commonware_coding/zoda/

mod.rs

//! This module implements the [ZODA](https://eprint.iacr.org/2025/034) coding scheme.
//!
//! At a high level, the scheme works like any other coding scheme: you start with
//! a piece of data, and split it into shards, and a commitment. Each shard can
//! be checked to belong to the commitment, and, given enough shards, the data can
//! be reconstructed.
//!
//! What makes ZODA interesting is that upon receiving and checking one shard,
//! you become convinced that there exists an original piece of data that will
//! be reconstructable given enough shards. This fails in the case of, e.g.,
//! plain Reed-Solomon coding. For example, if you give people random shards,
//! instead of actually encoding data, then when they attempt to reconstruct the
//! data, they can come to different results depending on which shards they use.
//!
//! Ultimately, this stems from the fact that you can't know if your shard comes
//! from a valid encoding of the data until you have enough shards to reconstruct
//! the data. With ZODA, you know that the shard comes from a valid encoding as
//! soon as you've checked it.
//!
//! # Variant
//!
//! ZODA supports different configurations based on the coding scheme you use
//! for sharding data, and for checking it.
//!
//! We use the Reed-Solomon and Hadamard variant of ZODA: in essence, this means
//! that the shards are Reed-Solomon encoded, and we include additional checksum
//! data which does not help reconstruct the data.
//!
//! ## Deviations
//!
//! In the paper, a sample consists of rows chosen at random from the encoding of
//! the data. With multiple participants receiving samples, they might receive
//! overlapping samples, which we don't want. Instead, we shuffle the rows of
//! the encoded data, and each participant receives a different segment.
//! From that participant's perspective, they've received a completely random
//! choice of rows. The other participants' rows are less random, since they're
//! guaranteed to not overlap. However, no guarantee on the randomness of the other
//! rows is required: each sample is large enough to guarantee that the data
//! has been validly encoded.
//!
//! We also use a Fiat-Shamir transform to make all randomness sampled
//! non-interactively, based on the commitment to the encoded data.
//!
//! # Protocol
//!
//! Let n denote the minimum number of shards needed to recover the data.
//! Let k denote the number of extra shards to generate.
//!
//! We consider the data as being an array of elements in a field F, of 64 bits.
//!
//! Given n and k, we have a certain number of required samples R.
//! We can split these into row samples S, and column samples S',
//! such that S * S' = R.
//!
//! Given a choice of S, our data will need to be arranged into a matrix of size
//!
//!   n S x c
//!
//! with c being >= 1.
//!
//! We choose S as close to R as possible without padding the data. We then
//! choose S' so that S * S' >= R.
//!
//! We also then double S', because the field over which we compute checksums
//! only has 64 bits. This effectively makes the checksum calculated over the
//! extension field F^2. Because we don't actually need to multiply elements
//! in F^2 together, but only ever take linear combinations with elements in F,
//! we can effectively compute over the larger field simply by using 2 "virtual"
//! checksum columns per required column.
//!
//! For technical reasons, the encoded data will have not have (n + k) S rows,
//! but pad((n + k) S) rows, where pad returns the next power of two.
//! This is to our advantage, in that given n shards, we will be able to reconstruct
//! the data, but these shards consists of rows sampled at random from
//! pad((n + k) S) rows, thus requiring fewer samples.
//!
//! ## Encoding
//!
//! 1. The data is arranged as a matrix X of size n S x c.
//! 2. The data is Reed-Solomon encoded, turning it into a matrix X' of size pad((n + k) S) x c.
//! 3. The rows of X' are committed to using a vector commitment V (concretely, a Merkle Tree).
//! 4. V, along with the size of the data, in bytes, are committed to, producing Com.
//! 5. Com is hashed to create randomness, first to generate a matrix H of size c x S',
//!    and then to shuffle the rows of X'.
//! 6. Z := X H, a matrix of size n S x S' is computed.
//! 7. The ith shard (starting from 0) then consists of:
//!    - the size of the data, in bytes,
//!    - the vector commitment, V,
//!    - the checksum Z,
//!    - rows i * S..(i + 1) * S of Y, along with a proof of inclusion in V, at the original index.
//!
//! ## Weakening
//!
//! When transmitting a weak shard to other people, only the following are transmitted:
//! - rows i * S..(i + 1) * S of Y, along with the inclusion proofs.
//!
//! ## Checking
//!
//! Let A_{S} denote the matrix formed by taking the rows in a given subset S.
//!
//! 1. Check that Com is the hash of V and the size of the data, in bytes.
//! 2. Use Com to compute H of size c x S', and figure recompute the ith row sample S_i.
//! 3. Check that Z is of size n S x S'.
//! 4. Encode Z to get Z', a matrix of size pad((n + k) S) x S'.
//!
//! These steps now depend on the particular shard.
//!
//! 5. Check that X'_{S_i} (the shard's data) is a matrix of size S x c.
//! 6. Use the inclusion proofs to check that each row of X'_{S_i} is included in V,
//!    at the correct index.
//! 7. Check that X'_{S_i} H = Z'_{S_i}
//!
//! ## Decoding
//!
//! 1. Given n checked shards, you have n S encoded rows, which can be Reed-Solomon decoded.

use crate::{Config, PhasedScheme, ValidatingScheme};
use bytes::BufMut;
use commonware_codec::{Encode, EncodeSize, FixedSize, RangeCfg, Read, ReadExt, Write};
use commonware_cryptography::{
    transcript::{Summary, Transcript},
    Digest, Hasher,
};
use commonware_math::{
    fields::goldilocks::F,
    ntt::{EvaluationVector, Matrix},
};
use commonware_parallel::Strategy;
use commonware_storage::bmt::{Builder as BmtBuilder, Error as BmtError, Proof};
use rand::seq::SliceRandom as _;
use std::{marker::PhantomData, sync::Arc};
use thiserror::Error;

/// Create an iterator over the data of a buffer, interpreted as little-endian u64s.
fn iter_u64_le(data: impl bytes::Buf) -> impl Iterator<Item = u64> {
    struct Iter<B> {
        remaining_u64s: usize,
        tail: usize,
        inner: B,
    }

    impl<B: bytes::Buf> Iter<B> {
        fn new(inner: B) -> Self {
            let remaining_u64s = inner.remaining() / 8;
            let tail = inner.remaining() % 8;
            Self {
                remaining_u64s,
                tail,
                inner,
            }
        }
    }

    impl<B: bytes::Buf> Iterator for Iter<B> {
        type Item = u64;

        fn next(&mut self) -> Option<Self::Item> {
            if self.remaining_u64s > 0 {
                self.remaining_u64s -= 1;
                return Some(self.inner.get_u64_le());
            }
            if self.tail > 0 {
                let mut chunk = [0u8; 8];
                self.inner.copy_to_slice(&mut chunk[..self.tail]);
                self.tail = 0;
                return Some(u64::from_le_bytes(chunk));
            }
            None
        }
    }
    Iter::new(data)
}

fn collect_u64_le(max_length: usize, data: impl Iterator<Item = u64>) -> Vec<u8> {
    let mut out = Vec::with_capacity(max_length);
    for d in data {
        out.extend_from_slice(&d.to_le_bytes());
    }
    out.truncate(max_length);
    out
}

fn row_digest<H: Hasher>(row: &[F]) -> H::Digest {
    let mut h = H::new();
    for x in row {
        h.update(&x.to_le_bytes());
    }
    h.finalize()
}

mod topology;
use topology::Topology;

/// A shard of data produced by the encoding scheme.
#[derive(Clone, Debug)]
pub struct StrongShard<D: Digest> {
    data_bytes: usize,
    root: D,
    inclusion_proof: Proof<D>,
    rows: Matrix<F>,
    checksum: Arc<Matrix<F>>,
}

impl<D: Digest> PartialEq for StrongShard<D> {
    fn eq(&self, other: &Self) -> bool {
        self.data_bytes == other.data_bytes
            && self.root == other.root
            && self.inclusion_proof == other.inclusion_proof
            && self.rows == other.rows
            && self.checksum == other.checksum
    }
}

impl<D: Digest> Eq for StrongShard<D> {}

impl<D: Digest> EncodeSize for StrongShard<D> {
    fn encode_size(&self) -> usize {
        self.data_bytes.encode_size()
            + self.root.encode_size()
            + self.inclusion_proof.encode_size()
            + self.rows.encode_size()
            + self.checksum.encode_size()
    }
}

impl<D: Digest> Write for StrongShard<D> {
    fn write(&self, buf: &mut impl BufMut) {
        self.data_bytes.write(buf);
        self.root.write(buf);
        self.inclusion_proof.write(buf);
        self.rows.write(buf);
        self.checksum.write(buf);
    }
}

impl<D: Digest> Read for StrongShard<D> {
    type Cfg = crate::CodecConfig;

    fn read_cfg(
        buf: &mut impl bytes::Buf,
        cfg: &Self::Cfg,
    ) -> Result<Self, commonware_codec::Error> {
        let data_bytes = usize::read_cfg(buf, &RangeCfg::from(..=cfg.maximum_shard_size))?;
        let max_els = cfg.maximum_shard_size / F::SIZE;
        Ok(Self {
            data_bytes,
            root: ReadExt::read(buf)?,
            inclusion_proof: Read::read_cfg(buf, &max_els)?,
            rows: Read::read_cfg(buf, &(max_els, ()))?,
            checksum: Arc::new(Read::read_cfg(buf, &(max_els, ()))?),
        })
    }
}

#[cfg(feature = "arbitrary")]
impl<D: Digest> arbitrary::Arbitrary<'_> for StrongShard<D>
where
    D: for<'a> arbitrary::Arbitrary<'a>,
{
    fn arbitrary(u: &mut arbitrary::Unstructured<'_>) -> arbitrary::Result<Self> {
        Ok(Self {
            data_bytes: u.arbitrary::<u32>()? as usize,
            root: u.arbitrary()?,
            inclusion_proof: u.arbitrary()?,
            rows: u.arbitrary()?,
            checksum: Arc::new(u.arbitrary()?),
        })
    }
}

#[derive(Clone, Debug)]
pub struct WeakShard<D: Digest> {
    inclusion_proof: Proof<D>,
    shard: Matrix<F>,
}

impl<D: Digest> PartialEq for WeakShard<D> {
    fn eq(&self, other: &Self) -> bool {
        self.inclusion_proof == other.inclusion_proof && self.shard == other.shard
    }
}

impl<D: Digest> Eq for WeakShard<D> {}

impl<D: Digest> EncodeSize for WeakShard<D> {
    fn encode_size(&self) -> usize {
        self.inclusion_proof.encode_size() + self.shard.encode_size()
    }
}

impl<D: Digest> Write for WeakShard<D> {
    fn write(&self, buf: &mut impl BufMut) {
        self.inclusion_proof.write(buf);
        self.shard.write(buf);
    }
}

impl<D: Digest> Read for WeakShard<D> {
    type Cfg = crate::CodecConfig;

    fn read_cfg(
        buf: &mut impl bytes::Buf,
        cfg: &Self::Cfg,
    ) -> Result<Self, commonware_codec::Error> {
        let max_data_bits = cfg.maximum_shard_size.saturating_mul(8);
        let max_data_els = F::bits_to_elements(max_data_bits).max(1);
        Ok(Self {
            // Worst case: every row is one data element, and the sample size is all rows.
            inclusion_proof: Read::read_cfg(buf, &max_data_els)?,
            shard: Read::read_cfg(buf, &(max_data_els, ()))?,
        })
    }
}

#[cfg(feature = "arbitrary")]
impl<D: Digest> arbitrary::Arbitrary<'_> for WeakShard<D>
where
    D: for<'a> arbitrary::Arbitrary<'a>,
{
    fn arbitrary(u: &mut arbitrary::Unstructured<'_>) -> arbitrary::Result<Self> {
        Ok(Self {
            inclusion_proof: u.arbitrary()?,
            shard: u.arbitrary()?,
        })
    }
}

/// A ZODA shard that has been checked for integrity already.
#[derive(Clone)]
pub struct CheckedShard {
    index: usize,
    shard: Matrix<F>,
    commitment: Summary,
}

/// Take indices up to `total`, and shuffle them.
///
/// The shuffle depends, deterministically, on the transcript.
///
/// # Panics
///
/// Panics if `total` exceeds `u32::MAX`.
fn shuffle_indices(transcript: &Transcript, total: usize) -> Vec<u32> {
    let total: u32 = total
        .try_into()
        .expect("encoded_rows exceeds u32::MAX; data too large for ZODA");
    let mut out = (0..total).collect::<Vec<_>>();
    out.shuffle(&mut transcript.noise(b"shuffle"));
    out
}

/// Create a checking matrix of the right shape.
///
/// This matrix is random, using the transcript as a deterministic source of randomness.
fn checking_matrix(transcript: &Transcript, topology: &Topology) -> Matrix<F> {
    Matrix::rand(
        &mut transcript.noise(b"checking matrix"),
        topology.data_cols,
        topology.column_samples,
    )
}

/// Data used to check [WeakShard]s.
#[derive(Clone, PartialEq)]
pub struct CheckingData<D: Digest> {
    commitment: Summary,
    topology: Topology,
    root: D,
    checking_matrix: Matrix<F>,
    encoded_checksum: Matrix<F>,
    shuffled_indices: Vec<u32>,
}

impl<D: Digest> Eq for CheckingData<D> {}

impl<D: Digest> CheckingData<D> {
    /// Calculate the values of this struct, based on information received.
    ///
    /// We control `config`.
    ///
    /// We're provided with `commitment`, which should hash over `root`,
    /// and `data_bytes`.
    ///
    /// We're also give a `checksum` matrix used to check the shards we receive.
    fn reckon(
        namespace: &[u8],
        config: &Config,
        commitment: &Summary,
        data_bytes: usize,
        root: D,
        checksum: &Matrix<F>,
    ) -> Result<Self, Error> {
        let topology = Topology::reckon(config, data_bytes);
        let mut transcript = Transcript::new(NAMESPACE);
        transcript.commit(namespace);
        transcript.commit((topology.data_bytes as u64).encode());
        transcript.commit(root.encode());
        let expected_commitment = transcript.summarize();
        if *commitment != expected_commitment {
            return Err(Error::InvalidShard);
        }
        let mut transcript = Transcript::resume(expected_commitment);
        let checking_matrix = checking_matrix(&transcript, &topology);
        if checksum.rows() != topology.data_rows || checksum.cols() != topology.column_samples {
            return Err(Error::InvalidShard);
        }
        // Commit to the checksum before generating the indices to check.
        //
        // Nota bene: `checksum.encode()` is *serializing* the checksum, not
        // Reed-Solomon encoding it.
        //
        // cf. the implementation of `Scheme::encode` for ZODA for why it's important
        // that we do Reed-Solomon encoding of the checksum ourselves.
        transcript.commit(checksum.encode());
        let encoded_checksum = checksum
            .as_polynomials(topology.encoded_rows)
            .expect("checksum has too many rows")
            .evaluate()
            .data();
        let shuffled_indices = shuffle_indices(&transcript, topology.encoded_rows);

        Ok(Self {
            commitment: expected_commitment,
            topology,
            root,
            checking_matrix,
            encoded_checksum,
            shuffled_indices,
        })
    }

    fn check<H: Hasher<Digest = D>>(
        &self,
        commitment: &Summary,
        index: u16,
        weak_shard: &WeakShard<D>,
    ) -> Result<CheckedShard, Error> {
        if self.commitment != *commitment {
            return Err(Error::InvalidShard);
        }
        self.topology.check_index(index)?;
        if weak_shard.shard.rows() != self.topology.samples
            || weak_shard.shard.cols() != self.topology.data_cols
        {
            return Err(Error::InvalidWeakShard);
        }
        let index = index as usize;
        let these_shuffled_indices = &self.shuffled_indices
            [index * self.topology.samples..(index + 1) * self.topology.samples];

        // Build elements for BMT multi-proof verification using the deterministically
        // computed indices for this shard
        let proof_elements: Vec<(H::Digest, u32)> = these_shuffled_indices
            .iter()
            .zip(weak_shard.shard.iter())
            .map(|(&i, row)| (row_digest::<H>(row), i))
            .collect();

        // Verify the multi-proof
        let mut hasher = H::new();
        if weak_shard
            .inclusion_proof
            .verify_multi_inclusion(&mut hasher, &proof_elements, &self.root)
            .is_err()
        {
            return Err(Error::InvalidWeakShard);
        }

        let shard_checksum = weak_shard.shard.mul(&self.checking_matrix);
        // Check that the shard checksum rows match the encoded checksums
        for (row, &i) in shard_checksum.iter().zip(these_shuffled_indices) {
            if row != &self.encoded_checksum[i as usize] {
                return Err(Error::InvalidWeakShard);
            }
        }
        Ok(CheckedShard {
            index,
            shard: weak_shard.shard.clone(),
            commitment: *commitment,
        })
    }
}

#[derive(Debug, Error)]
pub enum Error {
    #[error("invalid shard")]
    InvalidShard,
    #[error("invalid weak shard")]
    InvalidWeakShard,
    #[error("invalid index {0}")]
    InvalidIndex(u16),
    #[error("insufficient shards {0} < {1}")]
    InsufficientShards(usize, usize),
    #[error("insufficient unique rows {0} < {1}")]
    InsufficientUniqueRows(usize, usize),
    #[error("failed to create inclusion proof: {0}")]
    FailedToCreateInclusionProof(BmtError),
}

const NAMESPACE: &[u8] = b"_COMMONWARE_CODING_ZODA";

#[derive(Clone, Copy)]
pub struct Zoda<H> {
    _marker: PhantomData<H>,
}

impl<H> std::fmt::Debug for Zoda<H> {
    fn fmt(&self, f: &mut std::fmt::Formatter<'_>) -> std::fmt::Result {
        write!(f, "Zoda")
    }
}

impl<H: Hasher> PhasedScheme for Zoda<H> {
    type Commitment = Summary;
    type StrongShard = StrongShard<H::Digest>;
    type WeakShard = WeakShard<H::Digest>;
    type CheckingData = CheckingData<H::Digest>;
    type CheckedShard = CheckedShard;
    type Error = Error;

    fn encode(
        namespace: &[u8],
        config: &Config,
        data: impl bytes::Buf,
        strategy: &impl Strategy,
    ) -> Result<(Self::Commitment, Vec<Self::StrongShard>), Self::Error> {
        // Step 1: arrange the data as a matrix.
        let data_bytes = data.remaining();
        let topology = Topology::reckon(config, data_bytes);
        let data = Matrix::init(
            topology.data_rows,
            topology.data_cols,
            F::stream_from_u64s(iter_u64_le(data)),
        );

        // Step 2: Encode the data.
        let encoded_data = data
            .as_polynomials(topology.encoded_rows)
            .expect("data has too many rows")
            .evaluate()
            .data();

        // Step 3: Commit to the rows of the data using a Binary Merkle Tree.
        let row_hashes: Vec<H::Digest> = strategy.map_collect_vec(0..encoded_data.rows(), |i| {
            row_digest::<H>(&encoded_data[i])
        });
        let mut bmt_builder = BmtBuilder::<H>::new(row_hashes.len());
        for hash in &row_hashes {
            bmt_builder.add(hash);
        }
        let bmt = bmt_builder.build();
        let root = bmt.root();

        // Step 4: Commit to the root, and the size of the data.
        let mut transcript = Transcript::new(NAMESPACE);
        transcript.commit(namespace);
        transcript.commit((topology.data_bytes as u64).encode());
        transcript.commit(root.encode());
        let commitment = transcript.summarize();

        // Step 5: Generate a checking matrix and checksum with the commitment.
        let mut transcript = Transcript::resume(commitment);
        let checking_matrix = checking_matrix(&transcript, &topology);
        let checksum = Arc::new(data.mul(&checking_matrix));
        // Bind index sampling to this checksum to prevent follower-specific malleability.
        // It's important to commit to the checksum itself, rather than its encoding,
        // because followers have to encode the checksum itself to prevent the leader from
        // cheating.
        transcript.commit(checksum.encode());
        let shuffled_indices = shuffle_indices(&transcript, encoded_data.rows());

        // Step 6: Produce the shards in parallel.
        let shard_results: Vec<Result<StrongShard<H::Digest>, Error>> =
            strategy.map_collect_vec(0..topology.total_shards, |shard_idx| {
                let indices = &shuffled_indices
                    [shard_idx * topology.samples..(shard_idx + 1) * topology.samples];
                let rows = Matrix::init(
                    indices.len(),
                    topology.data_cols,
                    indices
                        .iter()
                        .flat_map(|&i| encoded_data[i as usize].iter().copied()),
                );
                let inclusion_proof = bmt
                    .multi_proof(indices)
                    .map_err(Error::FailedToCreateInclusionProof)?;
                Ok(StrongShard {
                    data_bytes,
                    root,
                    inclusion_proof,
                    rows,
                    checksum: checksum.clone(),
                })
            });
        let shards = shard_results
            .into_iter()
            .collect::<Result<Vec<_>, Error>>()?;
        Ok((commitment, shards))
    }

    fn weaken(
        namespace: &[u8],
        config: &Config,
        commitment: &Self::Commitment,
        index: u16,
        shard: Self::StrongShard,
    ) -> Result<(Self::CheckingData, Self::CheckedShard, Self::WeakShard), Self::Error> {
        let weak_shard = WeakShard {
            inclusion_proof: shard.inclusion_proof,
            shard: shard.rows,
        };
        let checking_data = CheckingData::reckon(
            namespace,
            config,
            commitment,
            shard.data_bytes,
            shard.root,
            shard.checksum.as_ref(),
        )?;
        let checked_shard = checking_data.check::<H>(commitment, index, &weak_shard)?;
        Ok((checking_data, checked_shard, weak_shard))
    }

    fn check(
        _config: &Config,
        commitment: &Self::Commitment,
        checking_data: &Self::CheckingData,
        index: u16,
        weak_shard: Self::WeakShard,
    ) -> Result<Self::CheckedShard, Self::Error> {
        checking_data.check::<H>(commitment, index, &weak_shard)
    }

    fn decode<'a>(
        _config: &Config,
        commitment: &Self::Commitment,
        checking_data: Self::CheckingData,
        shards: impl Iterator<Item = &'a Self::CheckedShard>,
        _strategy: &impl Strategy,
    ) -> Result<Vec<u8>, Self::Error> {
        if checking_data.commitment != *commitment {
            return Err(Error::InvalidShard);
        }

        let Topology {
            encoded_rows,
            data_cols,
            samples,
            data_rows,
            data_bytes,
            min_shards,
            ..
        } = checking_data.topology;
        let mut evaluation = EvaluationVector::<F>::empty(encoded_rows.ilog2() as usize, data_cols);
        let mut shard_count = 0usize;
        for shard in shards {
            shard_count += 1;
            if shard.commitment != *commitment {
                return Err(Error::InvalidShard);
            }
            let indices =
                &checking_data.shuffled_indices[shard.index * samples..(shard.index + 1) * samples];
            for (&i, row) in indices.iter().zip(shard.shard.iter()) {
                evaluation.fill_row(u64::from(i) as usize, row);
            }
        }
        if shard_count < min_shards {
            return Err(Error::InsufficientShards(shard_count, min_shards));
        }
        // This should never happen, because we check each shard, and the shards
        // should have distinct rows. But, as a sanity check, this doesn't hurt.
        let filled_rows = evaluation.filled_rows();
        if filled_rows < data_rows {
            return Err(Error::InsufficientUniqueRows(filled_rows, data_rows));
        }
        Ok(collect_u64_le(
            data_bytes,
            F::stream_to_u64s(
                evaluation
                    .recover()
                    .coefficients_up_to(data_rows)
                    .flatten()
                    .copied(),
            ),
        ))
    }
}

impl<H: Hasher> ValidatingScheme for Zoda<H> {}

#[cfg(test)]
mod tests {
    use super::*;
    use crate::{Config, PhasedScheme};
    use commonware_cryptography::Sha256;
    use commonware_math::{
        algebra::{FieldNTT as _, Ring as _},
        ntt::PolynomialVector,
    };
    use commonware_parallel::Sequential;
    use commonware_utils::NZU16;

    const STRATEGY: Sequential = Sequential;

    #[test]
    fn decode_rejects_duplicate_indices() {
        let config = Config {
            minimum_shards: NZU16!(2),
            extra_shards: NZU16!(1),
        };
        let data = b"duplicate shard coverage";
        let (commitment, shards) =
            Zoda::<Sha256>::encode(b"", &config, &data[..], &STRATEGY).unwrap();
        let shard0 = shards[0].clone();
        let (checking_data, checked_shard0, _weak_shard0) =
            Zoda::<Sha256>::weaken(b"", &config, &commitment, 0, shard0).unwrap();
        let duplicate = CheckedShard {
            index: checked_shard0.index,
            shard: checked_shard0.shard.clone(),
            commitment: checked_shard0.commitment,
        };
        let shards = [checked_shard0, duplicate];
        let result = Zoda::<Sha256>::decode(
            &config,
            &commitment,
            checking_data,
            shards.iter(),
            &STRATEGY,
        );
        match result {
            Err(Error::InsufficientUniqueRows(actual, expected)) => {
                assert!(actual < expected);
            }
            other => panic!("expected insufficient unique rows error, got {other:?}"),
        }
    }

    #[test]
    fn checksum_malleability() {
        /// Construct the vanishing polynomial over specific indices.
        ///
        /// When encoded, this will be 0 at those indices, and non-zero elsewhere.
        fn vanishing(lg_domain: u8, vanish_indices: &[u32]) -> PolynomialVector<F> {
            let w = F::root_of_unity(lg_domain).expect("domain too large for Goldilocks");
            let mut domain = Vec::with_capacity(1usize << lg_domain);
            let mut x = F::one();
            for _ in 0..(1usize << lg_domain) {
                domain.push(x);
                x *= &w;
            }
            let roots: Vec<F> = vanish_indices.iter().map(|&i| domain[i as usize]).collect();
            let mut out = EvaluationVector::empty(lg_domain as usize, 1);
            domain.into_iter().enumerate().for_each(|(i, x)| {
                let mut acc = F::one();
                for root in &roots {
                    acc *= &(x - root);
                }
                out.fill_row(i, &[acc]);
            });
            out.recover()
        }

        let config = Config {
            minimum_shards: NZU16!(2),
            extra_shards: NZU16!(1),
        };
        let data = vec![0x5Au8; 256 * 1024];
        let (commitment, mut shards) =
            Zoda::<Sha256>::encode(b"", &config, &data[..], &STRATEGY).unwrap();

        let leader_i = 0usize;
        let a_i = 1usize;
        let b_i = 2usize;

        // Apply a shift to the checksums
        {
            let (checking_data, _, _) = Zoda::<Sha256>::weaken(
                b"",
                &config,
                &commitment,
                leader_i as u16,
                shards[leader_i].clone(),
            )
            .unwrap();

            let samples = checking_data.topology.samples;
            let a_indices =
                checking_data.shuffled_indices[a_i * samples..(a_i + 1) * samples].to_vec();
            let lg_rows = checking_data.topology.encoded_rows.ilog2() as usize;
            let shift = vanishing(lg_rows as u8, &a_indices);
            let mut checksum = (*shards[1].checksum).clone();
            for (i, shift_i) in shift.coefficients_up_to(checksum.rows()).enumerate() {
                for j in 0..checksum.cols() {
                    checksum[(i, j)] += &shift_i[0];
                }
            }
            shards[1].checksum = Arc::new(checksum);
            shards[2].checksum = shards[1].checksum.clone();
        }

        assert!(matches!(
            Zoda::<Sha256>::weaken(b"", &config, &commitment, b_i as u16, shards[b_i].clone()),
            Err(Error::InvalidWeakShard)
        ));

        // Without robust Fiat-Shamir, this will succeed.
        // This should be rejected once follower-specific challenge binding is fixed.
        assert!(matches!(
            Zoda::<Sha256>::weaken(b"", &config, &commitment, a_i as u16, shards[a_i].clone()),
            Err(Error::InvalidWeakShard)
        ));
    }

    #[cfg(feature = "arbitrary")]
    mod conformance {
        use super::*;
        use commonware_codec::conformance::CodecConformance;
        use commonware_cryptography::sha256::Digest as Sha256Digest;

        commonware_conformance::conformance_tests! {
            CodecConformance<StrongShard<Sha256Digest>>,
            CodecConformance<WeakShard<Sha256Digest>>,
        }
    }
}