memstead_base/engine/

error.rs

//! Engine error envelopes.
//!
//! `EngineError` lifts the typed payloads every consumer pattern-matches
//! on (`BackendError` via `#[from]`, `ValidationError` from the runtime
//! validator, `SlugError` from the slug helper, `ParseError` from the
//! markdown parser). `BootError` is the smaller envelope produced by
//! `Engine::from_workspace_root` and its full counterpart — the failure
//! modes specific to layout detection, workspace-store load, per-mount
//! backend instantiation, and engine construction.

use std::fmt;
use std::path::PathBuf;

use crate::backend::BackendError;
use crate::entity::EntityId;
use crate::entity::id::SlugError;
use crate::entity::parser::ParseError;
use crate::runtime_validator::{MissingRequiredField, ValidationError};

/// Maximum items rendered inline before truncation kicks in. Picked to
/// keep the typical fanout (1–25 items) on one terminal line while
/// still bounding pathological cases (200+ referrers on a hub entity)
/// to a constant prefix plus a count.
pub const INLINE_LIST_CAP: usize = 3;

/// Every payload key an update recognises as mutation content, in one place
/// (consistency-sweep 03/04).
///
/// WHY a constant: four surfaces hand-copied this list and all four disagreed.
/// The `EMPTY_UPDATE` message named seven keys, its own `details` payload
/// named six (dropping `relations_unset`), the CLI's copy named six, and the
/// MCP copies named eight after one of them was corrected. An agent recovering
/// from the refusal was told, on the CLI, that `anchors` is not a recognised
/// mutation key: false, and false about exactly the flow anchors exist for.
/// The refusal now reads its own list, and so does every surface that repeats
/// it.
pub const RECOGNISED_MUTATION_KEYS: &[&str] = &[
    "sections",
    "append_sections",
    "patch_sections",
    "metadata",
    "metadata_unset",
    "declare_relations",
    "relations_unset",
    "anchors",
    "anchors_unset",
];

/// One blocked-direction summary entry for
/// [`EngineError::RenameBlockedByCrossMemPolicy`]. Pairs the
/// referrer's mem with the renaming entity's mem (the edge's
/// actual `referrer → renamed` direction post-rewrite) and the count
/// of distinct referrers in that mem that would emit the blocked
/// rewrite.
#[derive(Debug, Clone, PartialEq, Eq)]
pub struct BlockedReferrer {
    /// Referrer's mem — `from_mem` in the propagated edge's
    /// actual direction.
    pub from_mem: String,
    /// Renaming entity's mem — `to_mem` in the propagated edge's
    /// actual direction. Always the same value across every
    /// `blocked_referrers` entry of a single rename refusal.
    pub to_mem: String,
    /// Distinct referrers in `from_mem` that would emit the
    /// blocked rewrite.
    pub count: usize,
}

impl fmt::Display for BlockedReferrer {
    fn fmt(&self, f: &mut fmt::Formatter<'_>) -> fmt::Result {
        write!(
            f,
            "{} → {} ({} referrer{})",
            self.from_mem,
            self.to_mem,
            self.count,
            if self.count == 1 { "" } else { "s" }
        )
    }
}

fn format_blocked_referrers(items: &[BlockedReferrer]) -> String {
    format_inline_list_overflow(items, "blocked_referrers")
}

/// Occupant rendering for [`EngineError::AlreadyExists`]: a real
/// entity renders its quoted title; a stub renders as "a stub" (with
/// its title when it has one — a titleless stub must never render as
/// an empty title).
fn render_occupant(existing_title: &str, existing_is_stub: bool) -> String {
    match (existing_is_stub, existing_title.is_empty()) {
        (true, true) => "a stub".to_string(),
        (true, false) => format!("a stub titled '{existing_title}'"),
        (false, _) => format!("'{existing_title}'"),
    }
}

/// Render a structured-list payload onto the text-mirror message. The
/// first [`INLINE_LIST_CAP`] items appear inline, comma-separated; when
/// the list is longer, the suffix " +N more — see details.<field>"
/// points the agent at the structured channel's typed list under
/// `field`. Empty input renders as an empty string. The function is
/// generic over any [`fmt::Display`] item — wrap structs in a small
/// `Display` newtype if their default rendering is too verbose for the
/// text channel.
pub fn format_inline_list_overflow<T: fmt::Display>(items: &[T], field: &str) -> String {
    if items.is_empty() {
        return String::new();
    }
    let head: Vec<String> = items
        .iter()
        .take(INLINE_LIST_CAP)
        .map(|i| i.to_string())
        .collect();
    let inline = head.join(", ");
    if items.len() > INLINE_LIST_CAP {
        let extra = items.len() - INLINE_LIST_CAP;
        format!("{inline} +{extra} more — see details.{field}")
    } else {
        inline
    }
}

/// One resolution-source line on [`EngineError::SchemaNotFound`]'s
/// `details.sources` payload.
///
/// The schema registry consults sources in a fixed order — local
/// storage (the mem's own storage backend), built-in (compiled into
/// the engine binary), remote (memstead.io, reserved) — and records
/// what each held for the pinned *name* so an agent or operator can
/// tell *where* a pin failed: missing from local authoring, absent
/// from the shipped catalogue, or past the not-yet-wired remote. The
/// `local_storage`/`builtin` lines report a wrong-version partial
/// match (right name, wrong version) through `pinned_version_match`.
#[derive(Debug, Clone, PartialEq, Eq, serde::Serialize)]
pub struct SchemaSourceDiagnostic {
    /// Stable source label: `"local_storage"`, `"builtin"`, or
    /// `"remote"`. Agents may branch on it.
    pub source: &'static str,
    /// Versions of the pinned *name* this source held, ascending.
    /// Empty when the source carried nothing for that name — or was
    /// not enumerated (today only `remote`, see `status`).
    pub versions_found: Vec<String>,
    /// `true` when the pinned exact version is among `versions_found`.
    /// Always `false` across every source on a genuine not-found (the
    /// fixed resolution order means a match on any source would have
    /// resolved); a lone `true` here signals right-name/wrong-version.
    pub pinned_version_match: bool,
    /// Non-enumerable status for sources that do not list versions —
    /// today only `remote`, which reports `"not_configured"`. `None`
    /// for the enumerable `local_storage`/`builtin` sources.
    #[serde(skip_serializing_if = "Option::is_none")]
    pub status: Option<&'static str>,
}

impl SchemaSourceDiagnostic {
    /// Build the fixed-order source diagnostics for a failed pin.
    ///
    /// `consulted` is the resolution set the call site actually
    /// searched: at boot it is the workspace-authored schemas layered
    /// over the built-ins; at the create/migration sites it is the
    /// set that path consulted (built-in alone, or workspace + built-in
    /// for the migration resolver). The `builtin` line is recomputed
    /// from the static catalogue so it is honest regardless of what the
    /// caller passed; anything in `consulted` the built-in set does not
    /// carry is attributed to `local_storage`. `remote` is always the
    /// reserved `not_configured` slot.
    pub fn for_failed_pin(
        name: &str,
        requested: &semver::Version,
        consulted: &[std::sync::Arc<memstead_schema::Schema>],
    ) -> Vec<Self> {
        use std::collections::BTreeSet;
        let builtin: BTreeSet<semver::Version> = memstead_schema::builtins::load_builtin_schemas()
            .map(|set| {
                set.iter()
                    .filter(|s| s.manifest.name == name)
                    .map(|s| s.version.clone())
                    .collect()
            })
            .unwrap_or_default();
        let local: BTreeSet<semver::Version> = consulted
            .iter()
            .filter(|s| s.manifest.name == name)
            .map(|s| s.version.clone())
            .filter(|v| !builtin.contains(v))
            .collect();
        let to_strings =
            |set: &BTreeSet<semver::Version>| set.iter().map(|v| v.to_string()).collect::<Vec<_>>();
        vec![
            Self {
                source: "local_storage",
                pinned_version_match: local.contains(requested),
                versions_found: to_strings(&local),
                status: None,
            },
            Self {
                source: "builtin",
                pinned_version_match: builtin.contains(requested),
                versions_found: to_strings(&builtin),
                status: None,
            },
            Self {
                source: "remote",
                versions_found: Vec::new(),
                pinned_version_match: false,
                status: Some("not_configured"),
            },
        ]
    }
}

/// Errors surfaced by [`Engine`].
///
/// `Backend` lifts [`BackendError`] verbatim through a `#[from]`
/// conversion so the engine layer's error envelope preserves the
/// backend's typed `Sealed` / `HashMismatch` payloads. The MCP layer
/// branches on the discriminant when mapping into the typed `code`
/// field of its error envelope.
#[derive(Debug, thiserror::Error)]
pub enum EngineError {
    /// `Engine::from_mounts` received two mounts naming the same
    /// mem. Configuration error: the persistence adapter or
    /// caller produced a malformed mount list.
    #[error("duplicate mem in mount list: {0}")]
    DuplicateMem(String),
    /// No mount in this engine names the requested mem. Surfaced
    /// before reaching any backend so callers can distinguish
    /// "wrong mem name" from "backend failure".
    #[error("unknown mem: {0}")]
    UnknownMem(String),
    /// The mem exists in the workspace but failed its mem-level boot
    /// step and is quarantined — it serves nothing until repaired
    /// (degrade, never disappear; quarantine is not tolerance).
    /// `reason_message` is the underlying typed failure verbatim, its
    /// final clause the repair command; after the repair,
    /// `memstead_reload` re-attaches the mem without a restart.
    #[error(
        "mem '{mem}' is quarantined — it failed to attach at boot and serves nothing until \
         repaired: [{reason_code}] {reason_message}. After repairing, run memstead_reload \
         (or `memstead reload`) to bring it back into service."
    )]
    MemQuarantined {
        mem: String,
        reason_code: String,
        reason_message: String,
    },
    /// Mutation rejected because the mount declares
    /// [`MountCapability::ReadOnly`]. Surfaced before reaching the
    /// backend so the typed `Sealed` payload from the archive
    /// backend never triggers — capability gating runs first.
    #[error("mem {0} is mounted read-only; mutations rejected")]
    ReadOnlyMount(String),
    /// A check could not be persisted — either the engine has no
    /// workspace root (in-memory engines have no durable check
    /// store) or the ledger append failed. A check the caller
    /// believes recorded but was not is worse than a refusal, so
    /// recording is never best-effort.
    #[error("check not recorded: {reason}")]
    CheckNotRecorded { reason: String },
    /// Entity type is not declared in the pinned schema for this
    /// mem. Carries the declared types (sorted) and a fuzzy
    /// suggestion so the agent can recover without re-reading the
    /// schema. `schema_ref` is the pinned `<name>@<version>`.
    #[error(
        "unknown entity type '{name}' in schema '{schema_ref}'. Declared types: [{}]{}",
        declared.join(", "),
        suggestion.as_deref().map(|s| format!(". Did you mean '{s}'?")).unwrap_or_default()
    )]
    UnknownType {
        name: String,
        schema_ref: String,
        declared: Vec<String>,
        suggestion: Option<String>,
    },
    /// Title slug is empty / invalid.
    #[error("title is invalid: {0}")]
    InvalidTitle(#[from] SlugError),
    /// Create attempted against an id already present in the store.
    /// Names the occupant's title — distinct titles can derive the
    /// same slug, so the id alone does not tell the caller which
    /// entity holds it. `existing_is_stub` marks a stub occupant
    /// (reachable via rename; the create path adopts stubs instead
    /// of refusing).
    #[error(
        "entity already exists: {id} — occupied by {}",
        render_occupant(existing_title, *existing_is_stub)
    )]
    AlreadyExists {
        id: String,
        existing_title: String,
        existing_is_stub: bool,
    },
    /// Write refused: the entity as written would violate a
    /// block-tier declared constraint of its type (`severity: block`
    /// in the schema's `constraints`). Warn-tier violations warn
    /// instead (`WarningHint::ConstraintUnsatisfied`) — same
    /// evaluation, tier decided by the declaration. `violations`
    /// restates each violated declaration so the caller can repair
    /// without re-fetching the schema.
    #[error(
        "write refused: {entity_id} ({entity_type}) violates {n} block-tier declared constraint(s) — first: {first}",
        n = violations.len(),
        first = violations.first().map(|v| v.describe()).unwrap_or_default(),
    )]
    ConstraintUnsatisfied {
        entity_type: String,
        entity_id: String,
        violations: Vec<crate::ops::health::UnsatisfiedConstraint>,
    },
    /// Write refused: a section body violates its schema-declared
    /// markdown format (`content` / `item_pattern` / `table` on the
    /// section, `format_severity: block`). The code and recovery
    /// payload come from the violation itself
    /// (`SECTION_CONTENT_MISMATCH` / `SECTION_ITEM_PATTERN_MISMATCH`
    /// / `INVALID_TABLE_COLUMNS`, or `SECTION_CONTENT_INVALID` for a
    /// reserved setext heading); the payload echoes the declared
    /// `example` where one exists — for an agent, a conforming
    /// example outperforms any grammar string.
    #[error("write refused: {entity_id} ({entity_type}) — {}", violation.describe())]
    SectionFormatRefused {
        entity_type: String,
        entity_id: String,
        violation: crate::section_format::SectionFormatViolation,
    },
    /// Write refused: the entity's final edge set leaves a
    /// block-tier `required_outgoing` block unsatisfied
    /// (`severity: block` on the block). The default warn tier keeps
    /// the long-standing warning behavior; this refusal exists only
    /// where a schema explicitly promoted the block. Shares the
    /// `MISSING_REQUIRED_OUTGOING` code and `missing` payload shape
    /// with the warning — one condition, one vocabulary, tier decided
    /// by the declaration.
    #[error(
        "write refused: {entity_id} ({entity_type}) leaves {n} block-tier `required_outgoing` block(s) unsatisfied",
        n = missing.len(),
    )]
    RequiredOutgoingUnsatisfied {
        entity_type: String,
        entity_id: String,
        missing: Vec<crate::ops::MissingRequiredOutgoingBlock>,
    },
    /// A retype refused: every problem the target type has with the
    /// entity's sections, metadata, edges, and block-tier constraints,
    /// reported together (the report-all contract), with the target's
    /// declared sections, its catch-all, and a proposed `section_map`
    /// as the recovery payload. The wire code is the one shared code
    /// when every problem carries the same one (`UNKNOWN_SECTION`,
    /// `INVALID_REL_SHAPE`, …) and `RETYPE_REFUSED` when they mix.
    #[error(
        "retype of {id} from '{from_type}' to '{to_type}' refused: {} problem(s) — {}",
        problems.len(),
        problems.iter().map(|p| p.message()).collect::<Vec<_>>().join("; ")
    )]
    RetypeRefused {
        id: String,
        from_type: String,
        to_type: String,
        problems: Vec<crate::engine::outcomes::RetypeProblem>,
        target_sections: Vec<String>,
        target_catch_all: Option<String>,
        proposed_section_map: std::collections::BTreeMap<String, String>,
    },
    /// The entity already has the requested type.
    #[error("retype of {id} is a no-op: it already has type '{entity_type}'")]
    RetypeNoOp { id: String, entity_type: String },
    /// A check's structured finding does not match the fixed wrapper
    /// shape (`code` and `message` required and non-empty, `section`
    /// and `evidence` optional, no other keys). Nothing is appended.
    #[error("check finding refused: {reason}")]
    InvalidCheckFinding { reason: String },
    /// A deferred (lazy, unloaded) mem's storage could not be enumerated,
    /// so its edges into the entity could not be re-checked. The retype
    /// refuses rather than assuming those edges fit the target type.
    #[error(
        "retype of {id} refused: referrers in mem '{mem}' cannot be probed ({reason}); load the \
         mem (or repair its storage) and retry"
    )]
    RetypeReferrerUnprobeable {
        id: String,
        mem: String,
        reason: String,
    },
    /// Mutation rejected because the named entity is not in the
    /// store. Distinct from `UnknownMem`: the mem exists, the
    /// entity does not.
    #[error("entity not found: {id}")]
    NotFound { id: String },
    /// Optimistic-locking failure: the caller's `expected_hash` does
    /// not match the entity's current `content_hash` in the store.
    /// `current` is the live hash — pass it as `expected_hash` after
    /// re-reading to retry. `is_stub` is set when the entity is a
    /// stub (no body, no content_hash); the corrective action is to
    /// pass `expected_hash: ""` rather than re-read via `memstead_entity`.
    /// Surfaces on `details.is_stub` so MCP callers branch on the
    /// structured payload instead of parsing the message text — pre-fix
    /// the wire emitted `(current: )` with an empty paren that
    /// misdirected toward hash-recovery for a stub-shaped entity.
    #[error("{}", _hash_mismatch_msg(id, current, *is_stub))]
    HashMismatch {
        id: String,
        current: String,
        is_stub: bool,
    },
    /// Refusal to delete or rename an entity because other entities
    /// in **Write-Mems** still reference it. There is no force flag
    /// or escape hatch — the agent removes the offending references
    /// (via `memstead_relate --remove` or `memstead_update`) before retrying.
    /// `referrers` carries the typed referrer info (source id,
    /// rel-type, source mem) so the response payload describes the
    /// full surface in one round-trip. ReadOnly-mount referrers are
    /// excluded from this list — they are handled by the residual-
    /// stub demotion path on the destructive mutation.
    #[error(
        "entity {id} has {n} incoming reference(s) in write mems ({inline}); remove them first via memstead_relate --remove or memstead_update",
        n = referrers.len(),
        inline = format_inline_list_overflow(referrers, "referrers"),
    )]
    HasIncomingRefs {
        id: String,
        referrers: Vec<ReferrerInfo>,
    },
    /// Refusal to delete a mem because entities in other Write-Mems
    /// still reference entities inside it. Mirrors entity-level
    /// [`Self::HasIncomingRefs`] at the mem granularity — the
    /// edge-graph axis (F15 / CLI F8). Revoking a workspace-level grant only closes
    /// the policy axis; this check closes the actual-edge axis so a
    /// mem delete that would orphan cross-mem edges refuses with
    /// the typed envelope listing every offending `(from_id, rel_type,
    /// source_mem)` triple. No force flag — the operator must
    /// `memstead_relate --remove` (or `memstead_update` to drop the section)
    /// on each referrer first, then retry. ReadOnly-mount referrers
    /// stay out of this list and route through the residual-stub
    /// demotion path on the destructive mutation, same posture as the
    /// entity-level variant.
    #[error(
        "mem `{mem}` has {n} incoming reference(s) in write mems ({inline}); remove them first via memstead_relate --remove or memstead_update",
        n = referrers.len(),
        inline = format_inline_list_overflow(referrers, "referrers"),
    )]
    MemHasIncomingRefs {
        mem: String,
        referrers: Vec<ReferrerInfo>,
    },
    /// Relate across mems rejected because the workspace's
    /// `[cross_mem_links]` policy (or the per-create-rule
    /// `default_cross_links` synthesis) does not permit `from_mem →
    /// to_mem`. Agents adjust the policy or pick a same-mem
    /// target. The hint points at the workspace `[cross_mem_links]`
    /// section.
    #[error(
        "cross-mem link from mem `{from_mem}` to mem `{to_mem}` is not allowed by the workspace `[cross_mem_links]` policy"
    )]
    CrossMemLinkNotAllowed { from_mem: String, to_mem: String },
    /// Any add-shaped cross-mem edge write (`memstead_relate`,
    /// `memstead_create.relations[]`, `memstead_update.declare_relations`,
    /// or a body wiki-link) to a target whose mem is mounted
    /// `MountCapability::ReadOnly` and the target is absent —
    /// judged against the mem's real storage, so an unloaded (lazy)
    /// read-only mem answers without loading and the refusal never
    /// fires for an entity storage actually contains. Auto-stub
    /// is unavailable across the engine/ReadOnly-mem boundary (the
    /// engine cannot persist a stub in a mem it has no write access
    /// to), and a read-only mem never gains the entity later — the
    /// target must already exist before the link is written.
    #[error(
        "cross-mem link target {target_id} is absent in read-only mem `{target_mem}` — auto-stub is unavailable across the read-only boundary; the target must exist before linking"
    )]
    CrossMemTargetNotFound {
        target_id: String,
        target_mem: String,
    },
    /// `memstead_relate` across mems pinning schemas with different
    /// *names* refused because the source schema's
    /// `cross_mem_relationships:` section declares no entry for the
    /// target schema's domain. Each source schema must explicitly
    /// enumerate outbound cross-mem edges per target domain; the
    /// absence here means the source schema does not speak the target
    /// domain's vocabulary. Eligibility is name-based — a declaration
    /// covers every version of the named target schema. The agent's
    /// recovery is to declare the rel-type in the source schema's
    /// `cross_mem_relationships:` section under the target's bare
    /// schema name (`to_schema: <name>`).
    ///
    /// Orthogonal to the `cross_mem_links` permission policy:
    /// vocabulary and permission fire independently. A policy-admissible
    /// edge that violates vocabulary surfaces here; a vocabulary-admissible
    /// edge that violates policy surfaces as
    /// [`Self::CrossMemLinkNotAllowed`].
    #[error(
        "cross-mem edge {rel_type} from `{from_id}` (schema {source_schema}) to `{to_id}` (schema {target_schema}) is not declared in {source_schema}'s `cross_mem_relationships:` section"
    )]
    CrossMemEdgeNotDeclared {
        source_schema: String,
        target_schema: String,
        rel_type: String,
        from_id: String,
        to_id: String,
    },
    /// `memstead_update` received repair-shaped input (`relations_unset`)
    /// for an entity that currently passes the conformance check.
    /// Repair-powers gate on evidence — a conformance failure on the
    /// target entity — and a conformant entity has the focused tools
    /// instead: `memstead_relate(remove)` detaches an edge, the additive
    /// `memstead_update` params evolve content. The entity is not
    /// modified.
    #[error(
        "repair input refused for {id}: the entity currently passes the conformance check — {recovery}"
    )]
    RepairNotNeeded { id: String, recovery: String },
    /// Rename where the new title would slugify to the existing id.
    /// Surfaced as a typed no-op so callers don't loop on a degenerate
    /// retry.
    #[error(
        "rename would not change the id of {id} — new title {new_title:?} produces the same slug"
    )]
    RenameNoOp { id: String, new_title: String },
    /// `memstead_update` / `memstead_batch_update` payload parsed cleanly but
    /// carries no recognised mutation content — every mutation map is
    /// empty and no relations are declared. Distinct from
    /// `UPDATE_NOOP` (a warning that fires when mutation content was
    /// provided but matched the current state): `EMPTY_UPDATE` is
    /// keyed on "no mutation content provided at all", and refuses
    /// before any mutation work runs so a misspelled/omitted mutation
    /// key doesn't silently land as `succeeded: 1, write_id: ""`.
    #[error(
        "no mutation content for {id}: payload carries an id but every mutation map is empty \
         (recognised keys: {})",
        RECOGNISED_MUTATION_KEYS.join(", ")
    )]
    EmptyUpdate { id: String },
    /// `memstead_rename` cannot proceed because one or more cross-mem
    /// referrers would emit a propagated rewrite whose direction the
    /// workspace's `cross_mem_links` policy does not permit. The
    /// engine refuses the rename up-front (before any write); the
    /// agent's recovery is either to grant the missing direction in
    /// `[cross_mem_links]` or to drop the offending edges first.
    ///
    /// Each `blocked_referrers` entry names a single blocked direction
    /// (`from_mem → to_mem`) — the referrer's mem and the
    /// renaming entity's mem, respectively — together with the
    /// count of distinct referrers in that mem that would emit the
    /// blocked rewrite. The direction is the edge's actual direction
    /// post-rewrite (`referrer → renamed`), which is what the policy
    /// gates.
    #[error(
        "rename blocked: cross-mem rewrite from referrer mem(s) into `{from_mem}` is not permitted by `[cross_mem_links]` — blocked: {} — grant the missing direction or rewrite the blocked referrers manually",
        format_blocked_referrers(blocked_referrers)
    )]
    RenameBlockedByCrossMemPolicy {
        from_mem: String,
        blocked_referrers: Vec<BlockedReferrer>,
    },
    /// `memstead_create` / `memstead_update` / `memstead_batch_update` refused
    /// because the post-mutation entity's section bodies contain
    /// inline wiki-links to targets that have no corresponding
    /// explicit relation in `entity.relationships`. Strict
    /// wiki-link / relation invariant: every body wiki-link must
    /// have a backing relation. The agent's recovery is
    /// `memstead_relate <this-entity> REFERENCES <target>` (or a more
    /// specific rel-type) for each missing entry, then re-issue
    /// the mutation. `missing` enumerates each violation as a
    /// `(section_key, target_id)` pair so the agent can fix every
    /// surviving link in one pass. This validator is gated behind
    /// the workspace's reference-coherence migration completion
    /// marker; workspaces that haven't been migrated continue
    /// running the permissive auto-stub regime.
    #[error(
        "post-mutation body of {from_id} has {n} wiki-link(s) without a backing relation ({inline}) — declare the relation(s) via memstead_relate first (REFERENCES or a more specific rel-type), then retry",
        n = missing.len(),
        inline = format_inline_list_overflow(missing, "missing"),
    )]
    WikiLinkWithoutRelation {
        from_id: String,
        missing: Vec<MissingWikiLink>,
    },
    /// `memstead_relate --remove` refused because the source entity's
    /// section bodies still contain `[[<target>]]` (or
    /// `[[<mem>:<target>]]`) wiki-links pointing at the relation's
    /// target. Removing the explicit relation while body links
    /// survive would violate the strict wiki-link/relation invariant
    /// (inline links require a backing relation). The agent's
    /// recovery is `memstead_update <source-id>` with section content
    /// that drops the wiki-link tokens, then re-issue `memstead_relate
    /// --remove`. `body_links` enumerates the surviving section keys
    /// so the agent can patch them in one pass.
    #[error(
        "cannot remove {rel_type} {from_id} → {to_id}: source body still contains wiki-link(s) to the target in section(s) {inline} — drop them via memstead_update before removing the relation",
        inline = format_inline_list_overflow(body_links, "body_links"),
    )]
    RelationHasBodyLinks {
        from_id: String,
        to_id: String,
        rel_type: String,
        body_links: Vec<String>,
    },
    /// A multi-mem `memstead_rename` partially landed: at least one
    /// mem committed successfully, then a subsequent per-mem
    /// commit aborted (typically because a sibling writer advanced
    /// the failed mem's head between the rename's snapshot and the
    /// commit attempt — the parent-ref pin tripped via
    /// `BackendError::ParentMismatch`). The committed mems' state
    /// has already landed and is durable; the failed mem's writes
    /// did not land. The agent's recovery options: retry the rename
    /// (reload the workspace first so the engine re-derives the right
    /// referrer set), or accept the partial state and reconcile
    /// manually via subsequent mutations.
    #[error(
        "rename partial-failure: mem `{failed_mem}` aborted with cause {failure_cause:?} after {committed_mems:?} already committed — reload and retry, or reconcile manually"
    )]
    RenamePartialFailure {
        committed_mems: Vec<String>,
        failed_mem: String,
        failure_cause: String,
    },
    /// `memstead_relate` source is a stub — stubs have no `entity_type`
    /// and cannot author edges. The agent must promote the stub to a
    /// real entity via `memstead_create` (stub adoption preserves any
    /// incoming references) before relating. Pre-fix surfaced as the
    /// cryptic `UnknownType { name: "" }`.
    #[error("source entity {id} is a stub — promote it to a real entity via memstead_create first")]
    StubCannotRelate { id: String },
    /// `memstead_update` target is a stub — stubs have no body, no
    /// metadata, no schema-resolved type to validate against. The
    /// agent must promote the stub to a real entity via `memstead_create`
    /// (stub adoption preserves any incoming references) before
    /// updating. Pre-Item-02 surfaced as the cryptic
    /// `UnknownType { name: "" }` cascade — identical symptom to the
    /// one `StubCannotRelate` was added to replace on `memstead_relate`.
    #[error("entity {id} is a stub — promote it to a real entity via memstead_create first")]
    StubNotUpdatable { id: String },
    /// `memstead_rename` target is a stub — stubs do not have a title to
    /// rename (their title is derived from the id). Same recovery
    /// path as [`Self::StubNotUpdatable`].
    #[error(
        "entity {id} is a stub — promote it to a real entity via memstead_create before renaming"
    )]
    StubNotRenamable { id: String },
    /// An `EntityId` reaching a write path (notably `memstead_relate to=`)
    /// does not match the wiki-link grammar
    /// (`^[a-z0-9-]+(/[a-z0-9-]+)*$` for the slug; `^[a-z0-9-]+$` for
    /// the mem). The gate prevents an auto-stub being created at a
    /// malformed id — once present, that stub would fail any
    /// downstream wiki-link parse that referenced it.
    #[error("entity id '{id}' is malformed: {reason}")]
    InvalidEntityId { id: String, reason: String },
    /// A body wiki-link target in a section body failed the strict
    /// slug-form grammar gate. The invariant is that every wiki-link target reaching
    /// `entity.relationships` carries a grammar-valid `EntityId` — the
    /// alias-synthesis pass would otherwise emit a relation pointing
    /// at a literal id (e.g. `mem--Knowledge Graph`) that no
    /// downstream wiki-link parse could ever resolve. `raw` is the
    /// input between brackets (after alias / `.md` strip); `suggested`
    /// is the `title_to_slug`-derived slug-form the agent lifts
    /// directly into the retry (omitted when the input has no
    /// meaningful canonical form — empty, all-punctuation, all-emoji);
    /// `section` is the section key whose body carried the link;
    /// `source` is a stable discriminator (`"body_link"`) future-
    /// proofed against additional ingress surfaces.
    #[error("body wiki-link target '{raw}' in section '{section}' is not slug-form: {reason}")]
    InvalidWikiLinkTarget {
        raw: String,
        suggested: Option<String>,
        section: String,
        link_source: String,
        reason: String,
    },
    /// A body wiki-link's Tier-2 mem prefix `[[mem:slug]]` failed
    /// the mem-name grammar (`^[a-z0-9-]+(/[a-z0-9-]+)*$`). Distinct
    /// from `InvalidWikiLinkTarget` because the recovery is different
    /// — mem names are fixed identifiers in the workspace, not
    /// free-form text the agent can mechanically slugify; the agent
    /// correlates the bad prefix against the workspace's known mems
    /// rather than reaching for `title_to_slug`.
    #[error(
        "body wiki-link mem prefix '{raw}' in section '{section}' is not a valid mem name: {reason}"
    )]
    InvalidWikiLinkMem {
        raw: String,
        section: String,
        reason: String,
    },
    /// `memstead_update` was asked to apply more than one section-
    /// mutation mode (`sections`, `append_sections`,
    /// `patch_sections`) to the same key. The request is ambiguous
    /// and rejected before any disk write. `modes` lists the
    /// conflicting modes for the key in canonical order.
    #[error("conflicting section modes for {section}: {modes:?}")]
    ConflictingSectionModes { section: String, modes: Vec<String> },
    /// Adding the proposed edge would close a cycle in an
    /// acyclic-declared subgraph. Carries the existing back-path
    /// `[from, …, current, target's intermediates, … from]` so MCP
    /// envelopes ship the cycle's shape without a follow-up
    /// `memstead_search`. Truncated at
    /// [`RELATIONSHIP_CYCLE_PATH_CAP`] entries. A refusal from a
    /// declared acyclicity SET additionally carries the set and one
    /// rel-type per hop of the path (the path may mix the set's
    /// rel-types); single-rel-type refusals keep their byte-identical
    /// payload (both extras absent).
    #[error("{}", _relationship_cycle_msg(rel_type, from, to, acyclic_set.as_deref()))]
    RelationshipCycle {
        rel_type: String,
        from: EntityId,
        to: EntityId,
        existing_path: Vec<EntityId>,
        path_truncated: bool,
        /// The declared acyclicity set, on set refusals only.
        acyclic_set: Option<Vec<String>>,
        /// One rel-type per hop of `existing_path`, on set refusals
        /// only (truncated alongside the path).
        existing_path_rel_types: Option<Vec<String>>,
    },
    /// `memstead_update` received the same metadata key in both `metadata`
    /// (set) and `metadata_unset` lists. The request is ambiguous and
    /// rejected before any disk write — the caller picks which map the
    /// key belongs in. `keys` lists every overlapping key in alphabetical
    /// order so a single envelope describes the full conflict.
    #[error("metadata keys appear in both set and unset: {keys:?}")]
    SetAndUnsetConflict { keys: Vec<String> },
    /// `metadata_unset` targeted a required field. Carries the
    /// recovery payload so the agent reads the field's purpose,
    /// allowed values, and type-level write rules from the envelope
    /// rather than re-fetching the schema.
    ///
    /// Also fires from `memstead_create` when the
    /// caller did not supply a required metadata field that the
    /// schema does not auto-fill (`default_value` / `init_timestamp`
    /// / `auto_timestamp` all absent). Pre-fix the create path
    /// surfaced this as a `MISSING_REQUIRED_FIELD` warning and let
    /// the entity land with a placeholder — silently corrupted the
    /// export-then-install round-trip when the placeholder was
    /// invalid for the install-time strict validator. The refusal
    /// fires once per call on the first missing field (declaration
    /// order); subsequent fields surface on the next attempt.
    #[error("{}", _required_field_unset_msg(field, entity_type, *on_create))]
    RequiredFieldUnset {
        field: String,
        entity_type: String,
        /// Schema-supplied description of the field.
        field_description: Option<String>,
        /// Allowed enum values when the unset field is enum-typed;
        /// empty when the field is free-form.
        enum_values: Vec<String>,
        /// Type-level `write_rules` for the entity type.
        type_write_rules: Vec<String>,
        /// Path discriminator: `true` when the
        /// create path constructed the variant (caller didn't supply
        /// the field), `false` when the update path constructed it
        /// (caller passed `metadata_unset: ["field"]` against a
        /// required field). The typed code stays `REQUIRED_FIELD_UNSET`
        /// on both paths; only the rendered prose differs.
        ///
        /// Not exposed on the `details` payload — agents already
        /// branch on the typed code; the new field is for the prose
        /// dispatch only.
        on_create: bool,
        /// Multi-field
        /// accumulator on the create path. Every required-no-default
        /// field that was unset, in schema declaration order. Empty
        /// on the unset path (where the agent targets one field by
        /// definition and the singular fields above are authoritative);
        /// always non-empty (and at least a singleton echo of the
        /// singular fields) on the create path.
        ///
        /// Surfaces on `details.missing[]` so an agent fixes every
        /// missing field in one round-trip. `details.field` and
        /// `details.missing[0].field` agree on the first-missing
        /// entry, keeping the back-compat singular-field shape.
        missing: Vec<MissingRequiredField>,
    },
    /// `memstead_create`: one or more required sections for the entity's
    /// type were absent or whitespace-only in the request. Pre-fix
    /// the create path surfaced this as `MISSING_REQUIRED_SECTION`
    /// warnings and wrote the entity with empty placeholders for
    /// the missing sections; the resulting on-disk state failed the
    /// install-time strict validator, breaking the export-then-
    /// install round-trip. The refusal carries every missing section
    /// (one entry per affected key) plus the type-level `type_guidance`
    /// map so the agent has a single round-trip recovery via re-call
    /// with the missing content filled in.
    ///
    /// Loader / health / `memstead_update` paths keep their permissive
    /// posture — a legacy on-disk entity created when this gate was
    /// a warning continues to load, surface in health, and accept
    /// partial updates. The refusal is a write-boundary gate, not a
    /// global invariant.
    #[error("missing {missing_count} required section(s) for type '{entity_type}'")]
    MissingRequiredSection {
        entity_type: String,
        /// Echoed for diagnostics; equals `sections.len()`.
        missing_count: usize,
        /// One entry per missing required section, in schema
        /// declaration order. Each entry mirrors the shape of the
        /// pre-fix `WarningHint::MissingRequiredSection` warning so
        /// agents reading the recovery payload don't branch on
        /// surface (refusal vs warning).
        sections: Vec<crate::runtime_validator::MissingRequiredSection>,
        /// Type-level `write_rules` keyed by `entity_type`. Map shape
        /// matches the mutation-response top-level `type_guidance`
        /// the warning-surface ships so a single decoder reads
        /// guidance from either path.
        type_guidance: std::collections::BTreeMap<String, Vec<String>>,
        /// Cross-gate pre-announcement: what the metadata gate
        /// (`REQUIRED_FIELD_UNSET`) will also demand once the sections
        /// are fixed — computed in the same validation pass so a first
        /// write learns both gates' demands in one refusal. Element
        /// shape matches `RequiredFieldUnset::missing[]` so the same
        /// decoder reads both. Rides `details.pre_announced` on the
        /// wire, and only when non-empty — a refusal from a body
        /// failing only the section gate is byte-identical to the
        /// pre-announcement-free shape. Best-effort by contract: what
        /// is announced is true; gates that cannot run against the
        /// broken body are not forced. Empty on surfaces that report
        /// each gate separately anyway (the integrity linter).
        pre_announced_missing_fields: Vec<MissingRequiredField>,
    },
    /// `patch_sections` targeted a key whose section body is
    /// absent from the entity (or has never been authored).
    #[error("patch target section is empty: {section}")]
    PatchSectionEmpty { section: String },
    /// `patch_sections` provided an `old` substring that does not
    /// appear in the section's current body. Carries a truncated
    /// snapshot of the current content so the caller can surface
    /// the actual state to the operator, and the sections whose
    /// bodies DO contain the substring — the one-call recovery when
    /// the patch simply targeted the wrong section.
    #[error("patch `old` substring not found in {section}")]
    PatchOldNotFound {
        section: String,
        current_content: String,
        truncated: bool,
        found_in_sections: Vec<String>,
    },
    /// `UNTERMINATED_FENCE_IN_STORED_BODY`: the entity on disk already ends a
    /// section inside an open code fence, and this write does not resolve it
    /// (consistency-sweep 04/02, criterion 5).
    ///
    /// The state is not the caller's doing: the generator closes every fence
    /// it emits, so it can only arrive by hand-authoring, a folder mem edited
    /// outside the engine, or sibling-committed branch state. But the closer
    /// is appended AFTER the already-absorbed bytes, so a write here would
    /// seal the swallowed sections inside a legitimately closed fence, and no
    /// later pass can tell them from prose the author meant to fence. The
    /// freeze is unrecoverable through the engine, which is why this refuses
    /// rather than warns.
    ///
    /// The way out is replace mode on the named section: that value passes
    /// the `UNTERMINATED_FENCE` guard, so it cannot leave a fence open, and
    /// the caller can lift the swallowed content back out of it. Its sibling
    /// [`ValidationError::UnterminatedFence`] refuses the same condition in
    /// content the caller supplies.
    #[error(
        "entity '{id}' section '{section}' ends inside an unterminated `{fence}` code fence, and \
         this update does not replace it. Writing now would close the fence around content that \
         belongs to other sections and make the loss permanent. Replace section '{section}' with \
         a corrected body in the same call."
    )]
    UnterminatedFenceInStoredBody {
        id: String,
        section: String,
        fence: String,
        swallowed: Vec<String>,
    },
    /// Schema-strictness rejection from the runtime validator
    /// (`UNKNOWN_SECTION`, `UNKNOWN_METADATA`, `INVALID_ENUM_VALUE`).
    #[error("schema validation: {0}")]
    Validation(#[from] ValidationError),
    /// Re-parse of the freshly-generated markdown failed. Should
    /// never happen — the generator's contract is that its output
    /// round-trips through `parse_markdown`. Surfaces if a future
    /// generator change breaks that invariant.
    #[error("parse-after-write failed: {0}")]
    ParseAfterWrite(String),
    /// A wrapped parse error for completeness; today only the
    /// parse-after-write variant above is constructed in the create
    /// path.
    #[error("parse error: {0}")]
    Parse(#[from] ParseError),
    /// A backend operation failed. Inner error carries the typed
    /// payload (e.g. `Sealed`, `HashMismatch`, `Io`).
    #[error(transparent)]
    Backend(#[from] BackendError),
    /// A mem's schema pin did not resolve. `sources` carries the
    /// fixed-order resolution diagnostics (local storage / built-in /
    /// remote) so the caller can tell *where* the pin failed and spot a
    /// right-name/wrong-version partial match; it surfaces under
    /// `details.sources`. Empty `sources` marks an internal lookup miss
    /// (an already-resolved schema absent from the engine's per-mem
    /// map), not a genuine source-resolution failure.
    ///
    /// The MESSAGE summarises the trail — which sources were searched
    /// and whether the name was found at other versions — so the
    /// distinction between a wrong-version pin and a never-installed
    /// package reaches consumers that never open `details` (a reported
    /// autonomous loop burned five rounds on the payload-only shape).
    /// `install_hint` (set by [`EngineError::with_schema_install_probe`]
    /// where a workspace root is known) names the authoring package
    /// that exists in the working tree but was never installed, and
    /// the message then points at `memstead schema install`.
    #[error("{}", schema_not_found_message(mem, pin, sources, install_hint))]
    SchemaNotFound {
        mem: String,
        pin: String,
        sources: Vec<SchemaSourceDiagnostic>,
        /// Path to an authoring package in the working tree whose
        /// manifest name matches the pin's name while NO source holds
        /// any version of that name — i.e. the package was authored
        /// but never installed. `None` when no such package exists,
        /// when the name is installed at other versions (a version
        /// mismatch is a different fix), or when no workspace root
        /// was available to probe.
        install_hint: Option<String>,
    },
    /// A sealed schema package carried inside a mem archive could not
    /// be loaded — the archive's own `.memstead/schema/` tree is
    /// broken. Deliberately NOT `SchemaNotFound`: the package is right
    /// here, so the recovery is never "obtain the schema and install
    /// it". The message quotes the loader's own diagnosis and the
    /// refusal leaves nothing mounted and nothing staged; only the
    /// publisher can fix it.
    #[error(
        "mem {mem}: the schema {pin} embedded in the archive could not be loaded: {reason} — \
         the package is inside the archive, so this is the publisher's to fix; nothing was \
         staged or mounted"
    )]
    EmbeddedSchemaInvalid {
        mem: String,
        pin: String,
        reason: String,
    },
    /// A schema package handed to `install_schema` failed validation —
    /// the loader's semantic checks or the section-heading round-trip
    /// gate. The engine refuses to seal an invalid schema onto
    /// `__MEMSTEAD`: install time is the last moment the author can
    /// act, because a schema already sealed keeps loading even when a
    /// later rule would refuse it.
    #[error("schema package '{name}@{version}' failed validation: {message}")]
    SchemaPackageInvalid {
        name: String,
        version: String,
        message: String,
    },
    /// `memstead_schema::builtins::load_builtin_schemas` itself failed.
    /// Surfaces during `Engine::from_mounts`; should never trip in
    /// practice (the built-in catalogue is statically embedded), but
    /// the failure path is preserved so a future on-disk catalogue
    /// switch lifts cleanly.
    #[error("built-in schema catalogue failed to load: {0}")]
    SchemaResolverInit(String),
    /// Generic mem-level error message — used by accessors that
    /// surface "mem exists, but the requested resource is not
    /// available for this backend" (e.g. `gitdir_for` against a
    /// folder mount, `worktree_for` against a git-branch mount).
    #[error("mem error: {0}")]
    Mem(String),
    /// `register_writable_mem` rejected because `name` is already
    /// registered (writable OR read-only). `source_origin` is the
    /// human-readable description of the colliding registration,
    /// rendered via [`MemOrigin::render_source`] for writable
    /// entries or a stand-in for read-only ones.
    #[error("mem name collision: {name} is already registered ({source_origin})")]
    MemNameCollision { name: String, source_origin: String },
    /// Lifecycle orchestrator rejected the input. Carries a single
    /// free-form message — the orchestrator's typed payload (note
    /// length, malformed path, etc.) is the message text.
    #[error("invalid input: {0}")]
    InvalidInput(String),
    /// Merge-conflict listing/resolution targeted a mem whose backend
    /// cannot acquire git merge conflicts through supported use — the
    /// git-branch mem-repo is engine-managed, archives and in-memory
    /// sketches have no user-git seam at all. Only folder mems live in
    /// the user's own repository where an ordinary merge can write
    /// conflict markers into entity files. Typed code
    /// `CONFLICT_RESOLVE_UNSUPPORTED_BACKEND`.
    #[error(
        "mem `{mem}` is not folder-backed — its storage cannot acquire git merge \
         conflicts through supported use; `conflicts` operations apply to folder mems only"
    )]
    MergeConflictUnsupportedBackend { mem: String },
    /// Conflict resolution targeted an entity whose file carries no git
    /// merge-conflict markers — nothing to resolve. Distinct from
    /// `NotFound` so an agent can tell "already clean" from "no such
    /// entity". Typed code `NOT_CONFLICTED`.
    #[error(
        "entity `{id}` is not conflicted — its file carries no git merge-conflict \
         markers; nothing to resolve"
    )]
    NotConflicted { id: String },
    /// `memstead_fetch` / `memstead_pull` / `memstead_push` named a remote that is
    /// not configured on the workspace's mem-repo. Typed code
    /// `UNKNOWN_REMOTE`. Recovery: configure the remote via
    /// `memstead mem-repo remote-add <name> <url>`.
    #[error("unknown remote: {0}")]
    UnknownRemote(String),
    /// `memstead_pull` refused because the local branch has diverged from
    /// the remote-tracking ref — fast-forward is impossible without
    /// losing local commits. Recovery: run `memstead branch-reset` to the
    /// remote-tracking ref (if the local commits are dispensable) or
    /// run a replay workflow to rewrite them onto the new remote tip.
    /// Typed code `LOCAL_DIVERGENCE`.
    #[error(
        "mem `{mem}`'s local branch has diverged from `{remote_ref}` — pull cannot fast-forward without losing local commits; rebase / replay first or run memstead branch-reset"
    )]
    LocalDivergence { mem: String, remote_ref: String },
    /// `memstead_push` refused because the push would not be a fast-forward
    /// against the remote and the caller did not pass `force: true`.
    /// Typed code `NON_FAST_FORWARD`. Recovery: re-fetch + replay, or
    /// re-issue with `force: true` (warning: rewrites the remote's
    /// view of the branch — other peers will see the rewrite).
    #[error(
        "push to remote `{remote}` for mem `{mem}` is not a fast-forward; rebase / replay locally or pass `force: true` to overwrite the remote"
    )]
    NonFastForward { mem: String, remote: String },
    /// `memstead_push` refused because the local state failed pre-push
    /// schema validation. The remote was not contacted. Recovery: fix
    /// the schema violations (use `memstead_health` to find them) and
    /// retry. Typed code `LOCAL_INVALID_STATE`.
    #[error(
        "mem `{mem}` failed pre-push schema validation; remote `{remote}` was not contacted: {detail}"
    )]
    LocalInvalidState {
        mem: String,
        remote: String,
        detail: String,
    },
    /// `memstead_pull` (or any future merge path that consumes fetched
    /// commits) refused because the prospective post-merge tree
    /// contains entities that fail schema validation. The branch
    /// pointer was not moved. `violations` carries one entry per
    /// offending entity — typically `(relative_path, parse_error)`
    /// pairs rendered as strings — so the caller can surface the
    /// remediation surface without re-walking the tree. Typed code
    /// `SCHEMA_VIOLATION_IN_FETCH`.
    #[error(
        "mem `{mem}` would fail schema validation at `{ref_name}` — {n} violation(s); fix the remote or replay locally first",
        n = violations.len(),
    )]
    SchemaViolationInFetch {
        mem: String,
        ref_name: String,
        violations: Vec<String>,
    },
    /// `memstead_branch_reset` refused because at least one commit that
    /// would be discarded by the reset is already reachable from a
    /// `refs/remotes/*` ref (the engine's definition of "pushed").
    /// `pushed_shas` lists the offending commits. The agent's
    /// recovery is to pick a target SHA that does not strand a pushed
    /// commit, or to push the pre-reset state under a different
    /// branch name first. Typed code: `PUSHED_COMMITS_PROTECTED`.
    #[error(
        "branch_reset refused: {} pushed commit(s) would be discarded ({}); pick a target that preserves the pushed segment or push the pre-reset state under a different branch first",
        pushed_shas.len(),
        pushed_shas.join(", "),
    )]
    PushedCommitsProtected {
        mem: String,
        target_sha: String,
        pushed_shas: Vec<String>,
    },
    /// `branch_reset` refused because the live branch head no longer
    /// matches the head the caller observed (`expected_head`) — a
    /// sibling writer advanced the mem, and resetting now would discard
    /// that foreign work. Optimistic concurrency for history rewrites;
    /// the caller re-reads and re-decides. Typed code:
    /// `BRANCH_RESET_HEAD_MOVED`.
    #[error(
        "branch_reset refused: '{mem}' has advanced past the observed head (expected {expected}, live {current}) — the span now contains foreign commits; reload and review the accumulated delta instead"
    )]
    BranchResetHeadMoved {
        mem: String,
        expected: String,
        current: String,
    },
    /// `memstead_diff` (or any future ref-comparing op) received a ref
    /// that does not resolve against the workspace's mem-repo.
    /// Carries the ref string verbatim so the caller can fix the
    /// input. Typed code `UNKNOWN_REF`.
    #[error("unknown ref: {0}")]
    UnknownRef(String),
    /// `memstead_changes_since` received a `rename_similarity` value
    /// outside the allowed range. Maps to wire code `INVALID_INPUT`
    /// with `details.allowed_range: [min, max]` and
    /// `details.requested`. Promoted from the prior silent-clamp + LIMIT_CLAMPED warning so
    /// nonsense inputs surface as recoverable refusal rather than
    /// silent rounding.
    #[error("rename_similarity {requested} outside allowed range [{allowed_min}, {allowed_max}]")]
    RenameSimilarityOutOfRange {
        requested: f32,
        allowed_min: f32,
        allowed_max: f32,
    },
    /// `memstead_changes_since` / `memstead changes --since` was given a `since`
    /// commit cursor the mem's git repository can't resolve — a
    /// malformed prefix or a well-formed-but-absent 40-hex. Surfaces the
    /// `INVALID_CURSOR` code (the documented contract for this op, which
    /// the CLI previously leaked as the `MEM_ERROR` catch-all) so a
    /// sync loop branches cleanly: `INVALID_CURSOR` → re-seed from the
    /// empty-tree sentinel; `MEM_ERROR` → genuine backend fault.
    /// `details.since` carries the offending cursor untruncated.
    #[error(
        "commit cursor '{since}' is not a known commit in mem '{mem}' — pass the `head` a prior memstead_changes_since call returned, or the empty-tree sentinel to re-seed. A mutation's `write_id` is an identity, not a cursor"
    )]
    InvalidChangesCursor { mem: String, since: String },
    /// `memstead_changes_since` / `memstead changes --since` on a
    /// folder-backed (or in-memory) mem was given a `since` that is not
    /// an RFC3339 timestamp. These backends key the change ledger off
    /// timestamps and compare lexically, so before this refusal a
    /// mutation's `write_id` — fixed-width hex that sorts below every
    /// timestamp — silently replayed the whole history. Shares the
    /// `INVALID_CURSOR` code with the git-backed variant so a sync
    /// loop's branch (`INVALID_CURSOR` → re-seed) is backend-agnostic.
    /// `details.since` carries the offending cursor untruncated.
    #[error(
        "changes cursor '{since}' is not an RFC3339 timestamp — on mem '{mem}' pass the `since` a prior memstead_changes_since call returned (the ledger's latest `ts`), or the empty string / empty-tree sentinel to read from the beginning. A mutation's `write_id` is an identity, not a cursor"
    )]
    InvalidTimestampCursor { mem: String, since: String },
    /// `review_mark_diff` was called on a mem with no review mark set.
    /// Marklessness is a first-class, known-from-the-roster state — the
    /// diff surface refuses typed rather than silently equating "no
    /// mark" with "no changes".
    #[error(
        "mem '{mem}' has no review mark — set one first, or read the full history via changes_since"
    )]
    ReviewMarkNotSet { mem: String },
    /// Mem config is missing a required field that the engine
    /// itself would normally populate (today: `version` at mem
    /// init). Surfaced on the export path — pre-fix this collapsed
    /// to `INTERNAL` with a misleading `.memstead/config.json` reference
    /// that doesn't match the mem-repo backend's blob layout.
    /// Recovery: run `memstead mem set-version <mem> <version>` to
    /// populate the field, then retry the export. F1.
    #[error(
        "mem `{mem}` config is missing required field(s) {missing_fields:?} — \
         set via `memstead mem set-version {mem} <version>` (e.g. 0.1.0)"
    )]
    MemConfigIncomplete {
        mem: String,
        missing_fields: Vec<String>,
    },
    /// `memstead_relate` (or a `declare_relations` entry) targeted a
    /// rel-type whose schema declares `per_edge_description:
    /// required` without supplying a description. Recovery: re-issue
    /// the call with `--description "<text>"` describing why this
    /// particular edge exists (the rel-type's name documents the
    /// kind of edge; the description documents the instance).
    #[error(
        "rel-type `{rel_type}` declares `per_edge_description: required` — \
         {from_id} → {to_id} needs a description; re-issue with \
         `--description \"<text>\"`."
    )]
    MissingRequiredDescription {
        rel_type: String,
        from_id: String,
        to_id: String,
    },
    /// `memstead_relate` (or a `declare_relations` entry) supplied a
    /// description for a rel-type whose schema declares
    /// `per_edge_description: forbidden`. Recovery: drop the
    /// `description` parameter — the rel-type's name describes the
    /// edge; per-edge text is not permitted on this rel-type.
    #[error(
        "rel-type `{rel_type}` declares `per_edge_description: forbidden` — \
         {from_id} → {to_id} cannot carry a description; drop the \
         `--description` argument."
    )]
    DescriptionNotPermitted {
        rel_type: String,
        from_id: String,
        to_id: String,
    },
    /// `memstead_relate` (or a `declare_relations` / `memstead_create`'s
    /// inline `relations:` entry) targeted a rel-type whose schema
    /// declares `manual_authoring: forbidden`. The rel-type is
    /// reserved for engine-emitted synthesis (the body-link →
    /// relation alias machinery, typically). Recovery: don't author
    /// the relation explicitly; instead author a body wiki-link
    /// `[[target]]` in the source's section content, which the
    /// engine surfaces as the appropriate alias relation
    /// automatically.
    #[error(
        "rel-type `{rel_type}` declares `manual_authoring: forbidden` — \
         {from_id} → {to_id} cannot be authored explicitly; this rel-type \
         is reserved for engine-emitted synthesis via the body-link → \
         relation alias path. {guidance}"
    )]
    RelationManualAuthoringForbidden {
        rel_type: String,
        from_id: String,
        to_id: String,
        guidance: String,
    },
    /// Full-text search is unavailable in the current engine build —
    /// `Engine::search` is callable on every target so JS / FFI
    /// consumers don't need to re-shape their call sites, but `wasm32`
    /// builds omit the tantivy index entirely (its native-only
    /// transitives — `getrandom 0.2` without `js`, `memmap2`, `rayon`,
    /// `zstd-sys` — block WASM compilation). Browser consumers route
    /// queries to the bridge's `memstead_search` endpoint. The MCP layer
    /// maps this to typed code `SEARCH_UNAVAILABLE_IN_WASM`.
    #[error(
        "full-text search is unavailable in this engine build (wasm32); \
         route search queries to the bridge's memstead_search endpoint"
    )]
    SearchUnavailable,
    /// `memstead export --format markdown --mem-name <V>` was called
    /// against a mem whose active backend doesn't support markdown
    /// regeneration in place (today: every backend other than
    /// `folder`). Pre-fix this collapsed to a silent
    /// `ExportResult { written: 0, unchanged: 0 }` masquerading as
    /// success. Recovery: use `--format mem` to produce a portable
    /// `.mem` archive, which every backend supports.
    #[error(
        "mem `{mem}` is on backend `{active_backend}`; `memstead export --format markdown` \
         is supported only on backends [{}] — use `--format mem` to produce a portable \
         `.mem` archive instead",
        supported_backends.join(", ")
    )]
    MarkdownExportUnsupportedBackend {
        mem: String,
        active_backend: String,
        supported_backends: Vec<String>,
    },
    /// A `memstead_create` / `memstead_update` `anchors[]` element was
    /// malformed — an unknown provenance class or grain, a missing artifact
    /// reference, a content hash on a class without hash semantics, or a
    /// grain the resolving medium's namespace cannot express. The whole
    /// mutation refuses and the entity is not written; the wrapped
    /// [`crate::anchor::AnchorValidationError`] carries the recovery
    /// `details` (offending field, bad value, allowed set). Typed code
    /// `INVALID_ANCHOR`.
    #[error("invalid anchor: {0}")]
    InvalidAnchor(#[from] crate::anchor::AnchorValidationError),
}

/// Typed payload for a single Write-Mem referrer in
/// [`EngineError::HasIncomingRefs`]. Captures the (from_id, rel_types,
/// mem) triple the surface envelope projects so consumers can reason
/// about the offending edges without a follow-up `memstead_entity` call.
/// The mem is always a Write-Mem — ReadOnly referrers are
/// partitioned out before this struct is constructed and surfaced via
/// the residual-stub warning channel instead.
///
/// Per-source deduplication: when one source entity has multiple
/// edges of different rel-types pointing at the deletion target, the
/// engine collapses them into a single `ReferrerInfo` whose
/// `rel_types` list carries every edge type. A prior shape
/// emitted one entry per edge, making a source-with-N-edges look
/// like N distinct referrers in the error message and structured
/// payload.
#[derive(Debug, Clone, serde::Serialize)]
pub struct ReferrerInfo {
    pub from_id: String,
    pub rel_types: Vec<String>,
    pub mem: String,
}

/// Inline rendering on the text mirror. Single rel-type renders as
/// just the referring entity id; multiple rel-types append the
/// `×N [REL1, REL2]` annotation so the count and the offending
/// edge-types stay visible without parsing the structured payload.
impl fmt::Display for ReferrerInfo {
    fn fmt(&self, f: &mut fmt::Formatter<'_>) -> fmt::Result {
        if self.rel_types.len() <= 1 {
            f.write_str(&self.from_id)
        } else {
            write!(
                f,
                "{} ×{} [{}]",
                self.from_id,
                self.rel_types.len(),
                self.rel_types.join(", ")
            )
        }
    }
}

/// One body wiki-link that violates the strict wiki-link /
/// relation invariant. Surfaces inside
/// [`EngineError::WikiLinkWithoutRelation::missing`].
#[derive(Debug, Clone, serde::Serialize, PartialEq, Eq)]
pub struct MissingWikiLink {
    /// Section key of the entity body where the unbacked
    /// wiki-link appears.
    pub section_key: String,
    /// EntityId target of the unbacked wiki-link.
    pub target_id: String,
}

/// Inline rendering pairs the section key with the unbacked target id
/// so an agent reading only the text mirror can see both where the link
/// lives and what it points at without decoding the structured payload.
impl fmt::Display for MissingWikiLink {
    fn fmt(&self, f: &mut fmt::Formatter<'_>) -> fmt::Result {
        write!(f, "{}→{}", self.section_key, self.target_id)
    }
}

impl EngineError {
    /// Stable, surface-independent error code token.
    ///
    /// Each surface (MCP envelope, CLI envelope) maps
    /// the variant to its wire shape; the code returned here is the
    /// canonical name agents key on. Add a new code here when a new
    /// variant lands; do not invent ad-hoc strings inside the
    /// per-surface mapping.
    pub fn code(&self) -> &'static str {
        match self {
            EngineError::DuplicateMem(_) => "DUPLICATE_MEM",
            EngineError::UnknownMem(_) => "UNKNOWN_MEM",
            EngineError::MemQuarantined { .. } => "MEM_QUARANTINED",
            EngineError::UnknownRef(_) => "UNKNOWN_REF",
            EngineError::UnknownRemote(_) => "UNKNOWN_REMOTE",
            EngineError::LocalDivergence { .. } => "LOCAL_DIVERGENCE",
            EngineError::NonFastForward { .. } => "NON_FAST_FORWARD",
            EngineError::LocalInvalidState { .. } => "LOCAL_INVALID_STATE",
            EngineError::SchemaViolationInFetch { .. } => "SCHEMA_VIOLATION_IN_FETCH",
            EngineError::PushedCommitsProtected { .. } => "PUSHED_COMMITS_PROTECTED",
            EngineError::BranchResetHeadMoved { .. } => "BRANCH_RESET_HEAD_MOVED",
            EngineError::ReadOnlyMount(_) => "READ_ONLY_MOUNT",
            EngineError::CheckNotRecorded { .. } => "CHECK_NOT_RECORDED",
            EngineError::UnknownType { .. } => "UNKNOWN_ENTITY_TYPE",
            EngineError::InvalidTitle(_) => "INVALID_TITLE",
            EngineError::AlreadyExists { .. } => "ENTITY_ALREADY_EXISTS",
            EngineError::ConstraintUnsatisfied { .. } => "CONSTRAINT_UNSATISFIED",
            EngineError::RequiredOutgoingUnsatisfied { .. } => "MISSING_REQUIRED_OUTGOING",
            EngineError::SectionFormatRefused { violation, .. } => violation.code(),
            EngineError::NotFound { .. } => "ENTITY_NOT_FOUND",
            EngineError::HashMismatch { .. } => "HASH_MISMATCH",
            EngineError::HasIncomingRefs { .. } => "HAS_INCOMING_REFS",
            EngineError::MemHasIncomingRefs { .. } => "MEM_HAS_INCOMING_REFS",
            EngineError::CrossMemLinkNotAllowed { .. } => "CROSS_MEM_LINK_NOT_ALLOWED",
            EngineError::CrossMemTargetNotFound { .. } => "CROSS_MEM_TARGET_NOT_FOUND",
            EngineError::CrossMemEdgeNotDeclared { .. } => "CROSS_MEM_EDGE_NOT_DECLARED",
            EngineError::RepairNotNeeded { .. } => "REPAIR_NOT_NEEDED",
            EngineError::RenameNoOp { .. } => "RENAME_NO_OP",
            EngineError::RetypeRefused { problems, .. } => {
                // A section-map defect dominates: until the keys land where
                // the target declares them, nothing else about the sections
                // can be judged, and the missing-required findings it causes
                // ride along in `details.problems`.
                if problems.iter().any(|p| p.code() == "UNKNOWN_SECTION") {
                    return "UNKNOWN_SECTION";
                }
                let first = problems.first().map(|p| p.code());
                match first {
                    Some(code) if problems.iter().all(|p| p.code() == code) => code,
                    _ => "RETYPE_REFUSED",
                }
            }
            EngineError::RetypeNoOp { .. } => "RETYPE_NO_OP",
            EngineError::InvalidCheckFinding { .. } => crate::check::INVALID_CHECK_FINDING_CODE,
            EngineError::RetypeReferrerUnprobeable { .. } => "RETYPE_REFERRER_UNPROBEABLE",
            EngineError::EmptyUpdate { .. } => "EMPTY_UPDATE",
            EngineError::RenameBlockedByCrossMemPolicy { .. } => {
                "RENAME_BLOCKED_BY_CROSS_MEM_POLICY"
            }
            EngineError::RenamePartialFailure { .. } => "RENAME_PARTIAL_FAILURE",
            EngineError::RelationHasBodyLinks { .. } => "RELATION_HAS_BODY_LINKS",
            EngineError::WikiLinkWithoutRelation { .. } => "WIKILINK_WITHOUT_RELATION",
            EngineError::StubCannotRelate { .. } => "STUB_CANNOT_RELATE",
            EngineError::StubNotUpdatable { .. } => "STUB_NOT_UPDATABLE",
            EngineError::StubNotRenamable { .. } => "STUB_NOT_RENAMABLE",
            EngineError::InvalidEntityId { .. } => "INVALID_ENTITY_ID",
            EngineError::InvalidWikiLinkTarget { .. } => "INVALID_WIKI_LINK_TARGET",
            EngineError::InvalidWikiLinkMem { .. } => "INVALID_MEM_NAME",
            EngineError::ConflictingSectionModes { .. } => "CONFLICTING_SECTION_MODES",
            EngineError::RelationshipCycle { .. } => "RELATIONSHIP_CYCLE",
            EngineError::SetAndUnsetConflict { .. } => "SET_AND_UNSET_CONFLICT",
            EngineError::RequiredFieldUnset { .. } => "REQUIRED_FIELD_UNSET",
            EngineError::MissingRequiredSection { .. } => "MISSING_REQUIRED_SECTION",
            EngineError::PatchSectionEmpty { .. } => "PATCH_SECTION_EMPTY",
            EngineError::PatchOldNotFound { .. } => "PATCH_OLD_NOT_FOUND",
            EngineError::UnterminatedFenceInStoredBody { .. } => {
                "UNTERMINATED_FENCE_IN_STORED_BODY"
            }
            EngineError::Validation(v) => v.code(),
            EngineError::ParseAfterWrite(_) => "PARSE_ERROR",
            EngineError::Parse(_) => "PARSE_ERROR",
            EngineError::Backend(_) => "MEM_ERROR",
            EngineError::SchemaNotFound { .. } => "SCHEMA_NOT_FOUND",
            EngineError::EmbeddedSchemaInvalid { .. } => "EMBEDDED_SCHEMA_INVALID",
            EngineError::SchemaPackageInvalid { .. } => "SCHEMA_VALIDATION_FAILED",
            EngineError::SchemaResolverInit(_) => "SCHEMA_RESOLVER_INIT_FAILED",
            EngineError::Mem(_) => "MEM_ERROR",
            EngineError::MemNameCollision { .. } => "MEM_NAME_COLLISION",
            EngineError::InvalidInput(_) => "INVALID_INPUT",
            EngineError::MergeConflictUnsupportedBackend { .. } => {
                "CONFLICT_RESOLVE_UNSUPPORTED_BACKEND"
            }
            EngineError::NotConflicted { .. } => "NOT_CONFLICTED",
            EngineError::RenameSimilarityOutOfRange { .. } => "INVALID_INPUT",
            EngineError::InvalidChangesCursor { .. } => "INVALID_CURSOR",
            EngineError::InvalidTimestampCursor { .. } => "INVALID_CURSOR",
            EngineError::ReviewMarkNotSet { .. } => "REVIEW_MARK_NOT_SET",
            EngineError::MemConfigIncomplete { .. } => "MEM_CONFIG_INCOMPLETE",
            EngineError::MissingRequiredDescription { .. } => "MISSING_REQUIRED_DESCRIPTION",
            EngineError::DescriptionNotPermitted { .. } => "DESCRIPTION_NOT_PERMITTED",
            EngineError::RelationManualAuthoringForbidden { .. } => {
                "RELATION_MANUAL_AUTHORING_FORBIDDEN"
            }
            EngineError::SearchUnavailable => "SEARCH_UNAVAILABLE_IN_WASM",
            EngineError::MarkdownExportUnsupportedBackend { .. } => {
                "MARKDOWN_EXPORT_UNSUPPORTED_BACKEND"
            }
            EngineError::InvalidAnchor(_) => crate::anchor::INVALID_ANCHOR_CODE,
        }
    }

    /// Variant-specific recovery payload, rendered as a structured
    /// JSON object that surfaces under `error.details` in MCP /
    /// CLI envelopes.
    ///
    /// Pre-fix the
    /// batch-update per-item envelope (`batch_error_envelope`)
    /// shipped `{}` for every typed code except `Validation`, while
    /// the singleton-call surfaces (`CliError::from_engine_op`,
    /// `memstead-mcp`'s `engine_err_unified`) populated structured
    /// payloads per-variant. Two envelopes, two details paths —
    /// agents' "fix from `details`" recovery loop worked
    /// differently in batch vs singleton mode. The centralised
    /// helper here gives both surfaces one source of truth.
    ///
    /// Returns an empty object for variants whose recovery payload
    /// is the message text alone (no structured fields beyond
    /// `code` + `message`).
    pub fn details(&self) -> serde_json::Value {
        match self {
            EngineError::RetypeRefused {
                id,
                from_type,
                to_type,
                problems,
                target_sections,
                target_catch_all,
                proposed_section_map,
            } => serde_json::json!({
                "id": id,
                "from_type": from_type,
                "to_type": to_type,
                "problems": problems
                    .iter()
                    .map(|p| {
                        let mut v = serde_json::to_value(p).unwrap_or(serde_json::Value::Null);
                        if let Some(obj) = v.as_object_mut() {
                            obj.insert("code".into(), serde_json::json!(p.code()));
                            obj.insert("message".into(), serde_json::json!(p.message()));
                        }
                        v
                    })
                    .collect::<Vec<_>>(),
                "target_sections": target_sections,
                "target_catch_all": target_catch_all,
                "proposed_section_map": proposed_section_map,
            }),
            EngineError::RetypeNoOp { id, entity_type } => {
                serde_json::json!({ "id": id, "entity_type": entity_type })
            }
            EngineError::InvalidCheckFinding { reason } => serde_json::json!({
                "reason": reason,
                "shape": crate::check::CheckFinding::SHAPE,
            }),
            EngineError::RetypeReferrerUnprobeable { id, mem, reason } => {
                serde_json::json!({ "id": id, "mem": mem, "reason": reason })
            }
            EngineError::NotFound { id } => serde_json::json!({ "id": id }),
            EngineError::AlreadyExists {
                id,
                existing_title,
                existing_is_stub,
            } => serde_json::json!({
                "id": id,
                "existing_title": existing_title,
                "existing_is_stub": existing_is_stub,
            }),
            EngineError::MemQuarantined {
                mem,
                reason_code,
                reason_message,
            } => serde_json::json!({
                "mem": mem,
                "reason_code": reason_code,
                "reason_message": reason_message,
            }),
            EngineError::ConstraintUnsatisfied {
                entity_type,
                entity_id,
                violations,
            } => serde_json::json!({
                "entity_type": entity_type,
                "entity_id": entity_id,
                "violations": violations,
            }),
            EngineError::RequiredOutgoingUnsatisfied {
                entity_type,
                entity_id,
                missing,
            } => serde_json::json!({
                "entity_type": entity_type,
                "entity_id": entity_id,
                "missing": missing,
            }),
            EngineError::SectionFormatRefused {
                entity_type,
                entity_id,
                violation,
            } => {
                let mut v = serde_json::to_value(violation).unwrap_or_default();
                if let Some(obj) = v.as_object_mut() {
                    obj.insert("entity_type".into(), serde_json::json!(entity_type));
                    obj.insert("entity_id".into(), serde_json::json!(entity_id));
                }
                v
            }
            EngineError::RepairNotNeeded { id, recovery } => {
                serde_json::json!({ "id": id, "recovery": recovery })
            }
            // Same shape the full MCP singleton envelope ships for
            // UNKNOWN_ENTITY_TYPE — keeps the centralised helper (and
            // every consumer: batch envelopes, the integrity linter)
            // aligned with the wire payload agents already decode.
            EngineError::UnknownType {
                name,
                schema_ref,
                declared,
                suggestion,
            } => serde_json::json!({
                "name": name,
                "schema_ref": schema_ref,
                "declared": declared,
                "suggestion": suggestion,
            }),
            EngineError::HashMismatch {
                id,
                current,
                is_stub,
            } => serde_json::json!({
                "id": id,
                "current": current,
                "is_stub": is_stub,
            }),
            EngineError::HasIncomingRefs { id, referrers } => {
                let referrers_json: Vec<_> = referrers
                    .iter()
                    .map(|r| {
                        serde_json::json!({
                            "from_id": r.from_id,
                            "rel_types": r.rel_types,
                            "mem": r.mem,
                        })
                    })
                    .collect();
                serde_json::json!({ "id": id, "referrers": referrers_json })
            }
            EngineError::MemHasIncomingRefs { mem, referrers } => {
                let referrers_json: Vec<_> = referrers
                    .iter()
                    .map(|r| {
                        serde_json::json!({
                            "from_id": r.from_id,
                            "rel_types": r.rel_types,
                            "mem": r.mem,
                        })
                    })
                    .collect();
                serde_json::json!({ "mem": mem, "referrers": referrers_json })
            }
            EngineError::WikiLinkWithoutRelation { from_id, missing } => serde_json::json!({
                "from_id": from_id,
                "missing": missing,
            }),
            EngineError::RelationHasBodyLinks {
                from_id,
                to_id,
                rel_type,
                body_links,
            } => {
                serde_json::json!({
                    "from_id": from_id,
                    "to_id": to_id,
                    "rel_type": rel_type,
                    "body_links": body_links,
                })
            }
            EngineError::InvalidEntityId { id, reason } => {
                serde_json::json!({ "id": id, "reason": reason })
            }
            EngineError::InvalidWikiLinkTarget {
                raw,
                suggested,
                section,
                link_source,
                reason,
            } => {
                // Surface
                // the slug-form retry under `proposed_slug`, mirroring the
                // title gate's `INVALID_TITLE` recovery key, so an agent
                // that wrote `[[Idempotency]]` finds `idempotency` under
                // the same field it already knows. `suggested` is the
                // general hint and is sometimes a colon-form
                // (`mem:slug`) for the ambiguous-grammar case — only
                // promote it to `proposed_slug` when it's a bare slug.
                let proposed_slug = suggested
                    .as_ref()
                    .filter(|s| !s.contains(':') && !s.contains("--"));
                serde_json::json!({
                    "raw": raw,
                    "suggested": suggested,
                    "proposed_slug": proposed_slug,
                    "section": section,
                    "source": link_source,
                    "reason": reason,
                })
            }
            EngineError::InvalidWikiLinkMem {
                raw,
                section,
                reason,
            } => {
                serde_json::json!({ "raw": raw, "section": section, "reason": reason })
            }
            EngineError::ConflictingSectionModes { section, modes } => {
                serde_json::json!({ "section": section, "modes": modes })
            }
            EngineError::SetAndUnsetConflict { keys } => serde_json::json!({ "keys": keys }),
            EngineError::RequiredFieldUnset {
                field,
                entity_type,
                field_description,
                enum_values,
                type_write_rules,
                // `on_create` is a prose-dispatch
                // discriminator only; agents branch on the typed
                // `REQUIRED_FIELD_UNSET` code, not on this field.
                on_create: _,
                missing,
            } => {
                // `details.missing[]` carries every required-no-
                // default field unset on the create path so an
                // agent fixes the whole set in one retry. Each
                // entry echoes the type-level `write_rules` for
                // self-containment. Empty on the unset path.
                let missing_json: Vec<_> = missing
                    .iter()
                    .map(|m| {
                        serde_json::json!({
                            "field": m.key,
                            "description": m.description,
                            "enum_values": m.enum_values,
                            "write_rules": type_write_rules,
                        })
                    })
                    .collect();
                serde_json::json!({
                    "field": field,
                    "entity_type": entity_type,
                    "field_description": field_description,
                    "enum_values": enum_values,
                    "type_write_rules": type_write_rules,
                    "missing": missing_json,
                })
            }
            EngineError::MissingRequiredSection {
                entity_type,
                missing_count,
                sections,
                type_guidance,
                pre_announced_missing_fields,
            } => {
                let sections_json: Vec<_> = sections
                    .iter()
                    .map(|s| {
                        serde_json::json!({
                            "entity_type": s.entity_type,
                            "key": s.key,
                            "heading": s.heading,
                            "write_rules": s.write_rules,
                        })
                    })
                    .collect();
                let mut details = serde_json::json!({
                    "entity_type": entity_type,
                    "missing_count": missing_count,
                    "sections": sections_json,
                    "type_guidance": type_guidance,
                });
                // Cross-gate pre-announcement rides additionally and
                // only when non-empty: the established payload above
                // keeps its exact shape, and a single-gate refusal
                // stays byte-identical to the pre-announcement-free
                // form. Element shape mirrors `REQUIRED_FIELD_UNSET`'s
                // `details.missing[]` so one decoder reads both.
                if !pre_announced_missing_fields.is_empty() {
                    let type_rules = type_guidance.get(entity_type).cloned().unwrap_or_default();
                    let missing_json: Vec<_> = pre_announced_missing_fields
                        .iter()
                        .map(|m| {
                            serde_json::json!({
                                "field": m.key,
                                "description": m.description,
                                "enum_values": m.enum_values,
                                "write_rules": type_rules,
                            })
                        })
                        .collect();
                    details["pre_announced"] = serde_json::json!({
                        "required_field_unset": { "missing": missing_json }
                    });
                }
                details
            }
            EngineError::PatchSectionEmpty { section } => serde_json::json!({ "section": section }),
            EngineError::PatchOldNotFound {
                section,
                current_content,
                truncated,
                found_in_sections,
            } => {
                serde_json::json!({
                    "section": section,
                    "current_content": current_content,
                    "truncated": truncated,
                    "found_in_sections": found_in_sections,
                })
            }
            EngineError::RelationshipCycle {
                rel_type,
                from,
                to,
                existing_path,
                path_truncated,
                acyclic_set,
                existing_path_rel_types,
            } => {
                let path_json: Vec<_> = existing_path.iter().map(|id| id.to_string()).collect();
                let mut d = serde_json::json!({
                    "rel_type": rel_type,
                    "from": from.to_string(),
                    "to": to.to_string(),
                    "existing_path": path_json,
                    "path_truncated": path_truncated,
                });
                // Additive: only set refusals carry the set echo and
                // the per-hop rel-types; single-rel-type refusals stay
                // byte-identical.
                if let Some(set) = acyclic_set {
                    d["acyclic_set"] = serde_json::json!(set);
                }
                if let Some(rels) = existing_path_rel_types {
                    d["existing_path_rel_types"] = serde_json::json!(rels);
                }
                d
            }
            EngineError::CrossMemLinkNotAllowed { from_mem, to_mem } => {
                serde_json::json!({ "from_mem": from_mem, "to_mem": to_mem })
            }
            EngineError::EmptyUpdate { id } => {
                serde_json::json!({
                    "id": id,
                    "recognised_keys": RECOGNISED_MUTATION_KEYS,
                })
            }
            EngineError::RenameBlockedByCrossMemPolicy {
                from_mem,
                blocked_referrers,
            } => {
                let entries: Vec<_> = blocked_referrers
                    .iter()
                    .map(|r| {
                        serde_json::json!({
                            "from_mem": r.from_mem,
                            "to_mem": r.to_mem,
                            "count": r.count,
                        })
                    })
                    .collect();
                serde_json::json!({
                    "from_mem": from_mem,
                    "blocked_referrers": entries,
                })
            }
            EngineError::CrossMemTargetNotFound {
                target_id,
                target_mem,
            } => {
                serde_json::json!({ "target_id": target_id, "target_mem": target_mem })
            }
            EngineError::UnterminatedFenceInStoredBody {
                id,
                section,
                fence,
                swallowed,
            } => serde_json::json!({
                "id": id,
                "section": section,
                "fence": fence,
                "swallowed_sections": swallowed,
                "expected": format!(
                    "supply `sections` with a corrected body for '{section}': lift the swallowed \
                     content back into its own sections and close the fence"
                ),
            }),
            EngineError::Validation(v) => v.details(),
            EngineError::MissingRequiredDescription {
                rel_type,
                from_id,
                to_id,
            } => {
                serde_json::json!({
                    "rel_type": rel_type,
                    "from_id": from_id,
                    "to_id": to_id,
                })
            }
            EngineError::DescriptionNotPermitted {
                rel_type,
                from_id,
                to_id,
            } => {
                serde_json::json!({
                    "rel_type": rel_type,
                    "from_id": from_id,
                    "to_id": to_id,
                })
            }
            EngineError::RelationManualAuthoringForbidden {
                rel_type,
                from_id,
                to_id,
                guidance,
            } => serde_json::json!({
                "rel_type": rel_type,
                "from_id": from_id,
                "to_id": to_id,
                "guidance": guidance,
            }),
            EngineError::MarkdownExportUnsupportedBackend {
                mem,
                active_backend,
                supported_backends,
            } => serde_json::json!({
                "mem": mem,
                "active_backend": active_backend,
                "supported_backends": supported_backends,
            }),
            EngineError::ReviewMarkNotSet { mem } => serde_json::json!({ "mem": mem }),
            EngineError::InvalidChangesCursor { mem, since } => serde_json::json!({
                "mem": mem,
                "since": since,
            }),
            EngineError::SchemaNotFound {
                mem,
                pin,
                sources,
                install_hint,
            } => {
                let mut details = serde_json::json!({
                    "mem": mem,
                    "pin": pin,
                    "sources": sources,
                });
                if let Some(path) = install_hint {
                    details["install_hint"] = serde_json::json!({
                        "authoring_package": path,
                        "command": format!("memstead schema install {path}"),
                    });
                }
                details
            }
            EngineError::SchemaPackageInvalid {
                name,
                version,
                message,
            } => serde_json::json!({
                "schema": format!("{name}@{version}"),
                "error": message,
            }),
            EngineError::InvalidAnchor(e) => {
                serde_json::Value::Object(e.detail().into_iter().collect::<serde_json::Map<_, _>>())
            }
            _ => serde_json::Value::Object(serde_json::Map::new()),
        }
    }

    /// Render rich, fully-inlined recovery prose for the agent-visible
    /// text channel.
    ///
    /// Warnings
    /// already render their structured payload inline via
    /// `WarningHint::Display`; pre-fix errors with rich payloads
    /// collapsed to `Display` plus `format_inline_list_overflow`'s
    /// "+N more — see details.X" pointer pointing at a structured
    /// channel the agent's MCP client doesn't surface to the model.
    /// This method gives errors the same prose-rich rendering warnings
    /// have, so `result.content[0].text` is self-recoverable.
    ///
    /// Variants whose `Display` already inlines every recovery field
    /// (no truncation, no "see details" pointer) inherit the default
    /// trait impl — they just `to_string()`. Override only the
    /// variants that need richer rendering than `Display` provides.
    ///
    /// The structured `details()` channel is unchanged; consumers
    /// branching on `code` continue to receive the typed shape. The
    /// `Display` impl stays terse for logs, tracing, panic messages,
    /// and other non-agent consumers.
    pub fn prose_render(&self) -> String {
        match self {
            // The echoed conforming `example` is the highest-leverage
            // part of a format refusal — inline it on the text channel
            // too, not only under `details.example`.
            EngineError::SectionFormatRefused { violation, .. } => {
                let base = self.to_string();
                match violation.example() {
                    Some(example) => {
                        format!("{base}\nA conforming example:\n{}", example.trim_end())
                    }
                    None => base,
                }
            }
            EngineError::HasIncomingRefs { id, referrers } => {
                let inline = render_referrers_inline(referrers);
                format!(
                    "entity {id} has {n} incoming reference(s) in write mems ({inline}); remove them first via memstead_relate --remove or memstead_update",
                    n = referrers.len(),
                )
            }
            EngineError::MemHasIncomingRefs { mem, referrers } => {
                let inline = render_referrers_inline(referrers);
                format!(
                    "mem `{mem}` has {n} incoming reference(s) in write mems ({inline}); remove them first via memstead_relate --remove or memstead_update",
                    n = referrers.len(),
                )
            }
            EngineError::WikiLinkWithoutRelation { from_id, missing } => {
                let inline = missing
                    .iter()
                    .map(|m| m.to_string())
                    .collect::<Vec<_>>()
                    .join(", ");
                format!(
                    "post-mutation body of {from_id} has {n} wiki-link(s) without a backing relation ({inline}) — declare the relation(s) via memstead_relate first (REFERENCES or a more specific rel-type), then retry",
                    n = missing.len(),
                )
            }
            EngineError::RelationHasBodyLinks {
                from_id,
                to_id,
                rel_type,
                body_links,
            } => {
                let inline = body_links.join(", ");
                format!(
                    "cannot remove {rel_type} {from_id} → {to_id}: source body still contains wiki-link(s) to the target in section(s) {inline} — drop them via memstead_update before removing the relation"
                )
            }
            EngineError::RelationshipCycle {
                rel_type,
                from,
                to,
                existing_path,
                path_truncated,
                acyclic_set,
                ..
            } => {
                let path_inline = if existing_path.is_empty() {
                    String::from("(unavailable)")
                } else {
                    existing_path
                        .iter()
                        .map(|id| id.to_string())
                        .collect::<Vec<_>>()
                        .join(" → ")
                };
                let trunc = if *path_truncated {
                    " (path truncated)"
                } else {
                    ""
                };
                let subgraph = match acyclic_set {
                    Some(set) => format!("[{}] acyclicity-set", set.join(", ")),
                    None => rel_type.to_string(),
                };
                format!(
                    "creating edge {rel_type} from '{from}' to '{to}' would close a cycle in the {subgraph} subgraph — existing path: {path_inline}{trunc}; remove an edge along this path to break the cycle, then retry"
                )
            }
            EngineError::RequiredFieldUnset {
                field,
                entity_type,
                field_description,
                enum_values,
                type_write_rules,
                on_create,
                missing,
            } => {
                let desc_clause = field_description
                    .as_deref()
                    .map(|d| format!(" Field purpose: {d}."))
                    .unwrap_or_default();
                let enum_clause = if enum_values.is_empty() {
                    String::new()
                } else {
                    format!(" Allowed values: {}.", enum_values.join(", "))
                };
                let rules_clause = if type_write_rules.is_empty() {
                    String::new()
                } else {
                    format!(" Type-level write_rules: {}.", type_write_rules.join("; "))
                };
                // Path-aware wording — create
                // path says "not provided"; update path says "cannot
                // unset". Display impl shares the same dispatch via
                // `_required_field_unset_msg`.
                let lead = if *on_create {
                    format!(
                        "required metadata field '{field}' not provided — type '{entity_type}' declares the field as required and has no default for it"
                    )
                } else {
                    format!("cannot unset required field '{field}' for type '{entity_type}'")
                };
                // Multi-field accumulator. On the create path,
                // append a tail-list naming every other unset
                // required field so the agent's one-shot retry
                // covers all of them. The unset path's `missing`
                // is empty (or singleton), so the clause is empty
                // there.
                let tail_clause = if missing.len() > 1 {
                    let others: Vec<&str> =
                        missing.iter().skip(1).map(|m| m.key.as_str()).collect();
                    format!(" Also unset (declaration order): {}.", others.join(", "))
                } else {
                    String::new()
                };
                format!("{lead}.{desc_clause}{enum_clause}{rules_clause}{tail_clause}")
            }
            EngineError::MissingRequiredSection {
                entity_type,
                missing_count,
                sections,
                type_guidance,
                pre_announced_missing_fields,
            } => {
                let mut out = format!(
                    "missing {missing_count} required section(s) for type '{entity_type}':"
                );
                for s in sections {
                    let rules = if s.write_rules.is_empty() {
                        String::new()
                    } else {
                        format!(" — write_rules: {}", s.write_rules.join("; "))
                    };
                    out.push_str(&format!("\n  - '{}' ({}){rules}", s.key, s.heading));
                }
                if !type_guidance.is_empty() {
                    out.push_str("\nType guidance:");
                    for (etype, rules) in type_guidance {
                        if rules.is_empty() {
                            continue;
                        }
                        out.push_str(&format!("\n  - {etype}: {}", rules.join("; ")));
                    }
                }
                // Cross-gate pre-announcement on the text channel so a
                // consumer reading only prose still fixes both gates in
                // one retry.
                if !pre_announced_missing_fields.is_empty() {
                    out.push_str(
                        "\nPre-announced — the metadata gate will also require (supply in the same retry):",
                    );
                    for m in pre_announced_missing_fields {
                        let enums = if m.enum_values.is_empty() {
                            String::new()
                        } else {
                            format!(" (one of: {})", m.enum_values.join(", "))
                        };
                        out.push_str(&format!("\n  - '{}'{enums} — {}", m.key, m.description));
                    }
                }
                out
            }
            EngineError::UnterminatedFenceInStoredBody {
                id,
                section,
                fence,
                swallowed,
            } => {
                let buried = if swallowed.is_empty() {
                    "No declared section follows it in the file yet".to_string()
                } else {
                    format!("Buried right now: {}", swallowed.join(", "))
                };
                format!(
                    "entity '{id}' section '{section}' ends inside an unterminated `{fence}` code \
                     fence. In CommonMark an open fence runs to end of text, so the sections \
                     after it were absorbed into this body on the last read and are reported as \
                     empty. {buried}. Writing now appends the closing fence AFTER those bytes, \
                     sealing them inside a legitimately fenced block where nothing can tell them \
                     from prose the author meant to fence. Replace section '{section}' with a \
                     corrected body in this same call: lift the swallowed content back into its \
                     own sections and close the fence."
                )
            }
            EngineError::Validation(v) => v.prose_render(),
            // Variants whose `Display` already inlines every recovery
            // field — title invariants, hash mismatch (already explains
            // the stub case), unknown mem / type (already prints
            // declared list verbatim), cross-mem gates, stubs,
            // patch errors, etc. — fall back to `Display`. Logs and
            // tracing consumers see the same string.
            _ => self.to_string(),
        }
    }
}

/// Inline-render every [`ReferrerInfo`] without the truncation suffix
/// `format_inline_list_overflow` applies. Used by
/// [`EngineError::prose_render`]'s `HasIncomingRefs` /
/// `MemHasIncomingRefs` arms — the agent text channel inlines the
/// full list so recovery doesn't depend on the structured channel.
fn render_referrers_inline(referrers: &[ReferrerInfo]) -> String {
    referrers
        .iter()
        .map(|r| r.to_string())
        .collect::<Vec<_>>()
        .join(", ")
}

/// Format the `RequiredFieldUnset` message. The same typed code
/// fires from two semantically-distinct call sites:
///
/// * The create path constructs the variant when the caller didn't
///   supply a required metadata field. The pre-fix message ("cannot
///   unset required field …") was misleading because the field was
///   never set in the first place — `on_create: true` flips the
///   wording to "required metadata field … not provided".
/// * The update path constructs the variant when the caller passed
///   `metadata_unset: ["field"]` against a required field. The
///   pre-fix wording is correct for this path — `on_create: false`
///   keeps it.
///
/// Both paths share recovery (provide the field); the typed code
/// stays `REQUIRED_FIELD_UNSET` for code-key branching consumers.
fn _relationship_cycle_msg(
    rel_type: &str,
    from: &EntityId,
    to: &EntityId,
    acyclic_set: Option<&[String]>,
) -> String {
    match acyclic_set {
        Some(set) => format!(
            "creating edge {rel_type} from '{from}' to '{to}' would close a cycle in the [{}] acyclicity-set subgraph",
            set.join(", ")
        ),
        None => format!(
            "creating edge {rel_type} from '{from}' to '{to}' would close a cycle in the {rel_type} subgraph"
        ),
    }
}

fn _required_field_unset_msg(field: &str, entity_type: &str, on_create: bool) -> String {
    if on_create {
        format!(
            "required metadata field '{field}' not provided — type '{entity_type}' declares the field as required and has no default for it"
        )
    } else {
        format!("cannot unset required field '{field}' for type '{entity_type}'")
    }
}

/// Format the `HashMismatch` message. Stub-shaped entities have no
/// `content_hash` to compare against; rendering the empty `current:`
/// paren the way pre-fix code did misdirects an agent toward
/// hash-recovery via `memstead_entity` (which returns the same empty
/// hash). Surface the actual corrective action — pass
/// `expected_hash: ""` — instead.
/// Render the `SCHEMA_NOT_FOUND` message with its source-trail
/// summary. The trail says exactly which sources were searched and
/// what each held — never more (a source absent from `sources` is not
/// claimed searched). A right-name/wrong-version failure and a
/// never-installed failure are distinguishable from this sentence
/// alone; the structured `details.sources` stays the richer channel.
/// Empty `sources` (internal lookup miss) keeps the bare legacy
/// sentence — there was no source search to summarise.
fn schema_not_found_message(
    mem: &str,
    pin: &str,
    sources: &[SchemaSourceDiagnostic],
    install_hint: &Option<String>,
) -> String {
    let mut msg = format!("mem {mem}: schema pin {pin:?} did not resolve in any schema source");
    if sources.is_empty() {
        return msg;
    }
    let name = pin.split('@').next().unwrap_or(pin);
    let trail: Vec<String> = sources
        .iter()
        .map(|s| {
            if let Some(status) = s.status {
                format!("{} ({status})", s.source)
            } else if s.versions_found.is_empty() {
                format!("{} (nothing for {name:?})", s.source)
            } else {
                format!("{} (holds {})", s.source, s.versions_found.join(", "))
            }
        })
        .collect();
    msg.push_str(&format!(" — searched {}", trail.join(", ")));
    if sources.iter().any(|s| !s.versions_found.is_empty()) {
        // Right name, wrong version. The honest hint is version
        // repair, not silence: the final clause is the concrete repin
        // command against the newest version a source actually holds.
        let best = sources
            .iter()
            .flat_map(|s| &s.versions_found)
            .filter_map(|v| semver::Version::parse(v).ok())
            .max();
        msg.push_str(&format!(
            "; the name {name:?} exists at the versions listed — the pinned version is wrong, \
             or the pinned version was never installed"
        ));
        if let Some(best) = best {
            msg.push_str(&format!(
                "; repin to an installed version: run: memstead mem set-schema {mem} {name}@{best}"
            ));
        }
    } else if let Some(path) = install_hint {
        msg.push_str(&format!(
            "; an authoring package named {name:?} exists at {path:?} but is not installed — \
             run: memstead schema install {path}"
        ));
    } else {
        // Name unknown everywhere and no authoring package in sight —
        // the repair path is still the install path, stated without a
        // concrete package location because none exists to name.
        msg.push_str(&format!(
            "; no source holds any version of {name:?} — author or obtain the schema package, \
             then run: memstead schema install <package-dir>"
        ));
    }
    msg
}

impl EngineError {
    /// Attach the schema-install hint to a `SchemaNotFound` where a
    /// workspace root is known: probe the root's immediate
    /// subdirectories for an authoring schema package (a directory the
    /// schema loader accepts) whose manifest name matches the pin's
    /// name, and record its path when NO resolution source holds any
    /// version of that name. Any other error variant — and any
    /// `SchemaNotFound` where the name IS installed at some version
    /// (a version mismatch is a different fix), where `sources` is
    /// empty (internal miss, no source search happened), or where no
    /// candidate package exists — passes through unchanged. Read-only:
    /// the probe never writes, installs, or seals anything.
    pub fn with_schema_install_probe(self, workspace_root: Option<&std::path::Path>) -> Self {
        let EngineError::SchemaNotFound {
            mem,
            pin,
            sources,
            install_hint,
        } = self
        else {
            return self;
        };
        let hint = if install_hint.is_some() {
            install_hint
        } else if sources.is_empty() || sources.iter().any(|s| !s.versions_found.is_empty()) {
            None
        } else {
            let name = pin.split('@').next().unwrap_or(&pin).to_string();
            workspace_root.and_then(|root| probe_authoring_package(root, &name))
        };
        EngineError::SchemaNotFound {
            mem,
            pin,
            sources,
            install_hint: hint,
        }
    }
}

/// Scan `root`'s immediate subdirectories for a loadable schema
/// package whose manifest name is `name`. Hidden directories and the
/// workspace's own storage (`mem-repo`, `.memstead`) are skipped. The
/// full loader runs (error path only, so the cost is acceptable) — a
/// directory that merely LOOKS like a package but fails validation
/// produces no hint, because `memstead schema install` would refuse it
/// anyway.
fn probe_authoring_package(root: &std::path::Path, name: &str) -> Option<String> {
    let entries = std::fs::read_dir(root).ok()?;
    for entry in entries.flatten() {
        let path = entry.path();
        if !path.is_dir() {
            continue;
        }
        let dir_name = entry.file_name();
        let dir_name = dir_name.to_string_lossy();
        if dir_name.starts_with('.') || dir_name == "mem-repo" {
            continue;
        }
        if !path.join("schema.yaml").is_file() {
            continue;
        }
        if let Ok(schema) = memstead_schema::load_schema_from_dir(&path) {
            let (loaded_name, _) = schema.id();
            if loaded_name == name {
                return Some(path.display().to_string());
            }
        }
    }
    None
}

fn _hash_mismatch_msg(id: &str, current: &str, is_stub: bool) -> String {
    if is_stub {
        format!(
            "hash mismatch for {id} — entity is a stub (no content_hash); pass expected_hash: \"\" to operate on stubs"
        )
    } else {
        format!("hash mismatch for {id} — entity was modified concurrently (current: {current})")
    }
}

/// Errors surfaced by [`Engine::from_workspace_root`] (lean) and its
/// full counterpart (`memstead_git_branch::engine_from_workspace_root`).
///
/// The boot path layers three error sources: layout detection,
/// workspace-store load failures, per-mount backend instantiation
/// (folder + archive vs git-branch), and engine construction
/// (duplicate-mem checks). `#[from]` lifts the lower-layer types so
/// callers branch on a single error envelope.
// Variants lift lower-layer error types verbatim via `#[from]`, so the enum is
// as wide as its widest member. Boot errors are constructed at most once per
// process; boxing to equalise them would buy nothing.
#[allow(clippy::large_enum_variant)]
#[derive(Debug, thiserror::Error)]
pub enum BootError {
    /// `detect_layout` returned [`crate::Layout::Empty`] — workspace
    /// root has no recognised layout marker. Operator runs
    /// `memstead mem-repo init` rather than booting against an empty
    /// directory.
    #[error("workspace at {0} is not initialised — run `memstead mem-repo init` first")]
    NotInitialised(PathBuf),
    /// Underlying [`crate::WorkspaceStoreAdapter`] load failed
    /// (missing config file, parse error, format-mismatch).
    #[error(transparent)]
    Store(#[from] crate::workspace_store::StoreError),
    /// Per-mount backend instantiation failed. Today: a mount
    /// declared `MountStorage::GitBranch` while the lean boot path
    /// only knows folder + archive.
    #[error(transparent)]
    Instantiate(#[from] crate::workspace_store::InstantiateError),
    /// Engine construction failed (duplicate mem names, etc.).
    #[error(transparent)]
    Engine(#[from] EngineError),
}

impl BootError {
    /// Stable, surface-independent error code token (UPPER_SNAKE, per
    /// the [`EngineError::code`] convention). Every boot failure class
    /// resolves to a typed code — `INTERNAL` is not producible from
    /// this seam. The wrapped layers each own their vocabulary:
    /// store-load failures delegate to
    /// [`crate::workspace_store::StoreError::code`], backend
    /// instantiation to
    /// [`crate::workspace_store::InstantiateError::code`], engine
    /// construction to [`EngineError::code`].
    pub fn code(&self) -> &'static str {
        match self {
            // Same token the CLI's workspace walk uses — "no
            // workspace here" is one condition wherever detected.
            BootError::NotInitialised(_) => "WORKSPACE_NOT_INITIALISED",
            BootError::Store(e) => e.code(),
            BootError::Instantiate(e) => e.code(),
            BootError::Engine(e) => e.code(),
        }
    }

    /// Structured recovery payload for the boot failure, surfacing
    /// under `error.details` on `--json` envelopes. Engine-layer
    /// failures reuse [`EngineError::details`] (so e.g. a boot-time
    /// `SCHEMA_NOT_FOUND` ships the same `details.sources` trail the
    /// per-verb surfaces ship); the other layers name the offending
    /// path.
    pub fn details(&self) -> serde_json::Value {
        use crate::workspace_store::StoreError;
        match self {
            BootError::NotInitialised(path) => {
                serde_json::json!({
                    "path": path.display().to_string(),
                    "hint": { "recovery_command": "memstead mem-repo init" },
                })
            }
            BootError::Store(e) => match e {
                StoreError::NotInitialised { path }
                | StoreError::Io { path, .. }
                | StoreError::Parse { path, .. }
                | StoreError::FormatMismatch { path, .. }
                | StoreError::LegacyLayout { path, .. }
                | StoreError::UnknownBindingVersion { path, .. } => {
                    serde_json::json!({ "path": path.display().to_string() })
                }
                StoreError::LegacyProjectionStore { path } => serde_json::json!({
                    "path": path.display().to_string(),
                    "hint": { "recovery_command": "memstead projection migrate" },
                }),
                StoreError::Other(_) => serde_json::json!({}),
            },
            BootError::Instantiate(
                crate::workspace_store::InstantiateError::GitBranchRequiresMemRepoFeature { mem },
            ) => serde_json::json!({ "mem": mem }),
            BootError::Engine(e) => e.details(),
        }
    }

    /// The one boot-failure message every surface prints verbatim
    /// (CLI stderr / `--json`, MCP boot diagnostics), so the same
    /// broken workspace reads identically wherever it refuses. The
    /// leaf error's own message carries the repair command (or states
    /// plainly that none exists).
    pub fn surface_message(&self, workspace_root: &std::path::Path) -> String {
        format!("init engine at {}: {self}", workspace_root.display())
    }
}

#[cfg(test)]
mod plan05_subsystem_tests {
    use super::*;

    /// A title-case body wiki-link refusal carries the
    /// slug-form retry under `proposed_slug` (mirroring `INVALID_TITLE`),
    /// so an agent that wrote `[[Idempotency]]` finds `idempotency` under
    /// the key it already knows.
    #[test]
    fn invalid_wiki_link_details_carry_proposed_slug_for_title_case() {
        let err = EngineError::InvalidWikiLinkTarget {
            raw: "Idempotency".to_string(),
            suggested: Some("idempotency".to_string()),
            section: "purpose".to_string(),
            link_source: "body_link".to_string(),
            reason: "slugs must be lowercase".to_string(),
        };
        let d = err.details();
        assert_eq!(d["proposed_slug"], "idempotency");
        assert_eq!(d["suggested"], "idempotency");
    }

    /// `SCHEMA_NOT_FOUND` carries the fixed-order resolution
    /// diagnostics under `details.sources`: a right-name/wrong-version
    /// pin shows the built-in's available versions with
    /// `pinned_version_match = false`, and `remote` is the reserved
    /// `not_configured` slot. This is the agent-visible payload that
    /// tells the caller the name resolves but the version does not.
    #[test]
    fn schema_not_found_details_carry_fixed_order_source_diagnostics() {
        let requested: semver::Version = "99.0.0".parse().unwrap();
        let sources = SchemaSourceDiagnostic::for_failed_pin("default", &requested, &[]);
        let err = EngineError::SchemaNotFound {
            mem: "specs".to_string(),
            pin: "default@99.0.0".to_string(),
            sources,
            install_hint: None,
        };
        assert_eq!(err.code(), "SCHEMA_NOT_FOUND");
        let d = err.details();
        assert_eq!(d["mem"], "specs");
        assert_eq!(d["pin"], "default@99.0.0");
        let src = d["sources"].as_array().expect("sources is an array");
        let labels: Vec<&str> = src.iter().map(|s| s["source"].as_str().unwrap()).collect();
        assert_eq!(labels, ["local_storage", "builtin", "remote"]);
        // The `default` builtin exists at 1.0.0 — right name, wrong
        // version: builtin enumerates it but the pin does not match.
        let builtin = &src[1];
        assert!(
            builtin["versions_found"]
                .as_array()
                .unwrap()
                .iter()
                .any(|v| v == "1.0.0"),
            "builtin must enumerate default@1.0.0, got {builtin:?}",
        );
        assert_eq!(builtin["pinned_version_match"], false);
        // No local storage was consulted (empty `consulted` slice).
        assert_eq!(src[0]["versions_found"].as_array().unwrap().len(), 0);
        // Remote is the reserved, unenumerated slot.
        assert_eq!(src[2]["status"], "not_configured");
        assert!(
            src[2].get("versions_found").is_some(),
            "remote still ships an (empty) versions_found list",
        );
    }

    /// The MESSAGE (not just `details`) summarises the source trail,
    /// and a right-name/wrong-version failure is distinguishable from
    /// a never-installed one without opening `details`. The message
    /// names exactly the sources in `sources` — never one that was
    /// not searched — and the empty-sources internal miss keeps the
    /// bare legacy sentence.
    #[test]
    fn schema_not_found_message_summarises_trail_and_distinguishes_wrong_version() {
        // Wrong version: the builtin catalogue holds `default@1.0.0`,
        // the pin asks for 99.0.0.
        let requested: semver::Version = "99.0.0".parse().unwrap();
        let wrong_version = EngineError::SchemaNotFound {
            mem: "specs".to_string(),
            pin: "default@99.0.0".to_string(),
            sources: SchemaSourceDiagnostic::for_failed_pin("default", &requested, &[]),
            install_hint: None,
        };
        let msg = wrong_version.to_string();
        assert!(msg.contains("searched local_storage"), "got: {msg}");
        assert!(msg.contains("builtin (holds"), "got: {msg}");
        assert!(msg.contains("remote (not_configured)"), "got: {msg}");
        assert!(
            msg.contains("the pinned version is wrong"),
            "wrong-version case must be named in the message: {msg}"
        );
        assert!(
            msg.contains("memstead mem set-schema specs default@1.3.0"),
            "wrong-version case ends in the concrete repin command: {msg}"
        );

        // Never installed: no source holds any version of the name.
        let never: semver::Version = "1.0.0".parse().unwrap();
        let never_installed = EngineError::SchemaNotFound {
            mem: "specs".to_string(),
            pin: "no-such-schema@1.0.0".to_string(),
            sources: SchemaSourceDiagnostic::for_failed_pin("no-such-schema", &never, &[]),
            install_hint: None,
        };
        let msg2 = never_installed.to_string();
        assert!(
            msg2.contains("nothing for \"no-such-schema\""),
            "never-installed case names the empty sources: {msg2}"
        );
        assert!(
            !msg2.contains("the pinned version is wrong"),
            "never-installed must NOT claim a version mismatch: {msg2}"
        );
        assert!(
            msg2.contains("memstead schema install <package-dir>"),
            "never-installed (no probe) still names the install path: {msg2}"
        );
        assert_ne!(msg, msg2, "the two failures are distinguishable");

        // Internal lookup miss (empty sources): bare legacy sentence,
        // no trail is claimed.
        let internal = EngineError::SchemaNotFound {
            mem: "specs".to_string(),
            pin: "x@1.0.0".to_string(),
            sources: Vec::new(),
            install_hint: None,
        };
        assert_eq!(
            internal.to_string(),
            "mem specs: schema pin \"x@1.0.0\" did not resolve in any schema source",
        );
    }

    /// The install-hint probe attaches the authoring-package pointer
    /// exactly when a loadable package with the pin's name sits in the
    /// workspace root while NO source holds any version of the name —
    /// and stays silent for a version mismatch (installed at another
    /// version), for an absent package, and for a non-`SchemaNotFound`
    /// error.
    #[test]
    fn schema_install_probe_hints_only_for_uninstalled_authoring_package() {
        // Workspace root carrying the memstead-schema `examples/minimal`
        // package (name `recipe`) as an authoring folder.
        let tmp = tempfile::TempDir::new().unwrap();
        let src_pkg = std::path::Path::new(env!("CARGO_MANIFEST_DIR"))
            .join("../memstead-schema/examples/minimal");
        let dst = tmp.path().join("recipe");
        std::fs::create_dir_all(dst.join("types")).unwrap();
        std::fs::copy(src_pkg.join("schema.yaml"), dst.join("schema.yaml")).unwrap();
        for entry in std::fs::read_dir(src_pkg.join("types")).unwrap().flatten() {
            std::fs::copy(entry.path(), dst.join("types").join(entry.file_name())).unwrap();
        }

        let requested: semver::Version = "0.1.0".parse().unwrap();
        let not_found = || EngineError::SchemaNotFound {
            mem: "specs".to_string(),
            pin: "recipe@0.1.0".to_string(),
            sources: SchemaSourceDiagnostic::for_failed_pin("recipe", &requested, &[]),
            install_hint: None,
        };

        // Uninstalled + authored → hint attaches, message + details
        // point at `memstead schema install`.
        let hinted = not_found().with_schema_install_probe(Some(tmp.path()));
        let msg = hinted.to_string();
        assert!(
            msg.contains("memstead schema install"),
            "hint must name the install command: {msg}"
        );
        assert!(msg.contains("recipe"), "hint names the package: {msg}");
        let d = hinted.details();
        assert!(
            d["install_hint"]["command"]
                .as_str()
                .unwrap()
                .starts_with("memstead schema install"),
            "details carry the hint: {d}"
        );

        // No workspace root → no concrete package hint; the message
        // falls back to the generic install path.
        let no_root = not_found().with_schema_install_probe(None);
        let no_root_msg = no_root.to_string();
        assert!(
            no_root_msg.contains("memstead schema install <package-dir>"),
            "generic install path without a probe hit: {no_root_msg}"
        );
        assert!(
            !no_root_msg.contains(&tmp.path().display().to_string()),
            "no concrete package path without a probe hit: {no_root_msg}"
        );

        // No such authoring package → same generic fallback, no
        // concrete path.
        let other_tmp = tempfile::TempDir::new().unwrap();
        let absent = not_found().with_schema_install_probe(Some(other_tmp.path()));
        let absent_msg = absent.to_string();
        assert!(
            absent_msg.contains("memstead schema install <package-dir>"),
            "generic install path when no package exists: {absent_msg}"
        );
        assert!(
            !absent_msg.contains(&other_tmp.path().display().to_string()),
            "no concrete package path when no package exists: {absent_msg}"
        );

        // Version mismatch against an installed package (some source
        // holds versions of the name) → no hint even though the
        // authoring package exists.
        let mismatch_req: semver::Version = "99.0.0".parse().unwrap();
        let mismatch = EngineError::SchemaNotFound {
            mem: "specs".to_string(),
            pin: "default@99.0.0".to_string(),
            sources: SchemaSourceDiagnostic::for_failed_pin("default", &mismatch_req, &[]),
            install_hint: None,
        }
        .with_schema_install_probe(Some(tmp.path()));
        let mismatch_msg = mismatch.to_string();
        assert!(
            !mismatch_msg.contains("schema install"),
            "version mismatch must not hint install: {mismatch_msg}"
        );
        assert!(
            mismatch_msg.contains("memstead mem set-schema specs default@1.3.0"),
            "version mismatch hints version repair instead: {mismatch_msg}"
        );

        // Non-SchemaNotFound errors pass through unchanged.
        let other = EngineError::UnknownMem("specs".to_string())
            .with_schema_install_probe(Some(tmp.path()));
        assert_eq!(other.code(), "UNKNOWN_MEM");
    }

    /// The ambiguous-grammar case suggests a
    /// colon-form (`mem:slug`), which is NOT a bare slug — it must not
    /// be promoted to `proposed_slug`.
    #[test]
    fn invalid_wiki_link_colon_form_suggestion_is_not_a_proposed_slug() {
        let err = EngineError::InvalidWikiLinkTarget {
            raw: "team/sub--thing".to_string(),
            suggested: Some("team/sub:thing".to_string()),
            section: "purpose".to_string(),
            link_source: "body_link".to_string(),
            reason: "ambiguous".to_string(),
        };
        let d = err.details();
        assert!(
            d["proposed_slug"].is_null(),
            "colon-form must not be a proposed_slug: {d}"
        );
        assert_eq!(d["suggested"], "team/sub:thing");
    }

    /// A bad `--since` cursor is the typed `INVALID_CURSOR`
    /// code carrying the untruncated SHA in `details.since`.
    #[test]
    fn invalid_changes_cursor_code_and_details() {
        let sha = "deadbeefdeadbeefdeadbeefdeadbeefdeadbeef";
        let err = EngineError::InvalidChangesCursor {
            mem: "specs".to_string(),
            since: sha.to_string(),
        };
        assert_eq!(err.code(), "INVALID_CURSOR");
        let d = err.details();
        assert_eq!(d["mem"], "specs");
        assert_eq!(
            d["since"], sha,
            "the offending SHA must ride untruncated in details"
        );
    }
}

#[cfg(test)]
mod inline_list_tests {
    use super::*;

    #[test]
    fn empty_list_renders_empty_string() {
        let items: Vec<String> = Vec::new();
        assert_eq!(format_inline_list_overflow(&items, "x"), "");
    }

    #[test]
    fn list_at_cap_renders_all_no_overflow_suffix() {
        let items = vec!["a".to_string(), "b".to_string(), "c".to_string()];
        assert_eq!(format_inline_list_overflow(&items, "x"), "a, b, c");
    }

    #[test]
    fn list_under_cap_renders_all_no_overflow_suffix() {
        let items = vec!["a".to_string(), "b".to_string()];
        assert_eq!(format_inline_list_overflow(&items, "x"), "a, b");
    }

    #[test]
    fn list_over_cap_appends_count_and_field_name() {
        let items: Vec<String> = (0..23).map(|i| format!("id{i}")).collect();
        let rendered = format_inline_list_overflow(&items, "referrers");
        assert_eq!(rendered, "id0, id1, id2 +20 more — see details.referrers");
    }

    #[test]
    fn list_six_items_truncates_to_three_plus_three() {
        let items: Vec<String> = (0..6).map(|i| format!("t{i}")).collect();
        let rendered = format_inline_list_overflow(&items, "missing");
        assert_eq!(rendered, "t0, t1, t2 +3 more — see details.missing");
    }

    #[test]
    fn has_incoming_refs_display_inlines_first_three_referrer_ids() {
        let referrers: Vec<ReferrerInfo> = (0..23)
            .map(|i| ReferrerInfo {
                from_id: format!("specs--ref{i}"),
                rel_types: vec!["USES".to_string()],
                mem: "specs".to_string(),
            })
            .collect();
        let err = EngineError::HasIncomingRefs {
            id: "specs--hub".to_string(),
            referrers,
        };
        let s = err.to_string();
        // First three ids appear inline; the rest are summarised plus a
        // pointer to `details.referrers` on the structured channel.
        assert!(
            s.contains("specs--ref0, specs--ref1, specs--ref2"),
            "got: {s}"
        );
        assert!(s.contains("+20 more — see details.referrers"), "got: {s}");
        // Pre-fix the message only carried the count; check the count
        // still appears so callers parsing it for "N references" keep
        // working.
        assert!(s.contains("23 incoming reference"), "got: {s}");
    }

    #[test]
    fn wiki_link_without_relation_display_lists_all_when_under_cap() {
        let missing = vec![
            MissingWikiLink {
                section_key: "specifies".to_string(),
                target_id: "specs--a".to_string(),
            },
            MissingWikiLink {
                section_key: "specifies".to_string(),
                target_id: "specs--b".to_string(),
            },
            MissingWikiLink {
                section_key: "rationale".to_string(),
                target_id: "specs--c".to_string(),
            },
        ];
        let err = EngineError::WikiLinkWithoutRelation {
            from_id: "specs--src".to_string(),
            missing,
        };
        let s = err.to_string();
        assert!(s.contains("specifies→specs--a"), "got: {s}");
        assert!(s.contains("specifies→specs--b"), "got: {s}");
        assert!(s.contains("rationale→specs--c"), "got: {s}");
        assert!(!s.contains("more — see details"), "got: {s}");
    }

    #[test]
    fn wiki_link_without_relation_display_truncates_at_cap_with_pointer() {
        let missing: Vec<MissingWikiLink> = (0..6)
            .map(|i| MissingWikiLink {
                section_key: format!("s{i}"),
                target_id: format!("specs--t{i}"),
            })
            .collect();
        let err = EngineError::WikiLinkWithoutRelation {
            from_id: "specs--src".to_string(),
            missing,
        };
        let s = err.to_string();
        assert!(
            s.contains("s0→specs--t0, s1→specs--t1, s2→specs--t2"),
            "got: {s}"
        );
        assert!(s.contains("+3 more — see details.missing"), "got: {s}");
    }

    #[test]
    fn relation_has_body_links_display_inlines_section_keys() {
        let err = EngineError::RelationHasBodyLinks {
            from_id: "specs--src".to_string(),
            to_id: "specs--dst".to_string(),
            rel_type: "USES".to_string(),
            body_links: vec!["specifies".to_string(), "rationale".to_string()],
        };
        let s = err.to_string();
        assert!(s.contains("specifies, rationale"), "got: {s}");
        assert!(!s.contains("more — see details"), "got: {s}");
    }

    // --- prose_render -----------------------------------------------
    // The text
    // channel inlines full recovery payloads (no `+N more — see
    // details.X` pointer). Display stays terse for logs; prose_render
    // is the rich method MCP / CLI surfaces call for `content[0].text`.

    #[test]
    fn prose_render_has_incoming_refs_inlines_every_referrer() {
        let referrers = (0..7)
            .map(|i| ReferrerInfo {
                from_id: format!("specs--r{i}"),
                rel_types: vec!["DEPENDS_ON".to_string()],
                mem: "specs".to_string(),
            })
            .collect();
        let err = EngineError::HasIncomingRefs {
            id: "specs--target".to_string(),
            referrers,
        };
        let prose = err.prose_render();
        for i in 0..7 {
            assert!(
                prose.contains(&format!("specs--r{i}")),
                "every referrer must appear inline; missing r{i} in: {prose}"
            );
        }
        assert!(!prose.contains("see details"), "got: {prose}");
        // Display stays terse with the overflow suffix.
        let display = err.to_string();
        assert!(
            display.contains("+4 more — see details.referrers"),
            "got: {display}"
        );
    }

    #[test]
    fn prose_render_required_field_unset_inlines_field_description_and_rules() {
        // Update-path semantic: `on_create: false` → "cannot unset".
        let err = EngineError::RequiredFieldUnset {
            field: "verified_on".to_string(),
            entity_type: "requirement".to_string(),
            field_description: Some("ISO-8601 date the requirement was last validated".to_string()),
            enum_values: vec![],
            type_write_rules: vec!["bump verified_on on every status change".to_string()],
            on_create: false,
            missing: Vec::new(),
        };
        let prose = err.prose_render();
        assert!(
            prose.contains("ISO-8601 date"),
            "field_description missing: {prose}"
        );
        assert!(
            prose.contains("bump verified_on"),
            "type_write_rules missing: {prose}"
        );
        assert!(!prose.contains("see details"), "got: {prose}");
        assert!(
            prose.contains("cannot unset"),
            "update-path wording must say 'cannot unset': {prose}"
        );
    }

    /// Create
    /// path renders "not provided" instead of "cannot unset" — the
    /// pre-fix wording was misleading on a path where nothing was
    /// ever set in the first place.
    #[test]
    fn prose_render_required_field_unset_create_path_uses_not_provided_wording() {
        let err = EngineError::RequiredFieldUnset {
            field: "verified_on".to_string(),
            entity_type: "requirement".to_string(),
            field_description: Some("ISO-8601 date the requirement was last validated".to_string()),
            enum_values: vec![],
            type_write_rules: vec![],
            on_create: true,
            missing: Vec::new(),
        };
        let prose = err.prose_render();
        assert!(
            prose.contains("not provided"),
            "create-path wording must say 'not provided': {prose}"
        );
        assert!(
            !prose.contains("cannot unset"),
            "create-path wording must NOT say 'cannot unset': {prose}"
        );
        // Same Display dispatch — `to_string()` mirrors `prose_render`'s
        // create-path lead.
        let display = err.to_string();
        assert!(
            display.contains("not provided"),
            "Display must match: {display}"
        );
        assert!(
            !display.contains("cannot unset"),
            "Display must match: {display}"
        );
    }

    /// The
    /// create-path multi-field accumulator surfaces every required-
    /// no-default field unset in `details.missing[]`. Each entry
    /// carries `{field, description, enum_values, write_rules}` so
    /// the agent fixes the whole set in one retry. The singular
    /// `details.field` echoes `missing[0].field` for back-compat.
    #[test]
    fn details_required_field_unset_multi_field_envelope_shape() {
        use crate::runtime_validator::MissingRequiredField;
        let err = EngineError::RequiredFieldUnset {
            field: "decided_on".to_string(),
            entity_type: "decision".to_string(),
            field_description: Some("Date the decision was accepted. ISO YYYY-MM-DD.".to_string()),
            enum_values: vec![],
            type_write_rules: vec!["status transitions: proposed → accepted".to_string()],
            on_create: true,
            missing: vec![
                MissingRequiredField {
                    entity_type: "decision".to_string(),
                    key: "decided_on".to_string(),
                    description: "Date the decision was accepted. ISO YYYY-MM-DD.".to_string(),
                    enum_values: vec![],
                },
                MissingRequiredField {
                    entity_type: "decision".to_string(),
                    key: "deciders".to_string(),
                    description: "Who made the call. Comma-separated handles.".to_string(),
                    enum_values: vec![],
                },
            ],
        };
        let details = err.details();
        // Back-compat: singular `field` echoes the first-missing entry.
        assert_eq!(details["field"].as_str(), Some("decided_on"));
        // Multi-field accumulator surfaces every entry in
        // declaration order.
        let missing = details["missing"].as_array().expect("missing[] array");
        assert_eq!(missing.len(), 2);
        assert_eq!(missing[0]["field"].as_str(), Some("decided_on"));
        assert_eq!(missing[1]["field"].as_str(), Some("deciders"));
        // First entry's `field` agrees with the singular shape.
        assert_eq!(details["field"], missing[0]["field"]);
        // Per-entry `write_rules` echoes the type-level rules for
        // self-containment.
        assert_eq!(missing[0]["write_rules"], details["type_write_rules"]);
        // Prose mentions both field names so the agent reading the
        // text channel sees the whole set without crossing into the
        // structured channel.
        let prose = err.prose_render();
        assert!(prose.contains("decided_on"), "got: {prose}");
        assert!(prose.contains("deciders"), "got: {prose}");
    }

    /// The unset path's singular shape is
    /// preserved — `missing[]` is empty (the user targeted one field
    /// by definition); the singular fields above are authoritative.
    /// The typed code stays `REQUIRED_FIELD_UNSET`.
    #[test]
    fn details_required_field_unset_singular_shape_for_unset_path() {
        let err = EngineError::RequiredFieldUnset {
            field: "decided_on".to_string(),
            entity_type: "decision".to_string(),
            field_description: Some("…".to_string()),
            enum_values: vec![],
            type_write_rules: vec![],
            on_create: false,
            missing: Vec::new(),
        };
        let details = err.details();
        assert_eq!(details["field"].as_str(), Some("decided_on"));
        let missing = details["missing"]
            .as_array()
            .expect("missing[] array present");
        assert!(missing.is_empty(), "unset-path missing[] must be empty");
        assert_eq!(err.code(), "REQUIRED_FIELD_UNSET");
    }

    #[test]
    fn prose_render_missing_required_section_enumerates_each_section_with_write_rules() {
        use crate::runtime_validator::MissingRequiredSection;
        let sections = vec![
            MissingRequiredSection {
                entity_type: "spec".to_string(),
                key: "purpose".to_string(),
                heading: "Purpose".to_string(),
                write_rules: vec!["one-sentence statement of intent".to_string()],
            },
            MissingRequiredSection {
                entity_type: "spec".to_string(),
                key: "scope".to_string(),
                heading: "Scope".to_string(),
                write_rules: vec!["what is in and out of scope".to_string()],
            },
        ];
        let mut type_guidance: std::collections::BTreeMap<String, Vec<String>> = Default::default();
        type_guidance.insert(
            "spec".to_string(),
            vec!["specs are immutable once stable".to_string()],
        );
        let err = EngineError::MissingRequiredSection {
            entity_type: "spec".to_string(),
            missing_count: 2,
            sections,
            type_guidance,
            pre_announced_missing_fields: Vec::new(),
        };
        let prose = err.prose_render();
        assert!(prose.contains("purpose"), "got: {prose}");
        assert!(prose.contains("scope"), "got: {prose}");
        assert!(
            prose.contains("one-sentence statement of intent"),
            "got: {prose}"
        );
        assert!(
            prose.contains("specs are immutable once stable"),
            "got: {prose}"
        );
        assert!(!prose.contains("see details"), "got: {prose}");
    }

    #[test]
    fn prose_render_relationship_cycle_inlines_existing_path() {
        use crate::entity::EntityId;
        let path = vec![
            EntityId::canonical("specs--a"),
            EntityId::canonical("specs--b"),
            EntityId::canonical("specs--c"),
            EntityId::canonical("specs--a"),
        ];
        let err = EngineError::RelationshipCycle {
            rel_type: "PART_OF".to_string(),
            from: EntityId::canonical("specs--a"),
            to: EntityId::canonical("specs--c"),
            existing_path: path,
            path_truncated: false,
            acyclic_set: None,
            existing_path_rel_types: None,
        };
        let prose = err.prose_render();
        assert!(
            prose.contains("specs--a → specs--b → specs--c → specs--a"),
            "got: {prose}"
        );
        assert!(!prose.contains("see details"), "got: {prose}");
    }

    #[test]
    fn prose_render_falls_back_to_display_for_trivial_variants() {
        // ReadOnlyMount has no list payload — Display already inlines
        // the recovery context.
        let err = EngineError::ReadOnlyMount("archive-2024".to_string());
        assert_eq!(err.prose_render(), err.to_string());
    }

    /// A slug collision names the occupying title on both channels —
    /// two distinct titles can derive one id, and the id alone does
    /// not tell the caller which one is already there.
    #[test]
    fn already_exists_names_the_occupying_title_on_both_channels() {
        let err = EngineError::AlreadyExists {
            id: "muehle--bösenberg-grundstücks-gmbh-co-kg".to_string(),
            existing_title: "Bösenberg Grundstücks GmbH Co KG".to_string(),
            existing_is_stub: false,
        };
        assert!(
            err.to_string()
                .contains("occupied by 'Bösenberg Grundstücks GmbH Co KG'"),
            "got: {err}"
        );
        let details = err.details();
        assert_eq!(
            details["existing_title"],
            "Bösenberg Grundstücks GmbH Co KG"
        );
        assert_eq!(details["existing_is_stub"], false);
        assert_eq!(details["id"], "muehle--bösenberg-grundstücks-gmbh-co-kg");
    }

    /// A stub occupant states it is a stub; a titleless stub must not
    /// render as an empty or missing title.
    #[test]
    fn already_exists_stub_occupant_never_renders_an_empty_title() {
        let titled = EngineError::AlreadyExists {
            id: "specs--x".to_string(),
            existing_title: "X".to_string(),
            existing_is_stub: true,
        };
        assert!(
            titled.to_string().contains("a stub titled 'X'"),
            "got: {titled}"
        );

        let untitled = EngineError::AlreadyExists {
            id: "specs--x".to_string(),
            existing_title: String::new(),
            existing_is_stub: true,
        };
        let msg = untitled.to_string();
        assert!(msg.contains("occupied by a stub"), "got: {msg}");
        assert!(!msg.contains("''"), "empty title must not render: {msg}");
    }
}