has become meaningless"
- Multi-tier clock stub: `i64` multiplier + `i64` values
- Rollover detection triggering epoch increment
### 2d. Position struct
- Adopt Sinon's SmallVec suggestion: `SmallVec<[&'static str; 8]>`
- Stack-allocated for depth ≤ 8, heap for deeper
- `depth()`, `prepend()`, `as_path()` methods
---
## TIER 3: New Constructs (requires Tier 2)
### 3a. SymbolicInsanity enum (top-level Daemonic error category)
```rust
pub enum SymbolicInsanity {
Drift(InsanityDrift),
Spiral(InsanitySpiral),
Detachment(InsanityDetachment),
Crystallization(InsanityCrystallization),
GodSymbol(GodSymbolEmergence),
SharedHallucination(MeshInsanity),
}
```
With shared detection trait:
```rust
trait InsanityDetectable {
fn internal_consistency(&self) -> f64;
fn external_correlation(&self) -> f64;
fn observation_diversity(&self) -> f64;
fn is_self_reinforcing(&self) -> bool;
}
```
### 3b. Panic-safe repair enclosure wrapper
```rust
fn execute_repair<GLASS: Glass<GLASS>>(
repair: &dyn Fn(&GLASS) -> bool,
target: &GLASS,
position: Position,
) -> impl Glass<bool> {
match catch_unwind(AssertUnwindSafe(|| repair(target))) {
Ok(true) => Observation::ok(true, position),
Ok(false) => Observation::cracked(false, position)
.with_note("Repair executed but reported failure"),
Err(panic_info) => Observation::shattered(position)
.with_note(format!("Repair enclosure panicked: {}",
extract_panic_msg(&panic_info))),
}
}
```
### 3c. TemporalStackUnwind
```rust
struct TemporalStackUnwind {
trigger: DropSignature,
unwind_chain: Vec<UnwindFrame>,
initiation_tick: Timestamp,
}
```
Each frame unwound produces a Glass observation with timestamp.
The unwind IS the autopsy. Broken Sword protocol.
### 3d. Cross-Tier Reconciliation (NEW - from this session)
```rust
struct ReconciledObservation {
reconciled_severity: Severity,
tier_observations: Vec<(ObservationTier, Severity)>,
root_tier: ObservationTier,
tier_agreement: f64,
causal_direction: CausalDirection,
}
enum CausalDirection {
BottomUp { cause_tier: ObservationTier, effect_tier: ObservationTier },
TopDown { cause_tier: ObservationTier, effect_tier: ObservationTier },
Systemic,
Independent,
}
```
---
## TIER 4: Observer-side additions (requires Tier 3)
### 4a. Template accumulation on DaemonicObserver
```rust
trait DaemonicObserver<GLASS: Glass<GLASS>>: Send + Sync {
type TemplateLibrary;
fn absorb_template(&mut self, observation: &impl Glass<GLASS>);
fn match_against_templates<T: Observable>(
&self, target: &T
) -> impl Glass<MatchResult>;
}
```
Templates are observer-specific. Different observers accumulate
different templates from different observation histories.
### 4b. SeverityTrend (the Chernobyl monitor)
```rust
pub struct SeverityTrend {
pub current: Severity,
pub baseline: Severity,
pub window_size: usize,
pub escalation_rate: f64,
pub accelerating: bool,
}
```
First derivative: how fast is severity changing.
Second derivative: is the rate of change itself changing.
Trend overrides absolute severity when acceleration is positive.
### 4c. Observation cost ratio tracking
Track meta-observation ticks vs productive-work ticks.
Flag when ratio exceeds threshold (observation system
consuming disproportionate resources relative to productive work).
---
## TIER 5: Infrastructure (requires Tier 4, pre-mesh)
### 5a. PhysicsViolation error category
Produces Impossible states. For axiom violations,
temporal integrity violations, causality violations.
Includes StackTraversalError subtype.
### 5b. Entropic DOS detection
Variance-based noise floor detection for near-zero
delta oscillation that mimics work but produces no
meaningful state change.
### 5c. GodSymbol detection metrics
```rust
pub struct GodSymbolEmergence {
pub symbol_position: Position,
pub assessment_frame: Position,
pub bypass_cost: f64,
pub traversal_cost: f64,
pub gravity_ratio: f64,
pub routing_entropy: f64,
}
```
Three-property detection: reference density + routing influence
+ decision authority. All three required for God Symbol classification.
High-density supportive symbols (Tokio-like) are NOT God Symbols.
---
## Dependency Chain
```
Tier 0 (done)
→ Tier 1 (Glass additions)
→ Tier 2 (DE fixes)
→ Tier 3 (new constructs)
→ Tier 4 (observer additions)
→ Tier 5 (infrastructure)
```
Each tier builds on the previous. No tier can be skipped.
Tier 1 is the immediate next work. Everything else follows.
---
## Release Gating
**daemonic_axioms crate:** Ready to publish NOW.
Contains axiom paper, observations, template. No code dependencies.
**DaemonicError crate v7.0:** Requires Tier 1 + Tier 2 minimum.
Tier 3 can ship in v7.1. Tier 4 in v7.2. Tier 5 in v7.3.
**Ship the axiom crate first. Let the community digest it.
Ship DE when Tier 2 is complete. Iterate from there.**
---
*"The Glass doesn't lie. It reflects."*