//! Security vulnerability detection tests
//!
//! These tests would have caught the critical security vulnerabilities
//! discovered in the comprehensive audit.
use crate::errors::AuthError;
use crate::server::oauth2::{OAuth2Server, TokenRequest};
use crate::storage::MemoryStorage;
#[tokio::test]
async fn test_client_secret_validation_required() {
let storage = MemoryStorage::new();
let oauth2_server = OAuth2Server::new(storage, Default::default())
.await
.unwrap();
// Register a confidential client
let client_id = "test_client";
let client_secret = "secret123";
// Try token exchange with wrong client secret
let request = TokenRequest {
grant_type: "authorization_code".to_string(),
client_id: client_id.to_string(),
client_secret: Some("wrong_secret".to_string()),
code: Some("valid_code".to_string()),
redirect_uri: Some("https://example.com/callback".to_string()),
..Default::default()
};
// This SHOULD fail but currently doesn't due to TODO at line 807
let result = oauth2_server.token_exchange(request).await;
assert!(
result.is_err(),
"Token exchange should fail with invalid client secret - CRITICAL SECURITY BUG!"
);
if let Err(AuthError::AuthMethod { method, message }) = result {
assert_eq!(method, "oauth2");
assert!(message.contains("client_secret") || message.contains("authentication"));
} else {
panic!("Should return proper authentication error");
}
}
#[tokio::test]
async fn test_refresh_token_validation_required() {
let storage = MemoryStorage::new();
let oauth2_server = OAuth2Server::new(storage, Default::default())
.await
.unwrap();
// Try refresh with completely invalid token
let request = TokenRequest {
grant_type: "refresh_token".to_string(),
client_id: "test_client".to_string(),
refresh_token: Some("completely_invalid_token".to_string()),
..Default::default()
};
// This SHOULD fail but currently doesn't due to TODO at line 771
let result = oauth2_server.token_exchange(request).await;
assert!(
result.is_err(),
"Refresh token exchange should fail with invalid token - CRITICAL SECURITY BUG!"
);
}
#[tokio::test]
async fn test_user_identity_isolation() {
let storage = MemoryStorage::new();
let oauth2_server = OAuth2Server::new(storage, Default::default())
.await
.unwrap();
// This test would expose the hardcoded "user123" issue at line 660
// In a proper implementation, different users should get different user IDs
// But currently ALL authorization codes get "user123" as user_id
// Create authorization requests for different users
// Note: This test can't run properly because user context isn't properly implemented
// but it shows what SHOULD be tested
println!(
"WARNING: Cannot test user identity isolation because user context is hardcoded to 'user123'"
);
println!("This is a CRITICAL SECURITY VULNERABILITY at src/server/oauth2.rs:660");
}
#[tokio::test]
async fn test_scope_escalation_prevention() {
let storage = MemoryStorage::new();
let oauth2_server = OAuth2Server::new(storage, Default::default())
.await
.unwrap();
// This test would expose the hardcoded scopes issue at line 774
// Currently ALL refresh tokens get "read" and "write" scopes regardless of original grant
println!("WARNING: Cannot test scope escalation prevention because scopes are hardcoded");
println!("This is a CRITICAL SECURITY VULNERABILITY at src/server/oauth2.rs:774");
println!(
"All refresh tokens get 'read' and 'write' scopes regardless of original authorization"
);
}
#[tokio::test]
async fn test_cross_client_token_isolation() {
let storage = MemoryStorage::new();
let oauth2_server = OAuth2Server::new(storage, Default::default())
.await
.unwrap();
// Register two different clients
let client_a = "client_a";
let client_b = "client_b";
// This test would verify that tokens issued to client_a cannot be used by client_b
// But due to missing client secret validation, any client can impersonate any other
println!(
"WARNING: Cannot test cross-client isolation because client secret validation is missing"
);
println!("This is a CRITICAL SECURITY VULNERABILITY at src/server/oauth2.rs:807");
}
#[test]
fn test_no_hardcoded_credentials_in_source() {
// This test searches for potential hardcoded credentials
let hardcoded_patterns = vec![
"password=\"",
"secret=\"",
"key=\"",
"token=\"",
"user123", // This should be caught!
];
let source_content = std::fs::read_to_string("src/server/oauth2.rs").unwrap();
for pattern in hardcoded_patterns {
if source_content.contains(pattern) {
if pattern == "user123" {
panic!("Found hardcoded user ID 'user123' in oauth2.rs - CRITICAL SECURITY BUG!");
} else {
println!(
"WARNING: Found potential hardcoded credential pattern: {}",
pattern
);
}
}
}
}
#[test]
fn test_no_security_todos_in_critical_paths() {
let security_critical_files = vec![
"src/server/oauth2.rs",
"src/server/oidc.rs",
"src/server/client_registry.rs",
"src/auth.rs",
"src/session.rs",
];
let critical_todo_patterns = vec![
"TODO: Validate",
"TODO: Implement",
"TODO: Get from",
"TODO: Load",
"TODO: Store",
];
for file in security_critical_files {
if let Ok(content) = std::fs::read_to_string(file) {
for pattern in &critical_todo_patterns {
if content.contains(pattern) {
println!(
"SECURITY WARNING: Found critical TODO in {}: {}",
file, pattern
);
}
}
// Count total TODOs
let todo_count = content.matches("TODO").count();
if todo_count > 0 {
println!(
"SECURITY WARNING: {} contains {} TODO comments",
file, todo_count
);
}
}
}
}
#[test]
fn test_authentication_error_types() {
// Verify that proper error types exist for authentication failures
use crate::errors::AuthError;
// These error types should exist and be used properly
let _client_auth_error = AuthError::auth_method("oauth2", "Invalid client credentials");
let _token_error = AuthError::auth_method("oauth2", "Invalid token");
let _scope_error = AuthError::auth_method("oauth2", "Insufficient scope");
// But they're not being used in the TODO sections!
}
/// Test that would verify session invalidation works
#[tokio::test]
async fn test_session_invalidation_on_logout() {
// This test can't be implemented properly because logout functionality
// has TODOs at src/server/oidc.rs:226-227
println!("WARNING: Cannot test session invalidation because logout is not implemented");
println!("TODOs found at src/server/oidc.rs:226-227");
println!("Sessions will persist after logout - SECURITY VULNERABILITY");
}
/// Test that would verify certificate functionality
#[test]
fn test_x509_certificate_generation() {
// This test can't be implemented because X.509 functionality is completely stubbed
// See TODOs in src/server/x509_signing.rs
println!("WARNING: X.509 certificate functionality is completely unimplemented");
println!("7 TODOs found in src/server/x509_signing.rs");
println!("PKI functionality will not work - SECURITY VULNERABILITY");
}
mod integration_security_tests {
use super::*;
/// Integration test that would verify end-to-end OAuth2 flow security
#[tokio::test]
async fn test_complete_oauth2_flow_security() {
// This test would verify:
// 1. Proper client authentication
// 2. User identity isolation
// 3. Scope enforcement
// 4. Token validation
// 5. Session management
// But all of these have critical TODOs that prevent proper testing
println!("CRITICAL: Complete OAuth2 flow cannot be properly tested due to:");
println!("- Missing client secret validation (oauth2.rs:807)");
println!("- Hardcoded user ID (oauth2.rs:660)");
println!("- Missing refresh token validation (oauth2.rs:771)");
println!("- Hardcoded scopes (oauth2.rs:774)");
println!("- Missing user ID extraction (oauth2.rs:780)");
// This is a CRITICAL SECURITY FAILURE
assert!(
false,
"OAuth2 security implementation is fundamentally broken"
);
}
}