magi/

graph.rs

//! The competition graph.
//!
//! ```text
//! prep ──► implement ×N ──► judge ×M (blind) ──► split? ──► deliberate ──► vote (private)
//!                                                   │                          │
//!                                                   └──── unanimous ───────────┤
//!                                                                              ▼
//!   merge ◄── gate ◄── review ×R + E2E, fix, repeat ◄── fold losers ◄──────── tally
//! ```
//!
//! Every node persists before the next one starts, so a run can be resumed
//! after a crash, a rate limit, or a reboot without re-spending the work that
//! already landed.
//!
//! The design decision that matters most is *where the facilitator lives*.
//! There is no moderator agent: magi assigns the labels, decides the
//! presentation order, relays the transcript, and collects the final votes
//! one-to-one. A moderator that never learns an author cannot leak one.
use std::collections::{BTreeMap, BTreeSet};
use std::path::{Path, PathBuf};
use std::sync::atomic::{AtomicBool, Ordering};
use std::sync::{Arc, Mutex};
use std::time::{Duration, Instant};

use anyhow::{Context as _, Result, bail};
use jiff::Timestamp;
use tokio::sync::Semaphore;

use crate::advise;
use crate::agent::{self, AgentOutput, Invocation, SeatState};
use crate::ask;
use crate::blind;
use crate::bump;
use crate::config::{
    AgentSpec, Config, IncompleteReviewPolicy, LeakPolicy, MergeMode, MergeStyle, Prompts,
    ResolvedRoles,
};
use crate::fixer;
use crate::git;
use crate::land;
use crate::proc::Quiet as _;
use crate::prompt::{
    self, CandidateView, Lens, ReviewPatch, ReviewReconsiderCtx, ReviewSeatReport, Turn,
};
use crate::queue;
use crate::refs;
use crate::run::{
    BaseSync, Candidate, CommandOutcome, ContinuationOutcome, ContinuationRecord,
    DeliberationRound, DeliberationTurn, E2eStatus, FailClass, FixRecord, GateFixRecord, Handover,
    JobRecord, JobStatus, Judgement, MergeOutcome, OperatorFixFinding, OperatorFixOutcome,
    OperatorFixRequest, Origin, QuotaLoss, ReviewRecord, ReviewRevoteRecord, ReviewRound, RunState,
    RunStatus, SeatHistory, Tally, VoteRecord, tail, write_artifact,
};
use crate::verdict::{
    self, FinalVote, Finding, FixReport, Position, Proposal, Ranking, Review, ReviewRevote,
    ReviewVote, Severity,
};

/// How much verification output is kept and fed back to the fixer.
const OUTPUT_TAIL: usize = 8_000;

/// Bytes of a failing command's output kept in an event, so the reason a run
/// stopped is readable from the report without opening `run.json`.
const EVENT_OUTPUT_TAIL: usize = 2_000;

/// How often [`wait_for_timed_out_children_to_die`] re-checks a timed-out
/// command's pid before releasing the build cache's lease.
const LEASE_RELEASE_POLL: Duration = Duration::from_secs(1);

/// The most [`wait_for_timed_out_children_to_die`] will wait for a timed-out
/// command's pid to actually exit before giving up and releasing anyway.
///
/// A timeout means the process was asked to die (`kill_on_drop`,
/// `start_kill`), not that it already has — on Windows in particular that can
/// take a moment, the same reason `agent`'s own `PIPE_GRACE` exists. Releasing
/// the instant the command returns would let the very next acquirer (this
/// run's own next round, another run's verification, the janitor's prune)
/// start touching the same directory while it might still be writing to it,
/// so this polls the actual pid — real confirmation, not a fixed guess —
/// until it is gone or this ceiling is reached. It is still not full
/// process-tree reaping: a grandchild the timed-out process spawned and that
/// outlives it independently is invisible to a pid check, and continuing to
/// observe and collect *that* stays a different piece of work with its own
/// owner. Set generously because the common case returns early the moment
/// the pid is confirmed gone, not because every timeout pays this in full.
const LEASE_RELEASE_MAX_WAIT: Duration = Duration::from_secs(30);

/// Consecutive review rounds with no tree progress (see
/// [`crate::run::ReviewRound::progressed`]) before `review_loop` hands off
/// instead of spending the rest of the round budget.
///
/// Not 1: a single non-progressing round is not yet a pattern — a fixer that
/// legitimately finds nothing left to change (its previous round's fix already
/// covered it, and this round's reviewers re-raised only nits) looks the same
/// as one that is spinning, for exactly one round. Two in a row is where the
/// two stop being distinguishable, and a review round on this workload has
/// been measured at 30-45 minutes of reviewer-plus-fixer agent time, so a
/// third attempt at a tree that has not moved twice running is pure cost.
/// This does not touch `review_rounds` itself, which stays the operator's
/// call.
pub(crate) const STAGNANT_LIMIT: usize = 2;

/// How many times [`Runner::sync_to_base`] will re-land the winner's tree on
/// a base that moved before giving up and leaving the run `Blocked` for a
/// person.
///
/// Mirrors `land::Step::Rebase`'s budget and the reasoning behind it: a base
/// that keeps moving faster than a run can catch it is not something more
/// rebasing fixes, it is a person's call. Not the same *number as*
/// `land_rounds` - this budget is spent before a pull request exists, land's
/// after - but bounded for the identical reason, so it uses the same
/// default. Counted across both call sites in [`Runner::finish_after_tally`]
/// (once before review, once before the gate), because either one finding
/// the base still moving is the same signal.
const BASE_SYNC_ROUNDS: usize = 4;

/// How many times [`Runner::continue_fix_report`] will resume the fixer's own
/// seat when its CLI turn ended cleanly — usable, non-empty, exit 0 — but the
/// reply held no [`FixReport`].
///
/// The shape this recovers: run 20260912-114326-d3b8's fix-2 came back
/// `subtype=success`/`is_error=false`/`stop_reason=end_turn` with the reply
/// "I'll pause here until the `cargo make check` background run reports
/// back." — a CLI turn that ended cleanly while the fixer's own job had not.
/// No `FixReport` was ever collected from that seat, and the run moved on to
/// the next review round regardless.
///
/// Bounded independently of `review_rounds` and `graph.retries`: this
/// recovers one seat's missing report mid-round, not a new round of review or
/// an ordinary parse retry, and must not itself become the unbounded wait the
/// rest of this module exists to avoid.
const MAX_FIX_CONTINUATIONS: usize = 2;

/// One queued agent invocation.
///
/// `Clone` so a node can keep the jobs it sent and re-send one: a seat whose
/// CLI hung up on its own stream is asked again from the same job rather than
/// rebuilt from scratch. See [`Runner::resume_undelivered`].
#[derive(Clone)]
struct SeatJob {
    spec: AgentSpec,
    seat: SeatState,
    cwd: PathBuf,
    prompt: String,
    timeout: Duration,
    allow_write: bool,
    sessions: bool,
    artifacts: PathBuf,
    stem: String,
    /// The prompt for a seat that has been handed to another roster agent
    /// (a fresh session): everything the original seat would have
    /// remembered. `None` when `prompt` already carries it, as the first
    /// ranking and the implement prompt do. Never a resume-style prompt.
    handover: Option<String>,
}

/// How the graph reads one agent invocation.
///
/// Quota is split out from an ordinary failure on purpose: a rate-limited call
/// is known to fail again if retried now, so the retry loop must not spend an
/// attempt on it. `Dropped` is split out for the opposite reason: unlike
/// `Failed`, it is worth re-asking, and unlike `Ok`, its text is the CLI's raw
/// error JSON, never the agent's answer — a caller that matched only
/// `Ok`/`Quota`/`Failed` before `Dropped` existed must be updated rather than
/// left to read that JSON as if it were usable output. `resume_undelivered`
/// is the only caller that acts on it; everywhere else it is reported like an
/// ordinary failure.
enum AgentOutcome {
    /// A usable output.
    Ok(AgentOutput),
    /// The CLI ran out of quota / rate limit. Retrying now is pointless.
    Quota(AgentOutput),
    /// The CLI hung up on its own stream after billed work. See
    /// [`agent::AgentOutput::work_undelivered`].
    Dropped(AgentOutput),
    /// Any other failure: a timeout, a bad exit code, an empty reply.
    Failed(String),
}

/// A request to park the run at its next node boundary.
///
/// Cloning is how the request travels: the loop keeps one handle and hands a
/// clone to each [`Runner`], and every clone points at the same flag. There
/// is no channel because there is nothing to send - the only message is
/// "park", it is idempotent, and a flag cannot be missed by a receiver that
/// was not listening yet.
///
/// The boundary is what makes this cheap. Every node writes the run's state
/// before the next one starts, and every node skips what is already recorded:
/// `prep` returns early once candidates exist, `implement` asks only the seats
/// with nothing on disk, `judge` returns early once judgements exist. So a
/// parked run resumes into exactly the node it stopped before, and no agent
/// work is thrown away. Killing the process mid-node, by contrast, loses
/// whatever the seats in flight had not yet written - which for an implement
/// wave is an hour of paid work.
///
/// A [`Runner`] watches two independent handles of this type - see
/// [`Runner::on_pause`] and [`Runner::watch_interrupt`] - never one shared
/// between them. `magi serve`'s own shutdown (`Stop::park`) hands out one
/// clone covering the whole daemon's lifetime and is never asked to un-park,
/// which is correct exactly because nothing is dispatched after it fires.
/// `magi serve`'s interrupt scheduler needs the opposite lifetime - a run
/// that parks for an interrupted task must go on to run other tasks
/// afterward - so it mints a fresh, unshared [`Pause`] per run instead of
/// reusing the daemon-wide one.
#[derive(Debug, Clone, Default)]
pub struct Pause(Arc<AtomicBool>, Arc<Mutex<Option<String>>>);

impl Pause {
    /// A pause nobody has asked for yet.
    #[must_use]
    pub fn new() -> Self {
        Self::default()
    }

    /// Ask the run to park at its next node boundary. Idempotent.
    pub fn park(&self) {
        self.0.store(true, Ordering::SeqCst);
    }

    /// Same as [`Pause::park`], but records why, for [`Runner::park_here`] to
    /// fold into the run's own `park` event - so an operator reading the run
    /// later knows this was a deliberate interrupt rather than a shutdown or
    /// a binary swap. The first reason recorded wins; a park already in
    /// flight is not relabelled by a second, unrelated request.
    pub fn park_because(&self, reason: impl Into<String>) {
        let mut reason_guard = self
            .1
            .lock()
            .unwrap_or_else(std::sync::PoisonError::into_inner);
        if reason_guard.is_none() {
            *reason_guard = Some(reason.into());
        }
        drop(reason_guard);
        self.park();
    }

    /// Has a park been asked for?
    #[must_use]
    pub fn parked(&self) -> bool {
        self.0.load(Ordering::SeqCst)
    }

    /// Why the park was asked for, when the caller used [`Pause::park_because`].
    #[must_use]
    pub fn reason(&self) -> Option<String> {
        self.1
            .lock()
            .unwrap_or_else(std::sync::PoisonError::into_inner)
            .clone()
    }
}

/// Drives one run.
pub struct Runner {
    /// Run state; public so the CLI can report on it.
    pub state: RunState,
    roles: ResolvedRoles,
    sem: Arc<Semaphore>,
    /// Set when the daemon's own shutdown (Ctrl-C, a binary swap) wants the
    /// run parked at its next node boundary. See [`Pause`]'s own doc for why
    /// this is never the same handle as `interrupt`.
    pause: Pause,
    /// Set when `magi serve`'s interrupt scheduler wants this specific run
    /// parked at its next node boundary, to let a task marked
    /// [`crate::queue::Task::interrupt`] run alone before this one carries
    /// on. Unlike `pause`, a fresh, unshared handle per run - see
    /// [`Runner::watch_interrupt`].
    interrupt: Pause,
}

/// Where the branch's own commits start: its merge base with the base branch
/// as the remote has it now, else with the recorded `base_commit`. A branch
/// rebased onto a base that moved past `base_commit` would otherwise count
/// the base's commits as its own under `base_commit..branch`.
async fn review_base(
    repo: &Path,
    remote: &str,
    base_branch: &str,
    base_commit: &str,
    branch: &str,
) -> String {
    review_base_checked(repo, remote, base_branch, base_commit, branch)
        .await
        .0
}

/// [`review_base`] plus whether the base was read from a freshly fetched
/// tracking ref. A failed fetch still uses whatever tracking ref exists (it is
/// never older than `base_commit`'s view of the base), but the answer is then
/// not trusted to rewrite a pull request's title.
async fn review_base_checked(
    repo: &Path,
    remote: &str,
    base_branch: &str,
    base_commit: &str,
    branch: &str,
) -> (String, bool) {
    let tracking = format!("{remote}/{base_branch}");
    let fresh = matches!(git::fetch(repo, remote, base_branch).await, Ok(o) if o.ok());
    if git::rev_exists(repo, &tracking).await
        && let Ok(mb) = git::merge_base(repo, &tracking, branch).await
        && !mb.is_empty()
    {
        return (mb, fresh);
    }
    let mb = git::merge_base(repo, base_commit, branch)
        .await
        .ok()
        .filter(|mb| !mb.is_empty())
        .unwrap_or_else(|| base_commit.to_owned());
    (mb, false)
}

/// Recompute `reviewed_commits` from the branch's own commits. Left as it was
/// when git cannot say or finds nothing: a stale list is better than a wrong
/// or empty one.
pub(crate) async fn refresh_reviewed_commits(state: &mut RunState, branch: &str) {
    if !is_review_run(state) {
        return;
    }
    let base = review_base(
        &state.repo,
        &state.config.merge.remote,
        &state.base_branch,
        &state.base_commit,
        branch,
    )
    .await;
    if let Ok(subjects) = git::subjects(&state.repo, &base, branch).await
        && !subjects.is_empty()
        && state.reviewed_commits.as_ref() != Some(&subjects)
    {
        state.reviewed_commits = Some(subjects);
        state.save().ok();
    }
}

/// Subjects of the base's commits between the recorded start and the branch's
/// merge base: what a stale `base_commit..branch` would have mistaken for the
/// branch's own work.
async fn leaked_subjects(state: &RunState, branch: &str) -> Option<Vec<String>> {
    let (base, trusted) = review_base_checked(
        &state.repo,
        &state.config.merge.remote,
        &state.base_branch,
        &state.base_commit,
        branch,
    )
    .await;
    if !trusted {
        return None;
    }
    git::subjects(&state.repo, &state.base_commit, &base)
        .await
        .ok()
}

/// May an adopted pull request's title be replaced with `computed`? Only when
/// it is empty, magi's own shape, or a base commit's subject that leaked in;
/// a title a person wrote stays. Never when `computed` is itself a leak.
fn should_retitle(current: &str, computed: &str, leaked: &[String]) -> bool {
    let is_leak = |t: &str| leaked.iter().any(|l| l.trim() == t.trim());
    if is_leak(computed) {
        return false;
    }
    let cur = current.trim();
    cur.is_empty()
        || cur.starts_with(REVIEW_PROMPT_OPENING)
        || cur.starts_with("chore: land candidate")
        || cur.starts_with("magi: candidate")
        || is_leak(cur)
}

/// The commit a run branches from: the base branch as the remote has it.
///
/// Two failures this replaces. A run used to branch off `HEAD` and so refused
/// to start on a dirty tree, which made `magi serve` decline every task for as
/// long as the operator had work in progress - most of the time. Branching off
/// the *local* base branch fixed that and introduced a worse one: `land` merges
/// the winner on GitHub, nothing updates the local ref, and the next run
/// branches off a base missing everything the previous runs landed. Two tasks
/// in a row from a phone would have had the second silently re-implementing
/// against stale code and opening a pull request that reverted the first.
///
/// Only refs move here - no checkout, no local branch, no merge - so it is safe
/// with uncommitted work in the tree. A machine with no network still starts:
/// the fetch may fail and the local tip is used with a warning, because
/// refusing to run offline is a worse failure than running against a base the
/// operator can see for themselves.
///
/// One function, called by both entry points. Two answers to "where does a run
/// branch from" is the kind of drift nobody notices until a diff is wrong.
/// Bring the local `branch` in line with `<remote>/<branch>` before a review
/// checks it out.
///
/// `git worktree add <branch>` resolves the *local* ref, and a branch pushed by
/// anything other than plain `git push` from this checkout (a jj colocated
/// workspace, another clone) moves only the remote-tracking ref - so the local
/// one can be a stale placeholder. It moves only when local is behind the remote or is an
/// empty placeholder that diverged from it; unpushed local work is kept, and a real
/// divergence is refused rather than guessed at.
async fn sync_review_branch(repo: &Path, branch: &str, remote: &str, base: &str) -> Result<()> {
    let tracking = format!("{remote}/{branch}");
    let fetched = git::fetch(repo, remote, branch).await;
    let fresh = matches!(&fetched, Ok(o) if o.ok()) && git::rev_exists(repo, &tracking).await;
    let local_exists = git::branch_exists(repo, branch).await?;
    if !fresh {
        if !local_exists {
            bail!("no branch `{branch}` in {} or on {remote}", repo.display());
        }
        tracing::warn!(
            "could not read {tracking}; reviewing the local `{branch}`, which may be stale"
        );
        return Ok(());
    }
    let remote_sha = git::rev_parse(repo, &tracking).await?;
    if !local_exists {
        git::git(repo, &["branch", branch, &tracking]).await?;
        return Ok(());
    }
    let local_sha = git::rev_parse(repo, &format!("refs/heads/{branch}")).await?;
    if local_sha == remote_sha || git::is_ancestor(repo, &remote_sha, &local_sha).await {
        return Ok(());
    }
    if !git::is_ancestor(repo, &local_sha, &remote_sha).await {
        // Diverged. `reconcile` settles it only when it can prove nothing is
        // lost: a local tip that is the remote's change rebased is pushed over
        // it (lease pinned to the tip read here), a tip whose every extra
        // commit is empty is a placeholder the remote's work replaced, and
        // anything else is two different changes - a question for a person.
        match crate::reconcile::reconcile(repo, remote, branch, &local_sha, &remote_sha, base)
            .await?
        {
            crate::reconcile::Reconciliation::Pushed => {
                tracing::warn!(
                    "local `{branch}` ({}) is {tracking} ({}) rebased; pushed it over",
                    short(&local_sha),
                    short(&remote_sha)
                );
                return Ok(());
            }
            crate::reconcile::Reconciliation::Placeholder => {}
            crate::reconcile::Reconciliation::Genuine(d) => return Err((*d).into()),
        }
    }
    let out = git::git_raw(repo, &["branch", "-f", branch, &tracking]).await?;
    if !out.ok() {
        bail!(
            "local `{branch}` ({}) is stale against {tracking} ({}) but git will not move it: {}",
            short(&local_sha),
            short(&remote_sha),
            out.stderr
        );
    }
    tracing::warn!(
        "local `{branch}` was stale: fast-forwarded {} -> {}",
        short(&local_sha),
        short(&remote_sha)
    );
    Ok(())
}

async fn resolve_base(repo: &Path, base_branch: &str, remote: &str) -> Result<String> {
    let tracking = format!("{remote}/{base_branch}");
    let fetched = git::fetch(repo, remote, base_branch).await;
    if let Ok(out) = &fetched
        && out.ok()
        && git::rev_exists(repo, &tracking).await
    {
        return git::rev_parse(repo, &tracking).await;
    }
    let why = match &fetched {
        Ok(out) if !out.ok() => out.stderr.lines().next().unwrap_or("").to_owned(),
        Ok(_) => format!("{remote} has no {base_branch}"),
        Err(e) => e.to_string(),
    };
    // No fallback to the local branch: it may be behind, and branching off an
    // old commit is the stale-checkout bug this check exists to prevent.
    bail!(
        "cannot read {tracking} ({why}); refusing to branch off the local \
         `{base_branch}`, which may be behind. Fix the remote, or set [merge] \
         base / remote in magi.toml"
    )
}

/// Exclusive claim on one run's `magi fix` step, released on drop — including
/// on an early return or a panic.
///
/// `daemon::is_working_on` only sees a heartbeat-publishing daemon; two
/// manual `magi fix` invocations against the same run are otherwise
/// invisible to each other and would race to remove and recreate the same
/// worktree (see [`Runner::fix_selected`]). The lock file itself is the same
/// `create_new` shape as `queue::Claim`, but unlike a queued task's lock —
/// which is only ever reclaimed later, out of band, by
/// `daemon::sweep_stale_claims` running inside `magi serve`/`magi web` — a
/// `magi fix` invocation is not necessarily running under either of those, so
/// nothing would ever sweep a lock a killed or crashed process left behind.
/// [`Self::acquire`] therefore reclaims a stale lock itself, on the same
/// conservative PID-liveness policy `sweep_stale_claims` and `cache`'s own
/// lease use: an unreadable or unparsable pid, or a liveness query the
/// platform cannot answer, reads as alive and the lock is left in place.
struct FixClaim {
    path: PathBuf,
}

impl FixClaim {
    fn acquire(dir: &Path) -> Result<Self> {
        std::fs::create_dir_all(dir).with_context(|| format!("create {}", dir.display()))?;
        let path = dir.join("fix.lock");
        match Self::create(&path) {
            Ok(claim) => Ok(claim),
            Err(e) if e.kind() == std::io::ErrorKind::AlreadyExists => {
                if Self::reclaim_if_dead(&path) {
                    Self::create(&path).with_context(|| format!("lock {}", path.display()))
                } else {
                    bail!(
                        "another `magi fix` is already running for this run ({} exists)",
                        path.display()
                    )
                }
            }
            Err(e) => Err(e).with_context(|| format!("lock {}", path.display())),
        }
    }

    fn create(path: &Path) -> std::io::Result<Self> {
        let mut f = std::fs::OpenOptions::new()
            .write(true)
            .create_new(true)
            .open(path)?;
        use std::io::Write as _;
        // Read back by `reclaim_if_dead` on a later, stuck invocation.
        writeln!(f, "{}", std::process::id())?;
        Ok(Self {
            path: path.to_owned(),
        })
    }

    /// True if the lock named a process confirmed dead, in which case it was
    /// also removed. Never true on an unreadable file, an unparsable pid, or
    /// a liveness query the platform cannot answer — see this type's own doc.
    fn reclaim_if_dead(path: &Path) -> bool {
        let dead = std::fs::read_to_string(path)
            .ok()
            .and_then(|body| body.trim().parse::<u32>().ok())
            .is_some_and(|pid| !crate::proc::pid_alive(pid));
        dead && std::fs::remove_file(path).is_ok()
    }
}

impl Drop for FixClaim {
    fn drop(&mut self) {
        let _ = std::fs::remove_file(&self.path);
    }
}

impl Runner {
    /// Start a fresh run against `repo`.
    pub async fn start(
        repo: &Path,
        instruction: String,
        config: Config,
        origin: Origin,
    ) -> Result<Self> {
        Self::start_naming(repo, instruction, "", config, origin).await
    }

    /// [`Runner::start`] for a queued task: `also_scan` (the task's title) is
    /// searched for branch and commit references along with the instruction,
    /// since a task may name the work it is about only in its title.
    pub async fn start_naming(
        repo: &Path,
        instruction: String,
        also_scan: &str,
        config: Config,
        origin: Origin,
    ) -> Result<Self> {
        let repo = git::toplevel(repo).await?;
        let missing = agent::missing_programs(&config.agents);
        if !missing.is_empty() {
            bail!(
                "these agent programs are not on PATH: {}. Fix the roster in \
                 magi.toml or install them.",
                missing.join(", ")
            );
        }
        let base_branch =
            git::merge_base_branch(&repo, &config.merge.remote, config.merge.base.as_deref())
                .await?;
        let base_commit = resolve_base(&repo, &base_branch, &config.merge.remote).await?;
        let roles = config.resolve_roles()?;
        let max_parallel = config.graph.max_parallel.max(1);
        // A task that points at work already in the repository starts from
        // it; what the repository says about each reference is recorded.
        let seeds = refs::resolve(
            &repo,
            &base_commit,
            &config.merge.remote,
            &format!("{also_scan}\n{instruction}"),
        )
        .await;
        refs::plan(&repo, &seeds).await?;
        let mut state = RunState::new(repo, base_branch, base_commit, instruction, config);
        // Recorded before the first save, so a crash right after minting
        // cannot leave a run with no origin. Legibility only: nothing reads it
        // to decide anything.
        state.origin = Some(origin);
        for seed in &seeds {
            state.event(
                "seed",
                refs::describe(std::slice::from_ref(seed)).unwrap_or_default(),
            );
        }
        state.seeds = seeds;
        state.event("start", format!("run {} created", state.id));
        state.save()?;
        Ok(Self {
            state,
            roles,
            sem: Arc::new(Semaphore::new(max_parallel)),
            pause: Pause::new(),
            interrupt: Pause::new(),
        })
    }

    /// Open a review-only run against work that already exists on `branch`.
    ///
    /// The expensive half of the graph is the implement wave — measured at
    /// 111 and 134 internal tool-loop turns on this repository, against a
    /// handful for a judge or a reviewer. The cheap half is worth running on
    /// hand-written work too, and there was no way to reach it.
    ///
    /// No new state and no schema change are needed: a run with **one** viable
    /// candidate and a tally already decided degrades `execute` to exactly
    /// review → gate → merge, because `judge` skips a single-candidate field,
    /// `deliberate` has fewer than two first choices to reconcile, `vote`
    /// returns early, `tally` is already present and `fold_losers` has no
    /// losers. Resuming such a run therefore does the right thing as well.
    pub async fn review(repo: &Path, branch: &str, config: Config, origin: Origin) -> Result<Self> {
        Self::review_taking_over(repo, branch, config, None, origin).await
    }

    /// [`Runner::review`] for a queued task's retry: when an earlier attempt
    /// at the same task still has `branch` checked out, its worktree is
    /// released first if that is safe (see [`crate::handover`]), and the
    /// review refuses with the reason if it is not. `None` is a hand-run
    /// review: it has no earlier attempts, so only a worktree of a dead run
    /// magi recorded itself can be released.
    pub async fn review_taking_over(
        repo: &Path,
        branch: &str,
        config: Config,
        takeover: Option<crate::handover::Takeover>,
        origin: Origin,
    ) -> Result<Self> {
        let repo = git::toplevel(repo).await?;
        let missing = agent::missing_programs(&config.agents);
        if !missing.is_empty() {
            bail!(
                "these agent programs are not on PATH: {}. Fix the roster in \
                 magi.toml or install them.",
                missing.join(", ")
            );
        }
        let base_branch =
            git::merge_base_branch(&repo, &config.merge.remote, config.merge.base.as_deref())
                .await?;
        if base_branch == branch {
            bail!("`{branch}` is the base branch; there is nothing to review against");
        }
        let base_commit = resolve_base(&repo, &base_branch, &config.merge.remote).await?;

        let roles = config.resolve_roles()?;
        let max_parallel = config.graph.max_parallel.max(1);
        let mut state = RunState::new(
            repo.clone(),
            base_branch,
            base_commit.clone(),
            String::new(),
            config,
        );
        state.origin = Some(origin);

        // Released before anything else touches the branch: a stale local
        // branch is moved with `git branch -f`, which git refuses while an
        // earlier attempt's worktree still has it checked out. Everything
        // after this point that can fail puts the old run back.
        // A hand-run review has no task, hence no earlier attempts, but a
        // worktree of a dead run magi made may still be released.
        let takeover = takeover.unwrap_or_else(|| crate::handover::Takeover {
            earlier: Vec::new(),
            home: crate::run::home(),
            choice: None,
        });
        let released = crate::handover::release(&repo, branch, &state.id, &takeover).await?;
        if let Some(released) = &released {
            state.event(
                "release",
                format!(
                    "took `{branch}` over from run {}: its worktree was released: {}",
                    crate::run::short_of(&released.old_id),
                    released.audit
                ),
            );
        }
        // The owner's answer to an earlier divergence question is applied
        // here: after the release (git will not move a checked-out branch)
        // and before the sync that would otherwise ask again.
        if let Some(choice) = takeover.choice.as_ref()
            && let Err(e) =
                crate::reconcile::apply_choice(&repo, &state.config.merge.remote, branch, choice)
                    .await
        {
            if let Some(released) = &released {
                released.restore(&repo, branch).await;
            }
            return Err(e.context("applying the owner's answer about the diverged branch"));
        }
        let opened =
            Self::open_review(&repo, branch, state, roles, max_parallel, base_commit).await;
        if opened.is_err()
            && let Some(released) = &released
        {
            released.restore(&repo, branch).await;
        }
        opened
    }

    /// The half of [`Runner::review_taking_over`] that can fail after an
    /// earlier attempt's worktree was released.
    async fn open_review(
        repo: &Path,
        branch: &str,
        mut state: RunState,
        roles: ResolvedRoles,
        max_parallel: usize,
        base_commit: String,
    ) -> Result<Self> {
        sync_review_branch(repo, branch, &state.config.merge.remote, &base_commit).await?;
        // The commit subjects are the closest thing to a task statement that
        // existing work carries, and the reviewers are told as much.
        let start = review_base(
            repo,
            &state.config.merge.remote,
            &state.base_branch,
            &base_commit,
            branch,
        )
        .await;
        let log = git::log_oneline(repo, &start, branch)
            .await
            .unwrap_or_default();
        let instruction = format!(
            "Review the work already on branch `{branch}`. There is no task \
             statement: what the change claims to do is whatever its commits \
             say.\n\n{}",
            if log.trim().is_empty() {
                "(no commit messages)"
            } else {
                log.trim()
            }
        );
        state.instruction = instruction;
        state.reviewed_commits = Some(
            git::subjects(repo, &start, branch)
                .await
                .unwrap_or_default(),
        );

        // An attached worktree, so the fixer's commits land on the branch under
        // review rather than on a detached head nobody will look at again.
        let worktree = state.worktree_root().join("under-review");
        if let Some(parent) = worktree.parent() {
            tokio::fs::create_dir_all(parent).await.ok();
        }
        let path = worktree.to_string_lossy().to_string();
        git::git(repo, &["worktree", "add", &path, branch])
            .await
            .with_context(|| {
                format!("checking out `{branch}` at {path} (is it checked out elsewhere?)")
            })?;

        let commits = git::commits_ahead(&worktree, &base_commit, "HEAD")
            .await
            .unwrap_or(0);
        if commits == 0 {
            git::worktree_remove(repo, &worktree).await.ok();
            bail!("`{branch}` has no commits beyond {}", short(&base_commit));
        }
        let files = git::changed_files(&worktree, &base_commit, "HEAD")
            .await
            .map(|f| f.len())
            .unwrap_or(0);
        if files == 0
            && let (Ok(head_tree), Ok(base_tree)) = (
                git::tree_of(&worktree, "HEAD").await,
                git::tree_of(&worktree, &base_commit).await,
            )
            && head_tree == base_tree
        {
            let head = git::rev_parse(&worktree, "HEAD").await.unwrap_or_default();
            git::worktree_remove(repo, &worktree).await.ok();
            bail!(
                "`{branch}` at {} has a tree identical to base {}; this usually means \
                 the branch ref is stale (check `git rev-parse refs/heads/{branch}` \
                 against `{}/{branch}`) rather than an empty change",
                short(&head),
                short(&base_commit),
                state.config.merge.remote
            );
        }
        let stat = git::diff_stat(&worktree, &base_commit, "HEAD")
            .await
            .unwrap_or_default();

        state.candidates.push(Candidate {
            index: 0,
            label: 'A',
            // Not an agent id on purpose: nothing in the roster wrote this, and
            // the stats tables must not credit anyone with a win for it.
            agent: EXISTING_BRANCH.to_owned(),
            branch: branch.to_owned(),
            worktree,
            summary: String::new(),
            stat,
            files,
            commits,
            empty: false,
            failed: None,
            verified_noop: None,
            duration_ms: 0,
            folded: false,
        });
        state.tally = Some(Tally {
            first_choice: BTreeMap::from([('A', 0)]),
            borda: BTreeMap::new(),
            winner: 'A',
            rankings: 0,
            unanimous_initial: false,
            deliberated: false,
            changed_votes: 0,
            unanimous_final: false,
            tie_break: None,
            // No panel sat, so no quorum applies. Zero judges is the correct
            // number for work that never competed, and must not be reported as
            // a collapsed panel.
            judges: 0,
            present: 0,
            quorum: 0,
            met_quorum: true,
            uncontested: Some("review-only run: nothing competed".to_owned()),
        });
        state.status = RunStatus::Reviewing;
        state.event(
            "start",
            format!(
                "review-only run {} on `{branch}` ({files} files, {commits} commits)",
                state.id
            ),
        );
        state.save()?;
        Ok(Self {
            state,
            roles,
            sem: Arc::new(Semaphore::new(max_parallel)),
            pause: Pause::new(),
            interrupt: Pause::new(),
        })
    }

    /// Reopen an existing run.
    pub fn resume(id: &str) -> Result<Self> {
        let state = RunState::load(id)?;
        if let Some(to) = &state.released_to {
            bail!(
                "run {} cannot be resumed: its worktree was released to run {}",
                state.short(),
                crate::run::short_of(to)
            );
        }
        let roles = state.config.resolve_roles()?;
        let max_parallel = state.config.graph.max_parallel.max(1);
        Ok(Self {
            state,
            roles,
            sem: Arc::new(Semaphore::new(max_parallel)),
            pause: Pause::new(),
            interrupt: Pause::new(),
        })
    }

    /// Walk the graph to a terminal state, skipping nodes already recorded.
    ///
    /// Every way a run is driven - the queue loop, `magi run`, a resume from
    /// the phone - ends here, so this is the one place a run that ended
    /// Blocked / Stalled / Failed, or died with an error, is announced to the
    /// notification centre. Best-effort: see [`crate::notices::raise`].
    pub async fn execute(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        let result = self.execute_graph().await;
        self.mark_driver_exited();
        let ended = if result.is_err() {
            Some(crate::notices::run_stopped(&self.state.id, &self.state))
        } else {
            crate::notices::run_ended(&self.state)
        };
        if let Some(notice) = ended {
            crate::notices::raise(notice);
        }
        result
    }

    /// Record that this process no longer drives the run, so its pid (a
    /// daemon's outlives the run) is not read as a live driver.
    ///
    /// Written onto the record as it is on disk, never this copy: another
    /// process may have resumed the run (recording its own pid and clearing
    /// the flag) or released its worktree since this copy was read, and
    /// saving over that would mark a running driver dead. Only a record still
    /// naming this process as the driver is touched.
    fn mark_driver_exited(&mut self) {
        self.state.driver_exited = true;
        let pid = std::process::id();
        let Ok(mut disk) = RunState::load(&self.state.id) else {
            return;
        };
        if disk.released_to.is_some() || disk.driver_pid != Some(pid) || disk.driver_exited {
            return;
        }
        disk.driver_exited = true;
        if let Err(e) = disk.save() {
            tracing::warn!("could not record that run {} stopped: {e:#}", self.state.id);
        }
    }

    async fn execute_graph(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        // Moving again, so it is no longer parked. Set before the walk rather
        // than in `resume`, so every way of re-entering the graph clears it
        // and a card cannot claim a run is waiting to be resumed while the
        // agents are already working.
        self.state.parked = false;
        // Any seat this state still lists as answering belongs to whatever
        // process last drove this run — this one included, if it crashed
        // mid-wave. Cleared and flushed immediately, before anything else
        // runs, so a resume can never show a seat as live when nothing is
        // asking it anything yet; the node that actually dispatches the next
        // wave repopulates it.
        self.state.clear_active();
        // Recorded in the same spot, and flushed together with the clear
        // above: this is the pid a reader checks (`RunState::liveness`) when
        // no daemon claim exists to answer "is a process still driving this
        // run" — a plain `magi run` / `magi review` typed into a terminal
        // claims nothing there. Always overwritten, never only-if-absent, so
        // a resumed run's stale pid from a previous, possibly-dead process
        // can never survive into this one's own report. Unlike
        // `clear_active`, this changes on every single `execute()` call, so
        // the save below is now unconditional rather than only-if-cleared.
        //
        // `driver_started_at` is recorded in the same breath, from this same
        // pid, so `liveness` can tell a live pid that is genuinely still us
        // apart from one the OS has since handed to an unrelated process —
        // see that field's own doc for why the pid alone is not enough.
        // A resume that raced a takeover: the record on disk says the worktree
        // was handed to a later run after this copy was read. Saving over it
        // would erase that and drive a run with nothing to run in.
        if let Ok(disk) = RunState::load(&self.state.id)
            && let Some(to) = &disk.released_to
        {
            bail!(
                "run {} cannot continue: its worktree was released to run {}",
                self.state.short(),
                crate::run::short_of(to)
            );
        }
        let pid = std::process::id();
        self.state.driver_pid = Some(pid);
        self.state.driver_started_at = crate::proc::process_started_at(pid);
        self.state.driver_exited = false;
        self.state.save()?;
        // A run that already lost its quorum never resumes into the verdict
        // machinery: `deliberate` and `vote` would otherwise clobber the
        // stalled marker back to Voting and the run would keep going past a
        // verdict that is no longer trustworthy. Everything already recorded is
        // kept, so the run stays resumable (or foldable) for a human to pick up.
        //
        // On --resume the run gets one chance to repair itself: the seats a
        // rate limit took out are re-asked. If their quota has since reset and
        // the quorum is restored, the run picks up and finishes; otherwise it
        // stays stale and still-resumable for a later retry. If it does not
        // recover, the returned status stays `Stalled` and nothing was
        // clobbered (the recovery only mutates entries for the lost seats).
        if self.state.status == RunStatus::Stalled {
            if self.recover_stall().await? {
                self.finish_after_tally().await?;
            } else {
                // Still below quorum: persist the marker and stay resumable.
                self.state.save()?;
            }
            return Ok(());
        }
        // A run parked inside `land` - watching CI, mid fix-round, or
        // waiting on the owner's merge approval - resumes directly into it,
        // never back through `prep`. Everything before `merge` already
        // concluded; that is the only way `status` reaches `Landing` in the
        // first place. Re-walking `review_loop` first would also be actively
        // wrong: its own status recomputation (see its doc) treats any
        // clean round as reason to set `status` to `Gating`, which would
        // clobber this marker before `merge` ever ran, and this run would
        // never find its way back into `land` at all.
        if self.state.status == RunStatus::Landing {
            self.run_land().await?;
            // `run_land` may have settled the run right here - CI came back
            // green and the PR merged, say - without ever passing back
            // through `merge`'s own trailing call. Whatever it left `status`
            // as is what this has to read.
            self.settle_questions();
            return Ok(());
        }
        self.prep().await?;
        if self.park_here()? {
            return Ok(());
        }
        self.advise().await?;
        if self.park_here()? {
            return Ok(());
        }
        self.implement().await?;
        if self.park_here()? {
            return Ok(());
        }
        // `after_implement` already saved the state and settled any open
        // questions when it set this; nothing later in the graph has
        // anything to judge.
        if self.state.status == RunStatus::VerifiedNoop {
            return Ok(());
        }
        self.judge().await?;
        if self.park_here()? {
            return Ok(());
        }
        self.deliberate().await?;
        if self.park_here()? {
            return Ok(());
        }
        self.vote().await?;
        if self.park_here()? {
            return Ok(());
        }
        self.tally()?;
        // A verdict that lost its quorum is not trustworthy: do not review,
        // gate, or merge on it. Everything already done is kept, so the run
        // stays resumable (or foldable); the human can replace the agent that
        // ran out of quota and pick it up.
        if self.state.status == RunStatus::Stalled {
            // Persist the stalled marker now — the normal end-of-execute save
            // below is below this early return, and without it a resumed run
            // would reload a pre-tally status and keep going.
            self.state.save()?;
            return Ok(());
        }
        self.finish_after_tally().await?;
        Ok(())
    }

    /// Park here if asked to, recording it in the run's own timeline.
    ///
    /// Returns whether the caller should stop walking the graph. The state is
    /// saved either way by the node that just finished; this adds the event so
    /// the operator's card says why a run that is neither finished nor moving
    /// is sitting where it is.
    fn park_here(&mut self) -> Result<bool> {
        // Either handle asking is enough - see `Pause`'s own doc for why
        // they are never the same one. `interrupt` is checked second so a
        // reason it carries is preferred in the message below over a plain
        // shutdown park racing it at the same boundary.
        if !self.pause.parked() && !self.interrupt.parked() {
            return Ok(false);
        }
        let why = match self.interrupt.reason().or_else(|| self.pause.reason()) {
            Some(reason) => format!(
                "parked after `{}` ({reason}) — resume to carry on from here",
                self.state.status.as_str()
            ),
            None => format!(
                "parked after `{}` — resume to carry on from here",
                self.state.status.as_str()
            ),
        };
        self.state.event("park", why);
        self.state.parked = true;
        self.state.save()?;
        Ok(true)
    }

    /// Hand the runner the pause `magi serve`'s own shutdown watches.
    pub fn on_pause(&mut self, pause: Pause) {
        self.pause = pause;
    }

    /// Hand the runner a second, independent pause: `magi serve`'s interrupt
    /// scheduler asking this one run - and no other - to park so a task
    /// marked [`crate::queue::Task::interrupt`] can run alone. See
    /// [`Pause`]'s own doc for why this is never [`Runner::on_pause`]'s
    /// handle.
    pub fn watch_interrupt(&mut self, pause: Pause) {
        self.interrupt = pause;
    }

    /// Abandon this run's own open questions, once `status` has actually
    /// settled rather than merely paused.
    ///
    /// `Blocked` and `Stalled` are `RunStatus::resumable` — a human can pick
    /// either back up with the candidates, the review round and the seat
    /// sessions already on disk, so a question an implementer asked mid-round
    /// may still get a real answer read by a real resume. Only the statuses
    /// `resumable` excludes are actually final: the run merged, it reached
    /// `Ready` with nothing left to do, it failed outright with no
    /// established point to continue from, or every candidate agreed, with
    /// evidence, that nothing belonged in the worktree (`VerifiedNoop`). In
    /// every one of those the seat that asked is gone for good, exactly like
    /// the run being deleted under `magi run rm` - so the same cleanup
    /// applies, worded for what actually happened instead of "the run was
    /// deleted".
    ///
    /// Best-effort and silent on success: called from every place `status`
    /// can land on one of those three, including ones a resumed run revisits,
    /// so it must cost nothing when there was nothing open to begin with.
    fn settle_questions(&mut self) {
        if let Err(e) = ask::Questions::open().settle_run(&self.state.id, self.state.status) {
            tracing::warn!("abandon questions for {}: {e:#}", self.state.id);
        }
    }

    /// The tail of the graph after a trustworthy tally: fold losers, review,
    /// gate, merge, and persist.
    async fn finish_after_tally(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        self.fold_losers().await?;
        // Before review starts, and again right before the gate: a run's
        // review rounds can themselves take long enough for the base to move
        // a second time, and the gate is the one node whose "green" gets
        // acted on.
        self.sync_to_base().await?;
        if self.state.status == RunStatus::AlreadyInBase {
            return Ok(());
        }
        self.review_loop().await?;
        self.sync_to_base().await?;
        if self.state.status == RunStatus::AlreadyInBase {
            return Ok(());
        }
        self.gate().await?;
        self.merge().await?;
        self.state.save()?;
        Ok(())
    }

    // ---------------------------------------------------------------- prep

    async fn prep(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        if !self.state.candidates.is_empty() {
            return Ok(());
        }
        self.state.status = RunStatus::Prep;
        let repo = self.state.repo.clone();
        let base = self.state.base_commit.clone();
        let plan = refs::plan(&repo, &self.state.seeds).await?;
        let start = plan.start.clone().unwrap_or_else(|| base.clone());
        let root = self.state.worktree_root();
        let labels = blind::assign_labels(self.roles.implementers.len(), self.state.seed);

        // The hook is the write-time half of the blindness contract; the
        // presentation filter in `blind` is the half that cannot be bypassed.
        let hooks_dir = self.state.dir().join("hooks");
        if self.state.config.blind.commit_msg_hook {
            std::fs::create_dir_all(&hooks_dir)
                .with_context(|| format!("create {}", hooks_dir.display()))?;
            let script = blind::commit_msg_hook(&self.state.config.blind.strip_lines);
            let path = hooks_dir.join("commit-msg");
            std::fs::write(&path, script).with_context(|| format!("write {}", path.display()))?;
            make_executable(&path)?;
            // Ref-counted rather than a plain idempotent set: with more than
            // one run able to be in flight in the same repository at once
            // (see `Config::daemon.max_concurrent_runs`), a bare "already
            // true?" check cannot tell "another run of mine still needs
            // this" from "nobody does", and the run that happens to finish
            // first would disable the hook out from under a sibling still
            // relying on it.
            git::acquire_worktree_config(&repo).await?;
            self.state.enabled_worktree_config = true;
        }

        for (index, (spec, label)) in self
            .roles
            .implementers
            .clone()
            .into_iter()
            .zip(labels)
            .enumerate()
        {
            let branch = self.state.branch_for(label);
            let worktree = root.join(format!("cand-{label}"));
            git::worktree_add_branch(&repo, &worktree, &branch, &start).await?;
            if self.state.config.blind.commit_msg_hook {
                git::set_worktree_hooks_path(&worktree, &hooks_dir).await?;
            }
            git::local_exclude(&worktree, "/.magi/").await?;
            for pick in &plan.picks {
                if let Err(e) = git::cherry_pick(&worktree, pick).await {
                    self.state.status = RunStatus::Blocked;
                    self.state
                        .event("prep", format!("cannot apply referenced commit: {e}"));
                    self.state.save()?;
                    return Err(e);
                }
            }
            self.state.candidates.push(Candidate {
                index,
                label,
                agent: spec.id.clone(),
                branch,
                worktree,
                summary: String::new(),
                stat: String::new(),
                files: 0,
                commits: 0,
                empty: false,
                failed: None,
                verified_noop: None,
                duration_ms: 0,
                folded: false,
            });
        }

        for j in 1..=self.roles.judges.len() {
            let wt = root.join(format!("judge-{j}"));
            if !wt.exists() {
                git::worktree_add_detached(&repo, &wt, &base).await?;
            }
        }

        // Disposable, detached checkouts for the design-deliberation stage's
        // advisor seats — the same shape as the judges' above, at the same
        // base commit, since advisors also only ever read. Sized off the
        // configured count directly rather than a resolved roster: unlike
        // `implementers`/`judges`/`reviewers`, advisor seats are resolved
        // lazily inside `advise` itself (see `Config::advisors`'s doc), so
        // `prep` has no `ResolvedRoles` field to read a count from here.
        if self.state.config.graph.advise {
            for k in 1..=self.state.config.graph.advisors {
                let wt = root.join(format!("advisor-{k}"));
                if !wt.exists() {
                    git::worktree_add_detached(&repo, &wt, &base).await?;
                }
            }
        }

        // A judge cannot tell it is looking at its own patch — the seats keep
        // separate conversations — but a panel that shares agents with the
        // field is less independent than it looks, and that is worth saying out
        // loud once per run rather than leaving it in the config.
        let authors: Vec<&str> = self
            .roles
            .implementers
            .iter()
            .map(|a| a.id.as_str())
            .collect();
        let overlap: Vec<String> = self
            .roles
            .judges
            .iter()
            .enumerate()
            .filter(|(_, j)| authors.contains(&j.id.as_str()))
            .map(|(i, j)| format!("judge {} = {}", i + 1, j.id))
            .collect();
        if !overlap.is_empty() {
            let note = format!(
                "{} also authored a candidate; blind, but the panel is less \
                 independent than {} distinct agents would be",
                overlap.join(", "),
                self.roles.judges.len()
            );
            self.state.event("prep", note);
        }

        self.state.event(
            "prep",
            format!(
                "{} candidates, {} judges, base {} ({})",
                self.state.candidates.len(),
                self.roles.judges.len(),
                &self.state.base_commit[..7.min(self.state.base_commit.len())],
                self.state.base_branch
            ),
        );
        self.state.status = RunStatus::Implementing;
        self.state.save()?;
        Ok(())
    }

    // -------------------------------------------------------------- advise

    /// The design-deliberation stage: independent, read-only advisor seats
    /// each sketch a design before any implementer touches the repository,
    /// and (when at least one produced a usable proposal) a synthesis seat
    /// blends them into a brief `implement` carries in every candidate's
    /// prompt.
    ///
    /// `[graph] advise` is the on/off switch, on by default; `[graph]
    /// advisors` is the proposal count. Everything here is best-effort and
    /// non-fatal to the run: a misconfigured `[roles] advisors`, a roster
    /// that cannot reach quota, or a synthesis seat that produced nothing
    /// usable all leave `implement` exactly as it was before this stage
    /// existed — the task instruction alone — rather than failing the whole
    /// competition over an enrichment stage. Every outcome is still recorded
    /// as an event, so a run that got nothing from this stage says why.
    ///
    /// [`RunState::advise_attempted`] is this node's idempotency marker, the
    /// same role [`RunState::judge_skipped`] plays for `judge`: without it a
    /// resumed run whose stage failed would re-run it, and re-spend the
    /// agent calls, on every reentry before `implement`.
    ///
    /// Also skipped once any candidate shows implementation progress — the
    /// exact predicate `implement` itself uses to decide a candidate is no
    /// longer "todo" (see its own `todo` filter). `advise_attempted` alone
    /// is not enough: a run created by an older binary that predates this
    /// field deserializes it as `false` (`#[serde(default)]`), so resuming
    /// an already-`Implementing`-or-later run under this build would
    /// otherwise walk straight back through `prep` (a no-op once candidates
    /// exist) into this node and spawn every advisor seat against worktrees
    /// `prep` never recreated — after implementation has already started,
    /// which is exactly the invariant this stage exists to guarantee.
    async fn advise(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        let implement_untouched = self
            .state
            .candidates
            .iter()
            .all(|c| c.commits == 0 && c.failed.is_none() && !c.empty);
        if !self.state.config.graph.advise || self.state.advise_attempted {
            return Ok(());
        }
        if !implement_untouched {
            self.state.event(
                "advise",
                "skipping the design-deliberation stage: at least one \
                 candidate already shows implementation progress, so this \
                 run is past the point the stage exists to run before"
                    .to_owned(),
            );
            self.state.advise_attempted = true;
            self.state.save()?;
            return Ok(());
        }
        let run_id = self.state.id.clone();
        let prompts = self.state.config.prompts.clone();
        let instruction = self.state.instruction.clone();
        let language = self.state.config.graph.language.clone();
        let root = self.state.worktree_root();
        let n = self.state.config.graph.advisors;
        let where_recorded = self.state.dir().join("run.json");

        let seats = match self.state.config.advisors() {
            Ok(seats) if !seats.is_empty() => seats,
            Ok(_) => {
                self.state.event(
                    "advise",
                    format!(
                        "[graph] advisors is 0; skipping the design-deliberation \
                         stage and continuing without a synthesis brief (see {})",
                        where_recorded.display()
                    ),
                );
                self.state.advise_attempted = true;
                self.state.save()?;
                return Ok(());
            }
            Err(e) => {
                self.state.event(
                    "advise",
                    format!(
                        "could not resolve advisor seats ({e:#}); continuing \
                         without a design-deliberation brief (see {})",
                        where_recorded.display()
                    ),
                );
                self.state.advise_attempted = true;
                self.state.save()?;
                return Ok(());
            }
        };

        let timeout = Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.timeout_judge.max(1));
        let artifacts = agent::artifacts_dir(&self.state.dir());
        let worktrees: Vec<PathBuf> = (1..=n).map(|k| root.join(format!("advisor-{k}"))).collect();

        let mut jobs = Vec::new();
        for (i, spec) in seats.iter().cloned().enumerate() {
            let seat_key = format!("advisor-{}", i + 1);
            let seat = self.seat(&seat_key, &spec.id);
            jobs.push(SeatJob {
                prompt: prompt::advisor(&instruction, i + 1, seats.len(), &language),
                spec,
                seat,
                cwd: worktrees[i % worktrees.len()].clone(),
                timeout,
                allow_write: false,
                sessions: false,
                artifacts: artifacts.clone(),
                stem: seat_key,
                handover: None,
            });
        }

        self.state.event(
            "advise",
            format!(
                "{} advisor seat(s) sketching a design in parallel",
                jobs.len()
            ),
        );
        let mut quota_losses = Vec::new();
        let cache = self.state.config.cache_dir();
        let ctx = WaveCtx {
            carry_seats: false,
            run: &run_id,
            node: "advise",
            prompts: &prompts,
            cache: cache.as_deref(),
            round: None,
        };
        let advisor_roster = self.state.config.advisor_roster().unwrap_or_default();
        let results = ask_json_wave::<Proposal>(
            jobs,
            Arc::clone(&self.sem),
            self.state.config.graph.retries,
            &advisor_roster,
            &ctx,
            &mut quota_losses,
            &mut self.state,
            &|p: &Proposal| p.validate(),
        )
        .await;
        self.state.quota.extend(quota_losses);

        let mut records = Vec::with_capacity(results.len());
        for (i, (seat, res, _attempts)) in results.into_iter().enumerate() {
            let agent_id = seat.agent.clone();
            self.state.seats.insert(seat.key.clone(), seat);
            match res {
                Ok((proposal, out)) => {
                    self.state
                        .event("advise", format!("advisor-{} proposed a design", i + 1));
                    records.push(advise::AdvisorRecord::proposed(
                        i + 1,
                        agent_id,
                        proposal,
                        out.duration_ms,
                    ));
                }
                Err(e) => {
                    self.state.event(
                        "advise",
                        format!("advisor-{} produced no usable proposal: {e:#}", i + 1),
                    );
                    records.push(advise::AdvisorRecord::failed(
                        i + 1,
                        agent_id,
                        e.to_string(),
                    ));
                }
            }
        }

        let mut advice = advise::Advice {
            records,
            synthesis: None,
        };
        if advice.proposals().is_empty() {
            self.state.event(
                "advise",
                "no advisor produced a usable proposal; continuing without a \
                 synthesis brief"
                    .to_owned(),
            );
        } else {
            match self
                .synthesize_brief(
                    &advice,
                    &instruction,
                    &language,
                    &worktrees[0],
                    &artifacts,
                    &run_id,
                    &prompts,
                    cache.as_deref(),
                )
                .await
            {
                Ok(Some(text)) => {
                    self.state.event(
                        "advise",
                        "synthesized a design brief for the implementer".to_owned(),
                    );
                    advice.synthesis = Some(text);
                }
                Ok(None) => {
                    self.state.event(
                        "advise",
                        "the synthesis seat produced nothing usable; continuing \
                         without a design brief"
                            .to_owned(),
                    );
                }
                Err(e) => {
                    self.state.event(
                        "advise",
                        format!("could not synthesize a design brief: {e:#}"),
                    );
                }
            }
        }
        advise::apply_reflection(&mut advice);

        self.state.advice = Some(advice);
        self.state.advise_attempted = true;
        self.state.save()?;
        Ok(())
    }

    /// The synthesis seat: reads every advisor's proposal and blends them
    /// into the design brief `advise` stores on [`RunState::advice`]. Split
    /// out of [`Runner::advise`] only for readability — it is not called
    /// anywhere else.
    ///
    /// Picked the same way [`crate::talk`]'s standing conversation and
    /// [`crate::bump`]'s release-bump decision are: [`agent::pick`], with
    /// `[roles] synthesizer` checked first and [`agent::pick`]'s own default
    /// order (a claude seat, else the first runnable agent in roster order)
    /// used when that field is unset — see `[roles] synthesizer`'s own doc
    /// in [`crate::config`] for why a dedicated field exists here at all.
    #[allow(clippy::too_many_arguments)]
    async fn synthesize_brief(
        &mut self,
        advice: &advise::Advice,
        instruction: &str,
        language: &str,
        cwd: &Path,
        artifacts: &Path,
        run_id: &str,
        prompts: &Prompts,
        cache: Option<&Path>,
    ) -> Result<Option<String>> {
        let chain = agent::pick_chain(
            &self.state.config.agents,
            self.state.config.roles.synthesizer.as_ref(),
            &agent::installed,
            "synthesizer",
        )?;
        let proposals = advice.proposals();
        let mut prompt = prompt::with_overlay(
            prompt::synthesize_brief(instruction, &proposals, language),
            prompts.overlay("advise"),
        );
        if cache.is_some() {
            // This seat never writes, so it is never handed `CARGO_TARGET_DIR`
            // below — see `prompt::build_cache_note`'s doc for why telling a
            // read-only seat to build through the shared cache is exactly how
            // a sandbox's write refusal gets misread as a defect.
            prompt.push('\n');
            prompt.push_str(&prompt::build_cache_note("advise", false));
        }
        let timeout = Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.timeout_judge.max(1));
        // Each id is tried once, in order; a quota hit, error or unusable
        // answer moves to the next. The seat is single-turn (`sessions:
        // false`) and the prompt is the whole context, so a fallback agent
        // needs nothing carried over.
        let mut last = None;
        for (n, spec) in chain.iter().enumerate() {
            if n > 0 {
                self.state
                    .event("advise", format!("synthesis falling back to {}", spec.id));
            }
            let mut seat = self.seat("advise-synthesis", &spec.id);
            let outcome = agent::invoke(
                spec,
                &mut seat,
                &Invocation {
                    cwd,
                    prompt: &prompt,
                    timeout,
                    allow_write: false,
                    unsandboxed: false,
                    sessions: false,
                    artifacts,
                    stem: &if n == 0 {
                        "advise-synthesis".to_owned()
                    } else {
                        format!("advise-synthesis-{}", spec.id)
                    },
                    run: run_id,
                    node: "advise",
                    cache_dir: None,
                    attachments: &[],
                    writable: &[],
                },
            )
            .await;
            if outcome.is_ok() {
                self.state.seats.insert(seat.key.clone(), seat);
            }
            let advance = agent::chain_advances(&outcome);
            last = Some(outcome);
            if !advance {
                break;
            }
        }
        // Exhausted: the last attempt's result is what a single failed seat
        // would have produced.
        let out = last.expect("a chain holds at least one agent")?;
        if !out.usable() {
            return Ok(None);
        }
        let text =
            verdict::section(&out.text, "synthesis").unwrap_or_else(|| out.text.trim().to_owned());
        Ok((!text.trim().is_empty()).then_some(text))
    }

    // ----------------------------------------------------------- implement

    async fn implement(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        // Attribution for every agent this node spawns: `MAGI_RUN` lets a task the
        // agent files with `magi task add` name the run that paid for it. The
        // prompt overlay is cloned alongside it because the waves borrow it
        // while `self` is mutably borrowed by the node's own bookkeeping.
        let run_id = self.state.id.clone();
        let prompts = self.state.config.prompts.clone();
        let todo: Vec<usize> = self
            .state
            .candidates
            .iter()
            .enumerate()
            .filter(|(_, c)| c.commits == 0 && c.failed.is_none() && !c.empty)
            .map(|(i, _)| i)
            .collect();
        if todo.is_empty() {
            return self.after_implement();
        }
        self.state.status = RunStatus::Implementing;

        let language = self.state.config.graph.language.clone();
        let timeout = Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.timeout_implement);
        let sessions = self.state.config.graph.sessions;
        let artifacts = agent::artifacts_dir(&self.state.dir());
        // The design-deliberation stage's blended brief, when `advise` found
        // one — carried into every implementer's prompt the same way
        // regardless of which candidate it is.
        let brief = self
            .state
            .advice
            .as_ref()
            .and_then(|a| a.synthesis.as_deref())
            .map(str::to_owned);
        let attachments = self.state.attachments.clone();

        let mut jobs = Vec::new();
        for &i in &todo {
            let (index, label, worktree) = {
                let c = &self.state.candidates[i];
                (c.index, c.label, c.worktree.clone())
            };
            let spec = self.roles.implementers[index].clone();
            let seat_key = format!("impl-{label}");
            let seat = self.seat(&seat_key, &spec.id);
            let instruction = seeded_instruction(&self.state);
            jobs.push(SeatJob {
                spec,
                seat,
                prompt: prompt::implement(
                    &instruction,
                    &worktree.to_string_lossy(),
                    &language,
                    brief.as_deref(),
                    &attachments,
                ),
                cwd: worktree,
                timeout,
                allow_write: true,
                sessions,
                artifacts: artifacts.clone(),
                stem: format!("impl-{label}"),
                handover: None,
            });
        }

        self.state.event(
            "implement",
            format!("{} candidates in parallel", jobs.len()),
        );
        // Kept so a seat whose CLI hung up can be asked again from the same
        // job: `wave` consumes what it is given. Mutable so `resume_seat_handovers`
        // can update a seat's own entry once a fallback agent takes it over —
        // `resume_unconfirmed_commands`, which reads `sent` afterward, must see
        // whichever agent actually answered, not the one that quota'd out.
        let mut sent = jobs.clone();
        let cache = self.state.config.cache_dir();
        let ctx = WaveCtx {
            carry_seats: false,
            run: &run_id,
            node: "implement",
            prompts: &prompts,
            cache: cache.as_deref(),
            round: None,
        };
        let mut results = wave(jobs, Arc::clone(&self.sem), &ctx, &mut self.state, 0).await;
        self.resume_undelivered(&mut results, &sent, &prompts, &run_id)
            .await;
        self.resume_seat_handovers(&mut results, &mut sent, &prompts, &run_id)
            .await;
        self.resume_unconfirmed_commands(&mut results, &sent, &prompts, &run_id)
            .await;

        for (&i, (_wi, seat, out)) in todo.iter().zip(results) {
            let seat_key = seat.key.clone();
            // A quota fallback (`resume_seat_handovers`) may have handed this
            // seat to a different agent than the one `prep` recorded on the
            // candidate; the stats tables and any later fixer-defaults-to-
            // winner's-author lookup must credit whoever actually answered —
            // unless every fallback also quota'd out, in which case nobody
            // actually answered and crediting the last agent tried would
            // erase every earlier agent's own quota loss from the stats
            // tables instead of just this one seat's.
            let agent = seat.agent.clone();
            let exhausted_the_fallback_chain = FailClass::of(&out).is_some();
            self.state.seats.insert(seat.key.clone(), seat);
            let label = self.state.candidates[i].label;
            let worktree = self.state.candidates[i].worktree.clone();
            let base = self.state.base_commit.clone();

            let (summary, duration, failed, verified_claim) = match out {
                AgentOutcome::Ok(o) => {
                    let text = verdict::section(&o.text, "summary").unwrap_or(o.text.clone());
                    let failed = (!o.usable()).then(|| {
                        if o.timed_out {
                            "agent timed out".to_owned()
                        } else {
                            format!("agent exited with {:?}", o.exit_code)
                        }
                    });
                    let verified_claim = verified_noop_claim(failed.is_none(), &o.commands, &text);
                    (text, o.duration_ms, failed, verified_claim)
                }
                // Left un-resumed by `resume_undelivered` (a dirty tree
                // already rescues the work, or there was no session left to
                // resume into) — reported like the ordinary failure it is,
                // never as if `o.text` (the CLI's raw error JSON) were an
                // answer.
                AgentOutcome::Dropped(o) => {
                    let why = o
                        .dropped
                        .as_ref()
                        .map(|d| d.why.as_str())
                        .unwrap_or("the CLI ended the stream without delivering its answer");
                    (
                        String::new(),
                        o.duration_ms,
                        Some(format!("the CLI dropped the stream ({why})")),
                        None,
                    )
                }
                AgentOutcome::Quota(o) => {
                    self.state.quota.push(QuotaLoss {
                        seat: seat_key,
                        node: "implement".to_owned(),
                        at: Timestamp::now(),
                        reset: o.quota.as_ref().and_then(|q| q.reset.clone()),
                    });
                    (
                        String::new(),
                        o.duration_ms,
                        Some("rate limited (quota); produced no change".to_owned()),
                        None,
                    )
                }
                AgentOutcome::Failed(e) => (String::new(), 0, Some(e), None),
            };

            // Rescue anything the agent edited but never committed: an
            // uncommitted candidate would silently be an empty one.
            let rescued = match git::rescue_commit(
                &worktree,
                &format!("magi: candidate {label} (uncommitted work)"),
            )
            .await
            {
                Ok(r) => {
                    self.state.note_withheld("implement", &r.withheld);
                    r.committed
                }
                Err(_) => false,
            };
            let commits = git::commits_ahead(&worktree, &base, "HEAD")
                .await
                .unwrap_or(0);
            let patch = git::diff(&worktree, &base, "HEAD")
                .await
                .unwrap_or_default();
            let stat = git::diff_stat(&worktree, &base, "HEAD")
                .await
                .unwrap_or_default();
            let files = git::changed_files(&worktree, &base, "HEAD")
                .await
                .map(|f| f.len())
                .unwrap_or(0);
            write_artifact(&self.state, &format!("cand-{label}.patch"), &patch)?;

            let c = &mut self.state.candidates[i];
            if !exhausted_the_fallback_chain {
                c.agent = agent;
            }
            c.summary = blind::sanitize_prose(&summary, &self.state.config.blind);
            c.stat = stat;
            c.files = files;
            c.commits = commits;
            c.duration_ms = duration;
            c.empty = commits == 0 || patch.trim().is_empty();
            // An agent that failed but still produced a committed change stays
            // in the running: the patch is what gets judged, not the exit code.
            c.failed = match failed {
                Some(_) if c.empty => failed,
                _ => None,
            };
            // Only an empty candidate can be a verified no-op: a claim next
            // to a real patch is not what the marker is for, and `c.failed`
            // being `Some` here already implies `verified_claim` was never
            // set (see the guard above the match that produced it).
            c.verified_noop = if c.empty { verified_claim } else { None };
            let note = match (&c.failed, c.empty, &c.verified_noop, rescued) {
                (Some(e), _, _, _) => format!("candidate {label}: {e}"),
                (None, true, Some(_), _) => {
                    format!("candidate {label}: no change produced (agent-verified no-op)")
                }
                (None, true, None, _) => format!("candidate {label}: no change produced"),
                (None, false, _, true) => {
                    format!(
                        "candidate {label}: {files} files, {commits} commits (rescued an uncommitted tree)"
                    )
                }
                (None, false, _, false) => {
                    format!("candidate {label}: {files} files, {commits} commits")
                }
            };
            self.state.event("implement", note);
            self.state.save()?;
        }

        self.after_implement()
    }

    /// Ask again, once, for work a CLI did and then failed to hand over.
    ///
    /// [`agent::dropped_stream`] recognises the one shape observed: an error
    /// status with an empty response and a usage report showing output tokens,
    /// i.e. **billed work with nothing delivered**. Run 26c7's candidate B was
    /// seven minutes and 14,267 output tokens that arrived as an empty
    /// candidate, because `agy`'s own subscriber fell behind and hung up.
    ///
    /// Two conditions, and both matter:
    ///
    /// - **Only when the tree is untouched.** Often the agent has already
    ///   written its files and only the closing message was lost; the rescue
    ///   commit below picks that up and there is nothing to ask for. Re-asking
    ///   then would pay for a second implementation of work already on disk.
    /// - **Once.** A CLI that drops one stream can drop the next, and this
    ///   node is the most expensive in the graph.
    ///
    /// The re-ask is a resume, not a re-run: `has_context` is true because the
    /// dropped reply still carried its `conversation_id`, so the seat is asked
    /// to finish what it was doing rather than sent the whole task again. It
    /// therefore gets a nudge's budget ([`retry_budget`]) - a quarter of the
    /// node's - for the same reason a re-ranked judge does: restating finished
    /// work is not the work.
    ///
    /// Unlike a quota this is worth retrying at all: a rate limit fails the
    /// same way until it resets, while an abandoned conversation is still
    /// there to be picked up.
    async fn resume_undelivered(
        &mut self,
        results: &mut [(usize, SeatState, AgentOutcome)],
        sent: &[SeatJob],
        prompts: &Prompts,
        run_id: &str,
    ) {
        for (wi, seat, out) in results.iter_mut() {
            let Some(dropped) = (match &*out {
                AgentOutcome::Dropped(o) => o.dropped.clone(),
                _ => None,
            }) else {
                continue;
            };
            let Some(job) = sent.get(*wi) else { continue };
            // Already on disk? Then only the closing message was lost.
            if !git::is_clean(&job.cwd).await.unwrap_or(true) {
                self.state.event(
                    "implement",
                    format!(
                        "{}: the CLI dropped the stream after {} output tokens ({}), but the \
                         work is in the tree",
                        seat.key, dropped.output_tokens, dropped.why
                    ),
                );
                continue;
            }
            // The re-ask only makes sense as a resume: `resume_after_drop`
            // says nothing about the task, trusting the seat to still hold it.
            // Without a session to resume — sessions disabled, or this CLI's
            // drop shape happened not to carry a session id — that prompt
            // would open a brand-new conversation with no context at all,
            // which is worse than leaving this as the ordinary failure it
            // already is.
            if !has_context(&job.spec, seat, job.sessions) {
                self.state.event(
                    "implement",
                    format!(
                        "{}: the CLI dropped the stream after {} output tokens ({}), but there \
                         is no session left to resume",
                        seat.key, dropped.output_tokens, dropped.why
                    ),
                );
                continue;
            }
            self.state.event(
                "implement",
                format!(
                    "{}: the CLI dropped the stream after {} output tokens ({}); resuming the \
                     conversation",
                    seat.key, dropped.output_tokens, dropped.why
                ),
            );
            let mut retry = job.clone();
            retry.seat = seat.clone();
            retry.prompt = prompt::resume_after_drop(&dropped.why);
            retry.timeout = retry_budget(job.timeout, true);
            retry.stem = format!("{}-resume", job.stem);
            let cache = self.state.config.cache_dir();
            let ctx = WaveCtx {
                carry_seats: false,
                run: run_id,
                node: "implement",
                prompts,
                cache: cache.as_deref(),
                round: None,
            };
            let (resumed_seat, resumed) =
                run_one(retry, Arc::clone(&self.sem), &ctx, &mut self.state, 1).await;
            *seat = resumed_seat;
            *out = resumed;
        }
    }

    /// Fall an implement seat through to the next untried agent in the
    /// implementer roster when it lost to quota — or, since the handover was
    /// generalised, to a timeout or an ordinary failure (see [`FailClass`] and
    /// [`should_hand_over`] for when a non-quota failure stops the chain), the
    /// quota path itself being unchanged — instead of leaving the
    /// seat's loss final the moment one agent's account runs dry.
    ///
    /// Solo runs (`graph.implementers = 1`, `daemon::apply_solo`'s forced shape)
    /// are the motivating case: `Config::resolve_roles`'s `implementers`
    /// truncates to the single slot rotation picked, so a solo task whose one
    /// implementer hits quota mid-run used to have nothing else to try. This
    /// walks [`ResolvedRoles::implementer_roster`] instead — the untruncated,
    /// unrotated roster — which is the only place the *other* candidates in
    /// the machine's roster still exist once `implementers` has been cut down
    /// to size.
    ///
    /// Walks forward from just past the seat's own original position in the
    /// roster, never wrapping back to the front: a later candidate slot (say
    /// `beta`, the roster's second entry) must fall through to the *next*
    /// entry (`gamma`) on its own quota loss, not back to `alpha`, which is
    /// almost certainly a different candidate's own agent already — and once
    /// the roster's tail is exhausted there is nothing left to fall through
    /// to for *this* seat, wrapping or not. Tried by `spec.id`, never the
    /// whole [`AgentSpec`]: a roster with the same id named twice must not
    /// let this retry that id forever. The loop keeps falling through until
    /// an attempt lands something other than `Quota` or the roster's tail
    /// runs out of untried ids, at which point the seat is left exactly as
    /// `implement`'s own `AgentOutcome::Quota` arm already handles it: one
    /// `QuotaLoss` recorded, the candidate failed/empty.
    ///
    /// `sent` is taken mutably and updated with the fallback agent's spec:
    /// `resume_unconfirmed_commands`, which runs after this and also reads
    /// `sent`, must see whichever agent actually ended up answering the seat
    /// — reading the stale, original spec there would check session
    /// eligibility against the wrong CLI and could hand a fallback agent's
    /// session id to the agent that just lost the seat to quota.
    ///
    /// Every fallback gets a fresh [`SeatState`], never the quota'd seat's own
    /// — `self.seat` only reuses state when the agent id is unchanged, so
    /// handing it a different id already gets this for free. Reusing the old
    /// seat would resume a different CLI's session as if it were a
    /// continuation of this one.
    ///
    /// Unlike [`Runner::resume_undelivered`], not gated on a clean worktree:
    /// a quota loss cuts an agent off mid-turn, so anything already in the
    /// tree is unfinished work, not a completed candidate a re-ask would pay
    /// for twice. A dirty tree is rescued into a commit first (the same
    /// neutral-identity rescue `implement`'s own outcome loop gives every
    /// candidate) so the next agent starts clean.
    ///
    /// The new agent gets the implementer's full prompt and full
    /// `timeout_implement` budget, not `resume_after_drop`'s nudge-sized one:
    /// it has no session and no context, and is implementing the task from
    /// nothing, unlike a resumed drop which is only restating work already
    /// done.
    ///
    /// Every intermediate `Quota` this loop absorbs is folded into a plain
    /// `implement` event, never into `self.state.quota` — that is what
    /// `daemon.rs`'s own backoff reads to decide a run's task attempt should
    /// go unspent, and a seat that ultimately recovered on its second or
    /// third agent is not the stalled panel that check exists to catch. Only
    /// the final, unrecovered `Quota` (once the roster runs out) ever reaches
    /// `self.state.quota`, via the ordinary `AgentOutcome::Quota` arm the
    /// outcome loop already has — this helper never pushes to it itself.
    async fn resume_seat_handovers(
        &mut self,
        results: &mut [(usize, SeatState, AgentOutcome)],
        sent: &mut [SeatJob],
        prompts: &Prompts,
        run_id: &str,
    ) {
        let instruction = seeded_instruction(&self.state);
        let language = self.state.config.graph.language.clone();
        let brief = self
            .state
            .advice
            .as_ref()
            .and_then(|a| a.synthesis.as_deref())
            .map(str::to_owned);
        let attachments = self.state.attachments.clone();
        for (wi, seat, out) in results.iter_mut() {
            // Who holds the other candidate seats of this wave right now
            // (earlier handovers already written back to `sent`).
            let others: BTreeSet<String> = sent
                .iter()
                .enumerate()
                .filter(|(j, _)| j != wi)
                .map(|(_, j)| j.spec.id.clone())
                .collect();
            let Some(job) = sent.get_mut(*wi) else {
                continue;
            };
            // Where the seat's own original agent sits in the roster — the
            // fallback walk starts just past here, never at the front, so a
            // later candidate slot's quota loss does not fall back onto an
            // earlier slot's own agent.
            let start = self
                .roles
                .implementer_roster
                .iter()
                .position(|s| s.id == job.spec.id)
                .unwrap_or(0);
            let mut tried: BTreeSet<String> = BTreeSet::from([job.spec.id.clone()]);
            let mut fallback_attempt = 0usize;
            let mut prev: Option<FailClass> = None;
            while let Some(cur) = FailClass::of(&*out) {
                if !should_hand_over(prev.as_ref(), &cur) {
                    break;
                }
                let Some(next) =
                    pick_successor(&self.roles.implementer_roster, start, &tried, None, &others)
                        .cloned()
                else {
                    break;
                };
                tried.insert(next.id.clone());
                fallback_attempt += 1;

                if let Ok(r) = git::rescue_commit(
                    &job.cwd,
                    &format!(
                        "magi: candidate {} (uncommitted work before {} fallback)",
                        seat.key,
                        if cur == FailClass::Quota {
                            "quota"
                        } else {
                            "handover"
                        }
                    ),
                )
                .await
                {
                    self.state.note_withheld("implement", &r.withheld);
                }

                record_handover(
                    &mut self.state,
                    "implement",
                    &seat.key,
                    &seat.agent,
                    &next.id,
                    &cur,
                    &fail_reason(&*out),
                );
                prev = Some(cur.clone());

                let new_seat = handover_seat(&seat.key, &next.id, self.state.next_seat_seed());
                self.state.seats.insert(seat.key.clone(), new_seat.clone());
                // Kept in sync on `sent` itself, not just the local retry: a
                // later helper (`resume_unconfirmed_commands`) reads `sent`
                // after this one returns and must see whichever agent is now
                // occupying the seat, not the one that just quota'd out —
                // otherwise it would judge session/continuation eligibility
                // by the wrong CLI and could resend a fallback's session id
                // to the agent that lost it the seat in the first place.
                job.spec = next.clone();
                let mut retry = job.clone();
                retry.seat = new_seat;
                retry.prompt = prompt::implement(
                    &instruction,
                    &job.cwd.to_string_lossy(),
                    &language,
                    brief.as_deref(),
                    &attachments,
                );
                retry.stem = format!("{}-{}-{}", job.stem, cur.stem_word(), next.id);
                let cache = self.state.config.cache_dir();
                let ctx = WaveCtx {
                    carry_seats: false,
                    run: run_id,
                    node: "implement",
                    prompts,
                    cache: cache.as_deref(),
                    round: None,
                };
                let (fallback_seat, fallback_out) = run_one(
                    retry,
                    Arc::clone(&self.sem),
                    &ctx,
                    &mut self.state,
                    fallback_attempt,
                )
                .await;
                *seat = fallback_seat;
                *out = fallback_out;
            }
        }
    }

    /// Ask an implement seat's own CLI to confirm what it started, once, when
    /// its reply reported a command whose completion status it never
    /// confirmed — see [`has_unconfirmed_command`]'s own doc for exactly what
    /// that does and does not mean.
    ///
    /// The completion contract this task asks for, extended to `implement`
    /// with the same signal `continue_fix_report` reads for the fixer,
    /// rather than a keyword search over the reply or a hard requirement on
    /// `## SUMMARY`'s presence — the shape behind fb35, 9566 and e185, where
    /// a candidate's CLI turn ended cleanly while a test run it had started
    /// had not. A short, ordinary reply with no `## SUMMARY` and no commands
    /// named in it at all is untouched by this: `commands` is empty, so
    /// there is nothing to be unconfirmed.
    ///
    /// Unlike `resume_undelivered`, not gated on the tree being untouched:
    /// this is not about recovering edits that might already be on disk, it
    /// is about a result the seat itself never vouched for, which resuming
    /// asks for regardless of what the tree already holds. Bounded to one
    /// attempt for the same reason `resume_undelivered` is — this is the
    /// most expensive node in the graph — and a seat that still cannot
    /// confirm on that attempt is left as whatever its (possibly still
    /// unconfirmed) reply says; this does not invent a new "failed" reason
    /// for a candidate that otherwise produced a real, committed change.
    async fn resume_unconfirmed_commands(
        &mut self,
        results: &mut [(usize, SeatState, AgentOutcome)],
        sent: &[SeatJob],
        prompts: &Prompts,
        run_id: &str,
    ) {
        for (wi, seat, out) in results.iter_mut() {
            let AgentOutcome::Ok(o) = &*out else {
                continue;
            };
            if !has_unconfirmed_command(&o.commands) {
                continue;
            }
            let Some(job) = sent.get(*wi) else { continue };
            if !has_context(&job.spec, seat, job.sessions) {
                self.state.event(
                    "implement",
                    format!(
                        "{}: the reply named a command whose own CLI never confirmed the exit \
                         status of, but there is no session left to resume",
                        seat.key
                    ),
                );
                continue;
            }
            self.state.event(
                "implement",
                format!(
                    "{}: the reply named a command whose own CLI never confirmed the exit \
                     status of; resuming the conversation",
                    seat.key
                ),
            );
            let mut retry = job.clone();
            retry.seat = seat.clone();
            retry.prompt = prompt::resume_incomplete(
                "a command in your last reply had no confirmed exit status",
            );
            retry.timeout = retry_budget(job.timeout, true);
            retry.stem = format!("{}-confirm", job.stem);
            let cache = self.state.config.cache_dir();
            let ctx = WaveCtx {
                carry_seats: false,
                run: run_id,
                node: "implement",
                prompts,
                cache: cache.as_deref(),
                round: None,
            };
            let (resumed_seat, resumed) =
                run_one(retry, Arc::clone(&self.sem), &ctx, &mut self.state, 1).await;
            *seat = resumed_seat;
            *out = resumed;
        }
    }

    /// Ask the fixer's own seat again, up to [`MAX_FIX_CONTINUATIONS`] times,
    /// when its CLI turn ended cleanly (`AgentOutcome::Ok`) but the reply held
    /// no [`FixReport`] — see [`MAX_FIX_CONTINUATIONS`]'s own doc for the run
    /// that motivated this.
    ///
    /// Not the same gap as an unparsable *shape*, which [`ask_json_wave`]'s
    /// own nudge loop already covers for judge/review/vote seats, and not a
    /// dropped stream, which [`Runner::resume_undelivered`] covers for
    /// implement seats: here the CLI turn genuinely finished while the node's
    /// own work — the fixer's account of what it did — had not. Gated purely
    /// on `extract_json::<FixReport>` having failed on an otherwise-usable
    /// reply, never on any wording in it, so a fixer whose valid, first-try
    /// `FixReport` happens to mention having waited on a background test is
    /// never resumed — the `Ok(report)` branch at the call site returns
    /// before this is ever invoked.
    ///
    /// Same discipline as `resume_undelivered`: a nudge-sized timeout per
    /// attempt ([`retry_budget`]), nothing attempted once the session is
    /// gone, and a quota hit ends the loop immediately rather than retrying a
    /// rate limit that fails the same way again.
    async fn continue_fix_report(
        &mut self,
        mut seat: SeatState,
        parse_err: String,
        job: &SeatJob,
        prompts: &Prompts,
        run_id: &str,
        round: usize,
    ) -> (
        SeatState,
        Option<FixReport>,
        Option<String>,
        ContinuationRecord,
    ) {
        let mut last_err = parse_err;
        let mut cumulative_wait_ms = 0u64;
        let mut attempts = 0usize;
        loop {
            if !has_context(&job.spec, &seat, job.sessions) {
                self.state.event(
                    "fix",
                    format!(
                        "round {round}: fixer's reply had no adoption report ({last_err}); no \
                         session left to resume into"
                    ),
                );
                let outcome = if attempts == 0 {
                    ContinuationOutcome::NoSession
                } else {
                    ContinuationOutcome::Exhausted
                };
                return (
                    seat,
                    None,
                    Some(format!("unparsable fix report: {last_err}")),
                    ContinuationRecord {
                        attempts,
                        cumulative_wait_ms,
                        outcome,
                    },
                );
            }
            if attempts >= MAX_FIX_CONTINUATIONS {
                self.state.event(
                    "fix",
                    format!(
                        "round {round}: fixer's reply still had no adoption report after \
                         {attempts} continuation(s) ({last_err}); giving up"
                    ),
                );
                return (
                    seat,
                    None,
                    Some(format!(
                        "unparsable fix report after {attempts} continuation(s): {last_err}"
                    )),
                    ContinuationRecord {
                        attempts,
                        cumulative_wait_ms,
                        outcome: ContinuationOutcome::Exhausted,
                    },
                );
            }
            attempts += 1;
            self.state.event(
                "fix",
                format!(
                    "round {round}: fixer's reply had no adoption report ({last_err}); resuming \
                     the conversation (attempt {attempts}/{MAX_FIX_CONTINUATIONS})"
                ),
            );
            let mut retry = job.clone();
            retry.seat = seat.clone();
            retry.prompt = prompt::resume_incomplete(&last_err);
            retry.timeout = retry_budget(job.timeout, true);
            retry.stem = format!("{}-continue{attempts}", job.stem);
            let cache = self.state.config.cache_dir();
            let ctx = WaveCtx {
                carry_seats: false,
                run: run_id,
                node: "fix",
                prompts,
                cache: cache.as_deref(),
                round: Some(round),
            };
            let (resumed_seat, resumed_out) = run_one(
                retry,
                Arc::clone(&self.sem),
                &ctx,
                &mut self.state,
                attempts,
            )
            .await;
            seat = resumed_seat;
            match resumed_out {
                AgentOutcome::Ok(o) => {
                    cumulative_wait_ms += o.duration_ms;
                    match verdict::extract_json::<FixReport>(&o.text) {
                        Ok(report) if !has_unconfirmed_command(&o.commands) => {
                            self.state.event(
                                "fix",
                                format!(
                                    "round {round}: fixer's adoption report recovered after \
                                     {attempts} continuation(s)"
                                ),
                            );
                            return (
                                seat,
                                Some(report),
                                None,
                                ContinuationRecord {
                                    attempts,
                                    cumulative_wait_ms,
                                    outcome: ContinuationOutcome::Resumed,
                                },
                            );
                        }
                        // The report parsed, but this same reply's own
                        // CommandEvidence — the identical record `state.jobs`
                        // renders — names a command whose CLI never
                        // confirmed an exit status. Read together, that is
                        // not a resolved answer: keep nudging rather than
                        // accept a report standing next to a command the
                        // seat's own CLI cannot vouch for.
                        Ok(_) => {
                            last_err = "the reply parsed, but it reported a command whose own CLI \
                                 never confirmed an exit status"
                                .to_owned();
                        }
                        Err(e) => last_err = e.to_string(),
                    }
                }
                AgentOutcome::Quota(o) => {
                    cumulative_wait_ms += o.duration_ms;
                    self.state.quota.push(QuotaLoss {
                        seat: seat.key.clone(),
                        node: "fix".to_owned(),
                        at: Timestamp::now(),
                        reset: o.quota.as_ref().and_then(|q| q.reset.clone()),
                    });
                    self.state.event(
                        "fix",
                        format!(
                            "round {round}: continuation rate limited (quota); not retrying now"
                        ),
                    );
                    return (
                        seat,
                        None,
                        Some("rate limited (quota) while recovering the fix report".to_owned()),
                        ContinuationRecord {
                            attempts,
                            cumulative_wait_ms,
                            outcome: ContinuationOutcome::QuotaLost,
                        },
                    );
                }
                AgentOutcome::Dropped(o) => {
                    cumulative_wait_ms += o.duration_ms;
                    let why = o
                        .dropped
                        .as_ref()
                        .map(|d| d.why.as_str())
                        .unwrap_or("the CLI ended the stream without delivering its answer");
                    last_err = format!("the CLI dropped the stream ({why})");
                }
                AgentOutcome::Failed(e) => last_err = e,
            }
        }
    }

    fn after_implement(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        // Scan every candidate patch once the set is complete.
        if self.state.leaks.is_empty() {
            let cfg = self.state.config.blind.clone();
            let mut leaks = Vec::new();
            for c in &self.state.candidates {
                let Some(patch) =
                    crate::run::read_artifact(&self.state, &format!("cand-{}.patch", c.label))
                else {
                    continue;
                };
                leaks.extend(blind::scan(
                    &format!("candidate {} patch", c.label),
                    &patch,
                    &cfg.vendor_tokens,
                ));
            }
            if !leaks.is_empty() {
                let summary = leaks
                    .iter()
                    .map(|l| format!("{}×{} in {}", l.token, l.count, l.site))
                    .collect::<Vec<_>>()
                    .join(", ");
                match cfg.on_leak {
                    LeakPolicy::Fail => {
                        self.state.status = RunStatus::Failed;
                        self.state
                            .event("blind", format!("vendor text in a patch: {summary}"));
                        self.state.leaks = leaks;
                        self.state.save()?;
                        self.settle_questions();
                        bail!(
                            "blind.on_leak = \"fail\" and vendor text reached a \
                             judged patch: {summary}"
                        );
                    }
                    LeakPolicy::Redact => self.state.event(
                        "blind",
                        format!("redacting vendor text for judging: {summary}"),
                    ),
                    LeakPolicy::Warn => self.state.event(
                        "blind",
                        format!("vendor text present in a judged patch (shown as-is): {summary}"),
                    ),
                }
                self.state.leaks = leaks;
            }
        }

        if self.state.viable().is_empty() {
            if self.state.all_candidates_verified_noop() {
                // Every candidate agreed, with evidence the adoption guard
                // accepted, that nothing belongs in this worktree. That is
                // not the same fact as a candidate that simply failed to
                // write anything, and settling it as an ordinary `Failed`
                // (see `SCHEMA`'s doc for schema 10) is what let two of
                // task 391f's attempts burn a retry each re-discovering the
                // same already-landed fix. Terminal either way, so `judge`
                // must never run over an empty candidate set — unlike the
                // `Failed` branch below this returns `Ok`, not an error:
                // nothing here failed.
                self.state.status = RunStatus::VerifiedNoop;
                self.state.save()?;
                self.settle_questions();
                return Ok(());
            }
            self.state.status = RunStatus::Failed;
            self.state.save()?;
            self.settle_questions();
            bail!("no candidate produced a change; nothing to judge");
        }
        self.state.status = RunStatus::Judging;
        self.state.save()?;
        Ok(())
    }

    // --------------------------------------------------------------- judge

    async fn judge(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        // Attribution for every agent this node spawns: `MAGI_RUN` lets a task the
        // agent files with `magi task add` name the run that paid for it. The
        // prompt overlay is cloned alongside it because the waves borrow it
        // while `self` is mutably borrowed by the node's own bookkeeping.
        let run_id = self.state.id.clone();
        let prompts = self.state.config.prompts.clone();
        if !self.state.judgements.is_empty() || self.state.judge_skipped {
            return Ok(());
        }
        let viable: Vec<Candidate> = self.state.viable().into_iter().cloned().collect();
        if viable.len() == 1 {
            // Recorded so this is a one-time event: `judgements` stays empty
            // either way, which without this flag is indistinguishable from
            // "not yet judged" on the next reentry — and status is left
            // untouched, so a later node's conclusion (e.g. `Blocked` after
            // the review budget ran out) survives a resume instead of being
            // clobbered back to `Judging` by this node running again.
            self.state.judge_skipped = true;
            self.state.event(
                "judge",
                format!(
                    "only candidate {} produced a change; judging skipped",
                    viable[0].label
                ),
            );
            self.state.save()?;
            return Ok(());
        }
        self.state.status = RunStatus::Judging;

        let labels: Vec<char> = viable.iter().map(|c| c.label).collect();
        let language = self.state.config.graph.language.clone();
        let timeout = Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.timeout_judge);
        let sessions = self.state.config.graph.sessions;
        let artifacts = agent::artifacts_dir(&self.state.dir());
        let root = self.state.worktree_root();
        let base_short = short(&self.state.base_commit);

        let mut jobs = Vec::new();
        let mut orders = Vec::new();
        for (j, spec) in self.roles.judges.clone().into_iter().enumerate() {
            let order = blind::presentation_order(viable.len(), j, self.state.seed);
            let views: Vec<CandidateView> = order.iter().map(|&k| self.view(&viable[k])).collect();
            orders.push(order.iter().map(|&k| viable[k].index).collect::<Vec<_>>());
            let seat_key = format!("judge-{}", j + 1);
            let seat = self.seat(&seat_key, &spec.id);
            jobs.push(SeatJob {
                prompt: prompt::judge(
                    &self.state.instruction,
                    &views,
                    self.roles.judges.len(),
                    &base_short,
                    &language,
                ),
                spec,
                seat,
                cwd: root.join(format!("judge-{}", j + 1)),
                timeout,
                allow_write: false,
                sessions,
                artifacts: artifacts.clone(),
                stem: format!("judge-{}", j + 1),
                handover: None,
            });
        }

        self.state.event(
            "judge",
            format!(
                "{} judges ranking {} candidates blind",
                jobs.len(),
                viable.len()
            ),
        );
        let labels_for_check = labels.clone();
        let mut quota_losses = Vec::new();
        let cache = self.state.config.cache_dir();
        let ctx = WaveCtx {
            carry_seats: false,
            run: &run_id,
            node: "judge",
            prompts: &prompts,
            cache: cache.as_deref(),
            round: None,
        };
        let results = ask_json_wave::<Ranking>(
            jobs,
            Arc::clone(&self.sem),
            self.state.config.graph.retries,
            &self.roles.judge_roster,
            &ctx,
            &mut quota_losses,
            &mut self.state,
            &move |r: &Ranking| r.validate(&labels_for_check),
        )
        .await;
        self.state.quota.extend(quota_losses);

        for (j, (seat, res, _attempts)) in results.into_iter().enumerate() {
            let agent_id = seat.agent.clone();
            self.state.seats.insert(seat.key.clone(), seat);
            let mut record = Judgement {
                judge: j + 1,
                seat: format!("judge-{}", j + 1),
                agent: agent_id,
                ranking: Vec::new(),
                reasons: BTreeMap::new(),
                confidence: None,
                order: orders[j].clone(),
                failed: None,
                duration_ms: 0,
            };
            match res {
                Ok((ranking, out)) => {
                    record.ranking = ranking.normalized();
                    record.reasons = ranking.reasons;
                    record.confidence = ranking.confidence;
                    record.duration_ms = out.duration_ms;
                    self.state.event(
                        "judge",
                        format!(
                            "judge {} ranked {}",
                            j + 1,
                            record.ranking.iter().collect::<String>()
                        ),
                    );
                }
                Err(e) => {
                    record.failed = Some(e.to_string());
                    self.state
                        .event("judge", format!("judge {} produced no ranking: {e}", j + 1));
                }
            }
            self.state.judgements.push(record);
            self.state.save()?;
        }
        Ok(())
    }

    // ---------------------------------------------------------- deliberate

    async fn deliberate(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        // Attribution for every agent this node spawns: `MAGI_RUN` lets a task the
        // agent files with `magi task add` name the run that paid for it. The
        // prompt overlay is cloned alongside it because the waves borrow it
        // while `self` is mutably borrowed by the node's own bookkeeping.
        let run_id = self.state.id.clone();
        let prompts = self.state.config.prompts.clone();
        if !self.state.deliberation.is_empty() {
            return Ok(());
        }
        let tops: Vec<char> = self
            .state
            .judgements
            .iter()
            .filter_map(|j| j.ranking.first().copied())
            .collect();
        let rounds = self.state.config.graph.deliberate_rounds;
        if tops.len() < 2 || tops.iter().all(|t| *t == tops[0]) || rounds == 0 {
            if tops.len() >= 2 && tops.iter().all(|t| *t == tops[0]) {
                self.state.event(
                    "deliberate",
                    format!("judges agreed on {} outright; no deliberation", tops[0]),
                );
            }
            self.state.status = RunStatus::Voting;
            self.state.save()?;
            return Ok(());
        }

        self.state.status = RunStatus::Deliberating;
        self.state.event(
            "deliberate",
            format!(
                "split: first choices were {} — opening {rounds} round(s)",
                tops.iter().collect::<String>()
            ),
        );

        let viable: Vec<Candidate> = self.state.viable().into_iter().cloned().collect();
        let language = self.state.config.graph.language.clone();
        let timeout = Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.timeout_judge);
        let sessions = self.state.config.graph.sessions;
        let artifacts = agent::artifacts_dir(&self.state.dir());
        let root = self.state.worktree_root();
        let base_short = short(&self.state.base_commit);

        // Judges argue in sequence so that a turn can answer the one before it;
        // that is the difference between deliberation and three parallel
        // monologues.
        for round in 1..=rounds {
            let mut turns: Vec<DeliberationTurn> = Vec::new();
            for (j, spec) in self.roles.judges.clone().into_iter().enumerate() {
                if self.state.judgements[j].failed.is_some() {
                    continue;
                }
                let seat_key = format!("judge-{}", j + 1);
                let spec = self.occupant(&seat_key, spec);
                let mut seat = self.seat(&seat_key, &spec.id);
                let transcript = self.transcript(&turns, j);
                let build = |context: Option<&str>| {
                    prompt::deliberate(
                        &self.state.instruction,
                        context,
                        &transcript,
                        round,
                        rounds,
                        &language,
                    )
                };
                let block = self.candidate_block(&viable, &base_short);
                let full = build(Some(&block));
                let text = if has_context(&spec, &seat, sessions) {
                    build(None)
                } else {
                    full.clone()
                };
                let job = SeatJob {
                    spec,
                    seat: seat.clone(),
                    prompt: text,
                    cwd: root.join(format!("judge-{}", j + 1)),
                    timeout,
                    allow_write: false,
                    sessions,
                    artifacts: artifacts.clone(),
                    stem: format!("delib-{round}-judge-{}", j + 1),
                    handover: Some(full),
                };
                let cache = self.state.config.cache_dir();
                let ctx = WaveCtx {
                    carry_seats: false,
                    run: &run_id,
                    node: "deliberate",
                    prompts: &prompts,
                    cache: cache.as_deref(),
                    round: None,
                };
                // A turn is never nudged (`retries` 0): a failed seat is
                // handed to the next roster agent, which gets the full
                // context. An empty answer is a turn, not a failure.
                let mut losses = Vec::new();
                let mut results = ask_wave_with::<String>(
                    vec![job],
                    Arc::clone(&self.sem),
                    0,
                    &self.roles.judge_roster,
                    &ctx,
                    &mut losses,
                    &mut self.state,
                    &|text: &str| {
                        Ok(verdict::section(text, "position").unwrap_or_else(|| text.to_owned()))
                    },
                )
                .await;
                self.state.quota.extend(losses);
                let (updated, res, _) = results.pop().expect("one job in, one result out");
                seat = updated;
                let agent_id = seat.agent.clone();
                self.state.seats.insert(seat.key.clone(), seat);
                let body = match res {
                    Ok((body, _)) => body,
                    // Skip the seat; a CLI's raw error JSON is never read as
                    // this judge's position.
                    Err(e) => {
                        self.state
                            .event("deliberate", format!("judge {} skipped: {e}", j + 1));
                        continue;
                    }
                };
                let tentative = verdict::extract_json::<Position>(&body)
                    .ok()
                    .and_then(|p| p.tentative)
                    .and_then(|s| s.trim().chars().next())
                    .map(|c| c.to_ascii_uppercase());
                self.state.event(
                    "deliberate",
                    format!(
                        "round {round}: judge {} now favours {}",
                        j + 1,
                        tentative.map_or("—".to_owned(), |c| c.to_string())
                    ),
                );
                turns.push(DeliberationTurn {
                    judge: j + 1,
                    agent: agent_id,
                    body: blind::sanitize_prose(&body, &self.state.config.blind),
                    tentative,
                });
            }
            self.state
                .deliberation
                .push(DeliberationRound { round, turns });
            self.state.save()?;
        }

        self.state.status = RunStatus::Voting;
        self.state.save()?;
        Ok(())
    }

    // ---------------------------------------------------------------- vote

    async fn vote(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        // Attribution for every agent this node spawns: `MAGI_RUN` lets a task the
        // agent files with `magi task add` name the run that paid for it. The
        // prompt overlay is cloned alongside it because the waves borrow it
        // while `self` is mutably borrowed by the node's own bookkeeping.
        let run_id = self.state.id.clone();
        let prompts = self.state.config.prompts.clone();
        if !self.state.votes.is_empty() {
            return Ok(());
        }
        let viable: Vec<char> = self.state.viable().into_iter().map(|c| c.label).collect();
        if viable.len() == 1 {
            return Ok(());
        }
        self.state.status = RunStatus::Voting;

        let language = self.state.config.graph.language.clone();
        let timeout = Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.timeout_judge);
        let sessions = self.state.config.graph.sessions;
        let artifacts = agent::artifacts_dir(&self.state.dir());
        let root = self.state.worktree_root();
        let base_short = short(&self.state.base_commit);
        let candidates: Vec<Candidate> = self.state.viable().into_iter().cloned().collect();

        let mut jobs = Vec::new();
        let mut seats_at = Vec::new();
        for (j, spec) in self.roles.judges.clone().into_iter().enumerate() {
            if self
                .state
                .judgements
                .get(j)
                .is_some_and(|r| r.failed.is_some())
            {
                continue;
            }
            let seat_key = format!("judge-{}", j + 1);
            let spec = self.occupant(&seat_key, spec);
            let seat = self.seat(&seat_key, &spec.id);
            let full = self.vote_prompt_full(j, &viable, &language, &candidates, &base_short);
            let text = if has_context(&spec, &seat, sessions) {
                prompt::final_vote(&viable, &language)
            } else {
                full.clone()
            };
            jobs.push(SeatJob {
                spec,
                seat,
                prompt: text,
                cwd: root.join(format!("judge-{}", j + 1)),
                timeout,
                allow_write: false,
                sessions,
                artifacts: artifacts.clone(),
                stem: format!("vote-judge-{}", j + 1),
                handover: Some(full),
            });
            seats_at.push(j);
        }

        self.state.event(
            "vote",
            format!(
                "collecting {} final votes one by one, privately",
                jobs.len()
            ),
        );
        let allowed = viable.clone();
        let mut quota_losses = Vec::new();
        let cache = self.state.config.cache_dir();
        let ctx = WaveCtx {
            carry_seats: false,
            run: &run_id,
            node: "vote",
            prompts: &prompts,
            cache: cache.as_deref(),
            round: None,
        };
        let results = ask_json_wave::<FinalVote>(
            jobs,
            Arc::clone(&self.sem),
            self.state.config.graph.retries,
            &self.roles.judge_roster,
            &ctx,
            &mut quota_losses,
            &mut self.state,
            &move |v: &FinalVote| match v.label() {
                Some(c) if allowed.contains(&c) => Ok(()),
                other => bail!("vote {other:?} is not one of {allowed:?}"),
            },
        )
        .await;
        self.state.quota.extend(quota_losses);

        for (&j, (seat, res, _attempts)) in seats_at.iter().zip(results) {
            let agent_id = seat.agent.clone();
            self.state.seats.insert(seat.key.clone(), seat);
            let initial = self
                .state
                .judgements
                .get(j)
                .and_then(|r| r.ranking.first().copied());
            let mut record = VoteRecord {
                judge: j + 1,
                agent: agent_id,
                vote: None,
                reason: String::new(),
                changed: false,
            };
            match res {
                Ok((v, _)) => {
                    record.vote = v.label();
                    record.reason = blind::sanitize_prose(&v.reason, &self.state.config.blind);
                    record.changed = matches!((record.vote, initial), (Some(a), Some(b)) if a != b);
                    self.state.event(
                        "vote",
                        format!(
                            "judge {} voted {}{}",
                            j + 1,
                            record.vote.unwrap_or('?'),
                            if record.changed { " (changed)" } else { "" }
                        ),
                    );
                }
                Err(e) => {
                    self.state
                        .event("vote", format!("judge {} cast no vote: {e}", j + 1));
                }
            }
            self.state.votes.push(record);
            self.state.save()?;
        }
        Ok(())
    }

    // --------------------------------------------------------------- tally

    fn tally(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        if self.state.tally.is_some() {
            return Ok(());
        }
        let viable: Vec<char> = self.state.viable().into_iter().map(|c| c.label).collect();
        let tops: Vec<char> = self
            .state
            .judgements
            .iter()
            .filter_map(|j| j.ranking.first().copied())
            .collect();
        let unanimous_initial = tops.len() > 1 && tops.iter().all(|t| *t == tops[0]);

        // A judge whose private vote failed still counted once, in the initial
        // ranking; using it beats discarding a whole seat.
        let mut first_choice: BTreeMap<char, usize> = viable.iter().map(|l| (*l, 0)).collect();
        let mut cast: Vec<char> = Vec::new();
        for (i, j) in self.state.judgements.iter().enumerate() {
            let vote = self
                .state
                .votes
                .iter()
                .find(|v| v.judge == i + 1)
                .and_then(|v| v.vote)
                .or_else(|| j.ranking.first().copied());
            if let Some(v) = vote {
                *first_choice.entry(v).or_insert(0) += 1;
                cast.push(v);
            }
        }

        let mut borda: BTreeMap<char, usize> = viable.iter().map(|l| (*l, 0)).collect();
        for j in &self.state.judgements {
            let n = j.ranking.len();
            for (pos, label) in j.ranking.iter().enumerate() {
                *borda.entry(*label).or_insert(0) += n.saturating_sub(pos + 1);
            }
        }

        let best = first_choice.values().copied().max().unwrap_or(0);
        let mut leaders: Vec<char> = first_choice
            .iter()
            .filter(|(_, v)| **v == best)
            .map(|(k, _)| *k)
            .collect();
        let mut tie_break = None;
        if leaders.len() > 1 {
            let top_borda = leaders.iter().map(|l| borda[l]).max().unwrap_or(0);
            let borda_leaders: Vec<char> = leaders
                .iter()
                .copied()
                .filter(|l| borda[l] == top_borda)
                .collect();
            tie_break = Some(if borda_leaders.len() == 1 {
                format!(
                    "{} way tie on first-choice votes, broken by Borda points from the initial rankings",
                    leaders.len()
                )
            } else {
                format!(
                    "{} way tie on both first-choice votes and Borda points, broken by label order",
                    leaders.len()
                )
            });
            leaders = borda_leaders;
            leaders.sort_unstable();
        }
        let winner = *leaders
            .first()
            .or(viable.first())
            .context("no candidate to declare a winner from")?;

        let changed_votes = self.state.votes.iter().filter(|v| v.changed).count();
        let unanimous_final = !cast.is_empty() && cast.iter().all(|c| *c == cast[0]);
        let deliberated = !self.state.deliberation.is_empty();

        // Whose verdict is this? A rate-limited seat is absent even if it
        // ranked before the limit hit, so presence is measured against the
        // recorded losses, not just "did a ranking ever appear".
        let quota_seats: std::collections::BTreeSet<&str> =
            self.state.quota.iter().map(|q| q.seat.as_str()).collect();
        let mut present = 0usize;
        for (i, j) in self.state.judgements.iter().enumerate() {
            if quota_seats.contains(j.seat.as_str()) {
                continue;
            }
            let ranked = !j.ranking.is_empty() && j.failed.is_none();
            let voted = self
                .state
                .votes
                .iter()
                .any(|v| v.judge == i + 1 && v.vote.is_some());
            if ranked || voted {
                present += 1;
            }
        }
        // Strict majority of the configured panel. A bare majority is real
        // signal we can act on, while a minority verdict must never stand in
        // for a healthy one. A one-candidate run needs no panel at all, and
        // `judges` stays `0` rather than the roster size a panel that never
        // sat would otherwise be credited with.
        let needs_quorum = viable.len() > 1;
        let judges_total = if needs_quorum {
            self.roles.judges.len()
        } else {
            0
        };
        let quorum = if needs_quorum {
            judges_total / 2 + 1
        } else {
            0
        };
        let met_quorum = !needs_quorum || present >= quorum;
        let uncontested = (!needs_quorum).then(|| {
            format!("only one candidate ({winner}) produced a usable change; no panel was asked")
        });

        self.state.event(
            "tally",
            match &uncontested {
                Some(reason) => format!("winner {winner} — {reason}"),
                None => format!(
                    "winner {winner} — votes {} | initial {} | {} changed | \
                     {present}/{judges_total} judges{}",
                    first_choice
                        .iter()
                        .map(|(k, v)| format!("{k}:{v}"))
                        .collect::<Vec<_>>()
                        .join(" "),
                    if unanimous_initial {
                        "unanimous"
                    } else {
                        "split"
                    },
                    changed_votes,
                    if met_quorum {
                        String::new()
                    } else {
                        format!(" — below quorum ({quorum} required)")
                    },
                ),
            },
        );
        if !met_quorum {
            self.state.event(
                "stall",
                format!(
                    "verdict rests on {present} of {judges_total} judges (quorum {quorum}); \
                     the run stops here, resumable"
                ),
            );
        }
        self.state.tally = Some(Tally {
            first_choice,
            borda,
            winner,
            rankings: tops.len(),
            unanimous_initial,
            deliberated,
            changed_votes,
            unanimous_final,
            tie_break,
            judges: judges_total,
            present,
            quorum,
            met_quorum,
            uncontested,
        });
        self.state.status = if met_quorum {
            RunStatus::Reviewing
        } else {
            RunStatus::Stalled
        };
        self.state.save()?;
        Ok(())
    }

    // ------------------------------------------------------------- recover

    /// Re-ask the judge seats `tally` counts as absent, so a `Stalled` run can be
    /// resumed toward completion once the transient cause clears.
    ///
    /// A seat is absent — and therefore re-asked — when `tally` refuses to count
    /// it toward the quorum, which is exactly the set of seats whose absence
    /// collapsed the panel: struck by a rate limit at *any* node (the quorum must
    /// not depend on which node happened to hit the limit), or an ordinary
    /// failure (`failed = Some`) that never produced a usable ranking. A healthy
    /// seat is never disturbed.
    ///
    /// A seat that now answers with a usable ranking is "recovered": its
    /// `Judgement` is refreshed, its `QuotaLoss`/`failed` state cleared (so
    /// `tally` counts it present again), and its vote re-collected. A seat that
    /// still fails keeps its loss and stays absent.
    ///
    /// Returns `true` when the re-tally restores the quorum (the run may proceed
    /// to review/gate/merge), `false` when it is still below quorum (the run
    /// stays `Stalled`, still resumable for a later retry).
    #[allow(clippy::too_many_lines)]
    async fn recover_stall(&mut self) -> Result<bool> {
        // Attribution for every agent this node spawns: `MAGI_RUN` lets a task the
        // agent files with `magi task add` name the run that paid for it. The
        // prompt overlay is cloned alongside it because the waves borrow it
        // while `self` is mutably borrowed by the node's own bookkeeping.
        let run_id = self.state.id.clone();
        let prompts = self.state.config.prompts.clone();
        // Absent seats = quota-lost at any node, or failed outright. Mirroring
        // `tally`'s presence test (rather than the old quota-judge/vote filter)
        // is what keeps a non-quota collapse — or a quota loss recorded at the
        // deliberate node — from being a permanent dead-end on `--resume`.
        let quota_seats: BTreeSet<&str> =
            self.state.quota.iter().map(|q| q.seat.as_str()).collect();
        let absent: Vec<String> = self
            .state
            .judgements
            .iter()
            .filter(|j| quota_seats.contains(j.seat.as_str()) || j.failed.is_some())
            .map(|j| j.seat.clone())
            .collect();
        if absent.is_empty() {
            return Ok(false);
        }
        let viable: Vec<Candidate> = self.state.viable().into_iter().cloned().collect();
        if viable.len() <= 1 {
            return Ok(false);
        }
        let labels: Vec<char> = viable.iter().map(|c| c.label).collect();
        let language = self.state.config.graph.language.clone();
        let timeout = Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.timeout_judge);
        let sessions = self.state.config.graph.sessions;
        let artifacts = agent::artifacts_dir(&self.state.dir());
        let root = self.state.worktree_root();
        let base_short = short(&self.state.base_commit);
        let candidates: Vec<Candidate> = viable.clone();

        // Map each absent seat key to its 0-based position in `roles.judges`.
        let mut positions: Vec<usize> = absent
            .iter()
            .filter_map(|k| self.state.judgements.iter().position(|r| &r.seat == k))
            .collect();
        if positions.is_empty() {
            return Ok(false);
        }
        positions.sort_unstable();
        positions.dedup();

        // Re-rank the lost seats, one blind prompt each.
        let mut judge_jobs = Vec::new();
        for &j in &positions {
            let order = blind::presentation_order(viable.len(), j, self.state.seed);
            let views: Vec<CandidateView> = order.iter().map(|&k| self.view(&viable[k])).collect();
            let seat_key = format!("judge-{}", j + 1);
            let spec = self.occupant(&seat_key, self.roles.judges[j].clone());
            let seat = self.seat(&seat_key, &spec.id);
            judge_jobs.push(SeatJob {
                spec,
                seat,
                prompt: prompt::judge(
                    &self.state.instruction,
                    &views,
                    self.roles.judges.len(),
                    &base_short,
                    &language,
                ),
                cwd: root.join(seat_key),
                timeout,
                allow_write: false,
                sessions,
                artifacts: artifacts.clone(),
                stem: format!("judge-{}-recover", j + 1),
                handover: None,
            });
        }

        let labels_for_check = labels.clone();
        let mut judge_losses = Vec::new();
        let retries = self.state.config.graph.retries;
        let cache = self.state.config.cache_dir();
        let ctx = WaveCtx {
            carry_seats: false,
            run: &run_id,
            node: "judge",
            prompts: &prompts,
            cache: cache.as_deref(),
            round: None,
        };
        let results = ask_json_wave::<Ranking>(
            judge_jobs,
            Arc::clone(&self.sem),
            retries,
            &self.roles.judge_roster,
            &ctx,
            &mut judge_losses,
            &mut self.state,
            &move |r: &Ranking| r.validate(&labels_for_check),
        )
        .await;

        // Refresh the judgement of every seat that ranked again.
        let mut recovered: BTreeSet<usize> = BTreeSet::new();
        for (&j, (seat, res, _attempts)) in positions.iter().zip(results) {
            let agent_id = seat.agent.clone();
            self.state.seats.insert(seat.key.clone(), seat);
            let record = &mut self.state.judgements[j];
            match res {
                Ok((ranking, out)) => {
                    record.agent = agent_id;
                    record.ranking = ranking.normalized();
                    record.reasons = ranking.reasons;
                    record.confidence = ranking.confidence;
                    record.failed = None;
                    record.duration_ms = out.duration_ms;
                    recovered.insert(j);
                    self.state.event(
                        "recover",
                        format!("judge {} ranked again after the limit", j + 1),
                    );
                }
                Err(e) => {
                    self.state
                        .event("recover", format!("judge {} still cannot rank: {e}", j + 1));
                }
            }
        }

        // Re-ask the votes of the seats that recovered a ranking.
        let mut vote_jobs = Vec::new();
        let mut vote_pos: Vec<usize> = Vec::new();
        for &j in &recovered {
            let seat_key = format!("judge-{}", j + 1);
            let spec = self.occupant(&seat_key, self.roles.judges[j].clone());
            let seat = self.seat(&seat_key, &spec.id);
            let full = self.vote_prompt_full(j, &labels, &language, &candidates, &base_short);
            let text = if has_context(&spec, &seat, sessions) {
                prompt::final_vote(&labels, &language)
            } else {
                full.clone()
            };
            vote_jobs.push(SeatJob {
                spec,
                seat,
                prompt: text,
                cwd: root.join(seat_key),
                timeout,
                allow_write: false,
                sessions,
                artifacts: artifacts.clone(),
                stem: format!("vote-judge-{}-recover", j + 1),
                handover: Some(full),
            });
            vote_pos.push(j);
        }
        let allowed = labels.clone();
        let mut vote_losses = Vec::new();
        let vote_retries = self.state.config.graph.retries;
        let vote_cache = self.state.config.cache_dir();
        let ctx = WaveCtx {
            carry_seats: false,
            run: &run_id,
            node: "vote",
            prompts: &prompts,
            cache: vote_cache.as_deref(),
            round: None,
        };
        let votes = ask_json_wave::<FinalVote>(
            vote_jobs,
            Arc::clone(&self.sem),
            vote_retries,
            &self.roles.judge_roster,
            &ctx,
            &mut vote_losses,
            &mut self.state,
            &move |v: &FinalVote| match v.label() {
                Some(c) if allowed.contains(&c) => Ok(()),
                other => bail!("vote {other:?} is not one of {allowed:?}"),
            },
        )
        .await;
        for (&j, (seat, res, _attempts)) in vote_pos.iter().zip(votes) {
            let agent_id = seat.agent.clone();
            self.state.seats.insert(seat.key.clone(), seat);
            match res {
                Ok((v, _)) => {
                    if let Some(rec) = self.state.votes.iter_mut().find(|r| r.judge == j + 1) {
                        rec.vote = v.label();
                        rec.reason = blind::sanitize_prose(&v.reason, &self.state.config.blind);
                    } else {
                        self.state.votes.push(VoteRecord {
                            judge: j + 1,
                            agent: agent_id,
                            vote: v.label(),
                            reason: blind::sanitize_prose(&v.reason, &self.state.config.blind),
                            changed: false,
                        });
                    }
                    self.state.event(
                        "recover",
                        format!("judge {} voted again after the limit", j + 1),
                    );
                }
                Err(e) => {
                    self.state
                        .event("recover", format!("judge {} still cannot vote: {e}", j + 1));
                }
            }
        }

        // A seat that ranked again is present even if its re-vote failed —
        // `tally` falls back to the initial ranking's first choice — so clear
        // its quota loss. Seats that still fail keep theirs and stay absent.
        let recovered_keys: BTreeSet<String> = recovered
            .iter()
            .map(|&j| format!("judge-{}", j + 1))
            .collect();
        self.state
            .quota
            .retain(|q| !recovered_keys.contains(&q.seat));
        // A seat that hit the limit again is a fresh loss, not the old one:
        // replace the stale entry so the history stays one-per-seat and the
        // daemon can tell this attempt's loss from a previous session's.
        for loss in judge_losses.into_iter().chain(vote_losses) {
            if recovered_keys.contains(&loss.seat) {
                continue;
            }
            self.state.quota.retain(|q| q.seat != loss.seat);
            self.state.quota.push(loss);
        }

        // Recompute the verdict from the refreshed panel.
        self.state.tally = None;
        self.tally()?;
        Ok(self
            .state
            .tally
            .as_ref()
            .map(|t| t.met_quorum)
            .unwrap_or(false))
    }

    // ----------------------------------------------------------------- fold

    async fn fold_losers(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        let Some(winner) = self.state.tally.as_ref().map(|t| t.winner) else {
            return Ok(());
        };
        let repo = self.state.repo.clone();
        let mut folded = Vec::new();
        for i in 0..self.state.candidates.len() {
            let c = &self.state.candidates[i];
            if c.label == winner || c.folded {
                continue;
            }
            let (wt, branch, label) = (c.worktree.clone(), c.branch.clone(), c.label);
            git::worktree_remove(&repo, &wt).await.ok();
            git::branch_delete(&repo, &branch).await.ok();
            self.state.candidates[i].folded = true;
            folded.push(label.to_string());
        }
        // The judges are finished; their checkouts are pure cost from here.
        let root = self.state.worktree_root();
        for j in 1..=self.roles.judges.len() {
            let wt = root.join(format!("judge-{j}"));
            if wt.exists() {
                git::worktree_remove(&repo, &wt).await.ok();
            }
        }
        // The design-deliberation stage is finished by the time a tally
        // exists — same reasoning as the judges above.
        if self.state.config.graph.advise {
            for k in 1..=self.state.config.graph.advisors {
                let wt = root.join(format!("advisor-{k}"));
                if wt.exists() {
                    git::worktree_remove(&repo, &wt).await.ok();
                }
            }
        }
        if !folded.is_empty() {
            self.state
                .event("fold", format!("folded candidates {}", folded.join(", ")));
            self.state.save()?;
        }
        Ok(())
    }

    // ------------------------------------------------------------ base sync

    /// Land the winner's tree on the current tip of `<remote>/<base>` before
    /// anything verifies it.
    ///
    /// `verify.e2e`, `verify.gate` and every reviewer in [`Self::review_loop`]
    /// read whatever is checked out in the winner's worktree. Left alone that
    /// tree stays rooted at `base_commit` - the base as [`resolve_base`] saw
    /// it when the run *branched* - and a run takes long enough that the base
    /// has usually moved by the time it gets here. A gate that ran there
    /// answers "green on the commit this run started from", not "green on
    /// what is about to land", and the difference showed up three times in
    /// one day as a green run whose merge would have reverted a file another
    /// pull request had already landed.
    ///
    /// Reuses [`crate::rebase::rebase_with_fixer`], the same routine
    /// `land::Step::Rebase` calls, rather than a second implementation of the
    /// same idea: a throwaway worktree, nothing runs in the primary tree, and
    /// a second rebase path is exactly the kind of drift `resolve_base`'s own
    /// doc warns about ("two answers to a question nobody notices until a
    /// diff is wrong").
    ///
    /// A conflict is not the end of the road: the standing rebase is handed
    /// to the fixer seat, at most `graph.review_rounds` times, counted in
    /// `state.rebase_fixes` (so it survives a park/resume and is shared with
    /// land). Once it finishes, review and the gate run as usual on the
    /// rebased tree, which is where a breakage the new base caused is caught
    /// by the ordinary gate-fix round. magi resolves nothing itself.
    ///
    /// Two different bounds, easy to confuse: [`BASE_SYNC_ROUNDS`], counted in
    /// `state.base_sync.attempts`, is how many times the base is *rebased
    /// onto* (a base that keeps moving); `rebase_fixes` is how many times a
    /// *conflict* was given to a fixer. When the fixer cannot finish the
    /// rebase the branch is restored, `state.base_sync.conflict` is set with
    /// what was tried (rounds spent, paths still conflicted) and the branch
    /// and worktree stay exactly as they were - untouched, for a person to
    /// look at - which is also what makes re-entering this function
    /// afterwards a no-op instead of a second attempt at the same wall. A
    /// push failure ends the same way.
    async fn sync_to_base(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        if self.state.status == RunStatus::AlreadyInBase {
            return Ok(());
        }
        let conflicted = self
            .state
            .base_sync
            .as_ref()
            .is_some_and(|s| s.conflict.is_some());
        let Some(winner) = self.state.winner().cloned() else {
            return Ok(());
        };

        let repo = self.state.repo.clone();
        let remote = self.state.config.merge.remote.clone();
        let base_branch = self.state.base_branch.clone();
        let tracking = format!("{remote}/{base_branch}");

        git::fetch(&repo, &remote, &base_branch).await.ok();
        // No network, or the remote never had this branch: the run already
        // started from a fetched `<remote>/<base>` (`resolve_base` refuses
        // otherwise), and one that got this far is not blocked by a fetch
        // that fails now. It just has no newer tip to compare against.
        let Ok(tip) = git::rev_parse(&repo, &tracking).await else {
            return Ok(());
        };

        let head = git::rev_parse(&winner.worktree, "HEAD").await?;
        let behind = git::commits_ahead(&repo, &head, &tip).await.unwrap_or(0);
        let attempts = self.state.base_sync.as_ref().map_or(0, |s| s.attempts);

        // Before any rebase, and before a recorded conflict is honoured: a
        // branch whose change reached the base under other commit ids has
        // nothing to rebase and nothing to conflict with, and a run that
        // already stopped on that phantom conflict recovers here on resume.
        // `behind == 0` with head == tip is a branch the base has since taken
        // in whole, whether or not a conflict was ever recorded: the ancestry
        // proof must still run (`classify` ignores a head still on the start
        // commit).
        if (behind > 0 || conflicted || head == tip)
            && self
                .settle_already_in(&winner.branch, &tip, &head, attempts, behind)
                .await?
        {
            return Ok(());
        }
        if conflicted {
            return Ok(());
        }

        if behind == 0 {
            // A fixer-finished rebase moves the branch ref before the
            // winner's worktree is told (`sync_to_head` below). A run that
            // died in between resumes here with `behind == 0` and a tree still
            // holding the pre-rebase files, which review and the gate would
            // then read. That state is exactly: HEAD moved off the tip the
            // rebase started from, yet the tree is still identical to that
            // tip. A tree with edits of its own differs from it, so nothing
            // is thrown away.
            if let Some(from) = self
                .state
                .rebase_fixes
                .iter()
                .rev()
                .find_map(|r| r.from.clone())
                && from != head
                && git::git_raw(&winner.worktree, &["diff", "--quiet", &from])
                    .await
                    .is_ok_and(|o| o.ok())
            {
                git::sync_to_head(&winner.worktree).await?;
            }
            // An earlier attempt may have rebased the branch locally and died
            // before pushing it (only the fresh-rebase arm below pushes).
            // Publish it now, so the plain push at PR time is not refused as
            // a non-fast-forward. A run already holding a recorded conflict
            // never reaches here; that case is out of scope.
            let conflict = self.publish_resumed_rebase(&winner.branch, &head).await;
            if let Some(why) = &conflict {
                self.state.status = RunStatus::Blocked;
                self.state.event("land", why.clone());
            }
            self.state.base_sync = Some(BaseSync {
                tip,
                behind: 0,
                attempts,
                conflict,
                already_in: None,
            });
            self.state.save()?;
            return Ok(());
        }

        if attempts >= BASE_SYNC_ROUNDS {
            let why = format!(
                "{base_branch} moved {behind} commit(s) ahead of {} after {BASE_SYNC_ROUNDS} \
                 rebase(s); rebasing again would only race it",
                winner.branch
            );
            self.state.status = RunStatus::Blocked;
            self.state.base_sync = Some(BaseSync {
                tip,
                behind,
                attempts,
                conflict: Some(why.clone()),
                already_in: None,
            });
            self.state.event("land", why);
            self.state.save()?;
            return Ok(());
        }

        self.state.event(
            "land",
            format!(
                "{base_branch} moved {behind} commit(s) ahead of {}; rebasing before verifying",
                winner.branch
            ),
        );
        self.state.save()?;

        // The remote's copy of the branch, read now and only if the fetch
        // really succeeded (a stale tracking ref must never pin a lease). It is
        // pushed over after a rebase only when it is a commit this branch
        // already contains, by ancestry or by patch (an earlier rebase of ours
        // that never reached the remote): anything else is somebody else's work.
        let branch_tracking = format!("{remote}/{}", winner.branch);
        let fetched_branch = git::fetch(&repo, &remote, &winner.branch).await;
        let remote_tip = if matches!(&fetched_branch, Ok(o) if o.ok()) {
            git::rev_parse(&repo, &branch_tracking).await.ok()
        } else {
            None
        };
        // A remote tip this branch does not contain is somebody else's work:
        // rebasing would leave a local tip that can never be pushed. Stop
        // before touching anything and say so.
        if let Some(theirs) = &remote_tip
            && !git::is_ancestor(&repo, theirs, &head).await
            && !crate::reconcile::origin_missing(&repo, &head, theirs)
                .await
                .is_ok_and(|missing| missing.is_empty())
        {
            let why = format!(
                "{branch_tracking} ({}) has commits {} does not contain; not rebasing over \
                 them",
                short(theirs),
                winner.branch
            );
            self.state.status = RunStatus::Blocked;
            self.state.base_sync = Some(BaseSync {
                tip,
                behind,
                attempts,
                conflict: Some(why.clone()),
                already_in: None,
            });
            self.state.event("land", why);
            self.state.save()?;
            return Ok(());
        }

        let scratch = self.state.dir().join("base-sync");
        let rebased = match crate::rebase::rebase_with_fixer(
            &mut self.state,
            &scratch,
            &winner.branch,
            &tracking,
        )
        .await
        {
            Ok(crate::rebase::Rebased::Applied) => Ok(None),
            Ok(crate::rebase::Rebased::Stopped(why)) => Ok(Some(why)),
            Err(e) => Err(e),
        };
        let attempts = attempts + 1;
        match rebased {
            Ok(None) => {
                // The branch ref moved, but a worktree that already had it
                // checked out (the winner's) was not told; sync its index and
                // files before anything reads them.
                git::sync_to_head(&winner.worktree).await?;
                refresh_reviewed_commits(&mut self.state, &winner.branch).await;
                let mut conflict = None;
                if let Some(pinned) = &remote_tip {
                    let pushed = git::push_pinned(&repo, &remote, &winner.branch, pinned).await;
                    match pushed {
                        Ok(o) if o.ok() => self.state.event(
                            "land",
                            format!("pushed rebased {} to {remote}", winner.branch),
                        ),
                        Ok(o) => {
                            conflict = Some(format!(
                                "rebased {} locally but {remote} refused the push (it moved                                  since {}; someone may have pushed): {}",
                                winner.branch,
                                short(pinned),
                                o.stderr.chars().take(600).collect::<String>()
                            ));
                        }
                        Err(e) => {
                            conflict = Some(format!(
                                "rebased {} locally but could not push it: {e:#}",
                                winner.branch
                            ));
                        }
                    }
                }
                if let Some(why) = &conflict {
                    self.state.status = RunStatus::Blocked;
                    self.state.event("land", why.clone());
                }
                self.state.base_sync = Some(BaseSync {
                    tip: tip.clone(),
                    behind: 0,
                    attempts,
                    conflict,
                    already_in: None,
                });
                self.state
                    .event("land", format!("rebased {} onto {tracking}", winner.branch));
            }
            Ok(Some(conflict)) => {
                let why = format!(
                    "{} conflicts with {tracking} and did not rebase: {}",
                    winner.branch,
                    conflict.chars().take(600).collect::<String>()
                );
                self.state.status = RunStatus::Blocked;
                self.state.base_sync = Some(BaseSync {
                    tip,
                    behind,
                    attempts,
                    conflict: Some(why.clone()),
                    already_in: None,
                });
                self.state.event("land", why);
            }
            Err(e) => {
                let why = format!("could not rebase {} onto {tracking}: {e:#}", winner.branch);
                self.state.status = RunStatus::Blocked;
                self.state.base_sync = Some(BaseSync {
                    tip,
                    behind,
                    attempts,
                    conflict: Some(why.clone()),
                    already_in: None,
                });
                self.state.event("land", why);
            }
        }
        self.state.save()?;
        Ok(())
    }

    /// Push a branch an earlier attempt rebased locally but never published,
    /// pinned to the remote tip read right after a successful fetch. Returns
    /// the reason when the run must stop; `None` when there was nothing to do
    /// (no remote copy, the same tip, or a remote copy this branch already
    /// contains, which the PR-time push fast-forwards) or the push succeeded.
    async fn publish_resumed_rebase(&mut self, branch: &str, head: &str) -> Option<String> {
        let repo = self.state.repo.clone();
        let remote = self.state.config.merge.remote.clone();
        let fetched = git::fetch(&repo, &remote, branch).await;
        if !matches!(&fetched, Ok(o) if o.ok()) {
            return None;
        }
        let branch_tracking = format!("{remote}/{branch}");
        let theirs = git::rev_parse(&repo, &branch_tracking).await.ok()?;
        if theirs == head || git::is_ancestor(&repo, &theirs, head).await {
            return None;
        }
        if !crate::reconcile::origin_missing(&repo, head, &theirs)
            .await
            .is_ok_and(|missing| missing.is_empty())
        {
            return Some(format!(
                "{branch_tracking} ({}) has commits {branch} does not contain; not pushing over \
                 them",
                short(&theirs)
            ));
        }
        match git::push_pinned(&repo, &remote, branch, &theirs).await {
            Ok(o) if o.ok() => {
                self.state
                    .event("land", format!("pushed rebased {branch} to {remote}"));
                None
            }
            Ok(o) => Some(format!(
                "{branch} is rebased locally but {remote} refused the push (it moved since {}; \
                 someone may have pushed): {}",
                short(&theirs),
                o.stderr.chars().take(600).collect::<String>()
            )),
            Err(e) => Some(format!(
                "{branch} is rebased locally but could not be pushed: {e:#}"
            )),
        }
    }

    /// End the run as [`RunStatus::AlreadyInBase`] when `head`'s whole change
    /// is already on `tip` under other commit ids ([`crate::already`]); returns
    /// whether it did.
    ///
    /// Checked only when the base is ahead of the branch. A failing check is
    /// "not proven" - the ordinary rebase path then decides - never a reason to
    /// stop the run.
    ///
    /// The remote copy of the branch is held to the same standard as the local
    /// one: if it carries a tip this worktree does not, that tip must itself be
    /// proven in the base, or nothing is settled (a pull request would
    /// otherwise be closed over commits nobody checked). The pull request is
    /// closed *before* the terminal status is saved; if that fails for a
    /// reason other than a refusal (no network, a `gh` error) the run is left
    /// `Blocked` with the reason as its conflict, which a resume retries -
    /// the same recovery a phantom conflict gets.
    async fn settle_already_in(
        &mut self,
        branch: &str,
        tip: &str,
        head: &str,
        attempts: usize,
        behind: usize,
    ) -> Result<bool> {
        let repo = self.state.repo.clone();
        let remote = self.state.config.merge.remote.clone();
        let start = self.state.base_commit.clone();
        let evidence = match crate::already::classify(&repo, tip, head, Some(&start)).await {
            Ok(Some(e)) => e,
            Ok(None) => return Ok(false),
            Err(e) => {
                tracing::warn!("already-in-base check for {branch}: {e:#}");
                return Ok(false);
            }
        };
        let mut verified = vec![head.to_owned()];
        let fetched = git::fetch(&repo, &remote, branch).await;
        if matches!(&fetched, Ok(o) if o.ok())
            && let Ok(theirs) = git::rev_parse(&repo, &format!("{remote}/{branch}")).await
            && theirs != head
        {
            match crate::already::classify(&repo, tip, &theirs, Some(&start)).await {
                Ok(Some(_)) => verified.push(theirs),
                _ => return Ok(false),
            }
        }
        let base_branch = self.state.base_branch.clone();
        let message = format!(
            "{branch} is already in {remote}/{base_branch} as {} ({} match); nothing left to \
             land",
            evidence.names(),
            evidence.proof.as_str()
        );
        let closed =
            crate::land::close_superseded_pr(&mut self.state, branch, &evidence, &verified).await;
        match closed {
            Ok(Ok(url)) => self
                .state
                .event("land", format!("closed {url}: superseded on {base_branch}")),
            Ok(Err(why)) => self
                .state
                .event("land", format!("did not close a pull request: {why}")),
            Err(e) => {
                let why = format!(
                    "{branch} is already in {remote}/{base_branch}, but its pull request could \
                     not be closed ({e:#}); resume to retry"
                );
                self.state.status = RunStatus::Blocked;
                self.state.base_sync = Some(BaseSync {
                    tip: tip.to_owned(),
                    behind,
                    attempts,
                    conflict: Some(why.clone()),
                    already_in: None,
                });
                self.state.event("land", why);
                self.state.save()?;
                return Ok(true);
            }
        }
        self.state.status = RunStatus::AlreadyInBase;
        self.state.base_sync = Some(BaseSync {
            tip: tip.to_owned(),
            behind,
            attempts,
            conflict: None,
            already_in: Some(evidence),
        });
        self.state.event("land", message);
        self.state.save()?;
        self.settle_questions();
        Ok(true)
    }

    /// The commit review and gate diff against: the tip [`Self::sync_to_base`]
    /// last landed the winner on, once it has run, else the commit the run
    /// branched from.
    ///
    /// Only [`Self::review_loop`] reads this. `prep`, `judge`, `deliberate`
    /// and `vote` all happen before there is a winner to rebase, so they
    /// compare every candidate against the branch point on purpose, and a
    /// base that moves after they are already done cannot change an answer
    /// they already gave.
    fn landing_base(&self) -> String {
        self.state
            .base_sync
            .as_ref()
            .map_or_else(|| self.state.base_commit.clone(), |s| s.tip.clone())
    }

    // ------------------------------------------------------- operator fix

    /// Route specific, already-recorded review findings to a fixer for a
    /// targeted, out-of-band fix on the winning branch — `magi fix`'s own
    /// entry point.
    ///
    /// Distinct from `review_loop`'s own fix step in three ways: it never
    /// runs a reviewer wave, it never spends review-round budget, and what
    /// happened is recorded as an [`OperatorFixRequest`] appended to
    /// [`RunState::operator_fixes`], never folded into a [`ReviewRound`] —
    /// see `run::SCHEMA`'s doc for schema 9 on why a reviewer's own severity
    /// and vote must never be rewritten to look like a manufactured blocking
    /// verdict.
    ///
    /// Only meaningful once review has actually concluded: `Ready` (handed
    /// off with findings still open, or simply concluded clean while minor
    /// findings sat unaddressed) or `Blocked` (round budget spent, or the
    /// gate failed). Everything else is refused: a run still in progress
    /// should simply be resumed, and a `Merged` run's branch has already
    /// landed — reopening *this* run's own record cannot change that, so the
    /// answer there is a fresh `magi review <branch>`.
    ///
    /// A real commit here re-verifies through a fresh, ordinary review-only
    /// run on the same branch ([`Self::review`]) rather than reopening this
    /// run's own `review_loop`: once any round in this run's history went
    /// clean, `review_conclusion` treats that as permanent by design (the
    /// same purity `gate`/`merge` rely on for safe reentry), so there is no
    /// way to force one more genuine reviewer wave out of *this* run without
    /// either rewriting history or weakening that guarantee for every other
    /// caller. A review-only run costs nothing extra — no implementation, no
    /// judging, no vote — and exercises the exact same review → verify →
    /// gate → (human) merge path, unmodified.
    pub async fn fix_selected(
        &mut self,
        ids: &[String],
        reason: &str,
        allow_stale: bool,
    ) -> Result<()> {
        let reason = reason.trim();
        if reason.is_empty() {
            bail!("a fix request needs a reason — that is the operator's own record of why");
        }
        if ids.is_empty() {
            bail!("no finding id given");
        }
        if !matches!(self.state.status, RunStatus::Ready | RunStatus::Blocked) {
            bail!(
                "run {} is `{}`; only a `ready` or `blocked` run — one whose review \
                 has already concluded — can be given a targeted fix. A run still \
                 in progress should simply be resumed; a `merged` run's branch has \
                 already landed, so its answer is a fresh `magi review <branch>`, \
                 not reopening this run's own record",
                self.state.id,
                self.state.status.as_str()
            );
        }
        let Some(winner) = self.state.winner().cloned() else {
            bail!("run {} has no winning candidate to fix", self.state.id);
        };
        if !git::branch_exists(&self.state.repo, &winner.branch).await? {
            bail!(
                "branch `{}` no longer exists; this run cannot be extended",
                winner.branch
            );
        }
        let home = crate::run::home();
        if crate::daemon::is_working_on(&home, &self.state.id, Timestamp::now()) {
            bail!(
                "run {} is currently being worked on by another magi process",
                self.state.id
            );
        }
        // Held for the rest of this call, including the follow-up review
        // below: two `magi fix` invocations against the same run must not
        // both reach the worktree manipulation further down, which would
        // otherwise race to remove and recreate the same directory — see
        // [`FixClaim`]'s own doc.
        let _claim = FixClaim::acquire(&self.state.dir())?;

        // Resolve every id before spending anything — an unknown id refuses
        // the whole request rather than silently dropping it — and dedup
        // while keeping the operator's own order.
        let mut seen = BTreeSet::new();
        let mut findings = Vec::new();
        let mut missing = Vec::new();
        for id in ids {
            if !seen.insert(id.clone()) {
                continue;
            }
            match self.state.finding(id) {
                Some((round, rec, f)) => findings.push(OperatorFixFinding {
                    id: f.id.clone(),
                    severity: f.severity,
                    reviewer_vote: rec.vote,
                    round: round.round,
                    round_head: round.head.clone(),
                    reviewer: rec.reviewer,
                    agent: rec.agent.clone(),
                    file: f.file.clone(),
                    line: f.line,
                    title: f.title.clone(),
                    detail: f.detail.clone(),
                    outcome: OperatorFixOutcome::Pending,
                }),
                None => missing.push(id.clone()),
            }
        }
        if !missing.is_empty() {
            bail!(
                "unknown finding id(s): {}; nothing was changed",
                missing.join(", ")
            );
        }

        let head_at_request = git::rev_parse(&self.state.repo, &winner.branch).await?;
        let stale_details: Vec<(String, String)> = findings
            .iter()
            .filter(|f| f.round_head != head_at_request)
            .map(|f| (f.id.clone(), f.round_head.clone()))
            .collect();
        let stale = !stale_details.is_empty();
        if stale && !allow_stale {
            bail!(
                "the branch has moved since some finding(s) were raised — {} — now \
                 at {}; pass --allow-stale to fix anyway, or re-run review first",
                stale_details
                    .iter()
                    .map(|(id, head)| format!("{id} (raised against {})", short(head)))
                    .collect::<Vec<_>>()
                    .join(", "),
                short(&head_at_request)
            );
        }

        let request = OperatorFixRequest {
            requested_at: Timestamp::now(),
            reason: reason.to_owned(),
            findings,
            head_at_request: head_at_request.clone(),
            allow_stale,
            stale,
            fix: None,
            result_head: None,
            follow_up_review_run: None,
        };
        self.state.event(
            "fix",
            format!(
                "operator requested a targeted fix on {} finding(s) ({}): {reason}",
                request.findings.len(),
                request
                    .findings
                    .iter()
                    .map(|f| f.id.as_str())
                    .collect::<Vec<_>>()
                    .join(", "),
            ),
        );
        // Recorded now, before any worktree work or the fixer call itself —
        // and re-saved at each checkpoint below: a crash at any point after
        // this (mid fixer call, mid follow-up review) must not lose the fact
        // that this was requested, for which findings, and why. Everything
        // past this point reads and writes through `request_index` rather
        // than a local variable, since `request` itself is moved here.
        self.state.operator_fixes.push(request);
        self.state.save()?;
        let request_index = self.state.operator_fixes.len() - 1;

        // A fresh, dedicated worktree for this one call, never the winner's
        // own worktree in place: that one may already be gone (folded away),
        // and reusing it in place would leave the branch checked out there
        // when the follow-up review below tries to check it out again. Freed
        // immediately after, either way — but only once confirmed clean:
        // `worktree_remove` is a `git worktree remove --force`, which would
        // otherwise discard uncommitted work left there by the operator or
        // another process before this had a chance to even look at it.
        if winner.worktree.exists() {
            // Lockfiles a rescue commit withheld stay untracked on purpose and
            // are already recorded; they are not the operator's work to protect.
            let dirty = git::git(
                &winner.worktree,
                &["status", "--porcelain", "--untracked-files=all"],
            )
            .await?;
            let only_withheld = dirty.lines().all(|l| {
                l.strip_prefix("?? ")
                    .is_some_and(|p| self.state.withheld.iter().any(|w| w.path == p))
            });
            if !only_withheld {
                bail!(
                    "`{}` has uncommitted changes; refusing to touch it — commit or \
                     discard them first",
                    winner.worktree.display()
                );
            }
            git::worktree_remove(&self.state.repo, &winner.worktree)
                .await
                .ok();
        }
        let fix_worktree = self.state.worktree_root().join("operator-fix");
        let fix_worktree_s = fix_worktree.to_string_lossy().to_string();
        git::git(
            &self.state.repo,
            &["worktree", "add", &fix_worktree_s, winner.branch.as_str()],
        )
        .await
        .with_context(|| format!("checking out `{}` for the fix", winner.branch))?;
        if !git::is_clean(&fix_worktree).await? {
            git::worktree_remove(&self.state.repo, &fix_worktree)
                .await
                .ok();
            bail!(
                "`{}` has uncommitted changes; refusing to start a fix on a dirty tree",
                winner.branch
            );
        }

        let run_id = self.state.id.clone();
        let prompts = self.state.config.prompts.clone();
        let language = self.state.config.graph.language.clone();
        let sessions = self.state.config.graph.sessions;
        let artifacts = agent::artifacts_dir(&self.state.dir());
        let finding_list: Vec<Finding> = self.state.operator_fixes[request_index]
            .findings
            .iter()
            .map(|f| Finding {
                id: f.id.clone(),
                severity: f.severity,
                file: f.file.clone(),
                line: f.line,
                title: f.title.clone(),
                detail: f.detail.clone(),
            })
            .collect();
        let fix_prompt = prompt::operator_fix(
            &self.state.instruction,
            &finding_list,
            reason,
            &stale_details,
            &head_at_request,
            &language,
        );
        let timeout = Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.timeout_fix);
        let (job, seat, out) = self
            .ask_fixer(&winner, "fix", None, |spec, seat| SeatJob {
                prompt: fix_prompt.clone(),
                spec,
                seat,
                cwd: fix_worktree.clone(),
                timeout,
                allow_write: true,
                sessions,
                artifacts: artifacts.clone(),
                stem: "operator-fix".to_owned(),
                handover: None,
            })
            .await;
        let agent_id = seat.agent.clone();

        let mut fix = FixRecord {
            agent: agent_id,
            addressed: Vec::new(),
            rejected: Vec::new(),
            notes: String::new(),
            committed: false,
            failed: None,
            duration_ms: 0,
            continuation: None,
        };
        let mut final_seat = seat.clone();
        match out {
            AgentOutcome::Ok(o) => {
                fix.duration_ms = o.duration_ms;
                let parsed = verdict::extract_json::<FixReport>(&o.text);
                let incomplete_reason = match &parsed {
                    Ok(_) if has_unconfirmed_command(&o.commands) => Some(
                        "the reply parsed, but it reported a command whose own CLI \
                         never confirmed an exit status"
                            .to_owned(),
                    ),
                    Ok(_) => None,
                    Err(e) => Some(e.to_string()),
                };
                match incomplete_reason {
                    None => {
                        let report = parsed.expect("checked Ok above");
                        fix.addressed = report.addressed;
                        fix.rejected = report.rejected;
                        fix.notes = blind::sanitize_prose(&report.notes, &self.state.config.blind);
                    }
                    Some(reason) => {
                        let (resumed_seat, resolved, failure, cont) = self
                            .continue_fix_report(seat, reason, &job, &prompts, &run_id, 0)
                            .await;
                        fix.duration_ms += cont.cumulative_wait_ms;
                        fix.continuation = Some(cont);
                        final_seat = resumed_seat;
                        match resolved {
                            Some(report) => {
                                fix.addressed = report.addressed;
                                fix.rejected = report.rejected;
                                fix.notes =
                                    blind::sanitize_prose(&report.notes, &self.state.config.blind);
                            }
                            None => fix.failed = failure,
                        }
                    }
                }
            }
            AgentOutcome::Dropped(o) => {
                fix.duration_ms = o.duration_ms;
                let why = o
                    .dropped
                    .as_ref()
                    .map(|d| d.why.as_str())
                    .unwrap_or("the CLI ended the stream without delivering its answer");
                fix.failed = Some(format!("the CLI dropped the stream ({why})"));
            }
            AgentOutcome::Quota(o) => {
                self.state.quota.push(QuotaLoss {
                    seat: final_seat.key.clone(),
                    node: "fix".to_owned(),
                    at: Timestamp::now(),
                    reset: o.quota.as_ref().and_then(|q| q.reset.clone()),
                });
                fix.failed = Some("rate limited (quota); fixer could not run".to_owned());
            }
            AgentOutcome::Failed(e) => fix.failed = Some(e),
        }
        if fix.continuation.is_none() {
            fix.continuation = Some(ContinuationRecord::not_needed());
        }
        self.state.seats.insert(final_seat.key.clone(), final_seat);

        let rescue_message = format!(
            "magi: operator-selected fix ({}) (uncommitted work)",
            self.state.operator_fixes[request_index]
                .findings
                .iter()
                .map(|f| f.id.as_str())
                .collect::<Vec<_>>()
                .join(", ")
        );
        if let Ok(r) = git::rescue_commit(&fix_worktree, &rescue_message).await {
            self.state.note_withheld("fix", &r.withheld);
        }
        let after = git::rev_parse(&fix_worktree, "HEAD").await?;
        fix.committed = after != head_at_request;
        git::worktree_remove(&self.state.repo, &fix_worktree)
            .await
            .ok();

        self.state.event(
            "fix",
            match &fix.failed {
                Some(reason) => format!(
                    "operator fix: adoption report was lost ({reason}); {}",
                    if fix.committed {
                        "committed"
                    } else {
                        "NO new commit"
                    }
                ),
                None => format!(
                    "operator fix: {} addressed, {} rejected, {}",
                    fix.addressed.len(),
                    fix.rejected.len(),
                    if fix.committed {
                        "committed"
                    } else {
                        "NO new commit"
                    }
                ),
            },
        );

        // Every selected finding gets an outcome — never left `Pending` once
        // the fixer's own turn is over. A report that never came back at all
        // marks every one of them `Unreported`, not silently "not addressed":
        // quota, a dropped stream, or an exhausted continuation are gaps in
        // the report, not evidence about the finding itself (see [`SCHEMA`]'s
        // doc for schema 9 and [`OperatorFixOutcome::Unreported`]).
        for f in &mut self.state.operator_fixes[request_index].findings {
            f.outcome = if fix.failed.is_some() {
                OperatorFixOutcome::Unreported
            } else if fix.addressed.contains(&f.id) {
                OperatorFixOutcome::Addressed
            } else if let Some(r) = fix.rejected.iter().find(|r| r.id == f.id) {
                OperatorFixOutcome::Rejected { why: r.why.clone() }
            } else {
                OperatorFixOutcome::Unreported
            };
        }

        let committed = fix.committed;
        if committed {
            self.state.operator_fixes[request_index].result_head = Some(after.clone());
        }
        self.state.operator_fixes[request_index].fix = Some(fix);
        // Saved again now that the fixer's own outcome is final, on top of
        // the save right after the request was first pushed above.
        self.state.save()?;

        if committed {
            self.state.event(
                "fix",
                format!(
                    "operator fix committed {}; opening a follow-up review-only run",
                    short(&after)
                ),
            );
            // The operator asked for the fix, and the follow-up serves whatever
            // task the run it follows served.
            let origin =
                Origin::operator().serving(self.state.origin.as_ref().and_then(|o| o.task.clone()));
            match Self::review(
                &self.state.repo,
                &winner.branch,
                self.state.config.clone(),
                origin,
            )
            .await
            {
                Ok(mut follow_up) => {
                    follow_up.state.event(
                        "start",
                        format!(
                            "requested by an operator fix on run {} for finding(s) {}",
                            self.state.id,
                            self.state.operator_fixes[request_index]
                                .findings
                                .iter()
                                .map(|f| f.id.as_str())
                                .collect::<Vec<_>>()
                                .join(", "),
                        ),
                    );
                    follow_up.state.save()?;
                    let follow_up_id = follow_up.state.id.clone();
                    // The follow-up is a run like any other: it belongs to the
                    // task of the run it follows, or to one filed for it.
                    let adopted = match crate::direct::adopt(
                        &follow_up.state,
                        self.state.origin.as_ref().and_then(|o| o.task.as_deref()),
                    ) {
                        Ok(a) => a,
                        Err(e) => {
                            // An ownerless run must not spend agent calls; it
                            // stays saved, and `magi run --resume` adopts it.
                            self.state.event(
                                "fix",
                                format!(
                                    "follow-up review {follow_up_id} got no owning task and was not executed: {e:#}"
                                ),
                            );
                            self.state.save()?;
                            return Ok(());
                        }
                    };
                    let executed = follow_up.execute().await;
                    let failure = executed.as_ref().err().map(|e| format!("{e:#}"));
                    if let Some(a) = adopted {
                        a.finish(&follow_up.state, executed);
                    }
                    if let Some(e) = failure {
                        self.state.event(
                            "fix",
                            format!(
                                "follow-up review {follow_up_id} did not complete cleanly: {e:#}"
                            ),
                        );
                    }
                    self.state.operator_fixes[request_index].follow_up_review_run =
                        Some(follow_up_id);
                }
                Err(e) => {
                    self.state.event(
                        "fix",
                        format!("committed the fix but could not open a follow-up review: {e:#}"),
                    );
                }
            }
            self.state.save()?;
        }

        Ok(())
    }

    // --------------------------------------------------------------- review

    /// Ask the fixer chain once for one fix call: the agents [`fixer::attempts`]
    /// names, in order, each at most once, moving on only when the call
    /// advances (an error, a quota hit or nothing usable - the same decision
    /// point `agent::chain_advances` is for the other chained roles).
    ///
    /// Each agent gets its own seat from `Runner::seat`: the same agent
    /// continues its conversation (the winner's own implementer seat when it
    /// is the winner's author, now that the competition is over), another
    /// takes a fresh one so the full prompt is sent again. A handover is
    /// recorded under `node`, which is what makes the fallback stick for the
    /// rest of the run (see `crate::fixer`). Only the last attempt's outcome
    /// is returned, so an exhausted chain reads exactly like a single failed
    /// fixer: one quota loss, the same wording, the same refund. An earlier
    /// attempt's edits are left in the tree and judged, with the final
    /// attempt's, by what git says afterwards.
    ///
    /// Returns the job that produced the outcome, for `continue_fix_report`.
    async fn ask_fixer(
        &mut self,
        winner: &Candidate,
        node: &'static str,
        round: Option<usize>,
        build: impl Fn(AgentSpec, SeatState) -> SeatJob,
    ) -> (SeatJob, SeatState, AgentOutcome) {
        let run_id = self.state.id.clone();
        let prompts = self.state.config.prompts.clone();
        let cache = self.state.config.cache_dir();
        let attempts = fixer::attempts(&self.state, &self.roles, winner);
        let ids: Vec<String> = attempts.iter().map(|(s, _)| s.id.clone()).collect();
        let mut last = None;
        for (i, (spec, key)) in attempts.into_iter().enumerate() {
            let seat = self.seat(&key, &spec.id);
            let mut job = build(spec.clone(), seat);
            if i > 0 {
                job.stem = format!("{}-{}", job.stem, spec.id);
            }
            let ctx = WaveCtx {
                carry_seats: false,
                run: &run_id,
                node,
                prompts: &prompts,
                cache: cache.as_deref(),
                round,
            };
            let (seat, out) =
                run_one(job.clone(), Arc::clone(&self.sem), &ctx, &mut self.state, 0).await;
            let advances = match &out {
                AgentOutcome::Ok(o) => agent::output_advances(o),
                _ => true,
            };
            if let Some(next) = ids.get(i + 1)
                && advances
            {
                self.state.seats.insert(seat.key.clone(), seat.clone());
                let class =
                    FailClass::of(&out).unwrap_or_else(|| FailClass::Other("unusable".to_owned()));
                let reason = match &out {
                    AgentOutcome::Ok(_) => "nothing usable".to_owned(),
                    other => fail_reason(other),
                };
                record_handover(
                    &mut self.state,
                    node,
                    &seat.key,
                    &spec.id,
                    next,
                    &class,
                    &reason,
                );
                continue;
            }
            last = Some((job, seat, out));
            break;
        }
        last.expect("the fixer chain always has an entry")
    }

    async fn review_loop(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        // A base that would not rebase is a person's decision, not a review
        // round: nothing here would change the answer, and reviewers and a
        // fixer would be spending real budget on a tree that cannot land
        // regardless of what they find.
        if self
            .state
            .base_sync
            .as_ref()
            .is_some_and(|s| s.conflict.is_some())
        {
            return Ok(());
        }
        // Attribution for every agent this node spawns: `MAGI_RUN` lets a task the
        // agent files with `magi task add` name the run that paid for it. The
        // prompt overlay is cloned alongside it because the waves borrow it
        // while `self` is mutably borrowed by the node's own bookkeeping.
        let run_id = self.state.id.clone();
        let prompts = self.state.config.prompts.clone();
        let Some(winner) = self.state.winner().cloned() else {
            return Ok(());
        };
        let max_rounds = self.state.config.graph.review_rounds;
        // A clean round, an exhausted round budget, or a stalled tree (see
        // `STAGNANT_LIMIT`) are all already-decided conclusions the moment
        // they are recorded — recomputed here, not read off `status`, so a
        // reentry into a run that already stopped restates the identical
        // verdict instead of silently handing back whatever an earlier node
        // in this same walk clobbered `status` to (a solo-candidate
        // `judge`/`deliberate` skip rewrites it on every reentry). The loop
        // below runs an empty range once the budget is spent, and would
        // otherwise fall through without touching `status` at all.
        if let Some(status) = review_conclusion(&self.state.reviews, max_rounds) {
            // A reentry after a crash between the last round's save and
            // `stop_reviewing` reaches the hand-off here, not there.
            if status == RunStatus::Gating {
                self.record_contested_handoff();
            }
            self.state.status = status;
            self.state.save()?;
            return Ok(());
        }
        self.state.status = RunStatus::Reviewing;
        // A last recorded round whose own verification never resolved
        // (`ResourceBlocked` — the shared build cache, not the patch) is
        // never a concluded round, whatever the round budget says: starting
        // a fresh round on top of it would spend a whole new reviewer wave
        // re-reading an unchanged patch instead of just retrying the one
        // check that actually needs it, and once the budget is spent the
        // loop below has nothing left to do at all (its range is empty).
        // Retry that check directly instead, exactly the same retry
        // `stop_reviewing` already does for its own catch-up case.
        if self
            .state
            .reviews
            .last()
            .is_some_and(|r| r.e2e_status() == E2eStatus::ResourceBlocked)
        {
            let shell = self.state.config.shell();
            return self
                .stop_reviewing(
                    "the last round's own verification never resolved",
                    &shell,
                    &winner.worktree,
                )
                .await;
        }

        let repo = self.state.repo.clone();
        let root = self.state.worktree_root();
        let language = self.state.config.graph.language.clone();
        let sessions = self.state.config.graph.sessions;
        let artifacts = agent::artifacts_dir(&self.state.dir());
        let base = self.landing_base();
        let base_short = short(&base);
        let reviewers = self.roles.reviewers.clone();
        let shell = self.state.config.shell();

        for round in (self.state.reviews.len() + 1)..=max_rounds {
            let head = git::rev_parse(&winner.worktree, "HEAD").await?;
            let patch = git::diff(&winner.worktree, &base, "HEAD").await?;
            let stat = git::diff_stat(&winner.worktree, &base, "HEAD").await?;
            // The prior round's own record, already persisted — never a
            // hand-carried variable of just its failing output: that is
            // exactly what let a round's e2e result drift out of sync with
            // which commit it was actually about (see `SCHEMA`'s doc for
            // schema 8). Judged against `head`, the commit reviewers are
            // about to look at now, so the summary always reads as "an
            // earlier head" here — this round's own patch has not been
            // checked yet.
            let prev_verification = self
                .state
                .reviews
                .last()
                .and_then(|r| r.verification_summary(&head));

            // Each reviewer gets its own detached checkout of exactly this
            // commit: nobody can perturb the winner's tree, and the fixer can
            // keep working without racing a reviewer.
            let mut jobs = Vec::new();
            for (r, spec) in reviewers.iter().cloned().enumerate() {
                let wt = root.join(format!("review-{}", r + 1));
                if wt.exists() {
                    git::reset_detached(&wt, &head).await?;
                } else {
                    git::worktree_add_detached(&repo, &wt, &head).await?;
                }
                let seat_key = format!("review-{}", r + 1);
                // The seat starts the round on whoever answered it last, not
                // on the agent the spec names, so a failure is not re-paid.
                let spec = pick_start_spec(
                    &self.roles.reviewer_roster,
                    spec,
                    self.state.seat_history.get(&seat_key),
                );
                let seat = self.seat(&seat_key, &spec.id);
                jobs.push(SeatJob {
                    prompt: prompt::review(&prompt::ReviewCtx {
                        instruction: &self.state.instruction,
                        branch: &winner.branch,
                        base_short: &base_short,
                        stat: &stat,
                        patch: &patch,
                        verification: prev_verification.as_ref(),
                        reviewers: reviewers.len(),
                        round,
                        rounds: max_rounds,
                        // A review-only run has no rankings, so nothing
                        // competed for this patch and the reviewer is told so.
                        competed: self.state.tally.as_ref().is_some_and(|t| t.rankings > 0),
                        lens: Lens::for_seat(r),
                        language: &language,
                    }),
                    spec,
                    seat,
                    cwd: wt,
                    timeout: Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.timeout_review),
                    allow_write: false,
                    sessions,
                    artifacts: artifacts.clone(),
                    stem: format!("review-{round}-{}", r + 1),
                    handover: None,
                });
            }

            self.state.event(
                "review",
                format!(
                    "round {round}: {} reviewers on {}",
                    jobs.len(),
                    short(&head)
                ),
            );
            let mut quota_losses = Vec::new();
            let review_retries = self.state.config.graph.retries;
            let review_cache = self.state.config.cache_dir();
            let ctx = WaveCtx {
                carry_seats: true,
                run: &run_id,
                node: "review",
                prompts: &prompts,
                cache: review_cache.as_deref(),
                round: Some(round),
            };
            let results = ask_json_wave::<Review>(
                jobs,
                Arc::clone(&self.sem),
                review_retries,
                &self.roles.reviewer_roster,
                &ctx,
                &mut quota_losses,
                &mut self.state,
                &|_: &Review| Ok(()),
            )
            .await;
            // Counted before the move below: how many of *this* round's
            // reviewer seats were lost to their own rate limit, as opposed to
            // a crash, a timeout, or unparsable output — see `round_is_clean`.
            let round_quota_missing = quota_losses.len();
            self.state.quota.extend(quota_losses);

            let mut records = Vec::new();
            let mut all_findings = Vec::new();
            for (r, (seat, res, attempts)) in results.into_iter().enumerate() {
                let agent_id = seat.agent.clone();
                self.state.seats.insert(seat.key.clone(), seat);
                let mut record = ReviewRecord {
                    reviewer: r + 1,
                    agent: agent_id,
                    summary: String::new(),
                    findings: Vec::new(),
                    vote: None,
                    failed: None,
                    duration_ms: 0,
                    // Set for both outcomes: `failed: Some(_)` with
                    // `attempts > 0` is a seat every retry still lost, not a
                    // recovered one — only `failed: None` with `attempts > 0`
                    // reads as "answered after a nudge" (see this field's own
                    // doc).
                    attempts,
                };
                match res {
                    Ok((review, out)) => {
                        // Sanitized here, at the point every other piece of
                        // agent prose in this file is (candidate summaries,
                        // deliberation turns, vote reasons): a reviewer's own
                        // words are the one thing about it that could name
                        // it, and reconsideration below broadcasts this same
                        // summary and these same findings to every other
                        // seat on the panel.
                        record.summary =
                            blind::sanitize_prose(&review.summary, &self.state.config.blind);
                        record.vote = Some(review.vote);
                        record.duration_ms = out.duration_ms;
                        for (n, mut f) in review.findings.into_iter().enumerate() {
                            // ids are magi's, never the agent's: the fixer's
                            // adoption report is keyed by them.
                            f.id = format!("R{round}-{}-{}", r + 1, n + 1);
                            f.title = blind::sanitize_prose(&f.title, &self.state.config.blind);
                            f.detail = blind::sanitize_prose(&f.detail, &self.state.config.blind);
                            // `file` is agent-supplied prose too, never
                            // checked against the real tree — the same
                            // exposure `title`/`detail` above have, just in
                            // a field easy to forget because it looks like a
                            // path rather than free text.
                            f.file = f
                                .file
                                .map(|file| blind::sanitize_prose(&file, &self.state.config.blind));
                            all_findings.push(f.clone());
                            record.findings.push(f);
                        }
                        self.state.event(
                            "review",
                            format!(
                                "round {round}: reviewer {} voted {} with {} finding(s)",
                                r + 1,
                                review.vote.label(),
                                record.findings.len()
                            ),
                        );
                    }
                    Err(e) => {
                        record.failed = Some(e.to_string());
                        self.state.event(
                            "review",
                            format!("round {round}: reviewer {} produced nothing: {e}", r + 1),
                        );
                    }
                }
                records.push(record);
            }

            // Tally the round's votes and, if they split, spend the one
            // round of reconsideration the split -> deliberate -> revote
            // shape `judge`/`vote` use for the panel, sized down to what a
            // read-only review round can afford: one round, and a revote
            // rather than an argument, because the panel already wrote its
            // reasoning down as findings the first time around.
            let initial_votes: Vec<ReviewVote> = records.iter().filter_map(|r| r.vote).collect();
            let vote_split =
                initial_votes.len() > 1 && !initial_votes.iter().all(|v| *v == initial_votes[0]);
            let mut reconsideration: Vec<ReviewRevoteRecord> = Vec::new();
            if vote_split {
                self.state.event(
                    "review",
                    format!(
                        "round {round}: votes split ({}) — one round of reconsideration",
                        initial_votes
                            .iter()
                            .map(|v| v.label())
                            .collect::<Vec<_>>()
                            .join(", ")
                    ),
                );
                // Seats read every seat's findings and votes, still numbered
                // and never named — the same anonymity `review` itself keeps.
                let panel: Vec<ReviewSeatReport<'_>> = records
                    .iter()
                    .filter_map(|r| {
                        r.vote.map(|vote| ReviewSeatReport {
                            reviewer: r.reviewer,
                            vote,
                            summary: &r.summary,
                            findings: &r.findings,
                        })
                    })
                    .collect();

                let mut jobs = Vec::new();
                let mut seats_at = Vec::new();
                for (r, spec) in reviewers.iter().cloned().enumerate() {
                    // A seat with no initial vote has nothing to reconsider
                    // from and stays absent, the same as it stayed absent
                    // from `panel` above.
                    if records[r].vote.is_none() {
                        continue;
                    }
                    let wt = root.join(format!("review-{}", r + 1));
                    let seat_key = format!("review-{}", r + 1);
                    let spec = self.occupant(&seat_key, spec);
                    let seat = self.seat(&seat_key, &spec.id);
                    // A seat with no live session has already forgotten the
                    // initial review's prompt — restate the patch it is
                    // voting on, the same as `deliberate`/`vote` do for a
                    // judge in the same position.
                    // The panel already carries this seat's own review and
                    // vote, so restating the patch makes the prompt whole for
                    // a seat handed to another agent.
                    let build = |with_patch: bool| {
                        prompt::review_reconsider(&ReviewReconsiderCtx {
                            instruction: &self.state.instruction,
                            reviewer: r + 1,
                            lens: Lens::for_seat(r),
                            panel: &panel,
                            patch: with_patch.then_some(ReviewPatch {
                                branch: &winner.branch,
                                base_short: &base_short,
                                stat: &stat,
                                patch: &patch,
                            }),
                            round,
                            rounds: max_rounds,
                            language: &language,
                        })
                    };
                    let full = build(true);
                    let prompt = if has_context(&spec, &seat, sessions) {
                        build(false)
                    } else {
                        full.clone()
                    };
                    jobs.push(SeatJob {
                        prompt,
                        spec,
                        seat,
                        cwd: wt,
                        timeout: Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.timeout_review),
                        allow_write: false,
                        sessions,
                        artifacts: artifacts.clone(),
                        stem: format!("review-{round}-reconsider-{}", r + 1),
                        handover: Some(full),
                    });
                    seats_at.push(r);
                }

                let mut recon_quota_losses = Vec::new();
                let recon_cache = self.state.config.cache_dir();
                let recon_ctx = WaveCtx {
                    carry_seats: true,
                    run: &run_id,
                    node: "review",
                    prompts: &prompts,
                    cache: recon_cache.as_deref(),
                    round: Some(round),
                };
                let recon_results = ask_json_wave::<ReviewRevote>(
                    jobs,
                    Arc::clone(&self.sem),
                    review_retries,
                    &self.roles.reviewer_roster,
                    &recon_ctx,
                    &mut recon_quota_losses,
                    &mut self.state,
                    &|_: &ReviewRevote| Ok(()),
                )
                .await;
                self.state.quota.extend(recon_quota_losses);

                for (&r, (seat, res, _attempts)) in seats_at.iter().zip(recon_results) {
                    let agent_id = seat.agent.clone();
                    self.state.seats.insert(seat.key.clone(), seat);
                    let mut rec = ReviewRevoteRecord {
                        reviewer: r + 1,
                        agent: agent_id,
                        vote: None,
                        reason: String::new(),
                        failed: None,
                    };
                    match res {
                        Ok((rv, _)) => {
                            rec.vote = Some(rv.vote);
                            rec.reason =
                                blind::sanitize_prose(&rv.reason, &self.state.config.blind);
                            self.state.event(
                                "review",
                                format!(
                                    "round {round}: reviewer {} revoted {}",
                                    r + 1,
                                    rv.vote.label()
                                ),
                            );
                        }
                        Err(e) => {
                            rec.failed = Some(e.to_string());
                            self.state.event(
                                "review",
                                format!("round {round}: reviewer {} did not revote: {e}", r + 1),
                            );
                        }
                    }
                    reconsideration.push(rec);
                }
            } else if initial_votes.len() > 1 {
                self.state.event(
                    "review",
                    format!(
                        "round {round}: votes agreed ({}) — no reconsideration",
                        initial_votes[0].label()
                    ),
                );
            }

            let blocking = all_findings.iter().filter(|f| f.severity.blocks()).count();
            let verify_timeout = Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.verify_timeout());
            // A round that already has a blocking finding and a round left to
            // try is going back to the fixer no matter what `verify.e2e`
            // says, so running it first only spends the loop's slowest step
            // (minutes, for a Rust repo's full test suite) on a head about
            // to be rewritten. Deferred, never skipped: `verify.e2e` still
            // runs once a round has no blocking findings left (see
            // `round_is_clean`, which a deferred — empty — `e2e` can never
            // satisfy since `blocking` is nonzero whenever this branch is
            // taken), and `stop_reviewing` forces a real run before it will
            // ever read a deferred round as green.
            let defer_e2e =
                blocking > 0 && round < max_rounds && !self.state.config.graph.e2e_every_round;
            let (e2e, verify_retried, e2e_deferred, e2e_defer_reason) = if defer_e2e {
                let reason =
                    format!("{blocking} blocking finding(s) already required a fix this round");
                self.state.event(
                    "verify",
                    format!(
                        "round {round}: {reason} — e2e deferred to the fixer (reviewed head \
                         {}); it will run once a round has none left",
                        short(&head)
                    ),
                );
                (Vec::new(), false, true, Some(reason))
            } else {
                let e2e_commands = self.state.config.verify.e2e.clone();
                let cache_dir = self.state.config.cache_dir();
                let context = format!("round {round}");
                let (e2e, verify_retried) = with_cache_lease(
                    &mut self.state,
                    cache_dir.as_deref(),
                    "e2e",
                    "e2e",
                    &winner.worktree,
                    &head,
                    verify_timeout,
                    &context,
                    |state, budget| {
                        let shell = shell.clone();
                        let e2e_commands = e2e_commands.clone();
                        let worktree = winner.worktree.clone();
                        let context = context.clone();
                        async move {
                            run_e2e_with_retry(
                                state,
                                &shell,
                                &e2e_commands,
                                &worktree,
                                budget,
                                &context,
                            )
                            .await
                        }
                    },
                )
                .await;
                (e2e, verify_retried, false, None)
            };

            let expected = records.len();
            let answered = records.iter().filter(|r| r.failed.is_none()).count();
            let incomplete = answered < expected;
            let e2e_ok = e2e.iter().all(CommandOutcome::ok);
            let policy = self.state.config.graph.incomplete_review;
            let clean = round_is_clean(
                blocking,
                e2e_ok,
                answered,
                expected,
                round_quota_missing,
                policy,
            );

            let mut round_record = ReviewRound {
                round,
                head: head.clone(),
                verified_head: None,
                verified_at: None,
                reviews: records,
                e2e,
                verify_retried,
                e2e_deferred,
                e2e_defer_reason,
                fix: None,
                blocking,
                answered,
                expected,
                clean,
                progressed: false,
                vote_split,
                reconsideration,
                verdict: None,
            };
            // The final vote per seat is its revote where reconsideration
            // ran and answered, its initial vote otherwise — the same
            // fallback `tally` uses for a judge whose private vote failed.
            round_record.verdict = ReviewVote::worst(
                round_record
                    .final_votes()
                    .into_iter()
                    .map(|(_, _, vote)| vote),
            );
            // Which commit and when magi actually attempted to check —
            // known the moment a command was dispatched against `head`,
            // whether or not it finished: a resource-blocked attempt still
            // targeted a specific commit at a specific time, and leaving
            // that unrecorded is exactly what made `verification_summary`
            // report a fresh attempt as "commit unknown ... recorded before
            // this was tracked", indistinguishable from a genuinely old,
            // untracked record. Only a deferred or unconfigured round never
            // ran at all and has nothing to record — see
            // `ReviewRound::verified_head`'s own doc.
            if !matches!(
                round_record.e2e_status(),
                E2eStatus::Deferred | E2eStatus::NotConfigured
            ) {
                round_record.verified_head = Some(head.clone());
                round_record.verified_at = Some(Timestamp::now());
            }
            let this_round_verification = round_record.verification_summary(&head);

            if incomplete {
                let missing: Vec<String> = round_record
                    .reviews
                    .iter()
                    .filter(|r| r.failed.is_some())
                    .map(|r| format!("review-{}", r.reviewer))
                    .collect();
                self.state.event(
                    "review",
                    format!(
                        "round {round}: {answered}/{expected} reviewer(s) answered ({} never answered)",
                        missing.join(", ")
                    ),
                );
            }

            if clean {
                self.state.event(
                    "review",
                    if incomplete && policy == IncompleteReviewPolicy::Warn {
                        format!(
                            "round {round}: clean (warn policy, incomplete panel) — no \
                             blocking findings from the seats that answered, verification green"
                        )
                    } else if incomplete {
                        format!(
                            "round {round}: clean ({} rate-limited reviewer(s) excluded from \
                             quorum) — no blocking findings from the seats that answered, \
                             verification green",
                            expected - answered
                        )
                    } else {
                        format!("round {round}: clean — no blocking findings, verification green")
                    },
                );
                self.state.reviews.push(round_record);
                self.state.status = RunStatus::Gating;
                self.state.save()?;
                return Ok(());
            }

            // Nothing was raised and verification passed, but not every seat
            // answered and `round_is_clean` still refused to call it clean —
            // either a seat is missing for a reason other than its own quota
            // (a crash, a timeout, unparsable output — worth another try), or
            // every seat that could have answered lost its quota and nobody
            // is left to decide on: re-review rather than send the fixer
            // after a round with nothing to fix.
            if incomplete && blocking == 0 && e2e_ok {
                self.state.reviews.push(round_record);
                self.state.save()?;
                if round == max_rounds {
                    self.state.status = RunStatus::Blocked;
                    self.state.event(
                        "review",
                        format!(
                            "{} reviewer seat(s) never answered after {max_rounds} rounds; \
                             refusing to call it clean",
                            expected - answered
                        ),
                    );
                    return Ok(());
                }
                continue;
            }

            // Nothing for the fixer to act on (`blocking == 0`) and the only
            // reason this round is not clean is that magi itself never got
            // a command to run — the shared build cache, not the patch (see
            // `CommandOutcome::resource_blocked`'s own doc). Sending that to
            // the fixer would invite a change to appease contention that has
            // nothing to do with the diff, and would leave this attempt
            // sitting in the next round's prompt as if it were about an
            // earlier, superseded commit rather than what it actually is:
            // the same head, still waiting to be checked. Wait for it the
            // same way the final round's own contention is already handled,
            // whatever round this happens to be.
            if blocking == 0 && round_record.e2e_status() == E2eStatus::ResourceBlocked {
                self.state.reviews.push(round_record);
                return self
                    .stop_reviewing(
                        "the round's own verification could not run",
                        &shell,
                        &winner.worktree,
                    )
                    .await;
            }

            if round == max_rounds {
                self.state.reviews.push(round_record);
                return self
                    .stop_reviewing(
                        &format!(
                            "{blocking} blocking finding(s) still open after {max_rounds} round(s)"
                        ),
                        &shell,
                        &winner.worktree,
                    )
                    .await;
            }

            // Fix. The winner's own implementer seat continues its conversation:
            // the competition is over, so context is pure benefit now.
            let blocking_findings: Vec<_> = all_findings
                .iter()
                .filter(|f| f.severity.blocks())
                .cloned()
                .collect();
            let fix_prompt = prompt::fix(
                &self.state.instruction,
                &blocking_findings,
                this_round_verification.as_ref(),
                round,
                max_rounds,
                &language,
            );
            let timeout = Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.timeout_fix);
            let before = git::rev_parse(&winner.worktree, "HEAD").await?;
            let (job, seat, out) = self
                .ask_fixer(&winner, "fix", Some(round), |spec, seat| SeatJob {
                    prompt: fix_prompt.clone(),
                    spec,
                    seat,
                    cwd: winner.worktree.clone(),
                    timeout,
                    allow_write: true,
                    sessions,
                    artifacts: artifacts.clone(),
                    stem: format!("fix-{round}"),
                    handover: None,
                })
                .await;
            let agent_id = seat.agent.clone();

            let mut fix = FixRecord {
                agent: agent_id,
                addressed: Vec::new(),
                rejected: Vec::new(),
                notes: String::new(),
                committed: false,
                failed: None,
                duration_ms: 0,
                continuation: None,
            };
            let mut continuation = ContinuationRecord::not_needed();
            let mut final_seat = seat.clone();
            match out {
                AgentOutcome::Ok(o) => {
                    fix.duration_ms = o.duration_ms;
                    let parsed = verdict::extract_json::<FixReport>(&o.text);
                    // A parsed report standing next to a command this same
                    // reply's own CLI never confirmed the exit status of is
                    // not a resolved answer — the identical `CommandEvidence`
                    // `state.jobs` renders, read here instead of only on
                    // display, per the completion judgment and the shown
                    // record needing to agree.
                    let incomplete_reason = match &parsed {
                        Ok(_) if has_unconfirmed_command(&o.commands) => Some(
                            "the reply parsed, but it reported a command whose own CLI never \
                             confirmed an exit status"
                                .to_owned(),
                        ),
                        Ok(_) => None,
                        Err(e) => Some(e.to_string()),
                    };
                    match incomplete_reason {
                        None => {
                            let report = parsed.expect("checked Ok above");
                            fix.addressed = report.addressed;
                            fix.rejected = report.rejected;
                            fix.notes =
                                blind::sanitize_prose(&report.notes, &self.state.config.blind);
                        }
                        Some(reason) => {
                            let (resumed_seat, resolved, failure, cont) = self
                                .continue_fix_report(seat, reason, &job, &prompts, &run_id, round)
                                .await;
                            fix.duration_ms += cont.cumulative_wait_ms;
                            continuation = cont;
                            final_seat = resumed_seat;
                            match resolved {
                                Some(report) => {
                                    fix.addressed = report.addressed;
                                    fix.rejected = report.rejected;
                                    fix.notes = blind::sanitize_prose(
                                        &report.notes,
                                        &self.state.config.blind,
                                    );
                                }
                                None => fix.failed = failure,
                            }
                        }
                    }
                }
                // The CLI's raw error JSON is not a fix report to parse.
                AgentOutcome::Dropped(o) => {
                    fix.duration_ms = o.duration_ms;
                    let why = o
                        .dropped
                        .as_ref()
                        .map(|d| d.why.as_str())
                        .unwrap_or("the CLI ended the stream without delivering its answer");
                    fix.failed = Some(format!("the CLI dropped the stream ({why})"));
                }
                AgentOutcome::Quota(o) => {
                    self.state.quota.push(QuotaLoss {
                        seat: final_seat.key.clone(),
                        node: "fix".to_owned(),
                        at: Timestamp::now(),
                        reset: o.quota.as_ref().and_then(|q| q.reset.clone()),
                    });
                    fix.failed = Some("rate limited (quota); fixer could not run".to_owned());
                }
                AgentOutcome::Failed(e) => fix.failed = Some(e),
            }
            fix.continuation = Some(continuation);
            self.state.seats.insert(final_seat.key.clone(), final_seat);
            if let Ok(r) = git::rescue_commit(
                &winner.worktree,
                &format!("magi: review round {round} fixes (uncommitted work)"),
            )
            .await
            {
                self.state.note_withheld("fix", &r.withheld);
            }
            let after = git::rev_parse(&winner.worktree, "HEAD").await?;
            fix.committed = after != before;
            // Judged by what `git` says moved against base, never by the
            // fixer's own `addressed`/`rejected` count — see
            // `ReviewRound::progressed`. Propagated with `?`, the same as the
            // `patch` snapshot above: swallowing this error would default
            // `diff_after` to empty, which almost always differs from a
            // non-empty `patch` and reads as "progressed" — exactly backwards
            // for a `git` failure the stagnation check cannot see through.
            let diff_after = git::diff(&winner.worktree, &base, "HEAD").await?;
            let progressed = diff_after != patch;
            let commit_note = if fix.committed {
                "committed"
            } else {
                "NO new commit"
            };
            let tree_note = if progressed {
                "changed vs base"
            } else {
                "unchanged vs base"
            };
            self.state.event(
                "fix",
                match &fix.failed {
                    // Distinct on purpose from "0 addressed, 0 rejected": the
                    // fixer's own diff still landed (blocking counts do keep
                    // falling round over round), only its adoption report did
                    // not come back, so this must never read like every
                    // finding was reviewed and declined.
                    Some(reason) => {
                        format!(
                            "round {round}: fixer's adoption report was lost ({reason}); \
                             {commit_note}, tree {tree_note}"
                        )
                    }
                    None => format!(
                        "round {round}: {} addressed, {} rejected, {commit_note}, tree \
                         {tree_note}{}",
                        fix.addressed.len(),
                        fix.rejected.len(),
                        if continuation.outcome == ContinuationOutcome::Resumed {
                            format!(
                                " (adoption report recovered after {} continuation(s))",
                                continuation.attempts
                            )
                        } else {
                            String::new()
                        },
                    ),
                },
            );
            round_record.fix = Some(fix);
            round_record.progressed = progressed;
            self.state.reviews.push(round_record);
            self.state.save()?;

            // The fixer's own report never came back this round, even after
            // `continue_fix_report`'s own budget was spent on it — not an
            // ordinary "no report" (dropped stream, quota, plain failure),
            // which already reads that way and is left to the existing round
            // budget. Stopping here, rather than opening another round, is
            // what keeps a next reviewer/fixer wave from ever being
            // dispatched onto `winner.worktree` while whatever the seat's
            // last call may still have running there is unaccounted for: no
            // process liveness check exists (and none is being added — see
            // AGENTS.md/this task's own scope), so the only way to honour
            // "nothing starts before a valid report returns" is to not start
            // anything further on this worktree from this run at all.
            if matches!(
                continuation.outcome,
                ContinuationOutcome::Exhausted
                    | ContinuationOutcome::QuotaLost
                    | ContinuationOutcome::NoSession
            ) {
                return self
                    .stop_reviewing(
                        "the fixer's adoption report never came back, even after resuming its \
                         own seat; refusing to start another round against the same worktree \
                         while that is unresolved",
                        &shell,
                        &winner.worktree,
                    )
                    .await;
            }

            let streak = self
                .state
                .reviews
                .iter()
                .rev()
                .take_while(|r| !r.progressed)
                .count();
            if streak >= STAGNANT_LIMIT {
                return self
                    .stop_reviewing(
                        &format!(
                            "the tree has not moved against base for {streak} round(s) in a row"
                        ),
                        &shell,
                        &winner.worktree,
                    )
                    .await;
            }
        }
        Ok(())
    }

    /// Decide, from the last recorded round's own verification, whether
    /// stopping the review loop is a hand-off or a genuine block.
    ///
    /// Called once the loop has given up trying — the round budget is spent,
    /// or the tree stopped moving (see [`STAGNANT_LIMIT`]) — with blocking
    /// findings still open, never while a round is still clean or the
    /// incomplete-panel case handled inline above. Gate and e2e are facts
    /// about the tree; a lingering review finding is an opinion, and this
    /// workload's own `magi stats` puts reviewer precision low enough
    /// (12-33%, 0.18-0.29 adopted per round) that a panel of open findings
    /// must not by itself stand between a green, verified change and the
    /// human who decides what to do with it. A red e2e is not an opinion, so
    /// that case still blocks, with the failing command and a tail of its
    /// output recorded here rather than left in `run.json` for someone to go
    /// find.
    ///
    /// A round that deferred its own e2e (see [`Config::graph`]'s
    /// `e2e_every_round`) is never read as that green: its `e2e` is empty
    /// only because nothing ran, and treating an empty list as a passing one
    /// here is exactly the "deferred painted green" bug this function exists
    /// to not have. When the last round's own verification never resolved —
    /// deferred on purpose, or a real attempt the shared build cache blocked
    /// — this makes (or retries) the real run, on the actual worktree this
    /// loop is about to stop touching, before deciding anything. A
    /// resource-blocked attempt is likewise never read as either green or
    /// red: it is evidence about the machine, not the patch (see
    /// [`CommandOutcome::resource_blocked`]'s own doc), so a persistently
    /// blocked cache leaves this call without deciding rather than guessing
    /// — the caller retries on a later reentry.
    /// Record, once, that the review loop handed off over a blocking finding
    /// a reviewer rejected on (see [`ReviewRound::contested_handoff`]), so
    /// `land` asks the owner even with `land_approval` off. Called from every
    /// path that concludes `Gating`; a reentry keeps the first record.
    fn record_contested_handoff(&mut self) {
        if self.state.contested_handoff.is_some() {
            return;
        }
        let Some(contested) = self
            .state
            .reviews
            .last()
            .and_then(ReviewRound::contested_handoff)
        else {
            return;
        };
        self.state.event(
            "review",
            format!(
                "{} blocking finding(s) open and {} reviewer(s) rejecting — the merge will \
                 wait for the owner's approval",
                contested.findings.len(),
                contested.rejecters.len()
            ),
        );
        self.state.contested_handoff = Some(contested);
    }

    async fn stop_reviewing(&mut self, why: &str, shell: &[String], worktree: &Path) -> Result<()> {
        let round_idx = self.state.reviews.len() - 1;
        // A deferred round and a resource-blocked one are the same shape
        // here: neither has a real result yet, and both get one more
        // attempt. Read off `e2e_status` — the single source for this —
        // rather than `e2e.is_empty()` alone, so a resource-blocked attempt
        // (whose `e2e` is *not* empty; see `CommandOutcome::resource_blocked`)
        // still retries instead of being read as a settled result the
        // instant it stops being empty.
        let needs_catchup_run = matches!(
            self.state.reviews[round_idx].e2e_status(),
            E2eStatus::Deferred | E2eStatus::ResourceBlocked
        );
        if needs_catchup_run {
            let round = self.state.reviews[round_idx].round;
            let timeout = Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.verify_timeout());
            let commands = self.state.config.verify.e2e.clone();
            let attempted_head = git::rev_parse(worktree, "HEAD").await?;
            let cache_dir = self.state.config.cache_dir();
            let context = format!(
                "round {round}: verification unresolved, catching up before the final decision"
            );
            let (outcomes, verify_retried) = with_cache_lease(
                &mut self.state,
                cache_dir.as_deref(),
                "e2e",
                "e2e",
                worktree,
                &attempted_head,
                timeout,
                &context,
                |state, budget| {
                    let shell = shell.to_vec();
                    let commands = commands.clone();
                    let context = context.clone();
                    async move {
                        run_e2e_with_retry(state, &shell, &commands, worktree, budget, &context)
                            .await
                    }
                },
            )
            .await;
            let last = &mut self.state.reviews[round_idx];
            last.e2e = outcomes;
            last.verify_retried = verify_retried;
            // Always the commit and time this attempt actually targeted,
            // whether or not it happens to equal the reviewed `head` and
            // whether or not a command finished — see
            // `ReviewRound::verified_head`'s own doc. A still-inconclusive
            // attempt is recorded too, so a later reader sees "attempted
            // again at T2" rather than silence.
            last.verified_head = Some(attempted_head);
            last.verified_at = Some(Timestamp::now());
            if verify_inconclusive(&last.e2e) {
                // Still not a real result: `e2e_deferred` is left exactly
                // as it was, so `needs_catchup_run` above reads
                // `ResourceBlocked` (via `e2e_status`, which checks
                // `resource_blocked` before `e2e_deferred`) and retries
                // again on the next reentry, rather than recording
                // contention as a red e2e and blocking the run on it.
                self.state.save()?;
                return Ok(());
            }
            last.e2e_deferred = false;
        }
        let last = &self.state.reviews[round_idx];
        let open: usize = last.reviews.iter().map(|r| r.findings.len()).sum();

        match last.e2e_status() {
            E2eStatus::Failed => {
                let red: Vec<String> = last
                    .e2e
                    .iter()
                    .filter(|o| !o.ok())
                    .map(|o| {
                        format!(
                            "`{}` -> {:?}\n{}",
                            o.command,
                            o.code,
                            tail(&o.output_tail, EVENT_OUTPUT_TAIL)
                        )
                    })
                    .collect();
                self.state
                    .event("review", format!("{why}; e2e failed:\n{}", red.join("\n")));
                self.state.status = RunStatus::Blocked;
            }
            // `needs_catchup_run` above already retried once this call; if
            // it is still blocked, this is magi's own admission it could
            // not get a command to run, never a verdict on the patch — the
            // run is left exactly where a later reentry can retry again.
            E2eStatus::ResourceBlocked => {
                self.state.event(
                    "review",
                    format!(
                        "{why}; e2e could not run (shared build cache unavailable); not \
                         deciding yet"
                    ),
                );
            }
            E2eStatus::Passed | E2eStatus::Deferred | E2eStatus::NotConfigured => {
                self.state.event(
                    "review",
                    format!("{why}; e2e is green — handing off with {open} finding(s) still open"),
                );
                self.record_contested_handoff();
                self.state.status = RunStatus::Gating;
            }
        }
        self.state.save()?;
        Ok(())
    }

    // ----------------------------------------------------------------- gate

    async fn gate(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        // Judged by the review record itself, not by `status`: a solo
        // candidate's `judge`/`deliberate` skip rewrites `status` on every
        // reentry (see `judge`), and trusting it here is exactly how a run
        // that exhausted its review budget got gated and merged a second
        // time around. `review_conclusion` recomputes the review loop's own
        // verdict from the round records themselves — `Gating` for a clean
        // round or a hand-off (see `stop_reviewing`), anything else means the
        // loop is still going or genuinely blocked.
        // A base the winner could not be replayed onto is a decision, not a
        // round: there is no landing tree to gate. Read as its own record for
        // the same reason the review verdict is.
        if self.state.status == RunStatus::Failed
            || self
                .state
                .base_sync
                .as_ref()
                .is_some_and(|s| s.conflict.is_some())
            || review_conclusion(&self.state.reviews, self.state.config.graph.review_rounds)
                != Some(RunStatus::Gating)
        {
            return Ok(());
        }
        if self.state.gate_ran {
            // `review_loop` derives its conclusion from the clean review
            // record on every reentry and therefore puts a completed run back
            // in `Gating`. A recorded gate is a stronger, terminal fact:
            // retain its original command output (or lack of any, for a repo
            // with no `verify.gate` commands — see `RunState::gate_ran`'s own
            // doc) and restore `Blocked` on a real failure rather than
            // pretending the command is still running or running it a second
            // time. `gate_ran == false` remains the only shape — unattempted,
            // or a resource-blocked retry — that may still need to execute a
            // command.
            if self.state.gate.iter().any(|outcome| !outcome.ok()) {
                self.state.status = RunStatus::Blocked;
                self.state.save()?;
            }
            return Ok(());
        }
        let Some(winner) = self.state.winner().cloned() else {
            return Ok(());
        };
        self.state.status = RunStatus::Gating;
        let mut outcomes = self.run_gate(&winner).await?;
        loop {
            // A resource-blocked outcome means the gate command never actually
            // ran - the shared build cache could not be acquired or confirmed
            // fresh in time - which is evidence about the machine, not about
            // the tree (see `CommandOutcome::resource_blocked`'s own doc).
            // Recording it as a red gate would mark a run `Blocked` on nothing
            // but contention magi has already logged; leaving `self.state.gate`
            // empty and `self.state.gate_ran` false instead keeps the shape
            // this function already treats as "still needs to run" (see the
            // early-return above), so the next call retries the command
            // rather than concluding anything.
            if verify_inconclusive(&outcomes) {
                self.state.save()?;
                return Ok(());
            }
            if outcomes.iter().all(CommandOutcome::ok) {
                break;
            }
            match self.gate_fix_round(&winner, &outcomes).await? {
                GateFix::Retry => outcomes = self.run_gate(&winner).await?,
                GateFix::Stop => break,
                GateFix::Defer => {
                    self.state.save()?;
                    return Ok(());
                }
            }
        }
        let passed = outcomes.iter().all(CommandOutcome::ok);
        self.state.gate = outcomes;
        self.state.gate_ran = true;
        if !passed {
            self.state.status = RunStatus::Blocked;
            let spent = self.state.gate_fixes.len();
            self.state.event(
                "gate",
                if spent == 0 {
                    "gate failed; not merging".to_owned()
                } else {
                    format!("gate failed after {spent} gate-fix round(s); not merging")
                },
            );
        }
        self.state.save()?;
        Ok(())
    }

    /// Run `verify.pre_gate` in the winner's worktree, then fold whatever it
    /// changed into one commit. Reached only from [`Self::run_gate`], i.e.
    /// after review is clean and never on a candidate awaiting judging.
    ///
    /// Never fails the run: a non-zero exit or timeout is a warning and a
    /// recorded outcome, and the gate remains the single arbiter. Nothing
    /// configured means nothing happens - no event, no commit. `commit_all`
    /// commits any leftover change under the neutral identity and returns
    /// `false` when the tree is clean, so no empty commit is ever made.
    async fn run_pre_gate(&mut self, winner: &Candidate) {
        let commands = self.state.config.verify.pre_gate.clone();
        if commands.is_empty() {
            return;
        }
        let shell = self.state.config.shell();
        let timeout = Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.verify_timeout());
        let (outcomes, _) = run_commands(
            &mut self.state,
            "pre_gate",
            "pre_gate",
            0,
            &shell,
            &commands,
            &winner.worktree,
            timeout,
        )
        .await;
        for o in &outcomes {
            if !o.ok() {
                tracing::warn!(
                    "pre_gate `{}` failed ({:?}); the gate decides",
                    o.command,
                    o.code
                );
            }
            self.state.event(
                "pre_gate",
                format!(
                    "`{}` -> {}",
                    o.command,
                    if o.ok() {
                        "pass".to_owned()
                    } else {
                        format!(
                            "FAIL ({:?})\n{}",
                            o.code,
                            tail(&o.output_tail, EVENT_OUTPUT_TAIL)
                        )
                    }
                ),
            );
        }
        self.state.pre_gate = outcomes;
        match git::commit_all(&winner.worktree, "magi: pre_gate (mechanical fixes)").await {
            Ok(true) => match git::rev_parse(&winner.worktree, "HEAD").await {
                Ok(head) => {
                    self.state
                        .event("pre_gate", format!("committed mechanical fixes ({head})"));
                    self.state.pre_gate_commit = Some(head);
                }
                Err(e) => tracing::warn!("pre_gate committed but HEAD unreadable: {e:#}"),
            },
            Ok(false) => {}
            Err(e) => tracing::warn!("pre_gate could not commit its changes: {e:#}"),
        }
        if let Err(e) = self.state.save() {
            tracing::warn!("could not persist the pre_gate record: {e:#}");
        }
    }

    /// Run `verify.gate` once against the winner's current tree, logging one
    /// event per command. Empty when nothing is configured.
    async fn run_gate(&mut self, winner: &Candidate) -> Result<Vec<CommandOutcome>> {
        self.run_pre_gate(winner).await;
        let shell = self.state.config.shell();
        let gate_commands = self.state.config.verify.gate.clone();
        // Zero commands has nothing to run and nothing that could touch the
        // shared build cache, so it never needs a lease: `Config::cache_dir`
        // is derived from `verify.e2e` too, so a repo with no `verify.gate`
        // commands but a `CARGO_TARGET_DIR`-using `verify.e2e` would
        // otherwise queue behind an unrelated run's lease and come back
        // resource-blocked - `gate_ran` would stay false on nothing but
        // cache contention, for a step that had nothing to check in the
        // first place.
        let outcomes = if gate_commands.is_empty() {
            Vec::new()
        } else {
            let timeout = Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.verify_timeout());
            let cache_dir = self.state.config.cache_dir();
            let head = git::rev_parse(&winner.worktree, "HEAD").await?;
            let (outcomes, _) = with_cache_lease(
                &mut self.state,
                cache_dir.as_deref(),
                "gate",
                "gate",
                &winner.worktree,
                &head,
                timeout,
                "final gate",
                |state, budget| {
                    let shell = shell.clone();
                    let gate_commands = gate_commands.clone();
                    let worktree = winner.worktree.clone();
                    async move {
                        let (outcomes, timed_out_pids) = run_commands(
                            state,
                            "gate",
                            "gate",
                            0,
                            &shell,
                            &gate_commands,
                            &worktree,
                            budget,
                        )
                        .await;
                        (outcomes, false, timed_out_pids)
                    }
                },
            )
            .await;
            outcomes
        };
        if outcomes.is_empty() {
            // Nothing configured to check — distinct from every other
            // silence in this run's event log, since an empty `gate` alone
            // no longer says whether the gate ran at all (see
            // `RunState::gate_ran`'s own doc).
            self.state.event(
                "gate",
                "no gate commands configured; nothing to check, passing",
            );
        }
        for o in &outcomes {
            self.state.event(
                "gate",
                format!(
                    "`{}` -> {}",
                    o.command,
                    if o.ok() {
                        "pass".to_owned()
                    } else {
                        format!(
                            "FAIL ({:?})\n{}",
                            o.code,
                            tail(&o.output_tail, EVENT_OUTPUT_TAIL)
                        )
                    }
                ),
            );
        }
        Ok(outcomes)
    }

    /// One bounded fix round for a failing gate.
    ///
    /// The fixer is told the failure came from the gate itself, not from a
    /// reviewer, and is shown the failed commands, their exit codes and a tail
    /// of their output - whatever `[verify].gate` holds, nothing here knows
    /// what those commands run. Only a normal non-zero exit that printed
    /// something earns a round (see [`gate_fixable`]): a timeout, a missing
    /// command or a full disk says nothing about the code, and a fixer sent
    /// after it can only appease the machine. The round is judged by what git
    /// says moved, never by the fixer's own report, and `verify.e2e` runs
    /// again before the gate does, so a fix cannot trade a green gate for a
    /// red e2e unnoticed.
    async fn gate_fix_round(
        &mut self,
        winner: &Candidate,
        outcomes: &[CommandOutcome],
    ) -> Result<GateFix> {
        let cap = self.state.config.graph.gate_fix_rounds;
        let spent = self.state.gate_fixes.len();
        if spent >= cap {
            if cap > 0 {
                self.state.event(
                    "gate",
                    format!("{spent} gate-fix round(s) spent and the gate still fails"),
                );
            }
            return Ok(GateFix::Stop);
        }
        if !gate_fixable(outcomes) {
            self.state.event(
                "gate",
                "gate failure is not an ordinary non-zero exit with output (timeout, missing \
                 command or similar); not spending a fix round on it",
            );
            return Ok(GateFix::Stop);
        }
        let min_free = self.state.config.disk.min_free_bytes;
        if min_free > 0 {
            match crate::disk::free_bytes(&winner.worktree) {
                Ok(free) if crate::disk::enough_space(free, min_free) => {}
                Ok(free) => {
                    self.state.event(
                        "gate",
                        format!(
                            "only {free} bytes free ({min_free} required by `[disk] \
                             min_free_bytes`); not spending a fix round on a failure the disk \
                             may explain"
                        ),
                    );
                    return Ok(GateFix::Stop);
                }
                Err(e) => {
                    self.state.event(
                        "gate",
                        format!("free disk space could not be measured ({e:#}); no fix round"),
                    );
                    return Ok(GateFix::Stop);
                }
            }
        }

        let attempt = spent + 1;
        let failed: Vec<CommandOutcome> = outcomes.iter().filter(|o| !o.ok()).cloned().collect();
        let base = self.landing_base();
        let fix_prompt = prompt::gate_fix(
            &self.state.instruction,
            &failed,
            attempt,
            cap,
            &self.state.config.graph.language,
        );
        let timeout = Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.timeout_fix);
        let sessions = self.state.config.graph.sessions;
        let artifacts = agent::artifacts_dir(&self.state.dir());
        self.state.event(
            "gate",
            format!("gate failed; gate-fix round {attempt} of {cap}"),
        );
        let before = git::rev_parse(&winner.worktree, "HEAD").await?;
        let patch = git::diff(&winner.worktree, &base, "HEAD").await?;
        let (_, seat, out) = self
            .ask_fixer(winner, "gate-fix", None, |spec, seat| SeatJob {
                prompt: fix_prompt.clone(),
                spec,
                seat,
                cwd: winner.worktree.clone(),
                timeout,
                allow_write: true,
                sessions,
                artifacts: artifacts.clone(),
                stem: format!("gate-fix-{attempt}"),
                handover: None,
            })
            .await;
        let mut record = GateFixRecord {
            agent: seat.agent.clone(),
            failed,
            notes: String::new(),
            committed: false,
            error: None,
        };
        match out {
            AgentOutcome::Ok(o) => {
                // A missing report is not a failed fix: the round is judged
                // by the tree below, and the report only carries prose.
                if let Ok(report) = verdict::extract_json::<FixReport>(&o.text) {
                    record.notes = blind::sanitize_prose(&report.notes, &self.state.config.blind);
                }
            }
            AgentOutcome::Dropped(_) => {
                record.error = Some("the CLI dropped the stream".to_owned());
            }
            AgentOutcome::Quota(o) => {
                self.state.quota.push(QuotaLoss {
                    seat: seat.key.clone(),
                    node: "gate-fix".to_owned(),
                    at: Timestamp::now(),
                    reset: o.quota.as_ref().and_then(|q| q.reset.clone()),
                });
                record.error = Some("rate limited (quota); fixer could not run".to_owned());
            }
            AgentOutcome::Failed(e) => record.error = Some(e),
        }
        self.state.seats.insert(seat.key.clone(), seat);
        if let Ok(r) = git::rescue_commit(
            &winner.worktree,
            &format!("magi: gate fix {attempt} (uncommitted work)"),
        )
        .await
        {
            self.state.note_withheld("gate-fix", &r.withheld);
        }
        let after = git::rev_parse(&winner.worktree, "HEAD").await?;
        record.committed = after != before;
        let changed = git::diff(&winner.worktree, &base, "HEAD").await? != patch;
        let note = record.error.clone();
        self.state.gate_fixes.push(record);
        self.state.save()?;
        if !changed {
            self.state.event(
                "gate",
                match note {
                    Some(why) => format!("gate-fix round {attempt}: fixer failed ({why})"),
                    None => format!("gate-fix round {attempt}: the tree did not change"),
                },
            );
            return Ok(GateFix::Stop);
        }
        self.state.event(
            "gate",
            format!("gate-fix round {attempt}: tree changed vs base; re-running verify.e2e"),
        );

        let commands = self.state.config.verify.e2e.clone();
        if !commands.is_empty() {
            let shell = self.state.config.shell();
            let timeout = Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.verify_timeout());
            let cache_dir = self.state.config.cache_dir();
            let context = format!("gate-fix round {attempt}");
            let (e2e, _) = with_cache_lease(
                &mut self.state,
                cache_dir.as_deref(),
                "e2e",
                "e2e",
                &winner.worktree,
                &after,
                timeout,
                &context,
                |state, budget| {
                    let shell = shell.clone();
                    let commands = commands.clone();
                    let context = context.clone();
                    let worktree = winner.worktree.clone();
                    async move {
                        run_e2e_with_retry(state, &shell, &commands, &worktree, budget, &context)
                            .await
                    }
                },
            )
            .await;
            if verify_inconclusive(&e2e) {
                return Ok(GateFix::Defer);
            }
            if e2e.iter().any(|o| !o.ok()) {
                self.state.event(
                    "gate",
                    format!("gate-fix round {attempt}: verify.e2e failed after the fix"),
                );
                return Ok(GateFix::Stop);
            }
        }
        Ok(GateFix::Retry)
    }

    // ---------------------------------------------------------------- merge

    /// One read-only rewrite by the summary's author, followed by a fixed fallback.
    async fn guarded_pr_message(
        &mut self,
        winner: &Candidate,
        facts: Option<&BranchFacts>,
        posting: bool,
    ) -> PrMessage {
        let mut pr = pr_message_raw(&self.state, winner.label, facts);
        if !posting {
            let identity = crate::scrub::Identity::current();
            return PrMessage {
                title: crate::scrub::scrub(&pr.title, &identity),
                body: crate::scrub::scrub(&pr.body, &identity),
            };
        }
        let mut decision = self.judge_pr_language(&winner.worktree, &pr).await;
        let mut violations = crate::github_text::check_with(&pr.title, &pr.body, decision);
        let identity = crate::scrub::Identity::current();
        if (crate::scrub::scrub(&pr.title, &identity) != pr.title
            || crate::scrub::scrub(&pr.body, &identity) != pr.body)
            && !violations.contains(&crate::github_text::Violation::SensitiveData)
        {
            violations.push(crate::github_text::Violation::SensitiveData);
        }
        // Sensitive-only hits are handled by `prepare`'s span redaction; a
        // rewrite cannot fix them (e.g. a quoted original task) and the
        // fallback would discard a useful description.
        violations.retain(|v| *v != crate::github_text::Violation::SensitiveData);
        if self.state.config.graph.github_text_guard && !violations.is_empty() {
            self.state.event(
                "github-text",
                format!("description rejected: {violations:?}; requesting one rewrite"),
            );
            let mut rewritten = false;
            if let Some(spec) = self
                .state
                .config
                .agents
                .iter()
                .find(|a| a.id == winner.agent)
                .cloned()
            {
                let key = format!("impl-{}", winner.label);
                let seat = self.seat(&key, &spec.id);
                let prompt = format!(
                    "Rewrite only the following pull request description. The posting gate reported {violations:?}. Write English prose and remove all machine or operator identifying data and secrets. Do not edit files or run commands. Return TITLE: followed by the title, then the complete Markdown body. Preserve the magi run marker.\n\nTITLE: {}\n{}",
                    pr.title, pr.body
                );
                let job = SeatJob {
                    spec,
                    seat,
                    cwd: winner.worktree.clone(),
                    prompt,
                    timeout: retry_budget(
                        Duration::from_secs(self.state.config.graph.timeout_implement),
                        true,
                    ),
                    allow_write: false,
                    sessions: self.state.config.graph.sessions,
                    artifacts: agent::artifacts_dir(&self.state.dir()),
                    stem: "github-text-rewrite".to_owned(),
                    handover: None,
                };
                let prompts = self.state.config.prompts.clone();
                let cache = self.state.config.cache_dir();
                let run = self.state.id.clone();
                let ctx = WaveCtx {
                    run: &run,
                    node: "github-text",
                    prompts: &prompts,
                    cache: cache.as_deref(),
                    round: None,
                    carry_seats: false,
                };
                let (seat, outcome) =
                    run_one(job, Arc::clone(&self.sem), &ctx, &mut self.state, 1).await;
                self.state.seats.insert(seat.key.clone(), seat);
                if let AgentOutcome::Ok(output) = outcome
                    && let Some(title) = summary_title(&output.text)
                {
                    let mut body = summary_without_title(&output.text);
                    let rewrite = PrMessage {
                        title: title.clone(),
                        body: body.clone(),
                    };
                    let redecision = self.judge_pr_language(&winner.worktree, &rewrite).await;
                    if !body.trim().is_empty()
                        && crate::github_text::check_with(&title, &body, redecision).is_empty()
                    {
                        decision = redecision;
                        let marker = format!("magi:run/{}", self.state.id);
                        if !body.contains(&marker) {
                            body.push_str(&format!("\n\n{marker}"));
                        }
                        pr = PrMessage { title, body };
                        rewritten = true;
                        self.state
                            .event("github-text", "description rewrite passed");
                    }
                }
            }
            if !rewritten {
                self.state.event(
                    "github-text",
                    "description rewrite unavailable or rejected; using neutral body",
                );
                pr = PrMessage {
                    title: pr.title,
                    body: format!(
                        "{}\n\nmagi:run/{}",
                        crate::github_text::NEUTRAL_BODY,
                        self.state.id
                    ),
                };
                // The neutral body is fixed English; only the title's verdict
                // still applies.
                decision = decision.map(|d| crate::github_text::LanguageDecision {
                    body_english: true,
                    ..d
                });
            }
        }
        let (title, body) =
            crate::github_text::prepare_with(&mut self.state, &pr.title, &pr.body, decision);
        PrMessage { title, body }
    }

    /// Ask `[roles] language_judge` about this text and record which source
    /// decided; the text itself is never recorded.
    async fn judge_pr_language(
        &mut self,
        cwd: &Path,
        pr: &PrMessage,
    ) -> Option<crate::github_text::LanguageDecision> {
        self.state.config.roles.language_judge.as_ref()?;
        let decision =
            crate::github_text::judge_language(&self.state.config, cwd, &pr.title, &pr.body).await;
        self.state.event(
            "github-text",
            if decision.is_some() {
                "language decided by the language judge"
            } else {
                "language judge unavailable; using built-in heuristics"
            },
        );
        decision
    }

    async fn merge(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        // Same reasoning as `gate`: ask the review and gate records directly
        // rather than `status`, which a solo-candidate `judge`/`deliberate`
        // skip can rewrite on reentry to something that no longer says
        // `Blocked`. `review_conclusion` is the same derivation `gate` uses,
        // so a hand-off (open findings, green verification) reaches merge
        // exactly like a genuinely clean round does.
        //
        // A run resumed mid-`land` never reaches here at all: `execute`
        // recognises `RunStatus::Landing` before it even calls `prep`, and
        // routes straight to `run_land` instead. That has to happen a level
        // up from this function, not with a check in here, because
        // `review_loop`'s own status recomputation (see its doc) runs
        // *before* `merge` on every reentry and would otherwise overwrite
        // the `Landing` marker with `Gating` before this node ever saw it.
        if self
            .state
            .base_sync
            .as_ref()
            .is_some_and(|s| s.conflict.is_some())
            || review_conclusion(&self.state.reviews, self.state.config.graph.review_rounds)
                != Some(RunStatus::Gating)
            // `gate_ran == false` is not "passed" - `gate` leaves it false
            // both before it has ever run and when its last attempt was
            // resource-blocked (see `Runner::gate`'s own doc), and neither is
            // permission to merge on nothing but the review record. Only a
            // gate that actually ran - zero commands configured and
            // vacuously passed, or one or more that all exited 0 - may
            // proceed; `RunState::gate_status` is the single place that
            // reading is computed.
            || !self.state.gate_status().ok()
        {
            return Ok(());
        }
        // This node's own record, not `status`: `status == Ready` is not
        // unique to the harmless `MergeMode::None` path this line was
        // written for. `land` (below) sets it too, when a `MergeMode::Pr`
        // run's PR was closed without merging — and on that run `mode` is
        // still `Pr`, so a reentry that fell through here would push and
        // open a second pull request. `self.state.merge` is set exactly once
        // this node (or `land`) has already produced a verdict, under every
        // mode, which is what "already done" actually means here.
        if self.state.merge.is_some() {
            return Ok(());
        }
        let Some(winner) = self.state.winner().cloned() else {
            return Ok(());
        };
        let repo = self.state.repo.clone();
        let base = self.state.base_branch.clone();
        let mode = self.state.config.merge.mode;
        let style = self.state.config.merge.style;
        let facts = if is_review_run(&self.state) {
            refresh_reviewed_commits(&mut self.state, &winner.branch).await;
            let start = review_base(
                &repo,
                &self.state.config.merge.remote,
                &base,
                &self.state.base_commit,
                &winner.branch,
            )
            .await;
            branch_facts(&repo, &start, &winner.branch).await
        } else {
            None
        };
        // `None` when the base could not be freshly read: then an adopted
        // pull request's title is left alone.
        let leaked = if is_review_run(&self.state) {
            leaked_subjects(&self.state, &winner.branch).await
        } else {
            Some(Vec::new())
        };
        let pr = self
            .guarded_pr_message(&winner, facts.as_ref(), mode == MergeMode::Pr)
            .await;
        let message = pr.commit_message();

        let outcome = match mode {
            MergeMode::None => MergeOutcome {
                mode,
                ok: true,
                detail: manual_merge_command(style, &repo, &winner.branch, &message),
                empty: false,
            },
            MergeMode::Pr | MergeMode::Local
                if merge_is_empty(&repo, &self.state, &winner.branch, mode).await =>
            {
                MergeOutcome {
                    mode,
                    ok: false,
                    detail: empty_candidate_detail(&self.state, &base),
                    empty: true,
                }
            }
            MergeMode::Local => {
                let on = git::current_branch(&repo).await?;
                if on.as_deref() != Some(base.as_str()) {
                    MergeOutcome {
                        mode,
                        ok: false,
                        detail: format!(
                            "{} has {} checked out, not the base branch {base}",
                            repo.display(),
                            on.unwrap_or_else(|| "a detached HEAD".to_owned())
                        ),
                        empty: false,
                    }
                } else if !git::is_clean(&repo).await? {
                    MergeOutcome {
                        mode,
                        ok: false,
                        detail: format!("{} is dirty; refusing to merge", repo.display()),
                        empty: false,
                    }
                } else {
                    let out = match style {
                        MergeStyle::Merge => {
                            git::merge_no_ff(&repo, &winner.branch, &message).await?
                        }
                        MergeStyle::Squash => {
                            git::merge_squash(&repo, &winner.branch, &message).await?
                        }
                        MergeStyle::Rebase => git::merge_ff_only(&repo, &winner.branch).await?,
                    };
                    MergeOutcome {
                        mode,
                        ok: out.ok(),
                        detail: if out.ok() { out.stdout } else { out.stderr },
                        empty: false,
                    }
                }
            }
            MergeMode::Pr => {
                let remote = self.state.config.merge.remote.clone();
                let pushed = git::push(&winner.worktree, &remote, &winner.branch).await?;
                if !pushed.ok() {
                    MergeOutcome {
                        mode,
                        ok: false,
                        detail: pushed.stderr,
                        empty: false,
                    }
                } else {
                    // A retry or resume of a run whose branch already has an
                    // open pull request adopts it rather than failing on a
                    // duplicate. Only this winner branch into this base:
                    // `branch_for` derives the name from the run id, so a
                    // different run's pull request never matches.
                    let found = land::find_open_pr(&winner.worktree, &winner.branch, &base).await;
                    let out = match pr_merge_plan(found) {
                        PrPlan::Create => {
                            gh_pr_create(
                                &winner.worktree,
                                &base,
                                &winner.branch,
                                &pr.title,
                                &pr.body,
                            )
                            .await
                        }
                        PrPlan::Adopt { url, title } => {
                            self.state
                                .event("merge", format!("Pr: adopted open pull request {url}"));
                            if title != pr.title
                                && (!is_review_run(&self.state)
                                    || leaked
                                        .as_deref()
                                        .is_some_and(|l| should_retitle(&title, &pr.title, l)))
                                && let Err(e) = land::set_pr_title(
                                    &mut self.state,
                                    &winner.worktree,
                                    &url,
                                    &pr.title,
                                )
                                .await
                            {
                                tracing::warn!("could not refresh title of {url}: {e:#}");
                                self.state
                                    .event("merge", format!("Pr: title refresh failed: {e:#}"));
                            }
                            Ok(url)
                        }
                        PrPlan::Stop(why) => Err(anyhow::anyhow!(why)),
                    };
                    match out {
                        Ok(url) => MergeOutcome {
                            mode,
                            ok: true,
                            detail: url,
                            empty: false,
                        },
                        Err(e) => MergeOutcome {
                            mode,
                            ok: false,
                            detail: e.to_string(),
                            empty: false,
                        },
                    }
                }
            }
        };

        self.state.status = match (mode, outcome.ok) {
            (MergeMode::None, _) => RunStatus::Ready,
            (_, true) => RunStatus::Merged,
            (_, false) => RunStatus::Blocked,
        };
        self.state.event(
            "merge",
            format!(
                "{:?}: {}",
                mode,
                outcome.detail.lines().next().unwrap_or("")
            ),
        );
        self.state.merge = Some(outcome);
        self.state.save()?;

        // The PR is open and the run would historically stop here, leaving the
        // operator to watch checks, feed review comments back to a fixer, and
        // merge. That was done by hand six times in one session before this
        // existed. Opt-in, because merging is the one irreversible thing magi
        // can do to a repository.
        if self.state.config.graph.land
            && mode == MergeMode::Pr
            && self.state.status == RunStatus::Merged
        {
            self.run_land().await?;
        }
        // `run_land` may have left `status` at `Landing` - still waiting on
        // CI or the owner's approval, not actually settled - so this has to
        // read whatever `status` ended up as here, not the `Merged` this
        // function set a few lines up.
        self.settle_questions();
        Ok(())
    }

    /// Enter `land`.
    ///
    /// Shared between a fresh run's first pass through [`Runner::merge`] and
    /// a resumed run's re-entry. `land::land` itself is what serialises the
    /// two git-mutating moments inside the loop — the rebase push and
    /// `gh pr merge` — per repository (see its own doc); nothing here needs
    /// to hold a lock across the whole call, and doing so would serialise
    /// this run's CI wait against a *different* run's land-approval resume
    /// in the same repository, which is exactly the "must not wait on
    /// another task" property the daemon's slot-freeing exists to give.
    async fn run_land(&mut self) -> Result<()> {
        let url = self
            .state
            .merge
            .as_ref()
            .map(|m| m.detail.clone())
            .unwrap_or_default();
        let url = url.lines().next().unwrap_or("").trim().to_owned();
        if !url.starts_with("http") {
            return Ok(());
        }
        // A land failure is not a lost run: the work is on a branch and the
        // pull request is open, which is exactly where a human takes over.
        match land::land(&mut self.state, &url).await {
            Ok(pr) if self.state.parked => {
                // `land` already saved the parked marker; nothing here
                // overrides `status` back to a terminal value while an
                // approval is still outstanding.
                let _ = pr;
            }
            Ok(pr) => {
                self.state.status = match pr.state {
                    land::PrLifecycle::Merged => RunStatus::Merged,
                    _ => RunStatus::Blocked,
                };
                // Downstream of a confirmed merge only - see
                // `bump::should_release_bump`'s own doc for why this one
                // check covers all three of `land`'s success paths.
                // Best-effort: the run already landed, so a failure here
                // (the decision call, `gh`, `cargo`) is recorded and never
                // turns a landed run into a failed one.
                if bump::should_release_bump(self.state.status)
                    && let Err(e) = bump::after_merge(&mut self.state, &pr.url).await
                {
                    // The event is the run's own record. Not-eligible cases
                    // (disabled, no `Cargo.toml`, ...) return `Ok`, so an
                    // `Err` is a bump that was tried and failed:
                    // `after_merge` itself raises the operator notice for
                    // that, whether or not a release PR exists yet.
                    self.state
                        .event("bump", format!("release bump skipped: {e:#}"));
                }
                // Independent of the bump, and best-effort in the same way:
                // findings the merge left open become follow-up tasks.
                if self.state.status == RunStatus::Merged {
                    crate::followup::after_merge(&mut self.state, &pr.url).await;
                }
                self.state.save()?;
            }
            Err(e) => {
                self.state.status = RunStatus::Blocked;
                self.state.event("land", format!("gave up: {e}"));
                self.state.save()?;
            }
        }
        Ok(())
    }

    // -------------------------------------------------------------- helpers

    /// Fetch or create a seat, keeping its conversation across nodes.
    fn seat(&mut self, key: &str, agent: &str) -> SeatState {
        if let Some(existing) = self.state.seats.get(key)
            && existing.agent == agent
        {
            return existing.clone();
        }
        // A seat that changes agent mints its session id from the agent too,
        // like a handover: the old agent's uuid is already taken by the CLI.
        let fresh = if self.state.seats.contains_key(key) {
            handover_seat(key, agent, self.state.next_seat_seed())
        } else {
            SeatState::new(key, agent, self.state.seed)
        };
        self.state.seats.insert(key.to_owned(), fresh.clone());
        fresh
    }

    /// The agent now holding seat `key`: `spec`, unless a handover moved the
    /// seat to another roster agent, in which case that agent. Nodes that
    /// continue a seat's conversation (deliberation, the votes, a reviewer's
    /// reconsideration) must keep talking to whoever answered it, not slip
    /// back to the agent that failed it.
    fn occupant(&self, key: &str, spec: AgentSpec) -> AgentSpec {
        match self.state.seats.get(key) {
            Some(s) if s.agent != spec.id => {
                self.state.config.agent(&s.agent).cloned().unwrap_or(spec)
            }
            _ => spec,
        }
    }

    /// A candidate rendered for judging, with the leak policy applied.
    fn view(&self, c: &Candidate) -> CandidateView {
        let raw = crate::run::read_artifact(&self.state, &format!("cand-{}.patch", c.label))
            .unwrap_or_default();
        let (patch, _) = blind::sanitize_patch(
            &format!("candidate {} patch", c.label),
            &raw,
            &self.state.config.blind,
        );
        CandidateView {
            label: c.label,
            branch: c.branch.clone(),
            summary: c.summary.clone(),
            stat: c.stat.clone(),
            patch,
        }
    }

    /// The full candidate set as prompt text, for seats with no live session.
    fn candidate_block(&self, candidates: &[Candidate], base_short: &str) -> String {
        let views: Vec<CandidateView> = candidates.iter().map(|c| self.view(c)).collect();
        prompt::judge(
            "(see above)",
            &views,
            self.roles.judges.len(),
            base_short,
            "en",
        )
    }

    /// The final-vote prompt with everything a seat that has no session of its
    /// own needs: the candidates, the seat's own ranking and reasons, and the
    /// anonymised deliberation it took part in (only when there was one, so a
    /// handed-over seat never sees more than the seat it replaces did). The
    /// `Final vote` heading stays first.
    fn vote_prompt_full(
        &self,
        j: usize,
        labels: &[char],
        language: &str,
        candidates: &[Candidate],
        base_short: &str,
    ) -> String {
        let mut text = format!(
            "{}\n\n# The task the candidates were given\n\n{}\n\n# Candidates\n\n{}",
            prompt::final_vote(labels, language),
            self.state.instruction,
            self.candidate_block(candidates, base_short)
        );
        if let Some(own) = self
            .state
            .judgements
            .get(j)
            .filter(|r| !r.ranking.is_empty())
        {
            let reasons = own
                .reasons
                .iter()
                .map(|(k, v)| format!("- {k}: {v}"))
                .collect::<Vec<_>>()
                .join("\n");
            text.push_str(&format!(
                "\n\n# Your own earlier ranking\n\nYou ranked {}{}{reasons}\n",
                own.ranking.iter().collect::<String>(),
                if reasons.is_empty() {
                    ""
                } else {
                    ", because:\n"
                }
            ));
        }
        if !self.state.deliberation.is_empty() {
            text.push_str("\n# What was argued before this vote\n");
            for t in self.transcript(&[], j) {
                text.push_str(&format!(
                    "\n## {}{}\n\n{}\n",
                    t.who,
                    if t.is_self { " (you)" } else { "" },
                    t.body.trim()
                ));
            }
        }
        text
    }

    /// Anonymised transcript for judge `self_idx`.
    ///
    /// The initial rankings are always the opening statements. Seeding them
    /// only when no turn had been taken yet meant every judge after the first
    /// argued against a single voice instead of against the actual split — the
    /// disagreement is the information, so it is always on the table.
    fn transcript(&self, current: &[DeliberationTurn], self_idx: usize) -> Vec<Turn> {
        let mut turns = Vec::new();
        for j in &self.state.judgements {
            if j.ranking.is_empty() {
                continue;
            }
            let reasons = j
                .reasons
                .iter()
                .map(|(k, v)| format!("- {k}: {v}"))
                .collect::<Vec<_>>()
                .join("\n");
            turns.push(Turn {
                who: format!("Judge {} (opening ranking)", j.judge),
                is_self: j.judge == self_idx + 1,
                body: format!(
                    "Ranked {}{}{reasons}",
                    j.ranking.iter().collect::<String>(),
                    if reasons.is_empty() {
                        ""
                    } else {
                        ", because:\n"
                    }
                ),
            });
        }
        for t in self
            .state
            .deliberation
            .iter()
            .flat_map(|r| r.turns.iter())
            .chain(current)
        {
            turns.push(Turn {
                who: format!("Judge {}", t.judge),
                is_self: t.judge == self_idx + 1,
                body: t.body.clone(),
            });
        }
        turns
    }
}

/// Does this seat still hold the context a follow-up prompt would rely on?
fn has_context(spec: &AgentSpec, seat: &SeatState, sessions: bool) -> bool {
    agent::has_session(spec.kind, seat, sessions)
}

/// The next entry in `roster` after `start`, never wrapping back to the
/// front, whose id is not in `tried` yet.
///
/// Starts one past `start` rather than at the front of `roster`: `start` is
/// the seat's own original position, and a seat whose candidate slot already
/// sits on the roster's second entry must fall through to the third next, not
/// restart at the first — which is very likely a different candidate's own
/// agent already. Never wraps back past `start`, for the same reason: an
/// entry earlier in the roster than the seat's own position is almost
/// certainly some *other* candidate slot's own agent, and once the tail of
/// the roster is exhausted there are no more untried agents for *this* seat
/// to fall through to — the caller's fallback chain ends there, exactly as
/// "no further untried agents remain in the list for that seat" asks for.
///
/// Matched by [`AgentSpec::id`], never the whole spec: a roster that names
/// the same id twice (an operator's `roles.implementers` typo, or a
/// `[[agents]]` list reused across roles) must not let
/// [`Runner::resume_seat_handovers`] retry that id forever — one forward pass
/// over `roster` either finds an untried id or runs out, so this always
/// terminates regardless of duplicates.
fn next_untried_in_roster<'a>(
    roster: &'a [AgentSpec],
    start: usize,
    tried: &BTreeSet<String>,
) -> Option<&'a AgentSpec> {
    roster
        .get(start + 1..)?
        .iter()
        .find(|s| !tried.contains(&s.id))
}

/// The successor for a seat, shared by all four seat kinds (implement, judge,
/// review, advise). `others` holds the ids that *currently* occupy the other
/// seats of the same wave (after any earlier handover, as [`Runner::occupant`]
/// sees them), so roster entries beyond the seat count act as spares: a failed
/// seat goes to an agent no other seat holds whenever the roster permits.
///
/// `carried` is `Some` only for the review loop's carried failure history.
/// Order: (1) forward from `start`, never wrapping, untried, not a carried
/// failure, not another seat's occupant; (2) with `carried`, a rescue over the
/// whole roster: untried and not another seat's occupant; (3) the plain walk
/// ([`next_untried_in_roster`] / [`next_for_seat`]) that ignores `others`.
/// Step 3 is deliberate: a duplicate agent on two seats is a worse panel but
/// a better outcome than an empty seat, and it keeps the answer to "is there
/// a successor at all" exactly what it was before occupants were considered,
/// so no handover rule (`should_hand_over`, nudges, the tried-once bound)
/// moves. The rescue excludes occupants too, on the same reasoning: retrying a
/// carried failure is a cheaper bet than doubling an agent on the panel, and
/// if it fails again `tried` bounds it and step 3 takes over. Seats failing in
/// the same round are handled one at a time, so a seat later in the batch
/// sees an earlier one's new occupant but not yet its own freed agent.
fn pick_successor<'a>(
    roster: &'a [AgentSpec],
    start: usize,
    tried: &BTreeSet<String>,
    carried: Option<&BTreeSet<String>>,
    others: &BTreeSet<String>,
) -> Option<&'a AgentSpec> {
    let free = |s: &&AgentSpec| !tried.contains(&s.id) && !others.contains(&s.id);
    roster
        .get(start + 1..)
        .and_then(|tail| {
            tail.iter()
                .filter(free)
                .find(|s| carried.is_none_or(|c| !c.contains(&s.id)))
        })
        .or_else(|| {
            carried
                .is_some()
                .then(|| roster.iter().find(free))
                .flatten()
        })
        .or_else(|| match carried {
            Some(c) => next_for_seat(roster, start, tried, c),
            None => next_untried_in_roster(roster, start, tried),
        })
}

/// The next agent for a seat that carries its failure history across rounds
/// (the review loop). `round_tried` is this round's own bound and starts
/// empty every round; `carried_failed` only decides priority.
///
/// First: an id walking forward from `start`, never wrapping, that is neither
/// tried this round nor failed in an earlier one. Only when that is exhausted
/// does it rescue: the first roster id (in roster order, so this one *does*
/// look before `start`) not yet tried this round, which is by then a carried
/// failure. Each id is rescued at most once per round, so it cannot loop.
fn next_for_seat<'a>(
    roster: &'a [AgentSpec],
    start: usize,
    round_tried: &BTreeSet<String>,
    carried_failed: &BTreeSet<String>,
) -> Option<&'a AgentSpec> {
    roster
        .get(start + 1..)?
        .iter()
        .find(|s| !round_tried.contains(&s.id) && !carried_failed.contains(&s.id))
        .or_else(|| roster.iter().find(|s| !round_tried.contains(&s.id)))
}

/// Where a reviewer seat starts a round: the agent that last answered it when
/// it is still on the roster and not marked failed, else the spec's own agent
/// unless it failed, else the next roster agent that has not failed, else the
/// spec's own agent again (the whole roster failed). Ids no longer on the
/// roster are ignored. An empty roster has no handover, so the spec stands.
fn pick_start_spec(roster: &[AgentSpec], spec: AgentSpec, hist: Option<&SeatHistory>) -> AgentSpec {
    let Some(h) = hist.filter(|_| !roster.is_empty()) else {
        return spec;
    };
    let ok = |id: &str| !h.failed.contains(id);
    if let Some(last) = h.last_ok.as_deref()
        && ok(last)
        && let Some(s) = roster.iter().find(|s| s.id == last)
    {
        return s.clone();
    }
    if ok(&spec.id) {
        return spec;
    }
    let from = roster.iter().position(|s| s.id == spec.id).unwrap_or(0);
    roster
        .get(from + 1..)
        .into_iter()
        .flatten()
        .chain(roster.iter())
        .find(|s| ok(&s.id))
        .cloned()
        .unwrap_or(spec)
}

/// A fresh seat for the agent taking over `key`. Mixes the agent id into the
/// seed so a CLI that mints its session id up front (`--session-id`) never
/// reuses the uuid the previous agent already opened under the same seat key.
pub(crate) fn handover_seat(key: &str, agent: &str, run_seed: u64) -> SeatState {
    SeatState::new(key, agent, run_seed ^ crate::rng::fnv1a(agent))
}

/// What an agent's turn timed out as, in [`AgentOutcome::Failed`]. One const
/// so the classifier below and the code that builds the message cannot drift.
const TIMED_OUT: &str = "timed out";

impl FailClass {
    /// `None` for an answer; otherwise how the turn failed.
    fn of(out: &AgentOutcome) -> Option<Self> {
        match out {
            AgentOutcome::Ok(_) => None,
            AgentOutcome::Quota(_) => Some(Self::Quota),
            AgentOutcome::Dropped(_) => Some(Self::Other("dropped".to_owned())),
            AgentOutcome::Failed(e) if e == TIMED_OUT => Some(Self::Timeout),
            AgentOutcome::Failed(e) => Some(Self::Other(failure_signature(e))),
        }
    }

    /// The word in a handover's artifact stem (`impl-A-quota-beta`).
    fn stem_word(&self) -> &'static str {
        match self {
            Self::Quota => "quota",
            _ => "handover",
        }
    }
}

/// The message's first line with its variable parts removed — digit runs and
/// path-like tokens — so "exited with Some(2)" and "exited with Some(7)" read
/// as one kind of failure.
fn failure_signature(msg: &str) -> String {
    let line = msg.lines().next().unwrap_or("").trim().to_lowercase();
    let mut out = Vec::new();
    for word in line.split_whitespace() {
        if word.contains('/') || word.contains('\\') {
            out.push("<path>".to_owned());
            continue;
        }
        let mut w = String::new();
        let mut in_digits = false;
        for c in word.chars() {
            if c.is_ascii_digit() {
                if !in_digits {
                    w.push('#');
                }
                in_digits = true;
            } else {
                in_digits = false;
                w.push(c);
            }
        }
        out.push(w);
    }
    out.join(" ").chars().take(120).collect()
}

/// Whether a seat that just failed with `cur` may go to the next roster agent.
/// A quota or a timeout always may. Any other failure may not when the agent
/// before it failed the same way: an error the prompt causes would otherwise
/// walk the whole roster. `prev` is the class of the immediately preceding
/// agent's failure, so a quota or timeout in between breaks the run of
/// identical failures by itself.
fn should_hand_over(prev: Option<&FailClass>, cur: &FailClass) -> bool {
    match cur {
        FailClass::Quota | FailClass::Timeout => true,
        FailClass::Other(_) => prev != Some(cur),
    }
}

/// A short human reason for a failed outcome, for the handover record.
fn fail_reason(out: &AgentOutcome) -> String {
    match out {
        AgentOutcome::Ok(_) => String::new(),
        AgentOutcome::Quota(_) => "rate limited (quota)".to_owned(),
        AgentOutcome::Dropped(o) => format!(
            "the CLI dropped the stream ({})",
            o.dropped
                .as_ref()
                .map(|d| d.why.as_str())
                .unwrap_or("it ended without delivering its answer")
        ),
        AgentOutcome::Failed(e) => e.lines().next().unwrap_or("").chars().take(160).collect(),
    }
}

/// Note one handover in the run: the structured record and, in the timeline,
/// the sentence a person reads. A quota keeps the wording it always had.
pub(crate) fn record_handover(
    state: &mut RunState,
    node: &str,
    seat: &str,
    from: &str,
    to: &str,
    class: &FailClass,
    reason: &str,
) {
    let message = if *class == FailClass::Quota {
        format!("{seat}: rate limited (quota) on {from}; retrying with {to}")
    } else {
        format!("{seat}: handed over {from} -> {to} ({reason})")
    };
    state.event(node, message);
    state.handovers.push(Handover {
        at: Timestamp::now(),
        node: node.to_owned(),
        seat: seat.to_owned(),
        from: from.to_owned(),
        to: to.to_owned(),
        reason: reason.to_owned(),
    });
}

/// Did this reply report running a command whose own CLI never confirmed an
/// exit status?
///
/// An [`agent::CommandEvidence`] only ever exists when the CLI reported the
/// command *finished* (see that type's own doc), so this can only be `true`
/// for a command whose completion event carried no readable exit code — not
/// for one that simply is not mentioned at all. That is the one signal this
/// crate can read, from the same record `state.jobs` renders, about a reply
/// standing next to work its own CLI cannot vouch for finishing; it is
/// deliberately not a check on the exit code's *value* (a fixer legitimately
/// runs a command that fails mid-iteration before it succeeds) and not a
/// guess at a command still running in the background (which emits no event
/// at all, and so leaves no evidence here to find).
fn has_unconfirmed_command(commands: &[agent::CommandEvidence]) -> bool {
    commands.iter().any(|c| c.exit_code.is_none())
}

/// Whether a `NO CHANGE NEEDED` marker in an implementer's reply should be
/// trusted as a verified no-op — the adoption guard's own text-level half.
///
/// `usable` is the caller's `AgentOutput::usable()` (a clean CLI exit, not
/// timed out): a marker only earns the benefit of the doubt from a turn the
/// CLI itself vouches for finishing properly, the same house style
/// `resume_unconfirmed_commands` and `continue_fix_report` already hold a
/// *fix* report to for `commands`. A candidate that timed out, exited
/// non-zero, or left a command unconfirmed is read as the ordinary loss it
/// is, whatever prose it wrote — this returns `None` before it ever looks at
/// `text`. The remaining guards (the tree really is empty, the evidence is
/// non-empty) are the caller's: this only reads what the reply *claimed*.
fn verified_noop_claim(
    usable: bool,
    commands: &[agent::CommandEvidence],
    text: &str,
) -> Option<String> {
    (usable && !has_unconfirmed_command(commands))
        .then(|| verdict::verified_noop(text))
        .flatten()
}

fn short(commit: &str) -> String {
    commit.chars().take(7).collect()
}

fn make_executable(path: &Path) -> Result<()> {
    #[cfg(unix)]
    {
        use std::os::unix::fs::PermissionsExt as _;
        let mut perms = std::fs::metadata(path)?.permissions();
        perms.set_mode(0o755);
        std::fs::set_permissions(path, perms)?;
    }
    #[cfg(not(unix))]
    {
        let _ = path;
    }
    Ok(())
}

/// What every seat in one batch shares: where the answers are attributed, the
/// prompt overlay they inherit, and the build cache they are told to use.
///
/// A struct rather than four more parameters: `wave` also needs the run's
/// state (to record who is answering right now) and the attempt number, and
/// eight positional arguments is both unreadable and a clippy error.
struct WaveCtx<'a> {
    /// Exported as `MAGI_RUN`, so a task an agent files names the run that
    /// paid for it.
    run: &'a str,
    /// Exported as `MAGI_NODE`, and the key the prompt overlay is chosen by.
    node: &'a str,
    prompts: &'a Prompts,
    /// The shared `CARGO_TARGET_DIR`, when the config declares one.
    cache: Option<&'a Path>,
    /// The review round this wave belongs to, for `"review"`/`"fix"` — see
    /// `JobRecord::round`. `None` for every other node.
    round: Option<usize>,
    /// Carry each seat's failed-agent history across waves (the review loop
    /// only): start-of-round priority and handover choice read
    /// [`RunState::seat_history`], and every answer or failure writes it.
    carry_seats: bool,
}

/// Run one job, honouring the parallelism budget.
async fn run_one(
    job: SeatJob,
    sem: Arc<Semaphore>,
    ctx: &WaveCtx<'_>,
    state: &mut RunState,
    attempt: usize,
) -> (SeatState, AgentOutcome) {
    let (_, seat, out) = wave(vec![job], sem, ctx, state, attempt)
        .await
        .pop()
        .expect("one job in, one result out");
    (seat, out)
}

/// Run every job concurrently, capped by the semaphore, preserving order.
///
/// Every seat in the batch is recorded into [`RunState::active`] before the
/// wave starts and cleared as each answer lands, so the run's own record says
/// who is still being waited on rather than only who finished.
async fn wave(
    jobs: Vec<SeatJob>,
    sem: Arc<Semaphore>,
    ctx: &WaveCtx<'_>,
    state: &mut RunState,
    attempt: usize,
) -> Vec<(usize, SeatState, AgentOutcome)> {
    let WaveCtx {
        run,
        node,
        prompts,
        cache,
        round,
        carry_seats: _,
    } = *ctx;
    for job in &jobs {
        state.seat_started(node, &job.seat.key, job.timeout, attempt);
    }
    if let Err(e) = state.save() {
        // A failed persist of "who is answering right now" must not abort the
        // wave: the seats are already being asked, and the alternative is
        // losing the answers to save a status line nobody may even be
        // watching.
        tracing::warn!("could not persist in-progress seats: {e:#}");
    }
    // Hold the shared build cache's lease for the whole batch, not per job:
    // several candidates (an implement wave) or a fixer legitimately share
    // one cache concurrently within this run, and that stays untouched — a
    // single lease taken once for the whole wave and released once it is
    // done is what stops a *different* borrower (another run's own wave, its
    // e2e/gate, a human's `magi review`) from interleaving a build into the
    // same directory while this one is in flight. Best-effort, not
    // all-or-nothing: a wave that cannot get the lease within its own
    // longest job's budget still runs — an hour of paid implementer calls is
    // not thrown away over cache contention — but every write-allowed seat
    // then goes without `CARGO_TARGET_DIR` for this wave too (see the filter
    // below), the same fallback a read-only seat always gets, rather than
    // building into a directory this run was never granted. The identity
    // record is still invalidated below either way, so the next tracked
    // caller (`e2e`/`gate`) never trusts a match it cannot vouch for.
    let jobs_had_a_writer = jobs.iter().any(|j| j.allow_write);
    let wait_started = Instant::now();
    let cache_guard = if let Some(cache_dir) = cache {
        if jobs_had_a_writer {
            let owner = crate::cache::Owner::here(run, node, "*", Path::new("(wave)"), "");
            let budget = jobs
                .iter()
                .map(|j| j.timeout)
                .max()
                .unwrap_or(Duration::from_secs(60));
            acquire_cache_lease(state, cache_dir, &owner, budget, node)
                .await
                .ok()
        } else {
            None
        }
    } else {
        None
    };
    // Carved out of each job's own budget, not added on top of it: a seat
    // that waited behind the lease must not also get its full timeout
    // afterward, or a run contended on the cache could double the time it
    // spends per wave. `saturating_sub` floors at zero rather than
    // wrapping - a job whose whole budget was spent waiting starts with
    // none left, which is the honest number, not a free minimum.
    let waited_for_lease = wait_started.elapsed();
    let mut set = tokio::task::JoinSet::new();
    let overlay = prompts.overlay(node);
    for (i, mut job) in jobs.into_iter().enumerate() {
        job.timeout = job.timeout.saturating_sub(waited_for_lease);
        job.prompt = prompt::with_overlay(job.prompt, overlay.clone());
        if cache.is_some() {
            job.prompt.push('\n');
            job.prompt
                .push_str(&prompt::build_cache_note(node, job.allow_write));
        }
        let sem = Arc::clone(&sem);
        let run = run.to_owned();
        let node = node.to_owned();
        // Only implementers were told about the task's attachments, so only
        // their seats get the directory widened for reading.
        let attachments = if node == "implement" {
            state.attachments.clone()
        } else {
            Vec::new()
        };
        // A read-only seat is never handed `CARGO_TARGET_DIR` — see
        // `prompt::build_cache_note`'s doc for why setting it anyway is
        // exactly how a sandboxed reviewer's write refusal got reported as a
        // defect in the patch, not a property of its own seat. And a
        // write-allowed one is handed it only when the lease above was
        // actually acquired: a wave that could not get it (`cache_guard` is
        // `None`, see its own comment) must not send seats to build into a
        // directory this run does not hold - that is the exact concurrent,
        // unmanaged-write race this module exists to prevent, not something
        // "proceeding anyway" is allowed to reintroduce.
        let cache = cache
            .filter(|_| job.allow_write && cache_guard.is_some())
            .map(Path::to_path_buf);
        set.spawn(async move {
            let _permit = sem.acquire().await;
            let mut seat = job.seat;
            let out = agent::invoke(
                &job.spec,
                &mut seat,
                &Invocation {
                    cwd: &job.cwd,
                    prompt: &job.prompt,
                    timeout: job.timeout,
                    allow_write: job.allow_write,
                    unsandboxed: false,
                    sessions: job.sessions,
                    artifacts: &job.artifacts,
                    stem: &job.stem,
                    run: &run,
                    node: &node,
                    cache_dir: cache.as_deref(),
                    attachments: &attachments,
                    writable: &[],
                },
            )
            .await;
            let out = match out {
                Ok(o) if o.usable() => AgentOutcome::Ok(o),
                Ok(o) if o.quota_exhausted() => AgentOutcome::Quota(o),
                // Billed work the CLI failed to hand over is not an ordinary
                // failure, but its text is the CLI's raw error JSON, not an
                // answer — `Dropped` keeps it out of `Ok` so a caller cannot
                // read it as one by forgetting to check. `usable()` is always
                // false here (dropped implies an empty response), so this has
                // to be checked before the catch-all `Failed` below or the
                // one shape this exists for is lost with the rest.
                Ok(o) if o.work_undelivered() => AgentOutcome::Dropped(o),
                Ok(o) if o.timed_out => AgentOutcome::Failed(TIMED_OUT.to_owned()),
                Ok(o) => AgentOutcome::Failed(format!(
                    "exited with {:?} and no usable output",
                    o.exit_code
                )),
                Err(e) => AgentOutcome::Failed(e.to_string()),
            };
            (i, seat, out)
        });
    }
    let mut collected: Vec<Option<(usize, SeatState, AgentOutcome)>> = Vec::new();
    while let Some(joined) = set.join_next().await {
        let (i, seat, out) = match joined {
            Ok(v) => v,
            // No seat to clear: a panicked task never reported which one it
            // was. The defensive sweep below this loop is what stops that
            // seat's `active` entry from surviving forever.
            Err(e) => {
                tracing::error!("agent task panicked: {e}");
                continue;
            }
        };
        state.seat_finished(&seat.key);
        record_jobs(state, node, round, &seat.key, &out);
        if let Err(e) = state.save() {
            tracing::warn!("could not persist a seat's completion: {e:#}");
        }
        if collected.len() <= i {
            collected.resize_with(i + 1, || None);
        }
        collected[i] = Some((i, seat, out));
    }
    // Belt-and-braces for the panic branch above: every seat this exact batch
    // started shares this `(node, attempt)` pair, and every seat that finished
    // normally already cleared itself, so anything left tagged with it here
    // can only be a panicked task's leftover. Cleared unconditionally rather
    // than left to read as still answering forever.
    if state
        .active
        .values()
        .any(|a| a.node == node && a.attempt == attempt)
    {
        state
            .active
            .retain(|_, a| !(a.node == node && a.attempt == attempt));
        if let Err(e) = state.save() {
            tracing::warn!("could not persist the end of a wave: {e:#}");
        }
    }
    // Whether or not the lease above was actually held, several worktrees
    // may just have built into the cache with nothing here able to name one
    // coherent (worktree, head) for it - see `cache::invalidate_identity`'s
    // own doc. Forgetting the old record costs the next `e2e`/`gate` one
    // clean it might not have strictly needed; trusting a stale match would
    // cost it a wrong answer.
    if let Some(cache_dir) = cache
        && jobs_had_a_writer
    {
        crate::cache::invalidate_identity(&crate::run::home(), cache_dir);
    }
    if let Some(guard) = cache_guard {
        guard.release();
    }
    collected.into_iter().flatten().collect()
}

/// Fold one seat's [`agent::CommandEvidence`] (if its outcome carries any)
/// into the run's [`JobRecord`] log — every node, every seat, uniformly:
/// this is data collection, not the fix-specific completion contract in
/// [`Runner::continue_fix_report`], and applies regardless of which node
/// asked.
///
/// Only `AgentOutcome::Ok`/`Quota`/`Dropped` carry an [`AgentOutput`] to read
/// evidence from; `Failed` does not, and correctly contributes nothing — a
/// timeout or crash is not itself evidence about a command the seat may have
/// started.
fn record_jobs(
    state: &mut RunState,
    node: &str,
    round: Option<usize>,
    seat: &str,
    out: &AgentOutcome,
) {
    let commands: &[agent::CommandEvidence] = match out {
        AgentOutcome::Ok(o) | AgentOutcome::Quota(o) | AgentOutcome::Dropped(o) => &o.commands,
        AgentOutcome::Failed(_) => &[],
    };
    let checked_at = Timestamp::now();
    for c in commands {
        state.jobs.push(JobRecord {
            node: node.to_owned(),
            round,
            seat: seat.to_owned(),
            id: c.id.clone(),
            description: c.description.clone(),
            checked_at,
            status: match c.exit_code {
                Some(0) => JobStatus::Completed,
                Some(_) => JobStatus::Failed,
                None => JobStatus::Unknown,
            },
            exit_code: c.exit_code,
            result_summary: c.result_summary.clone(),
            source: c.source.clone(),
        });
    }
}

/// Is a review round clean, given how many reviewer seats answered against
/// how many the round expected?
///
/// A seat that never answered (timeout, crash, unparsable output) is not a
/// seat that read the patch and found nothing — treating it as such is
/// exactly the bug this function exists to close. Under the default `block`
/// policy a missing seat can never be clean; `warn` still requires the seats
/// that *did* answer to have found nothing blocking and verification to be
/// green.
///
/// `quota_missing` narrows that `block` default for exactly one cause of
/// absence: a seat lost to its own rate limit this round. Re-reviewing hoping
/// a session limit lifts by the very next round buys nothing — the seat is
/// asked again with the same quota — so once every missing seat is accounted
/// for by a quota loss (and at least one seat *did* answer, so a decision has
/// something to rest on) the round is decided on the panel that could answer,
/// same as `warn` would. A panel that lost every seat to quota is not
/// decided here: `answered == 0` falls through to the existing `block`
/// fallback so a fully collapsed panel still waits rather than landing on no
/// review at all.
fn round_is_clean(
    blocking: usize,
    e2e_ok: bool,
    answered: usize,
    expected: usize,
    quota_missing: usize,
    policy: IncompleteReviewPolicy,
) -> bool {
    if blocking != 0 || !e2e_ok {
        return false;
    }
    if answered == expected || policy == IncompleteReviewPolicy::Warn {
        return true;
    }
    answered > 0 && expected - answered <= quota_missing
}

/// The review loop's own conclusion, derived entirely from its persisted
/// round records and the round budget that produced them — never from
/// `status`, so a reentry (or `gate`/`merge` reading it independently)
/// recomputes the identical answer regardless of what an earlier node in the
/// same walk, or a previous walk, did to `status`.
///
/// `None` while more rounds remain to try, including when review never ran
/// at all (`review_rounds = 0`, or nothing yet recorded). Once a round has
/// gone clean, or the budget is spent, or the tree has stopped moving (see
/// [`STAGNANT_LIMIT`]), the answer is one of two things:
///
/// - An incomplete panel that raised nothing is missing input, not a
///   verified tree — never a hand-off candidate, whatever verification said
///   (see [`ReviewRound::incomplete`], `IncompleteReviewPolicy`).
/// - Otherwise, green e2e on the last round hands off (see
///   [`Runner::stop_reviewing`]); red e2e blocks.
///
/// A last round whose own verification is still `ResourceBlocked` — magi
/// itself never got a command to run, not evidence the patch is broken —
/// is neither: this returns `None` for it too, the same as "more rounds
/// remain", so a reentry retries the check (see `Runner::review_loop`'s own
/// handling of that shape) instead of this cheap recomputation guessing a
/// verdict a real attempt never produced.
fn review_conclusion(reviews: &[ReviewRound], max_rounds: usize) -> Option<RunStatus> {
    if max_rounds == 0 || reviews.iter().any(|r| r.clean) {
        return Some(RunStatus::Gating);
    }
    let last = reviews.last()?;
    let stagnant = reviews.iter().rev().take_while(|r| !r.progressed).count() >= STAGNANT_LIMIT;
    if reviews.len() < max_rounds && !stagnant {
        return None;
    }
    if last.incomplete() && last.blocking == 0 {
        return Some(RunStatus::Blocked);
    }
    if last.e2e_status() == E2eStatus::ResourceBlocked {
        return None;
    }
    Some(if last.e2e.iter().all(CommandOutcome::ok) {
        RunStatus::Gating
    } else {
        RunStatus::Blocked
    })
}

/// How long a re-ask may take, given the budget the first attempt had.
///
/// A `nudged` retry is a request to restate an answer the seat has already
/// worked out: it carries no new work, so it does not deserve the original
/// budget. Measured on run 01c2, two judges restated their ranking in 41 and
/// 133 seconds while a third sat for over ten minutes on a resumed session
/// holding 410 KB of prior output - and because the retry had inherited the
/// full 1200s judge timeout, one stuck nudge nearly doubled the wall time of a
/// judging round whose other seats were long finished.
///
/// A quarter of the budget, with a floor so that a deliberately short timeout
/// does not collapse to nothing. A retry that re-sends the whole prompt
/// (because the seat kept no context) is the original job again, and keeps the
/// original budget.
pub(crate) fn retry_budget(full: Duration, nudged: bool) -> Duration {
    if nudged {
        (full / 4).max(Duration::from_secs(120)).min(full)
    } else {
        full
    }
}

/// Run a wave and parse each reply, re-asking the seats whose reply was
/// unusable.
///
/// The re-ask is a nudge rather than the whole prompt again when the seat still
/// holds its conversation, which is the difference between a cheap retry and
/// paying for the entire candidate set twice.
///
/// A seat whose agent *fails* (rate limit, timeout, any other error) and has a
/// successor in `roster` is handed to it instead of being re-asked: the
/// handover is the retry. A seat with no successor left (a single-agent
/// roster, the roster's tail) is nudged as before, up to `retries` times. So
/// the asks to one seat in one node number at most
/// `roster.len().max(1) * (1 + retries)`; an agent that still has a successor
/// is asked once (a dropped stream is nudged first), and only the last agent
/// of the chain gets the `retries` same-agent nudges. Each roster agent is
/// tried at most once per seat, walking forward from the seat's own position and never wrapping
/// ([`next_untried_in_roster`]); a quota or timeout always hands over, any
/// other failure stops the chain when the previous agent failed the same way
/// ([`should_hand_over`]). The new agent takes a fresh [`SeatState`], so
/// [`has_context`] is false and the job's own full prompt and full budget are
/// sent. A seat whose chain ends on a quota records one [`QuotaLoss`] (the
/// intermediate ones are not losses) and is returned as a failure like any
/// other absent seat — the caller decides whether the panel still has a
/// quorum. An empty `roster` disables handover: failures are nudged as they
/// always were, and a quota is simply lost. A reply that fails to parse or
/// validate is the prompt's doing and is only ever nudged, never handed over.
///
/// The returned [`SeatState`] names the agent that answered (or tried last).
#[allow(clippy::too_many_arguments)]
async fn ask_json_wave<T>(
    jobs: Vec<SeatJob>,
    sem: Arc<Semaphore>,
    retries: usize,
    roster: &[AgentSpec],
    ctx: &WaveCtx<'_>,
    losses: &mut Vec<QuotaLoss>,
    state: &mut RunState,
    validate: &(dyn Fn(&T) -> Result<()> + Send + Sync),
) -> Vec<(SeatState, Result<(T, AgentOutput)>, usize)>
where
    T: serde::de::DeserializeOwned + Send + 'static,
{
    ask_wave_with(
        jobs,
        sem,
        retries,
        roster,
        ctx,
        losses,
        state,
        &|text: &str| {
            let v = verdict::extract_json::<T>(text)?;
            validate(&v)?;
            Ok(v)
        },
    )
    .await
}

/// [`ask_json_wave`] with the reading of an answer supplied by the caller, so
/// a node whose answer is prose (deliberation) shares the same handover,
/// failure classification, quota bookkeeping and bounds instead of a copy.
///
/// A seat handed to another roster agent is sent the job's `handover` prompt
/// (when it has one) rather than `prompt`: the new agent has no session, so a
/// resume-style prompt would be incomplete. That holds for the handover ask
/// and for every nudge to that agent whose `has_context` is false.
#[allow(clippy::too_many_arguments)]
async fn ask_wave_with<T>(
    jobs: Vec<SeatJob>,
    sem: Arc<Semaphore>,
    retries: usize,
    roster: &[AgentSpec],
    ctx: &WaveCtx<'_>,
    losses: &mut Vec<QuotaLoss>,
    state: &mut RunState,
    parse: &(dyn Fn(&str) -> Result<T> + Send + Sync),
) -> Vec<(SeatState, Result<(T, AgentOutput)>, usize)>
where
    T: Send + 'static,
{
    let n = jobs.len();
    let originals: Vec<SeatJob> = jobs;
    let mut seats: Vec<SeatState> = originals.iter().map(|j| j.seat.clone()).collect();
    let mut done: Vec<Option<Result<(T, AgentOutput)>>> = (0..n).map(|_| None).collect();
    // Nudges each seat's *current* agent has taken — 0 for a first-ask
    // answer, N once it has gone through N nudges. Read back once this
    // returns, so a caller building a history record (`ReviewRecord`) can
    // tell "never answered" (`failed: Some(_)`, `attempts == 0`) apart from
    // "recovered after a nudge" (`failed: None`, `attempts > 0`) — see that
    // field's own doc.
    let mut nudges: Vec<usize> = vec![0; n];
    // The agent now occupying each seat, the ids it has already been through,
    // where in the roster the walk began, the class of the last failure, and
    // the stem word of a handover not yet asked (full prompt, full budget).
    let mut specs: Vec<AgentSpec> = originals.iter().map(|j| j.spec.clone()).collect();
    let mut tried: Vec<BTreeSet<String>> = specs
        .iter()
        .map(|s| BTreeSet::from([s.id.clone()]))
        .collect();
    let starts: Vec<usize> = specs
        .iter()
        .map(|s| roster.iter().position(|r| r.id == s.id).unwrap_or(0))
        .collect();
    let carry = ctx.carry_seats && !roster.is_empty();
    // Carried across rounds: ids that failed the seat earlier, and how the
    // last failure went (so a repeat of it is not handed over again).
    let carried: Vec<BTreeSet<String>> = originals
        .iter()
        .map(|j| {
            state
                .seat_history
                .get(&j.seat.key)
                .filter(|_| carry)
                .map(|h| h.failed.clone())
                .unwrap_or_default()
        })
        .collect();
    let mut prev: Vec<Option<FailClass>> = originals
        .iter()
        .map(|j| {
            state
                .seat_history
                .get(&j.seat.key)
                .filter(|_| carry)
                .and_then(|h| h.last_fail.clone())
        })
        .collect();
    let next_agent =
        |i: usize, tried: &BTreeSet<String>, specs: &[AgentSpec]| -> Option<AgentSpec> {
            let others: BTreeSet<String> = specs
                .iter()
                .enumerate()
                .filter(|(j, _)| *j != i)
                .map(|(_, s)| s.id.clone())
                .collect();
            pick_successor(
                roster,
                starts[i],
                tried,
                carry.then(|| &carried[i]),
                &others,
            )
            .cloned()
        };
    let mut fresh: Vec<Option<String>> = vec![None; n];
    let mut last_quota: Vec<Option<Option<String>>> = vec![None; n];
    let mut pending: Vec<usize> = (0..n).collect();

    // Per seat the work is bounded by `roster.len().max(1) * (1 + retries)`
    // asks: an agent with a successor is asked once and handed over, and only
    // a seat with no successor spends `retries` nudges on the same agent. This
    // only guarantees the loop's own termination whatever those say.
    let max_rounds = (retries + 1) * roster.len().max(1) + 1;
    for round in 0..max_rounds {
        if pending.is_empty() {
            break;
        }
        let mut batch = Vec::with_capacity(pending.len());
        let mut renudged: Vec<&str> = Vec::new();
        for &i in &pending {
            let src = &originals[i];
            // A seat now held by another agent than the job named has no
            // session of its own: it gets the full-context prompt whenever
            // it is asked in full (the handover ask, a nudge it cannot
            // resume).
            let full: &str = match &src.handover {
                Some(h) if specs[i].id != src.spec.id => h,
                _ => &src.prompt,
            };
            // The prompt and the budget are one decision: a nudge restates
            // finished work, a re-sent prompt redoes it.
            let (prompt, timeout, stem) = if let Some(word) = fresh[i].take() {
                (
                    full.to_owned(),
                    src.timeout,
                    format!("{}-{word}-{}", src.stem, specs[i].id),
                )
            } else if nudges[i] == 0 {
                (full.to_owned(), src.timeout, src.stem.clone())
            } else {
                renudged.push(src.seat.key.as_str());
                let why = done[i]
                    .as_ref()
                    .and_then(|r| r.as_ref().err().map(ToString::to_string))
                    .unwrap_or_else(|| "no parsable answer".to_owned());
                let nudge = prompt::nudge(&why);
                let nudged = has_context(&specs[i], &seats[i], src.sessions);
                let prompt = if nudged {
                    nudge
                } else {
                    format!("{full}\n\n---\n\n{nudge}")
                };
                (
                    prompt,
                    retry_budget(src.timeout, nudged),
                    format!("{}-retry{}", src.stem, nudges[i]),
                )
            };
            batch.push(SeatJob {
                spec: specs[i].clone(),
                seat: seats[i].clone(),
                cwd: src.cwd.clone(),
                prompt,
                timeout,
                allow_write: src.allow_write,
                sessions: src.sessions,
                artifacts: src.artifacts.clone(),
                stem,
                handover: None,
            });
        }

        if !renudged.is_empty() {
            state.event(
                ctx.node,
                format!("retry {round}: re-asking {}", renudged.join(", ")),
            );
        }
        let results = wave(batch, Arc::clone(&sem), ctx, state, round).await;
        let mut still = Vec::new();
        for (&i, (_wi, seat, out)) in pending.iter().zip(results) {
            seats[i] = seat;
            let class = FailClass::of(&out);
            // A dropped stream is nudged first (the conversation is still
            // there to pick up); only a seat whose nudges are spent hands over.
            let nudge_first = matches!(out, AgentOutcome::Dropped(_))
                && nudges[i] < retries
                && !roster.is_empty();
            if let Some(cur) = class.clone().filter(|_| !roster.is_empty() && !nudge_first) {
                let next = should_hand_over(prev[i].as_ref(), &cur)
                    .then(|| next_agent(i, &tried[i], &specs))
                    .flatten();
                if carry {
                    let h = state
                        .seat_history
                        .entry(originals[i].seat.key.clone())
                        .or_default();
                    h.failed.insert(specs[i].id.clone());
                    h.last_fail = Some(cur.clone());
                    if h.last_ok.as_deref() == Some(specs[i].id.as_str()) {
                        h.last_ok = None;
                    }
                    // Saved before the next agent is asked, so a restart in
                    // between does not forget who failed.
                    if let Err(e) = state.save() {
                        tracing::warn!("could not persist a seat's failure history: {e:#}");
                    }
                }
                if let Some(next) = next {
                    record_handover(
                        state,
                        ctx.node,
                        &originals[i].seat.key,
                        &specs[i].id,
                        &next.id,
                        &cur,
                        &fail_reason(&out),
                    );
                    tried[i].insert(next.id.clone());
                    prev[i] = Some(cur.clone());
                    seats[i] =
                        handover_seat(&originals[i].seat.key, &next.id, state.next_seat_seed());
                    specs[i] = next;
                    fresh[i] = Some(cur.stem_word().to_owned());
                    nudges[i] = 0;
                    done[i] = Some(Err(anyhow::anyhow!(
                        "handed over after: {}",
                        fail_reason(&out)
                    )));
                    still.push(i);
                    continue;
                }
            }
            if carry
                && !nudge_first
                && let Some(cur) = class.clone()
            {
                // The chain ended here (no successor, or a repeated failure).
                let h = state
                    .seat_history
                    .entry(originals[i].seat.key.clone())
                    .or_default();
                h.failed.insert(specs[i].id.clone());
                h.last_fail = Some(cur);
            }
            let parsed = match out {
                AgentOutcome::Ok(o) => parse(&o.text).map(|v| (v, o)),
                AgentOutcome::Quota(o) => {
                    last_quota[i] = Some(o.quota.as_ref().and_then(|q| q.reset.clone()));
                    Err(anyhow::anyhow!("rate limited (quota); not retrying now"))
                }
                // Not a parseable answer: the nudge loop re-asks it, which is
                // exactly what a dropped stream needs. Just don't hand its raw
                // error JSON to `extract_json`.
                AgentOutcome::Dropped(o) => {
                    let why = o
                        .dropped
                        .as_ref()
                        .map(|d| d.why.as_str())
                        .unwrap_or("the CLI ended the stream without delivering its answer");
                    Err(anyhow::anyhow!("the CLI dropped the stream ({why})"))
                }
                AgentOutcome::Failed(e) => Err(anyhow::anyhow!(e)),
            };
            let quota = class == Some(FailClass::Quota);
            let failed = parsed.is_err();
            done[i] = Some(parsed);
            if carry && !failed {
                let h = state
                    .seat_history
                    .entry(originals[i].seat.key.clone())
                    .or_default();
                h.failed.remove(&specs[i].id);
                h.last_ok = Some(specs[i].id.clone());
                h.last_fail = None;
            }
            // Do not re-ask a rate-limited seat (quota) — a retry is known to
            // fail the same way; and never re-ask a seat that already parsed.
            // A failed agent that still has a successor is not re-asked
            // either: the handover was its remedy and has just been refused
            // (the chain stops on a repeated failure class). A seat with no
            // successor left (a single-agent roster, the roster's tail, or an
            // empty roster) keeps the same-agent nudge, bounded by `retries`.
            let agent_failure = class.is_some()
                && !nudge_first
                && !roster.is_empty()
                && next_agent(i, &tried[i], &specs).is_some();
            if failed && !quota && !agent_failure && nudges[i] < retries {
                nudges[i] += 1;
                still.push(i);
            }
        }
        pending = still;
    }

    // One loss per seat whose chain ended on a quota: the intermediate ones
    // were absorbed by a handover and are not losses.
    for (i, q) in last_quota.into_iter().enumerate() {
        if let Some(reset) = q {
            losses.push(QuotaLoss {
                seat: originals[i].seat.key.clone(),
                node: ctx.node.to_owned(),
                at: Timestamp::now(),
                reset,
            });
        }
    }

    seats
        .into_iter()
        .zip(done)
        .zip(nudges)
        .map(|((seat, res), attempts)| {
            (
                seat,
                res.unwrap_or_else(|| Err(anyhow::anyhow!("no attempt was made"))),
                attempts,
            )
        })
        .collect()
}

/// Acquire the shared build cache's lease, waiting out contention within
/// `budget` (never past it — see AGENTS.md's build-cache section on why an
/// unbounded wait is never acceptable).
///
/// A first, non-blocking check happens before ever waiting; if it finds the
/// lease busy, that fact is logged as a `verify` event *and* flushed with
/// [`RunState::save`] immediately — not only once the wait finally succeeds
/// or gives up — so a `magi show` run by a different process while this one
/// is still waiting reads a `run.json` that says so, rather than whatever it
/// looked like before the wait started. The same applies to the terminal
/// failure: logged and saved before this returns `Err`, so a caller that
/// could not get the lease at all still leaves a legible record of why.
async fn acquire_cache_lease(
    state: &mut RunState,
    cache_dir: &Path,
    owner: &crate::cache::Owner,
    budget: Duration,
    context: &str,
) -> Result<crate::cache::Guard> {
    let home = crate::run::home();
    let started = Instant::now();
    let busy = match crate::cache::try_acquire(&home, cache_dir, owner) {
        Ok(crate::cache::AcquireOutcome::Acquired(g)) => return Ok(g),
        Ok(crate::cache::AcquireOutcome::Busy(busy)) => busy,
        Err(e) => {
            state.event(
                "verify",
                format!("{context}: could not check the shared build cache: {e:#}"),
            );
            if let Err(e2) = state.save() {
                tracing::warn!("could not persist a cache-check failure: {e2:#}");
            }
            return Err(e);
        }
    };
    state.event(
        "verify",
        format!(
            "{context}: waiting for the shared build cache at {} ({})",
            cache_dir.display(),
            busy.describe()
        ),
    );
    if let Err(e) = state.save() {
        tracing::warn!("could not persist a cache wait: {e:#}");
    }
    let remaining = budget.saturating_sub(started.elapsed());
    match crate::cache::wait_for(&home, cache_dir, owner, remaining, Duration::from_secs(5)).await {
        Ok(g) => Ok(g),
        Err(e) => {
            state.event("verify", format!("{context}: {e:#}"));
            if let Err(e2) = state.save() {
                tracing::warn!("could not persist a cache wait timeout: {e2:#}");
            }
            Err(e)
        }
    }
}

/// Run `body` — a verify command batch — while holding the shared build
/// cache's lease, so this run's own full verification (`e2e`, `gate`) can
/// never interleave with another borrower's build against the same
/// `CARGO_TARGET_DIR`: a different run, a lingering reviewer past its
/// timeout, or a human's own `magi review`. See the `cache` module doc for
/// why this matters more than Cargo's own per-target locking covers — two
/// *different* worktrees building the same package name/version into one
/// cache directory is a staleness bug, not a lock contention one.
///
/// The wait for the lease is carved out of `budget`, never on top of it —
/// `body` is handed whatever is left, so a caller's own node timeout is the
/// only clock involved, exactly what AGENTS.md's build-cache section asks
/// for ("never an unbounded wait"). When `cache_dir` is `None` — no shared
/// cache configured at all — this is a pass-through: `body` runs with the
/// full budget and nothing is leased.
///
/// A lease that cannot be acquired within `budget` is reported as a single
/// synthetic [`CommandOutcome`] (`code: None`) rather than silently skipping
/// verification — the same shape a spawn failure already takes in
/// [`run_commands`], so a caller need not special-case it.
#[allow(clippy::too_many_arguments)]
async fn with_cache_lease<'s, F, Fut>(
    state: &'s mut RunState,
    cache_dir: Option<&Path>,
    node: &str,
    seat: &str,
    worktree: &Path,
    head: &str,
    budget: Duration,
    context: &str,
    body: F,
) -> (Vec<CommandOutcome>, bool)
where
    F: FnOnce(&'s mut RunState, Duration) -> Fut,
    Fut: std::future::Future<Output = (Vec<CommandOutcome>, bool, Vec<u32>)>,
{
    let Some(cache_dir) = cache_dir else {
        let (outcomes, retried, _timed_out_pids) = body(state, budget).await;
        return (outcomes, retried);
    };
    let home = crate::run::home();
    let owner = crate::cache::Owner::here(&state.id, node, seat, worktree, head);
    let started = Instant::now();
    let guard = match acquire_cache_lease(state, cache_dir, &owner, budget, context).await {
        Ok(g) => g,
        Err(e) => {
            return (
                vec![CommandOutcome {
                    command: "(waiting for the shared build cache)".to_owned(),
                    code: None,
                    output_tail: e.to_string(),
                    duration_ms: started.elapsed().as_millis() as u64,
                    resource_blocked: true,
                }],
                false,
            );
        }
    };
    let identity = crate::cache::Identity::new(worktree, head);
    if let Err(e) = crate::cache::ensure_fresh(&home, cache_dir, &identity) {
        // A failed freshness check means this process cannot vouch for what
        // is sitting in the cache right now - on Windows this is exactly the
        // "a stale test executable is still locked, `cargo clean -p` cannot
        // remove it" case the evidence log records. Running verify anyway
        // and reporting whatever it says would let a result nobody can trust
        // stand for the tree it claims to have checked; fail the step
        // instead of the patch.
        state.event(
            "verify",
            format!(
                "{context}: could not confirm the shared build cache matches {} at {}: {e:#}",
                worktree.display(),
                short(head)
            ),
        );
        guard.release();
        return (
            vec![CommandOutcome {
                command: "(confirming the shared build cache is fresh)".to_owned(),
                code: None,
                output_tail: e.to_string(),
                duration_ms: started.elapsed().as_millis() as u64,
                resource_blocked: true,
            }],
            false,
        );
    }
    let remaining = budget.saturating_sub(started.elapsed());
    let (outcomes, retried, timed_out_pids) = body(state, remaining).await;
    // A timed-out command's process was only *asked* to die (`kill_on_drop`,
    // `start_kill`); confirm it actually has before handing the directory to
    // the next acquirer. See `wait_for_timed_out_children_to_die`'s own doc
    // for what this can and cannot see.
    if !timed_out_pids.is_empty() {
        wait_for_timed_out_children_to_die(&timed_out_pids).await;
    }
    guard.release();
    (outcomes, retried)
}

/// Poll `pids` — commands [`run_commands`] reports as still running when its
/// own timeout elapsed — until every one is confirmed gone, or
/// [`LEASE_RELEASE_MAX_WAIT`] passes, whichever comes first.
///
/// Real confirmation where confirmation is possible, not a substitute for
/// full process-tree observation: a grandchild the timed-out process spawned
/// and that survives independently of it is invisible to a pid check the
/// same way it always was, and continuing to observe and collect *that*
/// stays a different piece of work with its own owner. This only narrows a
/// fixed blind wait into an actual check of the pids this process does know
/// about.
async fn wait_for_timed_out_children_to_die(pids: &[u32]) {
    wait_for_pids_with(
        pids,
        crate::proc::pid_alive,
        LEASE_RELEASE_POLL,
        LEASE_RELEASE_MAX_WAIT,
    )
    .await;
}

/// [`wait_for_timed_out_children_to_die`] with its liveness query, poll
/// interval and ceiling supplied by the caller, so the polling *logic* -
/// returns as soon as every pid reports dead, gives up at the ceiling
/// otherwise - is testable on millisecond durations without asking the real
/// OS about a pid at all.
async fn wait_for_pids_with<F: Fn(u32) -> bool>(
    pids: &[u32],
    alive: F,
    poll: Duration,
    max_wait: Duration,
) {
    let deadline = Instant::now() + max_wait;
    loop {
        if pids.iter().all(|&pid| !alive(pid)) {
            return;
        }
        if Instant::now() >= deadline {
            return;
        }
        tokio::time::sleep(poll).await;
    }
}

/// Are any of `outcomes` [`CommandOutcome::resource_blocked`] - magi's own
/// admission that it could not even get a verify command to run, as opposed
/// to evidence the command actually produced? A caller that would otherwise
/// read a resource-blocked outcome as a red command must check this first:
/// see [`Runner::gate`], which retries rather than records `Blocked` when
/// this is true.
fn verify_inconclusive(outcomes: &[CommandOutcome]) -> bool {
    outcomes.iter().any(|o| o.resource_blocked)
}

/// What [`Runner::gate_fix_round`] decided.
enum GateFix {
    /// The tree changed and `verify.e2e` is still green: run the gate again.
    Retry,
    /// No more rounds, nothing to fix, or the fix did not hold: the gate's
    /// last failure stands and the run ends blocked.
    Stop,
    /// `verify.e2e` could not run after the fix (magi's own contention):
    /// decide nothing now, a later reentry retries.
    Defer,
}

/// Is every red command in `outcomes` an ordinary failure the code could
/// explain: it ran, exited non-zero, and said something?
///
/// A timeout, a spawn failure and a killed process all leave `code` `None`;
/// 126 / 127 are the POSIX shell's "cannot execute" / "not found". Output-free
/// exits carry nothing for a fixer to act on. Language-agnostic on purpose:
/// what the command is stays the gate's business.
fn gate_fixable(outcomes: &[CommandOutcome]) -> bool {
    let mut red = outcomes.iter().filter(|o| !o.ok()).peekable();
    red.peek().is_some()
        && red.all(|o| {
            !o.resource_blocked
                && matches!(o.code, Some(c) if c != 0 && c != 126 && c != 127)
                && !o.output_tail.trim().is_empty()
        })
}

/// Describe one verify command's outcome for the event log, distinguishing a
/// build/link failure — the toolchain never produced a binary to run — from
/// an actual test failure, since only the latter is a verdict on the patch.
fn e2e_outcome_label(o: &CommandOutcome) -> String {
    if o.ok() {
        return "pass".to_owned();
    }
    let reason = if o.build_failed() {
        format!("COULD NOT RUN ({:?}, build/link failure)", o.code)
    } else {
        format!("FAIL ({:?})", o.code)
    };
    format!("{reason}\n{}", tail(&o.output_tail, EVENT_OUTPUT_TAIL))
}

/// Run `verify.e2e`, retrying once if the first attempt could not build or
/// link — a build/link failure is frequently a race against a shared
/// `CARGO_TARGET_DIR` (see AGENTS.md), not a verdict on the patch. Emits one
/// `verify` event per command, tagged with `context` (normally `"round N"`)
/// so the two call sites that need this — the ordinary per-round leg in
/// `review_loop`, and the deferred catch-up run `stop_reviewing` makes before
/// it will ever call a round green — read identically in the event log.
async fn run_e2e_with_retry(
    state: &mut RunState,
    shell: &[String],
    commands: &[String],
    worktree: &Path,
    timeout: Duration,
    context: &str,
) -> (Vec<CommandOutcome>, bool, Vec<u32>) {
    let (mut e2e, mut timed_out_pids) = run_commands(
        state, "verify", "e2e", 0, shell, commands, worktree, timeout,
    )
    .await;
    for o in &e2e {
        state.event(
            "verify",
            format!("{context}: `{}` -> {}", o.command, e2e_outcome_label(o)),
        );
    }
    // A build/link failure is not a verdict on the patch — it is frequently a
    // race against a shared `CARGO_TARGET_DIR` (see AGENTS.md). Give verify
    // one retry before letting a red like that decide the round.
    let verify_retried = e2e.iter().any(CommandOutcome::build_failed);
    if verify_retried {
        state.event(
            "verify",
            format!(
                "{context}: verify could not build/link, not a test result — retrying once \
                 before concluding"
            ),
        );
        let retried = run_commands(
            state, "verify", "e2e", 1, shell, commands, worktree, timeout,
        )
        .await;
        e2e = retried.0;
        // Both attempts' timeouts matter, not just the last one: the first
        // attempt's descendants may still be alive alongside the retry's.
        timed_out_pids.extend(retried.1);
        for o in &e2e {
            state.event(
                "verify",
                format!(
                    "{context}: retry `{}` -> {}",
                    o.command,
                    e2e_outcome_label(o)
                ),
            );
        }
    }
    (e2e, verify_retried, timed_out_pids)
}

/// Run configured shell commands in `cwd`, in order. The second element is
/// the pid of every command that hit `timeout` and was still running when
/// this stopped waiting on it (best-effort: `None` when the platform did not
/// hand one back) — see [`with_cache_lease`]'s use of it for why a caller
/// that releases a shared resource afterward needs to know.
///
/// Records `task` into [`RunState::active`] at every command boundary
/// (`RunState::task_command`) and clears it once the whole list has run
/// (`RunState::task_finished`) — a `verify.e2e` / `verify.gate` list can run
/// for minutes with no seat and no output of its own to show for it (see
/// `CommandOutcome`'s doc on why an empty `e2e`/`gate` alone cannot be told
/// apart from "not yet run" without this), and this is the only place that
/// knows which command is running right now and how many are left. Three
/// saves per command — start, not per second — matching the same "only at a
/// boundary" rule [`wave`] already follows for seats.
#[allow(clippy::too_many_arguments)]
async fn run_commands(
    state: &mut RunState,
    node: &str,
    task: &str,
    attempt: usize,
    shell: &[String],
    commands: &[String],
    cwd: &Path,
    timeout: Duration,
) -> (Vec<CommandOutcome>, Vec<u32>) {
    if commands.is_empty() {
        // Nothing to mark as running and nothing to clear — an empty list
        // means "not configured", and touching `active` (or the disk) over
        // that would be a write for every round of a repo with no
        // `verify.e2e` / `verify.gate` commands at all.
        return (Vec::new(), Vec::new());
    }
    let mut out = Vec::new();
    let mut timed_out_pids = Vec::new();
    let total = commands.len();
    for (idx, command) in commands.iter().enumerate() {
        state.task_command(task, node, attempt, command, idx + 1, total, timeout);
        if let Err(e) = state.save() {
            tracing::warn!("could not persist an in-progress {task} command: {e:#}");
        }
        let started = Instant::now();
        let mut cmd = tokio::process::Command::new(&shell[0]);
        cmd.quiet();
        cmd.args(&shell[1..])
            .arg(command)
            .current_dir(cwd)
            .stdin(std::process::Stdio::null())
            .stdout(std::process::Stdio::piped())
            .stderr(std::process::Stdio::piped())
            .kill_on_drop(true);
        let spawned = cmd.spawn();
        let (code, body) = match spawned {
            Ok(child) => {
                // Captured before the child is consumed below: `kill_on_drop`
                // only *asks* the process to die when the timeout branch
                // drops it, and the pid is the only way anyone downstream can
                // later check whether that request actually took.
                let pid = child.id();
                match tokio::time::timeout(timeout, child.wait_with_output()).await {
                    Ok(Ok(o)) => {
                        let mut body = String::from_utf8_lossy(&o.stdout).into_owned();
                        body.push_str(&String::from_utf8_lossy(&o.stderr));
                        (o.status.code(), body)
                    }
                    Ok(Err(e)) => (None, format!("failed to run: {e}")),
                    Err(_) => {
                        if let Some(pid) = pid {
                            timed_out_pids.push(pid);
                        }
                        (None, format!("timed out after {}s", timeout.as_secs()))
                    }
                }
            }
            Err(e) => (None, format!("failed to spawn `{}`: {e}", shell[0])),
        };
        out.push(CommandOutcome {
            command: command.clone(),
            code,
            output_tail: tail(&body, OUTPUT_TAIL),
            duration_ms: started.elapsed().as_millis() as u64,
            resource_blocked: false,
        });
    }
    state.task_finished(task);
    if let Err(e) = state.save() {
        tracing::warn!("could not persist the end of {task}: {e:#}");
    }
    (out, timed_out_pids)
}

/// The shell command line `mode = "none"` prints — in `magi show`'s `merge`
/// section (`report::run`) and in the `merge` event this node records — for
/// the operator to run by hand.
///
/// Built from [`MergeStyle`] rather than always `git merge --no-ff`: a base
/// branch whose ruleset forbids merge commits (GitHub's "must not contain
/// merge commits", or "require linear history") rejects the push a `--no-ff`
/// merge would produce, which is exactly the guidance this function replaces.
/// `message`'s first line becomes the squash commit's subject, matching the
/// note `report::run` prints alongside this command — see that function for
/// why an explicit subject is not optional there.
fn manual_merge_command(style: MergeStyle, repo: &Path, branch: &str, message: &str) -> String {
    let repo = repo.display();
    match style {
        MergeStyle::Merge => format!("git -C {repo} merge --no-ff {branch}"),
        MergeStyle::Squash => {
            // The subject sits inside double quotes, and a title an agent
            // wrote may carry the characters that break out of them.
            let subject = message
                .lines()
                .next()
                .unwrap_or(branch)
                .replace(['\\', '"', '$', '`'], "");
            format!(
                "git -C {repo} merge --squash {branch} && git -C {repo} commit -m \"{subject}\""
            )
        }
        MergeStyle::Rebase => format!("git -C {repo} merge --ff-only {branch}"),
    }
}

/// GitHub's `createPullRequest` GraphQL mutation, which `gh pr create` calls
/// under the hood, rejects a `title` over 256 characters and the whole
/// command fails — no PR at all, for a run whose body was otherwise fine
/// (this is what happened to run 2963; see AGENTS.md). 240 leaves room below
/// that limit: titles are counted in `chars()` (Unicode scalars), which is not
/// always how GitHub counts. [`english_title`] keeps its trailing `...` inside
/// this bound. It is a margin, not a guarantee — a title packed
/// with multi-unit characters could still in principle land close to the
/// edge, but a real task title's occasional emoji or accented letter fits
/// comfortably inside it.
const PR_TITLE_MAX: usize = 240;

/// A pull request title from the opening line of `text`, or `None` when that
/// line is not English (GitHub text is) or has no letters.
///
/// A line within `max` is kept as is. A longer one is cut at the end of its
/// first sentence when that falls inside `max`, else at a word boundary with a
/// plain `...` (ASCII, unlike the `…` `queue::title_from` appends, which would
/// make every merely-truncated title look non-English). The language check
/// runs on the kept text before any mark is added, so only what GitHub will
/// show is judged: an English opening followed by non-ASCII far past the cut
/// still passes.
fn english_title(text: &str, max: usize) -> Option<String> {
    let line = queue::first_line(text)?;
    let chars: Vec<char> = line.chars().collect();
    let (kept, mark) = if chars.len() <= max {
        (line.to_owned(), "")
    } else if let Some(end) = sentence_end(&chars, max) {
        (chars[..end].iter().collect::<String>(), "")
    } else {
        let room = max.saturating_sub(3);
        // Cut at the last space inside the room; when the char just past the
        // room is a space the room already ends on a word.
        let cut = if chars[room].is_whitespace() {
            room
        } else {
            chars[..room]
                .iter()
                .rposition(|c| c.is_whitespace())
                .unwrap_or(room)
        };
        let head: String = chars[..cut].iter().collect();
        let head = head.trim_end_matches(|c: char| c.is_whitespace() || ",;:-".contains(c));
        (head.to_owned(), "...")
    };
    if kept.is_empty() || !kept.is_ascii() || !kept.chars().any(|c| c.is_ascii_alphabetic()) {
        return None;
    }
    Some(format!("{kept}{mark}"))
}

/// The char length of the first sentence of `chars` when it ends within `max`
/// (the closing `.`/`!`/`?` dropped), skipping very short stubs and common
/// abbreviations so `e.g. foo` does not end a title early.
fn sentence_end(chars: &[char], max: usize) -> Option<usize> {
    const MIN: usize = 20;
    for i in MIN..max.min(chars.len()) {
        if !matches!(chars[i], '.' | '!' | '?') {
            continue;
        }
        let Some(&next) = chars.get(i + 1) else {
            continue;
        };
        if !next.is_whitespace() {
            continue;
        }
        let after = chars[i + 1..].iter().find(|c| !c.is_whitespace());
        if after.is_some_and(|c| c.is_ascii_lowercase()) {
            continue;
        }
        let word: String = chars[..i]
            .iter()
            .rev()
            .take_while(|c| !c.is_whitespace())
            .collect::<Vec<_>>()
            .into_iter()
            .rev()
            .collect();
        let word = word.to_ascii_lowercase();
        if matches!(word.as_str(), "e.g" | "i.e" | "etc" | "vs" | "cf") {
            continue;
        }
        let end = chars[..i]
            .iter()
            .rposition(|c| !c.is_whitespace())
            .map_or(i, |p| p + 1);
        return Some(end);
    }
    None
}

/// What `merge = "pr"` (and the merge commit of the other modes) says about a
/// change: a title and a body describing what was *implemented*, not the task
/// that asked for it. A task reads as a request; a reader of the merged
/// history wants the change.
struct PrMessage {
    title: String,
    body: String,
}

impl PrMessage {
    /// Title, blank line, body. The first line is the squash/merge commit
    /// subject (`manual_merge_command` takes it via `lines().next()`), so it
    /// has to stay one sensible line.
    fn commit_message(&self) -> String {
        format!("{}\n\n{}", self.title, self.body)
    }
}

/// The text after a leading `TITLE:` (any case) on `line`.
fn title_marker(line: &str) -> Option<&str> {
    let line = line.trim();
    let head = line.get(..6)?;
    head.eq_ignore_ascii_case("title:")
        .then(|| line[6..].trim())
}

/// The implementer's own one-line title: the `TITLE:` line the implement
/// prompt asks for at the top of its SUMMARY. Candidate commits are all
/// `magi: candidate X (uncommitted work)`, so a commit subject is never a
/// source, and a title that says as much is refused here too.
fn summary_title(summary: &str) -> Option<String> {
    let first = summary.lines().find(|l| !l.trim().is_empty())?;
    let raw = title_marker(first)?;
    if raw.is_empty() {
        return None;
    }
    let title = queue::title_from(raw, PR_TITLE_MAX);
    let lower = title.to_ascii_lowercase();
    if lower.starts_with("magi:") || lower.contains("(uncommitted work)") {
        return None;
    }
    Some(title)
}

/// How `open_review`'s instruction begins; see [`landing_title`].
const REVIEW_PROMPT_OPENING: &str = "Review the work already on branch";

/// Marker `open_review` gives a candidate that nothing in the roster wrote.
const EXISTING_BRANCH: &str = "(existing branch)";

/// Does this run review work that already existed, rather than implement a
/// task? Runs recorded before `reviewed_commits` existed carry only the
/// candidate marker.
fn is_review_run(state: &RunState) -> bool {
    state.reviewed_commits.is_some() || state.candidates.iter().any(|c| c.agent == EXISTING_BRANCH)
}

/// The title of a review-only run: the subject of the oldest commit under
/// review. Later commits are usually fixups, and `instruction` is the review
/// prompt, which says nothing about the change. GitHub text is English, so a
/// non-ASCII or blank subject yields `None` and the caller's neutral title.
fn review_title(state: &RunState) -> Option<String> {
    english_subject(state.reviewed_commits.as_ref()?.first()?)
}

/// `raw` as a pull request title, or `None` when it is blank, not English
/// (GitHub text is), or one of magi's own candidate commit subjects.
fn english_subject(raw: &str) -> Option<String> {
    let raw = raw.trim();
    if raw.is_empty() || !raw.is_ascii() || !raw.chars().any(|c| c.is_ascii_alphabetic()) {
        return None;
    }
    let title = queue::title_from(raw, PR_TITLE_MAX);
    let lower = title.to_ascii_lowercase();
    if lower.starts_with("magi:") || lower.contains("(uncommitted work)") {
        return None;
    }
    Some(title)
}

/// What a review-only run's branch says about itself, read at the moment the
/// pull request is opened.
#[derive(Debug, Clone, PartialEq, Eq)]
struct BranchFacts {
    /// `(subject, body)` of each commit, oldest first.
    commits: Vec<(String, String)>,
    /// Trimmed `git diff --stat`.
    stat: String,
}

/// Longest diff stat shown: this many file lines plus the summary line.
const STAT_FILE_LINES: usize = 25;
/// Cap on the commit list, well inside GitHub's 65536-character body limit.
const COMMITS_MAX_CHARS: usize = 20_000;

/// Read the commits and diff stat of `base..branch`. `None` when git cannot
/// say or finds nothing, so the caller falls back to what the run recorded.
async fn branch_facts(repo: &Path, base: &str, branch: &str) -> Option<BranchFacts> {
    let commits = git::commit_log(repo, base, branch).await.ok()?;
    if commits.is_empty() {
        return None;
    }
    let stat = git::diff_stat(repo, base, branch).await.unwrap_or_default();
    let lines: Vec<&str> = stat.lines().collect();
    let stat = if lines.len() > STAT_FILE_LINES + 1 {
        let omitted = lines.len() - 1 - STAT_FILE_LINES;
        let more = format!(" ... {omitted} more file(s)");
        let mut kept: Vec<&str> = lines[..STAT_FILE_LINES].to_vec();
        kept.push(&more);
        kept.push(lines[lines.len() - 1]);
        kept.join("\n")
    } else {
        lines.join("\n")
    };
    Some(BranchFacts { commits, stat })
}

/// Defang what would break the surrounding markdown: a closing `</details>`
/// and a code fence.
fn markdown_safe(text: &str) -> String {
    text.replace("</details>", "&lt;/details&gt;")
        .replace("\x60\x60\x60", "~~~")
}

fn neutral_title(state: &RunState, winner: char) -> String {
    format!(
        "chore: land candidate {} of run {}",
        winner.to_ascii_uppercase(),
        state.id
    )
}

/// The pull request title to hand to `land::merge_subject`. A review-only run
/// opened by an earlier build titled its pull request with the review prompt;
/// that title is dropped (empty, so the fallback applies) rather than landed.
/// Any other title, including an operator's rename, passes through untouched,
/// and so does every title of a run that implements a task.
pub fn landing_title<'a>(state: &RunState, pr_title: &'a str) -> &'a str {
    if is_review_run(state) && pr_title.trim_start().starts_with(REVIEW_PROMPT_OPENING) {
        ""
    } else {
        pr_title
    }
}

/// What the squash subject falls back to when the pull request title is empty
/// or candidate-shaped: for a review-only run the derived title, never the
/// review prompt held in `instruction`.
pub fn landing_subject_source(state: &RunState) -> String {
    if is_review_run(state) {
        let winner = state.candidates.first().map_or('A', |c| c.label);
        return review_title(state).unwrap_or_else(|| neutral_title(state, winner));
    }
    state.instruction.clone()
}

/// `summary` without its `TITLE:` line, which the pull request title already
/// carries.
fn summary_without_title(summary: &str) -> String {
    let mut lines = summary.trim().lines().peekable();
    if lines.peek().is_some_and(|l| title_marker(l).is_some()) {
        lines.next();
    }
    lines.collect::<Vec<_>>().join("\n").trim().to_owned()
}

/// The pull request title and body for the winning candidate.
///
/// Title: the implementer's `TITLE:` line ([`summary_title`]), falling back to
/// the task's own opening line via [`queue::title_from`] when there is none.
/// `state.instruction` can open with blank lines (`task_text` only rejects a
/// body that is blank *entirely*), which `title_from` skips.
///
/// Body: the implementer's summary and the fixer's notes, then — when the
/// winning review round was not clean — the findings still open and whatever
/// the fixer declined, so `merge = "pr"` hands the reader the same material
/// `magi show` does. The task follows inside a collapsed block, and the
/// footer repeats the run and candidate as plain tags for a reader holding
/// only the merged commit or the PR body.
#[cfg(test)]
fn pr_message(state: &RunState, winner: char) -> PrMessage {
    pr_message_with(state, winner, None)
}

/// [`pr_message`] with what the branch of a review-only run says about itself.
/// `facts` is ignored for a run that implements a task.
#[cfg(test)]
fn pr_message_with(state: &RunState, winner: char, facts: Option<&BranchFacts>) -> PrMessage {
    let raw = pr_message_raw(state, winner, facts);
    let id = crate::scrub::Identity::current();
    PrMessage {
        title: crate::scrub::scrub(&raw.title, &id),
        body: crate::scrub::scrub(&raw.body, &id),
    }
}

fn pr_message_raw(state: &RunState, winner: char, facts: Option<&BranchFacts>) -> PrMessage {
    let summary = state
        .candidates
        .iter()
        .find(|c| c.label == winner)
        .map(|c| c.summary.as_str())
        .unwrap_or_default();
    // The fallback is the operator's own words and may not be English; GitHub
    // text always is, so a non-English task gets a neutral title instead.
    let review = is_review_run(state);
    let title = if review {
        facts
            .and_then(|f| english_subject(&f.commits.first()?.0))
            .or_else(|| review_title(state))
            .or_else(|| {
                state
                    .candidates
                    .iter()
                    .find(|c| c.label == winner)
                    .filter(|c| !c.branch.starts_with("magi/"))
                    .and_then(|c| english_subject(&c.branch))
            })
            .unwrap_or_else(|| neutral_title(state, winner))
    } else {
        summary_title(summary).unwrap_or_else(|| {
            english_title(&state.instruction, PR_TITLE_MAX)
                .unwrap_or_else(|| neutral_title(state, winner))
        })
    };

    let mut body = String::new();
    let what = summary_without_title(summary);
    if !what.is_empty() {
        body.push_str("## Summary\n\n");
        body.push_str(&what);
        body.push_str("\n\n");
    }

    // The last round is usually a clean verification pass with no fix of its
    // own, so every round's notes are read, not just the final one's.
    let notes: Vec<(usize, &str)> = state
        .reviews
        .iter()
        .filter_map(|r| {
            let n = r.fix.as_ref()?.notes.trim();
            (!n.is_empty()).then_some((r.round, n))
        })
        .collect();
    if !notes.is_empty() {
        body.push_str("## Review fixes\n\n");
        if let [(_, only)] = notes.as_slice() {
            body.push_str(only);
            body.push_str("\n\n");
        } else {
            for (round, n) in &notes {
                body.push_str(&format!("### Round {round}\n\n{n}\n\n"));
            }
        }
    }
    let fix = state.reviews.iter().rev().find_map(|r| r.fix.as_ref());

    let open = state.open_findings();
    if !open.is_empty() {
        body.push_str("## Open review findings\n\n");
        for f in &open {
            body.push_str(&format!("- `{}` [{:?}] {}\n", f.id, f.severity, f.title));
        }
        body.push('\n');
    }

    if let Some(fix) = fix
        && !fix.rejected.is_empty()
    {
        body.push_str("## Declined by the fixer\n\n");
        for r in &fix.rejected {
            body.push_str(&format!("- `{}`: {}\n", r.id, r.why));
        }
        body.push('\n');
    }

    if review {
        // The review prompt is not the task; list what the branch carries.
        body.push_str("## Commits under review\n\n");
        if let Some(facts) = facts {
            let mut left = COMMITS_MAX_CHARS;
            for (i, (subject, text)) in facts.commits.iter().enumerate() {
                let mut entry = format!("- {}\n", markdown_safe(subject));
                for l in markdown_safe(text).lines() {
                    entry.push_str(format!("  {l}\n").trim_end_matches(' '));
                }
                if left == 0 {
                    body.push_str(&format!(
                        "- ... {} more commit(s)\n",
                        facts.commits.len() - i
                    ));
                    break;
                }
                if entry.len() > left {
                    // Even the first commit is cut: one huge body must not
                    // push the whole description past GitHub's limit.
                    let mut end = left;
                    while !entry.is_char_boundary(end) {
                        end -= 1;
                    }
                    entry.truncate(end);
                    entry.push_str("\n  ... (truncated)\n");
                    left = 0;
                } else {
                    left -= entry.len();
                }
                body.push_str(&entry);
            }
            if !facts.stat.trim().is_empty() {
                body.push_str(&format!(
                    "\n## Diff stat\n\n```\n{}\n```\n",
                    markdown_safe(facts.stat.trim())
                ));
            }
        } else {
            match &state.reviewed_commits {
                Some(subjects) => {
                    for s in subjects {
                        body.push_str(&format!("- {}\n", s.trim()));
                    }
                }
                None => {
                    // An older run kept only the prompt, with the commit list
                    // after its first paragraph.
                    let rest = state.instruction.split_once("\n\n").map_or("", |(_, r)| r);
                    body.push_str(rest.trim());
                    body.push('\n');
                }
            }
        }
    } else {
        let task = state.instruction.trim();
        let task = if task.is_empty() {
            "(empty task)"
        } else {
            task
        };
        body.push_str(&format!(
            "<details>\n<summary>Original task</summary>\n\n{}\n\n</details>\n",
            task.replace("</details>", "&lt;/details&gt;")
        ));
    }

    body.push_str(&format!(
        "\n---\nmagi:run/{} magi:candidate-{}\n",
        state.id,
        winner.to_ascii_lowercase()
    ));

    PrMessage { title, body }
}

/// The task with what the repository says about the existing work it names
/// appended, so an implementer knows what it started from and what it must
/// not redo. Unchanged when the task names nothing.
fn seeded_instruction(state: &RunState) -> String {
    match refs::describe(&state.seeds) {
        Some(facts) => format!(
            "{}\n\n# Existing work the task refers to\n\n{facts}\n\n\
             Candidates start from the unmerged branch named above, when there \
             is one, and carry any unmerged commit named by sha as a \
             cherry-pick. Check that this is what the task meant before \
             building on it.",
            state.instruction
        ),
        None => state.instruction.clone(),
    }
}

/// Does the winner have no commits ahead of the base it would land on?
/// Any failure to find out reads as "not empty": the merge then behaves as it
/// always did rather than refusing on a guess.
async fn merge_is_empty(repo: &Path, state: &RunState, branch: &str, mode: MergeMode) -> bool {
    let base = &state.base_branch;
    let mut against = base.clone();
    if mode == MergeMode::Pr {
        // A pull request lands on the remote's base, never the local branch
        // of the same name: if that cannot be read, "not empty" is the safe
        // answer.
        let remote = &state.config.merge.remote;
        let tracking = format!("{remote}/{base}");
        let fetched = git::fetch(repo, remote, base).await;
        if fetched.is_ok_and(|o| o.ok()) && git::rev_exists(repo, &tracking).await {
            against = tracking;
        } else {
            return false;
        }
    }
    matches!(git::commits_ahead(repo, &against, branch).await, Ok(0))
}

/// Why nothing was opened for an empty winner, with what the task's own
/// references resolved to.
fn empty_candidate_detail(state: &RunState, base: &str) -> String {
    let mut detail = format!(
        "empty candidate: the winning branch has 0 commits ahead of {base}, so there is \
         nothing to open a pull request for"
    );
    match refs::describe(&state.seeds) {
        Some(facts) => detail.push_str(&format!("\nReferences in the task:\n{facts}")),
        None => detail.push_str(
            "\nThe task names no existing branch or commit; if it means to land work \
             that lives elsewhere, name the branch (magi/<run>/<label>) or the sha.",
        ),
    }
    detail
}

/// What the `Pr` merge does once it knows whether the branch already has an
/// open pull request.
#[derive(Debug, PartialEq, Eq)]
enum PrPlan {
    Create,
    Adopt { url: String, title: String },
    Stop(String),
}

/// Pure decision behind the `Pr` merge: none -> create, one -> adopt, many or
/// a failed lookup -> stop with the real reason. Never guesses.
fn pr_merge_plan(found: Result<land::OpenPr>) -> PrPlan {
    match found {
        Ok(land::OpenPr::None) => PrPlan::Create,
        Ok(land::OpenPr::One { url, title }) => PrPlan::Adopt { url, title },
        Ok(land::OpenPr::Many(urls)) => PrPlan::Stop(format!(
            "several open pull requests exist for this branch, not picking one: {}",
            urls.join(" ")
        )),
        Err(e) => PrPlan::Stop(format!("could not look up open pull requests: {e:#}")),
    }
}

/// `gh pr create`, returning the PR url.
async fn gh_pr_create(
    cwd: &Path,
    base: &str,
    head: &str,
    title: &str,
    body: &str,
) -> Result<String> {
    let out = tokio::process::Command::new("gh")
        .args([
            "pr", "create", "--base", base, "--head", head, "--title", title, "--body", body,
        ])
        .current_dir(cwd)
        .quiet()
        .stdin(std::process::Stdio::null())
        .output()
        .await
        .context("spawn gh")?;
    if out.status.success() {
        Ok(String::from_utf8_lossy(&out.stdout).trim().to_owned())
    } else {
        bail!("{}", String::from_utf8_lossy(&out.stderr).trim().to_owned())
    }
}

/// Tear a run's worktrees and branches down.
///
/// `home` is where the updated `run.json` is saved (via
/// [`RunState::save_under`]), never the process-global [`crate::run::home`]:
/// a housekeeping pass already has its own honest `home` handed to it, and
/// falling through to the global here would write back through whichever
/// directory some other process or test pinned into that `OnceLock` first,
/// not the one the caller actually resolved its `runs` and `state` from.
pub async fn fold_run(state: &mut RunState, drop_winner: bool, home: &Path) -> Result<Vec<String>> {
    let repo = state.repo.clone();
    let root = state.worktree_root();
    let winner = state.tally.as_ref().map(|t| t.winner);
    let mut removed = Vec::new();

    for i in 0..state.candidates.len() {
        let c = state.candidates[i].clone();
        let is_winner = Some(c.label) == winner;
        if is_winner && !drop_winner {
            continue;
        }
        if c.worktree.exists() {
            git::worktree_remove(&repo, &c.worktree).await.ok();
            removed.push(c.worktree.to_string_lossy().into_owned());
        }
        // A branch handed to a later run (and its pull request) is not this
        // run's to delete.
        let handed_over = state.released_branches.contains(&c.branch);
        if !handed_over && git::branch_exists(&repo, &c.branch).await.unwrap_or(false) {
            git::branch_delete(&repo, &c.branch).await.ok();
            removed.push(c.branch.clone());
        }
        state.candidates[i].folded = true;
    }

    for name in std::fs::read_dir(&root).into_iter().flatten().flatten() {
        let path = name.path();
        let keep = !drop_winner
            && winner.is_some_and(|w| {
                path.file_name()
                    .is_some_and(|n| n == format!("cand-{w}").as_str())
            });
        if keep {
            continue;
        }
        git::worktree_remove(&repo, &path).await.ok();
        removed.push(path.to_string_lossy().into_owned());
    }

    // `root` (`wt/<...>/<short>/`) held nothing but this run's candidate and
    // judge worktrees, so once the loop above has cleared all of them out,
    // the parent is a bare directory nobody else was ever going to remove -
    // git only ever managed what was inside it. Left alone, one of these
    // accumulates per fully-folded run; the operator's own machine had 74.
    // `remove_if_empty` re-checks rather than assuming: a run whose winner
    // was kept (`!drop_winner`) leaves its directory behind on purpose, and
    // so does anything a run never claimed that happens to share the bay.
    remove_if_empty(&root);

    if state.enabled_worktree_config && drop_winner {
        // A release, not a raw disable: some sibling run in this repository
        // may still hold its own reference (see `git::acquire_worktree_config`),
        // and only the last release actually turns the setting back off.
        git::release_worktree_config(&repo).await.ok();
        state.enabled_worktree_config = false;
    }
    state.save_under(home)?;
    Ok(removed)
}

/// Remove `dir` if it exists and has nothing in it.
///
/// Best-effort and silent by design: a directory that is not empty (a run
/// whose winner is still parked there, a stray file some other process left)
/// is exactly the case this must refuse, and a directory that is already gone
/// is not a failure worth reporting either. `std::fs::remove_dir` itself
/// already refuses a non-empty directory, so the emptiness check below is
/// belt, not suspenders - it is what keeps this from ever attempting the
/// removal in the case that matters, rather than trusting `remove_dir`'s
/// error path to have no side effects if it ever changed.
fn remove_if_empty(dir: &Path) {
    if dir.is_dir() && std::fs::read_dir(dir).is_ok_and(|mut entries| entries.next().is_none()) {
        std::fs::remove_dir(dir).ok();
    }
}

/// Severity of the worst open finding in the last review round, for reporting.
pub fn worst_open(state: &RunState) -> Option<Severity> {
    state
        .reviews
        .last()?
        .reviews
        .iter()
        .flat_map(|r| r.findings.iter())
        .map(|f| f.severity)
        .max()
}

#[cfg(test)]
mod tests {
    #[test]
    fn should_retitle_only_replaces_magi_shaped_or_leaked_titles() {
        let leaked = vec!["chore(deps): update a crate".to_owned()];
        let own = "fix(daemon): apply a chosen action";
        assert!(should_retitle("", own, &leaked));
        assert!(should_retitle(
            &format!("{REVIEW_PROMPT_OPENING} `x`"),
            own,
            &leaked
        ));
        assert!(should_retitle(
            "chore: land candidate A of run 1",
            own,
            &leaked
        ));
        assert!(should_retitle(
            "magi: candidate A (uncommitted work)",
            own,
            &leaked
        ));
        assert!(should_retitle("chore(deps): update a crate", own, &leaked));
        assert!(!should_retitle("feat: renamed by hand", own, &leaked));
        assert!(!should_retitle("", "chore(deps): update a crate", &leaked));
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_merge_plan_creates_adopts_or_stops() {
        assert_eq!(pr_merge_plan(Ok(land::OpenPr::None)), PrPlan::Create);
        assert_eq!(
            pr_merge_plan(Ok(land::OpenPr::One {
                url: "u".into(),
                title: "t".into()
            })),
            PrPlan::Adopt {
                url: "u".into(),
                title: "t".into()
            }
        );
        let PrPlan::Stop(many) =
            pr_merge_plan(Ok(land::OpenPr::Many(vec!["a".into(), "b".into()])))
        else {
            panic!("many must stop");
        };
        assert!(many.contains('a') && many.contains('b'));
        let PrPlan::Stop(err) = pr_merge_plan(Err(anyhow::anyhow!("bad token"))) else {
            panic!("a failed lookup must stop");
        };
        assert!(err.contains("bad token"));
    }

    use super::*;
    use crate::run::GateStatus;
    use std::collections::BTreeMap;
    use std::time::Duration;

    fn conductor() -> AgentSpec {
        AgentSpec {
            id: "conductor".to_owned(),
            kind: crate::config::AgentKind::Command,
            model: None,
            command: vec!["true".to_owned()],
            extra_args: Vec::new(),
            env: BTreeMap::new(),
            prompt_delivery: None,
        }
    }

    fn spec(id: &str) -> AgentSpec {
        AgentSpec {
            id: id.to_owned(),
            kind: crate::config::AgentKind::Command,
            model: None,
            command: vec!["true".to_owned()],
            extra_args: Vec::new(),
            env: BTreeMap::new(),
            prompt_delivery: None,
        }
    }

    fn ids(xs: &[&str]) -> BTreeSet<String> {
        xs.iter().map(|s| (*s).to_owned()).collect()
    }

    #[test]
    fn pick_successor_skips_an_agent_another_seat_holds() {
        // Seats a and b of roster [a, b, c]; a fails, b holds the other seat.
        let roster = [spec("a"), spec("b"), spec("c")];
        let next = pick_successor(&roster, 0, &ids(&["a"]), None, &ids(&["b"]));
        assert_eq!(next.map(|s| s.id.as_str()), Some("c"));
    }

    #[test]
    fn pick_successor_respects_the_occupant_after_an_earlier_handover() {
        // The other seat started on c but was handed to d; c is free again.
        let roster = [spec("a"), spec("b"), spec("c"), spec("d")];
        let next = pick_successor(&roster, 0, &ids(&["a"]), None, &ids(&["b"]));
        assert_eq!(next.map(|s| s.id.as_str()), Some("c"));
        let next = pick_successor(&roster, 0, &ids(&["a"]), None, &ids(&["b", "c"]));
        assert_eq!(next.map(|s| s.id.as_str()), Some("d"));
    }

    #[test]
    fn pick_successor_falls_back_to_a_duplicate_when_no_distinct_agent_remains() {
        let roster = [spec("a"), spec("b")];
        let next = pick_successor(&roster, 0, &ids(&["a"]), None, &ids(&["b"]));
        assert_eq!(next.map(|s| s.id.as_str()), Some("b"));
        let carried = ids(&["b"]);
        let next = pick_successor(&roster, 0, &ids(&["a"]), Some(&carried), &ids(&["b"]));
        assert_eq!(next.map(|s| s.id.as_str()), Some("b"));
    }

    #[test]
    fn pick_successor_returns_none_without_any_untried_successor() {
        let roster = [spec("a"), spec("b")];
        assert!(pick_successor(&roster, 1, &ids(&["b"]), None, &ids(&["a"])).is_none());
        assert!(pick_successor(&roster, 0, &ids(&["a", "b"]), None, &ids(&[])).is_none());
        let carried = ids(&["a"]);
        assert!(pick_successor(&roster, 0, &ids(&["a", "b"]), Some(&carried), &ids(&[])).is_none());
    }

    #[test]
    fn pick_successor_rescue_avoids_another_seats_occupant() {
        // b is a carried failure and free; a is held by the other seat.
        let roster = [spec("a"), spec("b"), spec("c")];
        let carried = ids(&["b", "c"]);
        let next = pick_successor(&roster, 2, &ids(&["c"]), Some(&carried), &ids(&["a"]));
        assert_eq!(next.map(|s| s.id.as_str()), Some("b"));
    }

    #[test]
    fn next_for_seat_prefers_an_agent_that_has_not_failed() {
        let roster = [spec("a"), spec("b"), spec("c")];
        let next = next_for_seat(&roster, 0, &ids(&["a"]), &ids(&["b"]));
        assert_eq!(next.map(|s| s.id.as_str()), Some("c"));
    }

    #[test]
    fn next_for_seat_rescues_a_failed_agent_only_when_nothing_else_is_left() {
        let roster = [spec("a"), spec("b"), spec("c")];
        let failed = ids(&["a", "b", "c"]);
        // Rescue looks at the whole roster, once per id, then runs out.
        let mut tried = ids(&["b"]);
        let first = next_for_seat(&roster, 1, &tried, &failed).expect("rescue");
        assert_eq!(first.id, "a");
        tried.insert(first.id.clone());
        let second = next_for_seat(&roster, 1, &tried, &failed).expect("rescue");
        assert_eq!(second.id, "c");
        tried.insert(second.id.clone());
        assert!(next_for_seat(&roster, 1, &tried, &failed).is_none());
    }

    #[test]
    fn next_for_seat_ignores_failed_ids_no_longer_on_the_roster() {
        let roster = [spec("a"), spec("b")];
        let next = next_for_seat(&roster, 0, &ids(&["a"]), &ids(&["gone"]));
        assert_eq!(next.map(|s| s.id.as_str()), Some("b"));
    }

    #[test]
    fn pick_start_spec_starts_on_the_last_answerer_when_still_eligible() {
        let roster = [spec("a"), spec("b"), spec("c")];
        let h = SeatHistory {
            failed: ids(&["a"]),
            last_ok: Some("b".to_owned()),
            last_fail: None,
        };
        assert_eq!(pick_start_spec(&roster, spec("a"), Some(&h)).id, "b");
        // A last answerer that left the roster, or later failed, is ignored.
        let gone = SeatHistory {
            last_ok: Some("zzz".to_owned()),
            ..h.clone()
        };
        assert_eq!(pick_start_spec(&roster, spec("a"), Some(&gone)).id, "b");
        let failed = SeatHistory {
            failed: ids(&["a", "b"]),
            last_ok: Some("b".to_owned()),
            last_fail: None,
        };
        assert_eq!(pick_start_spec(&roster, spec("a"), Some(&failed)).id, "c");
    }

    #[test]
    fn handover_seat_mints_a_session_id_distinct_from_the_previous_agents() {
        let first = SeatState::new("review-1", "alpha", 7);
        let next = handover_seat("review-1", "gamma", 7);
        assert_ne!(first.claude_session, next.claude_session);
    }

    #[test]
    fn re_handing_a_seat_to_the_same_agent_mints_a_new_session_id() {
        let mut state = state_with_summary("x", "y");
        let a = handover_seat("review-1", "beta", state.next_seat_seed());
        let b = handover_seat("review-1", "beta", state.next_seat_seed());
        assert_ne!(a.claude_session, b.claude_session);
    }

    #[test]
    fn pick_start_spec_falls_back_to_the_spec_when_the_whole_roster_failed() {
        let roster = [spec("a"), spec("b")];
        let h = SeatHistory {
            failed: ids(&["a", "b"]),
            ..SeatHistory::default()
        };
        assert_eq!(pick_start_spec(&roster, spec("b"), Some(&h)).id, "b");
        assert_eq!(pick_start_spec(&roster, spec("b"), None).id, "b");
        assert_eq!(pick_start_spec(&[], spec("b"), Some(&h)).id, "b");
    }

    // `next_untried_in_roster` is the property `resume_seat_handovers`'s own
    // fallback loop depends on to terminate: it must walk forward from the
    // seat's own position, never restart at the front of the roster, and it
    // must never hand back an id already tried, however many times that id
    // happens to appear.

    #[test]
    fn failure_signature_ignores_numbers_and_paths() {
        assert_eq!(
            failure_signature("exited with Some(2) and no usable output"),
            failure_signature("exited with Some(137) and no usable output")
        );
        assert_eq!(
            failure_signature("cannot open /tmp/a/b.txt: denied\nsecond line"),
            failure_signature("cannot open /var/x.txt: denied")
        );
        assert_ne!(failure_signature("boom"), failure_signature("bang"));
    }

    #[test]
    fn quota_and_timeout_always_hand_over_other_failures_stop_on_a_repeat() {
        let other = FailClass::Other("x".into());
        assert!(should_hand_over(None, &FailClass::Quota));
        assert!(should_hand_over(Some(&other), &FailClass::Quota));
        assert!(should_hand_over(
            Some(&FailClass::Timeout),
            &FailClass::Timeout
        ));
        assert!(should_hand_over(None, &other));
        assert!(!should_hand_over(Some(&other), &other));
        assert!(should_hand_over(
            Some(&other),
            &FailClass::Other("y".into())
        ));
        // A quota or timeout in between ends the run of identical failures.
        assert!(should_hand_over(Some(&FailClass::Timeout), &other));
        assert!(should_hand_over(Some(&FailClass::Quota), &other));
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_handover_seat_never_reuses_the_previous_agents_session_id() {
        let a = SeatState::new("judge-1", "alpha", 7);
        let b = handover_seat("judge-1", "beta", 7);
        assert_ne!(a.claude_session, b.claude_session);
        assert_eq!(b.turns, 0);
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_timeout_is_classified_apart_from_other_failures() {
        assert_eq!(
            FailClass::of(&AgentOutcome::Failed(TIMED_OUT.to_owned())),
            Some(FailClass::Timeout)
        );
        assert!(matches!(
            FailClass::of(&AgentOutcome::Failed("boom".to_owned())),
            Some(FailClass::Other(_))
        ));
    }

    #[test]
    fn next_untried_in_roster_walks_forward_from_the_seats_own_position() {
        let roster = vec![spec("alpha"), spec("beta"), spec("gamma")];
        let tried = BTreeSet::from(["beta".to_owned()]);
        // beta sits at index 1; the next candidate is gamma, never alpha —
        // which is very likely a different candidate slot's own agent.
        let next = next_untried_in_roster(&roster, 1, &tried);
        assert_eq!(next.map(|s| s.id.as_str()), Some("gamma"));
    }

    #[test]
    fn next_untried_in_roster_does_not_wrap_back_past_its_own_start() {
        let roster = vec![spec("alpha"), spec("beta")];
        let tried = BTreeSet::from(["beta".to_owned()]);
        // beta is the roster's last entry: nothing follows it, and alpha —
        // earlier in the roster, almost certainly a different candidate
        // slot's own agent — must not be reached by wrapping back to it.
        assert!(next_untried_in_roster(&roster, 1, &tried).is_none());
    }

    #[test]
    fn next_untried_in_roster_stops_once_the_tail_is_exhausted_even_if_earlier_ids_are_untried() {
        let roster = vec![spec("alpha"), spec("beta"), spec("gamma")];
        let tried = BTreeSet::from(["beta".to_owned(), "gamma".to_owned()]);
        // beta (index 1) and gamma (index 2, the only entry after it) have
        // both been tried; alpha (index 0) never has, but it comes before
        // beta's own position, so there is nothing further for this seat.
        assert!(next_untried_in_roster(&roster, 1, &tried).is_none());
    }

    #[test]
    fn next_untried_in_roster_skips_ids_already_tried_even_when_duplicated() {
        let roster = vec![spec("a"), spec("a"), spec("b")];
        let tried = BTreeSet::from(["a".to_owned()]);
        let next = next_untried_in_roster(&roster, 0, &tried);
        assert_eq!(next.map(|s| s.id.as_str()), Some("b"));
    }

    #[test]
    fn next_untried_in_roster_returns_none_once_every_id_is_tried() {
        let roster = vec![spec("a"), spec("b")];
        let tried = BTreeSet::from(["a".to_owned(), "b".to_owned()]);
        assert!(next_untried_in_roster(&roster, 0, &tried).is_none());
    }

    #[test]
    fn remove_if_empty_only_ever_takes_a_bare_directory() {
        let dir = tempfile::tempdir().unwrap();
        let bay = dir.path().join("ffff");

        // Not there yet: nothing to do, nothing to panic on.
        remove_if_empty(&bay);
        assert!(!bay.exists());

        // Something still inside - the winner's worktree, or a stray file -
        // keeps the directory standing.
        std::fs::create_dir_all(bay.join("cand-A")).unwrap();
        remove_if_empty(&bay);
        assert!(bay.exists(), "non-empty directory must survive");

        // Once the last entry is gone, so is the directory itself.
        std::fs::remove_dir(bay.join("cand-A")).unwrap();
        remove_if_empty(&bay);
        assert!(!bay.exists(), "an empty bay is a leftover, not a record");
    }

    // `round_is_clean` is the exact decision this task fixed: a round with a
    // seat that never answered must not read the same as a round every seat
    // actually reviewed. These are deterministic and process-free by design —
    // the equivalent end-to-end check (a real reviewer timing out under a
    // live graph run) is a genuine race against wall-clock contention, and a
    // spawn slow enough to blow even a generous budget under a loaded test
    // run must not turn this specific regression check flaky.

    #[test]
    fn a_full_panel_that_found_nothing_is_clean() {
        assert!(round_is_clean(
            0,
            true,
            2,
            2,
            0,
            IncompleteReviewPolicy::Block
        ));
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_missing_seat_is_never_clean_under_the_default_policy() {
        assert!(!round_is_clean(
            0,
            true,
            1,
            2,
            0,
            IncompleteReviewPolicy::Block
        ));
    }

    #[test]
    fn warn_policy_still_refuses_a_missing_seat_with_open_findings() {
        assert!(!round_is_clean(
            1,
            true,
            1,
            2,
            0,
            IncompleteReviewPolicy::Warn
        ));
    }

    #[test]
    fn warn_policy_gates_a_missing_seat_once_what_answered_is_clean() {
        assert!(round_is_clean(
            0,
            true,
            1,
            2,
            0,
            IncompleteReviewPolicy::Warn
        ));
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_full_panel_with_an_open_finding_is_not_clean() {
        assert!(!round_is_clean(
            1,
            true,
            2,
            2,
            0,
            IncompleteReviewPolicy::Block
        ));
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_full_panel_with_a_red_e2e_is_not_clean() {
        assert!(!round_is_clean(
            0,
            false,
            2,
            2,
            0,
            IncompleteReviewPolicy::Block
        ));
    }

    // The stall this task closes: under the default `block` policy, a seat
    // missing only because it was rate limited must not force a wait for a
    // session limit that will not lift by the next round. `round_is_clean`
    // is where that quorum carve-out lives; the review loop around it never
    // changes what a reviewer's vote or a finding's severity means.

    #[test]
    fn a_seat_missing_only_to_its_own_quota_is_clean_under_the_default_policy() {
        // 1 of 2 answered, and the one missing was quota'd — the exact
        // "review-2 rate limited (quota)" shape from the field report.
        assert!(round_is_clean(
            0,
            true,
            1,
            2,
            1,
            IncompleteReviewPolicy::Block
        ));
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_seat_missing_for_a_reason_other_than_quota_still_waits() {
        // 1 of 2 answered, but the miss was a crash/timeout/parse failure,
        // not a quota loss (`quota_missing` stays 0) — worth another try.
        assert!(!round_is_clean(
            0,
            true,
            1,
            2,
            0,
            IncompleteReviewPolicy::Block
        ));
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_quota_loss_does_not_excuse_an_open_finding_or_a_red_e2e() {
        assert!(!round_is_clean(
            1,
            true,
            1,
            2,
            1,
            IncompleteReviewPolicy::Block
        ));
        assert!(!round_is_clean(
            0,
            false,
            1,
            2,
            1,
            IncompleteReviewPolicy::Block
        ));
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_panel_lost_entirely_to_quota_still_waits_rather_than_deciding_on_nobody() {
        // Every seat quota'd, nobody answered: there is no panel to decide
        // on, so this must fall through to the existing block-and-retry
        // fallback rather than call an unreviewed patch clean.
        assert!(!round_is_clean(
            0,
            true,
            0,
            2,
            2,
            IncompleteReviewPolicy::Block
        ));
    }

    fn outcome(code: Option<i32>, resource_blocked: bool) -> CommandOutcome {
        CommandOutcome {
            command: "test".to_owned(),
            code,
            output_tail: String::new(),
            duration_ms: 0,
            resource_blocked,
        }
    }

    #[test]
    fn verify_is_inconclusive_only_when_a_resource_blocked_outcome_is_present() {
        assert!(!verify_inconclusive(&[outcome(Some(0), false)]));
        assert!(
            !verify_inconclusive(&[outcome(Some(1), false)]),
            "an ordinary failure is still evidence about the patch"
        );
        assert!(verify_inconclusive(&[outcome(None, true)]));
        assert!(
            verify_inconclusive(&[outcome(Some(0), false), outcome(None, true)]),
            "one inconclusive outcome taints the whole batch"
        );
        assert!(!verify_inconclusive(&[]));
    }

    #[tokio::test]
    async fn timed_out_pid_waiting_returns_as_soon_as_every_pid_is_confirmed_dead() {
        // Alive for the first two checks, then dead - confirms the loop
        // actually re-polls rather than deciding once and sleeping out the
        // ceiling regardless.
        let calls = std::sync::atomic::AtomicUsize::new(0);
        let started = Instant::now();
        wait_for_pids_with(
            &[123],
            |_| calls.fetch_add(1, std::sync::atomic::Ordering::SeqCst) < 2,
            Duration::from_millis(5),
            Duration::from_secs(5),
        )
        .await;
        assert!(
            calls.load(std::sync::atomic::Ordering::SeqCst) >= 3,
            "must keep checking rather than deciding on the first answer"
        );
        assert!(
            started.elapsed() < Duration::from_secs(1),
            "must return the moment it is confirmed dead, not wait out the ceiling"
        );
    }

    #[tokio::test]
    async fn timed_out_pid_waiting_gives_up_at_its_ceiling_if_never_confirmed_dead() {
        let started = Instant::now();
        wait_for_pids_with(
            &[123],
            |_| true, // never reports dead
            Duration::from_millis(5),
            Duration::from_millis(30),
        )
        .await;
        let elapsed = started.elapsed();
        assert!(
            elapsed >= Duration::from_millis(30),
            "must not give up before its own ceiling: {elapsed:?}"
        );
        assert!(
            elapsed < Duration::from_secs(1),
            "must not wait past its own ceiling either: {elapsed:?}"
        );
    }

    #[tokio::test]
    async fn timed_out_pid_waiting_is_a_no_op_when_nothing_was_still_running() {
        let started = Instant::now();
        wait_for_pids_with(
            &[],
            |_| true,
            Duration::from_secs(5),
            Duration::from_secs(5),
        )
        .await;
        assert!(
            started.elapsed() < Duration::from_millis(200),
            "an empty pid list has nothing to confirm"
        );
    }

    // `review_conclusion` is the exact decision the review hand-off task
    // fixed: a round budget spent (or a tree that stopped moving) must not
    // collapse into `Blocked` regardless of what verification actually
    // said. Deterministic and process-free for the same reason the
    // `round_is_clean` family above is.
    fn review_round(
        clean: bool,
        blocking: usize,
        answered: usize,
        expected: usize,
        progressed: bool,
        e2e_ok: bool,
    ) -> ReviewRound {
        ReviewRound {
            round: 1,
            head: "h".to_owned(),
            verified_head: None,
            verified_at: None,
            reviews: Vec::new(),
            e2e: vec![CommandOutcome {
                command: "test".to_owned(),
                code: Some(if e2e_ok { 0 } else { 1 }),
                output_tail: String::new(),
                duration_ms: 0,
                resource_blocked: false,
            }],
            verify_retried: false,
            e2e_deferred: false,
            e2e_defer_reason: None,
            fix: None,
            blocking,
            answered,
            expected,
            clean,
            progressed,
            vote_split: false,
            reconsideration: Vec::new(),
            verdict: None,
        }
    }

    #[test]
    fn review_conclusion_is_none_when_nothing_has_run() {
        assert_eq!(review_conclusion(&[], 3), None);
    }

    #[test]
    fn review_conclusion_is_none_while_rounds_remain() {
        let rounds = vec![review_round(false, 1, 2, 2, true, true)];
        assert_eq!(review_conclusion(&rounds, 3), None);
    }

    #[test]
    fn review_conclusion_is_gating_once_a_round_is_clean() {
        let rounds = vec![review_round(true, 0, 2, 2, false, true)];
        assert_eq!(review_conclusion(&rounds, 3), Some(RunStatus::Gating));
    }

    #[test]
    fn review_conclusion_hands_off_when_the_budget_is_spent_and_e2e_is_green() {
        let rounds = vec![
            review_round(false, 1, 2, 2, true, true),
            review_round(false, 1, 2, 2, true, true),
        ];
        assert_eq!(review_conclusion(&rounds, 2), Some(RunStatus::Gating));
    }

    #[test]
    fn review_conclusion_blocks_when_the_budget_is_spent_and_e2e_is_red() {
        let rounds = vec![
            review_round(false, 1, 2, 2, true, true),
            review_round(false, 1, 2, 2, true, false),
        ];
        assert_eq!(review_conclusion(&rounds, 2), Some(RunStatus::Blocked));
    }

    #[test]
    fn review_conclusion_stays_none_when_the_budget_is_spent_but_the_last_round_could_not_run() {
        // Magi never got a command to run against this round's own head — a
        // resource-blocked attempt, not a red one — so this must never
        // settle on `Blocked` the way a genuine e2e failure would. `None`
        // here is what tells `Runner::review_loop` to retry the check
        // itself rather than trust this cheap recomputation with a verdict
        // it cannot actually produce.
        let mut blocked = review_round(false, 1, 2, 2, true, false);
        blocked.e2e[0].resource_blocked = true;
        let rounds = vec![review_round(false, 1, 2, 2, true, true), blocked];
        assert_eq!(review_conclusion(&rounds, 2), None);
    }

    #[test]
    fn review_conclusion_blocks_an_incomplete_panel_that_raised_nothing_even_with_green_e2e() {
        // Missing input, not a verified tree — never a hand-off candidate.
        let rounds = vec![review_round(false, 0, 1, 2, false, true)];
        assert_eq!(review_conclusion(&rounds, 1), Some(RunStatus::Blocked));
    }

    #[test]
    fn review_conclusion_hands_off_when_the_tree_stagnates_before_the_budget_is_spent() {
        let rounds = vec![
            review_round(false, 1, 2, 2, false, true),
            review_round(false, 1, 2, 2, false, true),
        ];
        assert_eq!(review_conclusion(&rounds, 10), Some(RunStatus::Gating));
    }

    fn secs(n: u64) -> Duration {
        Duration::from_secs(n)
    }

    /// A throwaway repo with one commit on `main`, for tests that need `merge`
    /// to make real (and, if it runs at all, real*ly fail*) git calls.
    fn init_repo(dir: &Path) {
        let run = |args: &[&str]| {
            let out = std::process::Command::new("git")
                .args(args)
                .current_dir(dir)
                .quiet()
                .output()
                .expect("spawn git");
            assert!(
                out.status.success(),
                "git {args:?} failed: {}",
                String::from_utf8_lossy(&out.stderr)
            );
        };
        run(&["init", "-b", "main"]);
        run(&["config", "user.name", "magi test"]);
        run(&["config", "user.email", "magi@example.com"]);
        std::fs::write(dir.join("README.md"), "# fixture\n").unwrap();
        run(&["add", "-A"]);
        run(&["commit", "-m", "init"]);
    }

    // `settle_questions` is what closes the ghost the phone showed: a run's
    // seat asked something, the run then ended, and nothing was left to
    // abandon the question it left `open`. `HOME` is a process-wide
    // `OnceLock` (see `run::set_home`'s doc), so this only wins the race the
    // first time it runs in the binary — every test below still reaches the
    // same directory whichever call won, and each gets its own run id from
    // `RunState::new`, so they never collide there.
    fn ask_test_home() {
        crate::run::pin_test_home();
    }

    /// A minimal, git-free `Runner` at a given status — `settle_questions`
    /// reads nothing else off it.
    fn runner_at(status: RunStatus) -> Runner {
        let mut state = RunState::new(
            PathBuf::from("/nonexistent/repo"),
            "main".to_owned(),
            "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            "task".to_owned(),
            Config::default(),
        );
        state.status = status;
        Runner {
            state,
            roles: ResolvedRoles {
                implementers: Vec::new(),
                judges: Vec::new(),
                reviewers: Vec::new(),
                fixer: None,
                conductor: conductor(),
                implementer_roster: Vec::new(),
                judge_roster: Vec::new(),
                reviewer_roster: Vec::new(),
            },
            sem: Arc::new(Semaphore::new(1)),
            pause: Pause::new(),
            interrupt: Pause::new(),
        }
    }

    /// `park_here` folding in the reason `Pause::park_because` recorded -
    /// this is what lets an operator reading a run's events tell an
    /// interrupt-driven park from an ordinary shutdown park.
    #[test]
    fn park_here_folds_the_interrupt_reason_into_the_park_event() {
        crate::run::pin_test_home();
        let mut runner = runner_at(RunStatus::Implementing);
        let interrupt = Pause::new();
        runner.watch_interrupt(interrupt.clone());

        interrupt.park_because("task a1b2 asked to run first");

        assert!(runner.park_here().expect("park_here"));
        assert!(runner.state.parked);
        let last = runner.state.events.last().expect("a park event");
        assert_eq!(last.node, "park");
        assert!(
            last.message.contains("task a1b2 asked to run first"),
            "expected the interrupt reason in {:?}",
            last.message
        );
    }

    /// `watch_interrupt` and `on_pause` are genuinely independent: an ordinary
    /// shutdown `Pause` (what `Stop::park` hands every run, shared and never
    /// cleared) must not make a *different* run - one only watching its own,
    /// unshared interrupt `Pause` - see itself as parked. If a future change
    /// ever collapsed these back into one handle, the interrupt scheduler
    /// would park every run for the rest of the daemon's life, not just the
    /// one it meant to interrupt.
    #[test]
    fn the_stop_level_pause_and_a_runs_interrupt_pause_do_not_leak_into_each_other() {
        crate::run::pin_test_home();
        let mut runner = runner_at(RunStatus::Implementing);
        let shutdown = Pause::new();
        runner.on_pause(shutdown.clone());
        let interrupt = Pause::new();
        runner.watch_interrupt(interrupt.clone());

        // Nobody has asked for anything yet.
        assert!(!runner.park_here().expect("park_here"));
        assert!(!runner.state.parked);

        // Only the interrupt handle fires; the shutdown handle stays clear.
        interrupt.park_because("test");
        assert!(!shutdown.parked());
        assert!(runner.park_here().expect("park_here"));
    }

    /// The property every prior attempt at this feature failed to pin down:
    /// asking a run to park while one of its nodes has a real, in-flight
    /// async operation running (an agent call, in production) must not cut
    /// that operation short. `park_here` is only ever consulted *between*
    /// `execute`'s node calls - see its own doc - so nothing inside a node
    /// can observe a park request until the node itself returns. This proves
    /// that structurally, with real `tokio` concurrency and a channel
    /// handshake (never a sleep, which would only prove "usually", not
    /// "cannot"): the "node" below reports that it has genuinely started,
    /// and only then is the park requested; the node still has to be told to
    /// finish before `park_here` is ever called, exactly mirroring every
    /// `self.some_node().await; if self.park_here()? { return Ok(()); }` pair
    /// in `execute`.
    #[tokio::test]
    async fn a_park_request_made_mid_node_only_takes_effect_at_the_next_boundary() {
        crate::run::pin_test_home();
        let mut runner = runner_at(RunStatus::Implementing);
        let interrupt = Pause::new();
        runner.watch_interrupt(interrupt.clone());

        let (started_tx, started_rx) = tokio::sync::oneshot::channel::<()>();
        let (finish_tx, finish_rx) = tokio::sync::oneshot::channel::<()>();

        // Stands in for one node's in-flight agent call: it proves it has
        // genuinely started, then blocks - exactly as a spawned CLI process
        // does - until told to finish.
        let node = async move {
            started_tx.send(()).expect("send started");
            finish_rx.await.expect("recv finish");
            "node finished"
        };

        let interrupter = async move {
            started_rx.await.expect("recv started");
            // The call is now genuinely in flight. Ask it to park.
            interrupt.park_because("higher-priority task waiting");
            // Nothing the node does can observe this yet - there is no
            // check inside it, by construction - so let the executor run
            // anything pending and then let the node finish on its own.
            tokio::task::yield_now().await;
            finish_tx.send(()).expect("send finish");
        };

        let (node_result, ()) = tokio::join!(node, interrupter);
        assert_eq!(
            node_result, "node finished",
            "the in-flight call ran to completion"
        );

        // Only now, at the boundary the real `execute` would check right
        // after this node, does the park take effect.
        assert!(runner.park_here().expect("park_here"));
        assert!(runner.state.parked);
    }

    /// A run parked mid-competition carries every field it had accumulated
    /// through the exact same disk round-trip an ordinary resume uses -
    /// `RunState::save`/`RunState::load`, which is all `Runner::resume` is.
    /// Nothing about parking for an interrupt is a special case of that path;
    /// this is what proves it rather than assuming it.
    #[test]
    fn a_run_parked_for_an_interrupt_resumes_with_nothing_lost() {
        crate::run::pin_test_home();
        let mut runner = runner_at(RunStatus::Judging);
        // `Runner::resume` re-resolves roles from the saved config, which
        // refuses an empty roster - give it the same minimal one `conductor`
        // itself uses.
        runner.state.config.agents = vec![conductor()];
        runner.state.candidates = vec![Candidate {
            index: 0,
            label: 'A',
            agent: "alpha".to_owned(),
            branch: "magi/x/A".to_owned(),
            worktree: PathBuf::from("/nonexistent/worktree"),
            summary: "did the thing".to_owned(),
            stat: "1 file changed".to_owned(),
            files: 1,
            commits: 1,
            empty: false,
            failed: None,
            verified_noop: None,
            duration_ms: 1234,
            folded: false,
        }];
        let run_id = runner.state.id.clone();

        let interrupt = Pause::new();
        runner.watch_interrupt(interrupt.clone());
        interrupt.park_because("task c3d4 asked to run first");
        assert!(runner.park_here().expect("park_here"));

        let resumed = Runner::resume(&run_id).expect("resume");
        assert_eq!(resumed.state.candidates.len(), 1);
        assert_eq!(resumed.state.candidates[0].summary, "did the thing");
        assert_eq!(resumed.state.candidates[0].branch, "magi/x/A");
        assert_eq!(resumed.state.status, runner.state.status);
        assert!(
            resumed.state.parked,
            "still parked until `execute` actually walks the graph again"
        );
        assert!(resumed.state.events.iter().any(|e| e.node == "park"));
    }

    /// A fresh open question on `run`, stored and handed back for assertions.
    fn ask_open_question(store: &ask::Questions, run: &str) -> ask::Question {
        let mut q = ask::Question::new(
            run.to_owned(),
            "implement".to_owned(),
            "impl-A".to_owned(),
            "Which storage backend should the cache use?".to_owned(),
            String::new(),
            vec!["SQLite".to_owned(), "Redis".to_owned()],
        );
        store.put(&mut q).unwrap();
        q
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_failed_runs_open_question_is_abandoned() {
        ask_test_home();
        let store = ask::Questions::open();
        let mut runner = runner_at(RunStatus::Failed);
        let run = runner.state.id.clone();
        let q = ask_open_question(&store, &run);

        runner.settle_questions();

        let back = store.get(&q.id).unwrap();
        assert!(
            !back.status.open(),
            "the seat that asked died with the run; nobody is left to read an answer"
        );
        assert!(
            back.detail.contains(&run) && back.detail.contains("failed"),
            "the reason names what the run became, not just that it is gone: {}",
            back.detail
        );
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_merged_runs_open_question_is_abandoned_too() {
        ask_test_home();
        let store = ask::Questions::open();
        // A run that finishes cleanly still leaves nobody to read an answer -
        // this is not only a failure-path cleanup.
        for status in [RunStatus::Merged, RunStatus::Ready] {
            let mut runner = runner_at(status);
            let run = runner.state.id.clone();
            let q = ask_open_question(&store, &run);

            runner.settle_questions();

            let back = store.get(&q.id).unwrap();
            assert!(
                !back.status.open(),
                "{status:?} run's question must not outlive the run"
            );
        }
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_still_resumable_runs_open_question_is_left_alone() {
        ask_test_home();
        let store = ask::Questions::open();
        // `Blocked` and `Stalled` can still be resumed — the candidates, the
        // review round and the seat sessions are all still on disk — so a
        // question asked mid-round may yet get a real answer from a real
        // resume. Sweeping it here would be exactly the failure mode this
        // whole feature exists to avoid on the other side.
        for status in [RunStatus::Blocked, RunStatus::Stalled] {
            let mut runner = runner_at(status);
            let run = runner.state.id.clone();
            let q = ask_open_question(&store, &run);

            runner.settle_questions();

            let back = store.get(&q.id).unwrap();
            assert!(
                back.status.open(),
                "{status:?} is still alive; the question must still be waiting"
            );
        }
    }

    #[test]
    fn settle_questions_never_touches_an_already_answered_question() {
        ask_test_home();
        let store = ask::Questions::open();
        let mut runner = runner_at(RunStatus::Failed);
        let run = runner.state.id.clone();
        let mut q = ask_open_question(&store, &run);
        q.answer(crate::ask::Answer::Choice("SQLite".to_owned()))
            .unwrap();
        store.put(&mut q).unwrap();

        // Called twice, the way a crash-recovered daemon reclaim and the
        // graph's own cleanup both can for the same run — `abandon_for_run`
        // only ever touches what is still open, so this must be inert both
        // times, not merely the second.
        runner.settle_questions();
        runner.settle_questions();

        let back = store.get(&q.id).unwrap();
        assert_eq!(
            back.status,
            ask::QuestionStatus::Answered,
            "a real answer is a decision on record, never overwritten by a sweep"
        );
    }

    /// `fold_run(&mut state, drop_winner = false)` is exactly the call
    /// `clean::fold_due` makes for a `Ready`/`Failed` run - one that finished
    /// without merging, whose winner is still the operator's answer to read.
    /// Nothing previously called `fold_run` itself with a real `tally`, so
    /// this is the first test to pin down the one distinction the whole
    /// automatic-fold feature depends on: the winner's worktree and branch
    /// must survive, everything else sharing the run's worktree bay - a
    /// loser, standing in for a judge/review worktree too, since `fold_run`'s
    /// second sweep treats every non-winner directory under the bay alike -
    /// must not.
    #[tokio::test]
    async fn fold_run_keeps_only_the_winner_when_the_winner_is_not_dropped() {
        crate::run::pin_test_home();
        let tmp = tempfile::tempdir().expect("tempdir");
        let repo = tmp.path().join("repo");
        std::fs::create_dir_all(&repo).unwrap();
        init_repo(&repo);

        let mut config = Config::default();
        config.graph.worktree_root = Some(tmp.path().join("wt"));

        let mut state = RunState::new(
            repo.clone(),
            "main".to_owned(),
            "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            "task".to_owned(),
            config,
        );
        let root = state.worktree_root();
        let wt_a = root.join("cand-A");
        let wt_b = root.join("cand-B");
        git::worktree_add_branch(&repo, &wt_a, "magi/x/A", "main")
            .await
            .expect("worktree A");
        git::worktree_add_branch(&repo, &wt_b, "magi/x/B", "main")
            .await
            .expect("worktree B");

        state.candidates = vec![
            Candidate {
                index: 0,
                label: 'A',
                agent: "alpha".to_owned(),
                branch: "magi/x/A".to_owned(),
                worktree: wt_a.clone(),
                summary: String::new(),
                stat: String::new(),
                files: 0,
                commits: 0,
                empty: false,
                failed: None,
                verified_noop: None,
                duration_ms: 0,
                folded: false,
            },
            Candidate {
                index: 1,
                label: 'B',
                agent: "beta".to_owned(),
                branch: "magi/x/B".to_owned(),
                worktree: wt_b.clone(),
                summary: String::new(),
                stat: String::new(),
                files: 0,
                commits: 0,
                empty: false,
                failed: None,
                verified_noop: None,
                duration_ms: 0,
                folded: false,
            },
        ];
        state.tally = Some(Tally {
            first_choice: BTreeMap::from([('A', 1)]),
            borda: BTreeMap::new(),
            winner: 'A',
            rankings: 1,
            unanimous_initial: true,
            deliberated: false,
            changed_votes: 0,
            unanimous_final: true,
            tie_break: None,
            judges: 1,
            present: 1,
            quorum: 1,
            met_quorum: true,
            uncontested: None,
        });
        state.status = RunStatus::Ready;

        fold_run(&mut state, false, &crate::run::home())
            .await
            .expect("fold_run");

        assert!(wt_a.exists(), "the unmerged winner's worktree survives");
        assert!(
            git::branch_exists(&repo, "magi/x/A").await.unwrap(),
            "the unmerged winner's branch survives"
        );
        assert!(
            !state.candidates[0].folded,
            "the winner is not marked folded"
        );

        assert!(!wt_b.exists(), "the loser's worktree is removed");
        assert!(
            !git::branch_exists(&repo, "magi/x/B").await.unwrap(),
            "the loser's branch is removed"
        );
        assert!(state.candidates[1].folded, "the loser is marked folded");
    }

    /// A branch handed to a later run is that run's (and its pull request's):
    /// folding the run that released it must not delete it.
    #[tokio::test]
    async fn fold_run_keeps_a_branch_that_was_handed_to_a_later_run() {
        let tmp = tempfile::tempdir().expect("tempdir");
        let repo = tmp.path().join("repo");
        std::fs::create_dir_all(&repo).unwrap();
        init_repo(&repo);
        let home = tmp.path().join("home");

        let mut config = Config::default();
        config.graph.worktree_root = Some(tmp.path().join("wt"));
        let mut state = RunState::new(
            repo.clone(),
            "main".to_owned(),
            "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            "task".to_owned(),
            config,
        );
        // The worktree is already gone (released); the branch survives.
        git::git(&repo, &["branch", "magi/x/A", "main"])
            .await
            .expect("branch");
        state.candidates = vec![Candidate {
            index: 0,
            label: 'A',
            agent: "alpha".to_owned(),
            branch: "magi/x/A".to_owned(),
            worktree: state.worktree_root().join("cand-A"),
            summary: String::new(),
            stat: String::new(),
            files: 0,
            commits: 0,
            empty: false,
            failed: None,
            verified_noop: None,
            duration_ms: 0,
            folded: true,
        }];
        state.released_to = Some("20260901-000000-new1".to_owned());
        state.released_branches = vec!["magi/x/A".to_owned()];

        fold_run(&mut state, true, &home).await.expect("fold_run");

        assert!(
            git::branch_exists(&repo, "magi/x/A").await.unwrap(),
            "the handed-over branch survives a fold"
        );
    }

    /// A winner with nothing ahead of the base is caught before `gh` is ever
    /// asked for a pull request, and the message carries what the task's
    /// references resolved to.
    #[tokio::test]
    async fn an_empty_winner_is_detected_before_a_pull_request_is_attempted() {
        let tmp = tempfile::tempdir().expect("tempdir");
        let repo = tmp.path().join("repo");
        std::fs::create_dir_all(&repo).unwrap();
        init_repo(&repo);
        let run = |args: &[&str]| {
            let out = std::process::Command::new("git")
                .quiet()
                .args(args)
                .current_dir(&repo)
                .output()
                .expect("spawn git");
            assert!(out.status.success(), "git {args:?}");
        };
        run(&["branch", "magi/x/A"]);
        run(&["checkout", "-q", "-b", "magi/x/B"]);
        std::fs::write(repo.join("f.txt"), "x\n").unwrap();
        run(&["add", "-A"]);
        run(&["commit", "-q", "-m", "work"]);
        run(&["checkout", "-q", "main"]);

        // A pull request is compared against the remote's base, so the
        // fixture needs one. Before it exists nothing can be read, and the
        // answer must be "not empty".
        let probe = RunState::new(
            repo.clone(),
            "main".to_owned(),
            "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            "task".to_owned(),
            Config::default(),
        );
        assert!(!merge_is_empty(&repo, &probe, "magi/x/A", MergeMode::Pr).await);
        let bare = tmp.path().join("origin.git");
        let out = std::process::Command::new("git")
            .quiet()
            .args(["init", "-q", "--bare"])
            .arg(&bare)
            .output()
            .expect("spawn git");
        assert!(out.status.success(), "git init --bare");
        run(&["remote", "add", "origin", bare.to_str().unwrap()]);
        run(&["push", "-q", "origin", "main"]);

        let mut state = RunState::new(
            repo.clone(),
            "main".to_owned(),
            "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            "task".to_owned(),
            Config::default(),
        );
        state.seeds = vec![refs::Seed {
            token: "magi/27b2/A".to_owned(),
            kind: refs::SeedKind::Unresolved,
            sha: String::new(),
            branch: true,
            detail: "no branch or commit named magi/27b2/A".to_owned(),
        }];

        assert!(merge_is_empty(&repo, &state, "magi/x/A", MergeMode::Pr).await);
        assert!(merge_is_empty(&repo, &state, "magi/x/A", MergeMode::Local).await);
        assert!(!merge_is_empty(&repo, &state, "magi/x/B", MergeMode::Pr).await);
        let detail = empty_candidate_detail(&state, "main");
        assert!(detail.starts_with("empty candidate"), "{detail}");
        assert!(detail.contains("magi/27b2/A"), "{detail}");
    }

    /// `status == Ready` used to be read as "this is the harmless
    /// `MergeMode::None` no-op path, nothing to guard" (graph.rs, prior to
    /// this test). But `land` sets the very same status when a `MergeMode::Pr`
    /// run's PR was closed without merging — and reentering `merge` with
    /// `mode` still `Pr` does not know the difference, so it pushed and
    /// opened a second pull request. `mode == Local` reproduces the same
    /// blind spot without a network call: reentry must not attempt another
    /// git merge once this node has already recorded an outcome.
    #[tokio::test]
    async fn merge_does_not_reattempt_once_a_run_has_concluded() {
        let tmp = tempfile::tempdir().expect("tempdir");
        let repo = tmp.path().join("repo");
        std::fs::create_dir_all(&repo).unwrap();
        init_repo(&repo);

        let mut config = Config::default();
        config.merge.mode = MergeMode::Local;

        let mut state = RunState::new(
            repo.clone(),
            "main".to_owned(),
            "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            "task".to_owned(),
            config,
        );
        state.candidates = vec![Candidate {
            index: 0,
            label: 'A',
            agent: "alpha".to_owned(),
            branch: "does-not-exist".to_owned(),
            worktree: repo.clone(),
            summary: String::new(),
            stat: String::new(),
            files: 0,
            commits: 0,
            empty: false,
            failed: None,
            verified_noop: None,
            duration_ms: 0,
            folded: false,
        }];
        state.tally = Some(Tally {
            first_choice: BTreeMap::from([('A', 1)]),
            borda: BTreeMap::new(),
            winner: 'A',
            rankings: 1,
            unanimous_initial: true,
            deliberated: false,
            changed_votes: 0,
            unanimous_final: true,
            tie_break: None,
            judges: 0,
            present: 0,
            quorum: 0,
            met_quorum: true,
            uncontested: Some("only candidate A produced a change".to_owned()),
        });
        state.reviews = vec![ReviewRound {
            round: 1,
            head: "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            verified_head: None,
            verified_at: None,
            reviews: Vec::new(),
            e2e: Vec::new(),
            fix: None,
            blocking: 0,
            answered: 0,
            expected: 0,
            clean: true,
            verify_retried: false,
            e2e_deferred: false,
            e2e_defer_reason: None,
            progressed: false,
            vote_split: false,
            reconsideration: Vec::new(),
            verdict: None,
        }];
        state.gate = vec![CommandOutcome {
            command: "test".to_owned(),
            code: Some(0),
            output_tail: String::new(),
            duration_ms: 0,
            resource_blocked: false,
        }];
        state.gate_ran = true;
        // Reached its conclusion already — e.g. `land` closing the PR without
        // merging it, which (like the honest `MergeMode::None` path) leaves
        // `status` at `Ready`. The recorded outcome is what actually marks
        // this node done.
        state.status = RunStatus::Ready;
        state.merge = Some(MergeOutcome {
            mode: MergeMode::Local,
            ok: false,
            detail: "already concluded".to_owned(),
            empty: false,
        });

        let mut runner = Runner {
            state,
            roles: ResolvedRoles {
                implementers: Vec::new(),
                judges: Vec::new(),
                reviewers: Vec::new(),
                fixer: None,
                conductor: conductor(),
                implementer_roster: Vec::new(),
                judge_roster: Vec::new(),
                reviewer_roster: Vec::new(),
            },
            sem: Arc::new(Semaphore::new(1)),
            pause: Pause::new(),
            interrupt: Pause::new(),
        };

        runner.merge().await.expect("merge");

        assert_eq!(
            runner.state.status,
            RunStatus::Ready,
            "a concluded run's status must not change on reentry"
        );
        assert_eq!(
            runner.state.merge.as_ref().map(|m| m.detail.as_str()),
            Some("already concluded"),
            "merge must not run again once the node already recorded an outcome"
        );
    }

    /// `gate` leaves `state.gate_ran` false both before it has ever run and
    /// when its last attempt was resource-blocked (the shared build cache
    /// could not be acquired or confirmed fresh in time - see
    /// `CommandOutcome::resource_blocked`'s own doc). Trusting the empty
    /// `Vec` this also leaves behind used to read as "nothing failed" and let
    /// a run merge a tree the gate never actually checked - exactly the case
    /// a contended cache produces on every retry until it clears. `merge`
    /// must refuse until `gate` has actually recorded an attempt.
    #[tokio::test]
    async fn merge_refuses_a_gate_that_has_not_actually_run() {
        let tmp = tempfile::tempdir().expect("tempdir");
        let repo = tmp.path().join("repo");
        std::fs::create_dir_all(&repo).unwrap();
        init_repo(&repo);

        let mut config = Config::default();
        config.merge.mode = MergeMode::Local;

        let mut state = RunState::new(
            repo.clone(),
            "main".to_owned(),
            "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            "task".to_owned(),
            config,
        );
        state.candidates = vec![Candidate {
            index: 0,
            label: 'A',
            agent: "alpha".to_owned(),
            branch: "does-not-exist".to_owned(),
            worktree: repo.clone(),
            summary: String::new(),
            stat: String::new(),
            files: 0,
            commits: 0,
            empty: false,
            failed: None,
            verified_noop: None,
            duration_ms: 0,
            folded: false,
        }];
        state.tally = Some(Tally {
            first_choice: BTreeMap::from([('A', 1)]),
            borda: BTreeMap::new(),
            winner: 'A',
            rankings: 1,
            unanimous_initial: true,
            deliberated: false,
            changed_votes: 0,
            unanimous_final: true,
            tie_break: None,
            judges: 0,
            present: 0,
            quorum: 0,
            met_quorum: true,
            uncontested: Some("only candidate A produced a change".to_owned()),
        });
        state.reviews = vec![ReviewRound {
            round: 1,
            head: "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            verified_head: None,
            verified_at: None,
            reviews: Vec::new(),
            e2e: Vec::new(),
            fix: None,
            blocking: 0,
            answered: 0,
            expected: 0,
            clean: true,
            verify_retried: false,
            e2e_deferred: false,
            e2e_defer_reason: None,
            progressed: false,
            vote_split: false,
            reconsideration: Vec::new(),
            verdict: None,
        }];
        // The point: `gate` has not recorded anything yet.
        state.gate = Vec::new();
        state.gate_ran = false;
        state.status = RunStatus::Gating;

        let mut runner = Runner {
            state,
            roles: ResolvedRoles {
                implementers: Vec::new(),
                judges: Vec::new(),
                reviewers: Vec::new(),
                fixer: None,
                conductor: conductor(),
                implementer_roster: Vec::new(),
                judge_roster: Vec::new(),
                reviewer_roster: Vec::new(),
            },
            sem: Arc::new(Semaphore::new(1)),
            pause: Pause::new(),
            interrupt: Pause::new(),
        };

        runner.merge().await.expect("merge");

        assert!(
            runner.state.merge.is_none(),
            "an empty gate must never be read as a passing one: {:?}",
            runner.state.merge
        );
    }

    /// The `shoka` repro this schema bump exists for: `verify.gate` has no
    /// commands configured and `merge.mode` is `none` (a review-only run).
    /// `gate` must still record a real attempt — zero commands, vacuously
    /// passed — rather than leaving `state.gate` empty in a way `merge`
    /// cannot tell apart from "never ran"; otherwise the run reaches
    /// `Gating` and can never leave it. See `RunState::gate_ran`'s own doc.
    #[tokio::test]
    async fn gate_and_merge_reach_ready_when_no_gate_commands_are_configured() {
        let tmp = tempfile::tempdir().expect("tempdir");
        let repo = tmp.path().join("repo");
        std::fs::create_dir_all(&repo).unwrap();
        init_repo(&repo);

        // Default config: `verify.gate` empty, `merge.mode` is `none`.
        let config = Config::default();

        let mut state = RunState::new(
            repo.clone(),
            "main".to_owned(),
            "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            "task".to_owned(),
            config,
        );
        state.candidates = vec![Candidate {
            index: 0,
            label: 'A',
            agent: "alpha".to_owned(),
            branch: "does-not-exist".to_owned(),
            worktree: repo.clone(),
            summary: String::new(),
            stat: String::new(),
            files: 0,
            commits: 0,
            empty: false,
            failed: None,
            verified_noop: None,
            duration_ms: 0,
            folded: false,
        }];
        state.tally = Some(Tally {
            first_choice: BTreeMap::from([('A', 1)]),
            borda: BTreeMap::new(),
            winner: 'A',
            rankings: 1,
            unanimous_initial: true,
            deliberated: false,
            changed_votes: 0,
            unanimous_final: true,
            tie_break: None,
            judges: 0,
            present: 0,
            quorum: 0,
            met_quorum: true,
            uncontested: Some("only candidate A produced a change".to_owned()),
        });
        state.reviews = vec![ReviewRound {
            round: 1,
            head: "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            verified_head: None,
            verified_at: None,
            reviews: Vec::new(),
            e2e: Vec::new(),
            fix: None,
            blocking: 0,
            answered: 0,
            expected: 0,
            clean: true,
            verify_retried: false,
            e2e_deferred: false,
            e2e_defer_reason: None,
            progressed: false,
            vote_split: false,
            reconsideration: Vec::new(),
            verdict: None,
        }];

        let mut runner = Runner {
            state,
            roles: ResolvedRoles {
                implementers: Vec::new(),
                judges: Vec::new(),
                reviewers: Vec::new(),
                fixer: None,
                conductor: conductor(),
                implementer_roster: Vec::new(),
                judge_roster: Vec::new(),
                reviewer_roster: Vec::new(),
            },
            sem: Arc::new(Semaphore::new(1)),
            pause: Pause::new(),
            interrupt: Pause::new(),
        };

        runner.gate().await.expect("gate");
        assert!(
            runner.state.gate_ran,
            "zero configured commands is still a real attempt, not an unrun gate"
        );
        assert!(runner.state.gate.is_empty());
        assert_eq!(runner.state.gate_status(), GateStatus::PassedWithNoCommands);
        assert_ne!(
            runner.state.status,
            RunStatus::Blocked,
            "a gate with nothing to check must not read as failed"
        );

        runner.merge().await.expect("merge");
        assert_eq!(
            runner.state.status,
            RunStatus::Ready,
            "a clean review-only run with no gate commands must reach Ready, not stay stuck in Gating"
        );
    }

    /// `Config::cache_dir` is derived from `verify.e2e` as well as
    /// `verify.gate` (so the e2e leg and the final gate never build against
    /// different directories). With zero `verify.gate` commands but a
    /// `CARGO_TARGET_DIR`-using `verify.e2e`, `gate` used to still queue for
    /// that lease before discovering it had nothing to run - so a repo with
    /// no gate commands could come back `resource_blocked` (and therefore
    /// still `gate_ran == false`) on nothing but an unrelated run holding the
    /// cache, exactly the contention this run's own zero commands could
    /// never have touched. `gate` must recognise there is nothing to check
    /// before it ever asks for the lease.
    #[tokio::test]
    async fn gate_never_asks_for_the_cache_lease_when_it_has_no_commands_to_run() {
        crate::run::pin_test_home();
        let home = crate::run::home();

        let tmp = tempfile::tempdir().expect("tempdir");
        let repo = tmp.path().join("repo");
        std::fs::create_dir_all(&repo).unwrap();
        init_repo(&repo);
        // Unique to this test, so holding its lease cannot collide with
        // another test sharing the same process-wide `home`.
        let cache_dir = tmp.path().join("target");

        let mut config = Config::default();
        config.verify.e2e = vec![format!("CARGO_TARGET_DIR='{}' true", cache_dir.display())];
        // `verify.gate` stays empty (the default). Bounded so a regression
        // that does start waiting fails the test in seconds, not hangs it.
        config.graph.timeout_verify = Some(2);

        let other = crate::cache::Owner::here("other-run", "e2e", "e2e", &repo, "deadbeef");
        let _held = match crate::cache::try_acquire(&home, &cache_dir, &other)
            .expect("no io error acquiring directly")
        {
            crate::cache::AcquireOutcome::Acquired(g) => g,
            crate::cache::AcquireOutcome::Busy(b) => {
                panic!("expected the direct acquire to win the lease first: {b:?}")
            }
        };

        let mut state = RunState::new(
            repo.clone(),
            "main".to_owned(),
            "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            "task".to_owned(),
            config,
        );
        state.candidates = vec![Candidate {
            index: 0,
            label: 'A',
            agent: "alpha".to_owned(),
            branch: "does-not-exist".to_owned(),
            worktree: repo.clone(),
            summary: String::new(),
            stat: String::new(),
            files: 0,
            commits: 0,
            empty: false,
            failed: None,
            verified_noop: None,
            duration_ms: 0,
            folded: false,
        }];
        state.tally = Some(Tally {
            first_choice: BTreeMap::from([('A', 1)]),
            borda: BTreeMap::new(),
            winner: 'A',
            rankings: 1,
            unanimous_initial: true,
            deliberated: false,
            changed_votes: 0,
            unanimous_final: true,
            tie_break: None,
            judges: 0,
            present: 0,
            quorum: 0,
            met_quorum: true,
            uncontested: Some("only candidate A produced a change".to_owned()),
        });
        state.reviews = vec![ReviewRound {
            round: 1,
            head: "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            verified_head: None,
            verified_at: None,
            reviews: Vec::new(),
            e2e: Vec::new(),
            fix: None,
            blocking: 0,
            answered: 0,
            expected: 0,
            clean: true,
            verify_retried: false,
            e2e_deferred: false,
            e2e_defer_reason: None,
            progressed: false,
            vote_split: false,
            reconsideration: Vec::new(),
            verdict: None,
        }];

        let mut runner = Runner {
            state,
            roles: ResolvedRoles {
                implementers: Vec::new(),
                judges: Vec::new(),
                reviewers: Vec::new(),
                fixer: None,
                conductor: conductor(),
                implementer_roster: Vec::new(),
                judge_roster: Vec::new(),
                reviewer_roster: Vec::new(),
            },
            sem: Arc::new(Semaphore::new(1)),
            pause: Pause::new(),
            interrupt: Pause::new(),
        };

        let started = std::time::Instant::now();
        runner.gate().await.expect("gate");
        assert!(
            started.elapsed() < Duration::from_secs(1),
            "a gate with nothing to run must never wait on a lease it never needed"
        );
        assert!(
            runner.state.gate_ran,
            "zero commands is still a real, immediate attempt"
        );
        assert!(runner.state.gate.is_empty());
        assert_ne!(
            runner.state.status,
            RunStatus::Blocked,
            "must not read as resource-blocked on a lease it never asked for"
        );
    }

    /// The addendum's second gap: a `verify.gate` command running for real
    /// wall-clock time had nothing at all to show for it in `active` before
    /// `run_commands` learned to record it — a run could sit in `Gating` for
    /// minutes with `magi show` and `GET /api/runs/{id}` both silent about
    /// what was actually happening. Proven with a genuinely still-running
    /// command, not just a before/after check on the final state: a poller
    /// task reads the same `run.json` `gate()` is writing, the same way the
    /// phone or `magi show` would, while the shell command is still blocked
    /// on its own release marker.
    #[tokio::test]
    async fn gate_records_a_running_task_entry_while_its_command_is_still_in_flight() {
        crate::run::pin_test_home();

        let tmp = tempfile::tempdir().expect("tempdir");
        let repo = tmp.path().join("repo");
        std::fs::create_dir_all(&repo).unwrap();
        init_repo(&repo);

        let mut config = Config::default();
        config.verify.gate = vec![
            "printf started > started.marker; i=0; while [ ! -f release.marker ] && \
             [ \"$i\" -lt 100 ]; do i=$((i+1)); sleep 0.05; done"
                .to_owned(),
        ];

        let mut state = RunState::new(
            repo.clone(),
            "main".to_owned(),
            "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            "task".to_owned(),
            config,
        );
        let run_id = state.id.clone();
        state.candidates = vec![Candidate {
            index: 0,
            label: 'A',
            agent: "alpha".to_owned(),
            branch: "does-not-exist".to_owned(),
            worktree: repo.clone(),
            summary: String::new(),
            stat: String::new(),
            files: 0,
            commits: 0,
            empty: false,
            failed: None,
            verified_noop: None,
            duration_ms: 0,
            folded: false,
        }];
        state.tally = Some(Tally {
            first_choice: BTreeMap::from([('A', 1)]),
            borda: BTreeMap::new(),
            winner: 'A',
            rankings: 1,
            unanimous_initial: true,
            deliberated: false,
            changed_votes: 0,
            unanimous_final: true,
            tie_break: None,
            judges: 0,
            present: 0,
            quorum: 0,
            met_quorum: true,
            uncontested: Some("only candidate A produced a change".to_owned()),
        });
        state.reviews = vec![ReviewRound {
            round: 1,
            head: "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            verified_head: None,
            verified_at: None,
            reviews: Vec::new(),
            e2e: Vec::new(),
            fix: None,
            blocking: 0,
            answered: 0,
            expected: 0,
            clean: true,
            verify_retried: false,
            e2e_deferred: false,
            e2e_defer_reason: None,
            progressed: false,
            vote_split: false,
            reconsideration: Vec::new(),
            verdict: None,
        }];

        let mut runner = Runner {
            state,
            roles: ResolvedRoles {
                implementers: Vec::new(),
                judges: Vec::new(),
                reviewers: Vec::new(),
                fixer: None,
                conductor: conductor(),
                implementer_roster: Vec::new(),
                judge_roster: Vec::new(),
                reviewer_roster: Vec::new(),
            },
            sem: Arc::new(Semaphore::new(1)),
            pause: Pause::new(),
            interrupt: Pause::new(),
        };

        let started_marker = repo.join("started.marker");
        let release_marker = repo.join("release.marker");
        let poller = tokio::spawn(async move {
            // Bounded so a regression that never records the task entry
            // fails this test in seconds instead of hanging the suite —
            // the same shape `a_park_requested_while_a_seat_is_mid_call_
            // does_not_cut_it_short` uses for the same reason.
            for _ in 0..100 {
                if started_marker.exists()
                    && let Ok(s) = crate::run::RunState::load(&run_id)
                    && let Some(a) = s.active.get("gate")
                {
                    std::fs::write(&release_marker, b"go").expect("release marker");
                    return Some(a.clone());
                }
                tokio::time::sleep(Duration::from_millis(50)).await;
            }
            None
        });

        runner.gate().await.expect("gate");
        let captured = poller.await.expect("poller task");
        let captured = captured.expect(
            "the poller never saw a `gate` task entry in run.json while the command was \
             still blocked on its own release marker",
        );

        assert_eq!(captured.task.as_deref(), Some("gate"));
        assert_eq!(captured.node, "gate");
        assert_eq!(captured.index, Some(1));
        assert_eq!(captured.total, Some(1));
        assert!(
            captured
                .command
                .as_deref()
                .is_some_and(|c| c.contains("started.marker")),
            "{captured:?}"
        );

        assert!(
            runner.state.active.is_empty(),
            "the entry must be cleared once the command actually finished: {:?}",
            runner.state.active
        );
        assert!(runner.state.gate_ran);
        assert!(runner.state.gate.iter().all(CommandOutcome::ok));
    }

    /// The hand-off over a blocking finding a reviewer rejected on leaves a
    /// record for `land`; one with only a Minor, or no reject, leaves none.
    #[tokio::test]
    async fn stop_reviewing_records_a_contested_hand_off_only_for_major_plus_reject() {
        use crate::verdict::{Finding, ReviewVote, Severity};
        crate::run::pin_test_home();
        let tmp = tempfile::tempdir().expect("tempdir");
        let repo = tmp.path().join("repo");
        std::fs::create_dir_all(&repo).unwrap();
        init_repo(&repo);

        for (severity, vote, expect) in [
            (Severity::Major, ReviewVote::Reject, true),
            (Severity::Minor, ReviewVote::Reject, false),
            (Severity::Major, ReviewVote::Approve, false),
        ] {
            let mut round = review_round(false, 1, 1, 1, false, true);
            round.reviews = vec![ReviewRecord {
                reviewer: 1,
                agent: "alpha".to_owned(),
                summary: String::new(),
                findings: vec![Finding {
                    id: "R1-1-1".to_owned(),
                    severity,
                    file: None,
                    line: None,
                    title: "t".to_owned(),
                    detail: String::new(),
                }],
                vote: Some(vote),
                failed: None,
                duration_ms: 0,
                attempts: 0,
            }];
            let mut state = RunState::new(
                repo.clone(),
                "main".to_owned(),
                "deadbeef".to_owned(),
                "task".to_owned(),
                Config::default(),
            );
            state.reviews = vec![round];
            let mut runner = Runner {
                state,
                roles: ResolvedRoles {
                    implementers: Vec::new(),
                    judges: Vec::new(),
                    reviewers: Vec::new(),
                    fixer: None,
                    conductor: conductor(),
                    implementer_roster: Vec::new(),
                    judge_roster: Vec::new(),
                    reviewer_roster: Vec::new(),
                },
                sem: Arc::new(Semaphore::new(1)),
                pause: Pause::new(),
                interrupt: Pause::new(),
            };
            let shell = runner.state.config.shell();
            runner
                .stop_reviewing("round budget spent", &shell, &repo)
                .await
                .expect("stop_reviewing");
            assert_eq!(runner.state.status, RunStatus::Gating);
            assert_eq!(
                runner.state.contested_handoff.is_some(),
                expect,
                "{severity:?} + {vote:?}"
            );
        }
    }

    /// The shape the incident this whole fix responds to actually had: the
    /// round budget spent, the last round's own e2e blocked on the shared
    /// build cache (held here by a live pid — this test process — exactly
    /// `cache`'s own unit tests' pattern for "another owner, still alive"
    /// without forking a process). `stop_reviewing` must retry it — not
    /// silently leave the round looking untouched (the catch-up-only half of
    /// the bug), and not read the contention as a red `e2e` and block the
    /// run on it (the other half). Called directly, the same way
    /// `gate_never_asks_for_the_cache_lease_when_it_has_no_commands_to_run`
    /// above exercises `gate`, so this never needs a real cargo build to
    /// reach: the lease is never released, so `with_cache_lease` never gets
    /// past acquiring it into anything that would need a real workspace.
    #[tokio::test]
    async fn stop_reviewing_retries_a_resource_blocked_e2e_instead_of_reading_it_as_red() {
        crate::run::pin_test_home();
        let home = crate::run::home();

        let tmp = tempfile::tempdir().expect("tempdir");
        let repo = tmp.path().join("repo");
        std::fs::create_dir_all(&repo).unwrap();
        init_repo(&repo);
        let head = crate::git::rev_parse(&repo, "HEAD")
            .await
            .expect("rev-parse");
        // Unique to this test, so holding its lease cannot collide with
        // another test sharing the same process-wide `home`.
        let cache_dir = tmp.path().join("target");

        let mut config = Config::default();
        config.verify.e2e = vec![format!(
            "CARGO_TARGET_DIR='{}' test -f README.md",
            cache_dir.display()
        )];
        config.graph.review_rounds = 1;
        // Bounded so a regression that does start waiting fails the test in
        // seconds, not hangs it.
        config.graph.timeout_verify = Some(2);

        let other = crate::cache::Owner::here("other-run", "e2e", "e2e", &repo, "deadbeef");
        let held = match crate::cache::try_acquire(&home, &cache_dir, &other)
            .expect("no io error acquiring directly")
        {
            crate::cache::AcquireOutcome::Acquired(g) => g,
            crate::cache::AcquireOutcome::Busy(b) => {
                panic!("expected the direct acquire to win the lease first: {b:?}")
            }
        };

        let mut state = RunState::new(
            repo.clone(),
            "main".to_owned(),
            head.clone(),
            "task".to_owned(),
            config,
        );
        state.candidates = vec![Candidate {
            index: 0,
            label: 'A',
            agent: "alpha".to_owned(),
            branch: "does-not-exist".to_owned(),
            worktree: repo.clone(),
            summary: String::new(),
            stat: String::new(),
            files: 0,
            commits: 0,
            empty: false,
            failed: None,
            verified_noop: None,
            duration_ms: 0,
            folded: false,
        }];
        state.tally = Some(Tally {
            first_choice: BTreeMap::from([('A', 1)]),
            borda: BTreeMap::new(),
            winner: 'A',
            rankings: 1,
            unanimous_initial: true,
            deliberated: false,
            changed_votes: 0,
            unanimous_final: true,
            tie_break: None,
            judges: 0,
            present: 0,
            quorum: 0,
            met_quorum: true,
            uncontested: Some("only candidate A produced a change".to_owned()),
        });
        // The round budget's last round, deferred: `needs_catchup_run`'s
        // other trigger. `stop_reviewing`'s retry machinery must treat this
        // exactly like a resource-blocked attempt once it actually runs.
        state.reviews = vec![ReviewRound {
            round: 1,
            head: head.clone(),
            verified_head: None,
            verified_at: None,
            reviews: Vec::new(),
            e2e: Vec::new(),
            fix: None,
            blocking: 1,
            answered: 1,
            expected: 1,
            clean: false,
            verify_retried: false,
            e2e_deferred: true,
            e2e_defer_reason: Some("1 blocking finding(s) already required a fix".to_owned()),
            progressed: false,
            vote_split: false,
            reconsideration: Vec::new(),
            verdict: None,
        }];

        let mut runner = Runner {
            state,
            roles: ResolvedRoles {
                implementers: Vec::new(),
                judges: Vec::new(),
                reviewers: Vec::new(),
                fixer: None,
                conductor: conductor(),
                implementer_roster: Vec::new(),
                judge_roster: Vec::new(),
                reviewer_roster: Vec::new(),
            },
            sem: Arc::new(Semaphore::new(1)),
            pause: Pause::new(),
            interrupt: Pause::new(),
        };

        let shell = runner.state.config.shell();
        runner
            .stop_reviewing("round budget spent", &shell, &repo)
            .await
            .expect("stop_reviewing");

        let last = runner.state.reviews.last().expect("round record");
        assert_eq!(
            last.e2e_status(),
            E2eStatus::ResourceBlocked,
            "the shared cache is still held; the attempt must read as blocked, not deferred or \
             failed: {last:?}"
        );
        assert_eq!(
            last.verified_head.as_deref(),
            Some(head.as_str()),
            "which commit this attempt targeted is known even though nothing finished checking \
             it"
        );
        let first_attempt_at = last
            .verified_at
            .expect("when this attempt ran is known too");
        assert_ne!(
            runner.state.status,
            RunStatus::Blocked,
            "contention is evidence about the machine, not the patch — it must not settle the \
             run as blocked: {:?}",
            runner.state.status
        );
        assert!(
            !runner
                .state
                .events
                .iter()
                .any(|e| e.node == "review" && e.message.contains("e2e failed")),
            "a resource-blocked attempt must never be logged as a failed e2e: {:?}",
            runner.state.events
        );

        // The cache is still held: a later reentry must retry the same
        // round's verification again — not leave it looking exactly as
        // untouched as the first blocked attempt, which is indistinguishable
        // from never having tried again at all.
        runner
            .stop_reviewing("round budget spent", &shell, &repo)
            .await
            .expect("stop_reviewing retry");
        assert_eq!(
            runner.state.reviews.len(),
            1,
            "no new round was started: {:?}",
            runner.state.reviews
        );
        let last = runner.state.reviews.last().expect("round record");
        assert_eq!(last.e2e_status(), E2eStatus::ResourceBlocked, "{last:?}");
        assert!(
            last.verified_at.expect("still known") > first_attempt_at,
            "a second reentry must be a fresh attempt, not a stale copy of the first"
        );
        assert_ne!(runner.state.status, RunStatus::Blocked);

        held.release();
    }

    /// A resumed run — a fresh `Runner`, `self.state.reviews` already
    /// holding the round `stop_reviewing` left `ResourceBlocked` from a
    /// prior process — must not sit at `Reviewing` forever: `review_loop`'s
    /// own top-of-function fast path (`review_conclusion`) correctly reads
    /// this shape as `None` rather than guessing `Blocked`, and the loop's
    /// own `for` range is empty once the round budget is spent, so
    /// `review_loop` must retry the check itself rather than silently doing
    /// nothing. Reaches the exact same retry `stop_reviewing_retries_a_*`
    /// above exercises directly, but through `review_loop`'s own entry point
    /// this time, proving the wiring between the two rather than just the
    /// retry logic in isolation.
    #[tokio::test]
    async fn a_resumed_review_loop_retries_a_last_round_left_resource_blocked() {
        crate::run::pin_test_home();
        let home = crate::run::home();

        let tmp = tempfile::tempdir().expect("tempdir");
        let repo = tmp.path().join("repo");
        std::fs::create_dir_all(&repo).unwrap();
        init_repo(&repo);
        let head = crate::git::rev_parse(&repo, "HEAD")
            .await
            .expect("rev-parse");
        let cache_dir = tmp.path().join("target");

        let mut config = Config::default();
        config.verify.e2e = vec![format!(
            "CARGO_TARGET_DIR='{}' test -f README.md",
            cache_dir.display()
        )];
        config.graph.review_rounds = 1;
        config.graph.timeout_verify = Some(2);

        let other = crate::cache::Owner::here("other-run", "e2e", "e2e", &repo, "deadbeef");
        let held = match crate::cache::try_acquire(&home, &cache_dir, &other)
            .expect("no io error acquiring directly")
        {
            crate::cache::AcquireOutcome::Acquired(g) => g,
            crate::cache::AcquireOutcome::Busy(b) => {
                panic!("expected the direct acquire to win the lease first: {b:?}")
            }
        };

        let mut state = RunState::new(
            repo.clone(),
            "main".to_owned(),
            head.clone(),
            "task".to_owned(),
            config,
        );
        state.candidates = vec![Candidate {
            index: 0,
            label: 'A',
            agent: "alpha".to_owned(),
            branch: "does-not-exist".to_owned(),
            worktree: repo.clone(),
            summary: String::new(),
            stat: String::new(),
            files: 0,
            commits: 0,
            empty: false,
            failed: None,
            verified_noop: None,
            duration_ms: 0,
            folded: false,
        }];
        state.tally = Some(Tally {
            first_choice: BTreeMap::from([('A', 1)]),
            borda: BTreeMap::new(),
            winner: 'A',
            rankings: 1,
            unanimous_initial: true,
            deliberated: false,
            changed_votes: 0,
            unanimous_final: true,
            tie_break: None,
            judges: 0,
            present: 0,
            quorum: 0,
            met_quorum: true,
            uncontested: Some("only candidate A produced a change".to_owned()),
        });
        // The exact shape a prior process's `stop_reviewing` would have left
        // on disk: the round budget's last round, a real attempt already
        // made and already resource-blocked.
        state.reviews = vec![ReviewRound {
            round: 1,
            head: head.clone(),
            verified_head: Some(head.clone()),
            verified_at: Some(jiff::Timestamp::now()),
            reviews: Vec::new(),
            e2e: vec![CommandOutcome {
                command: format!(
                    "CARGO_TARGET_DIR='{}' test -f README.md",
                    cache_dir.display()
                ),
                code: None,
                output_tail: "waiting for the shared build cache".to_owned(),
                duration_ms: 0,
                resource_blocked: true,
            }],
            fix: None,
            blocking: 1,
            answered: 1,
            expected: 1,
            clean: false,
            verify_retried: false,
            e2e_deferred: false,
            e2e_defer_reason: None,
            progressed: false,
            vote_split: false,
            reconsideration: Vec::new(),
            verdict: None,
        }];

        let first_attempt_at = state.reviews[0].verified_at.expect("set above");
        let mut runner = Runner {
            state,
            roles: ResolvedRoles {
                implementers: Vec::new(),
                judges: Vec::new(),
                reviewers: Vec::new(),
                fixer: None,
                conductor: conductor(),
                implementer_roster: Vec::new(),
                judge_roster: Vec::new(),
                reviewer_roster: Vec::new(),
            },
            sem: Arc::new(Semaphore::new(1)),
            pause: Pause::new(),
            interrupt: Pause::new(),
        };

        // The lease is still held throughout, so this reentry's own retry is
        // also contended — proving `review_loop` actually tried again (not
        // that it happened to succeed) is what the timestamp comparison
        // below is for.
        runner.review_loop().await.expect("review_loop");

        assert_eq!(
            runner.state.reviews.len(),
            1,
            "no new round was started on top of the unresolved one: {:?}",
            runner.state.reviews
        );
        let last = &runner.state.reviews[0];
        assert_eq!(
            last.e2e_status(),
            E2eStatus::ResourceBlocked,
            "still contended: {last:?}"
        );
        assert!(
            last.verified_at.expect("still known") > first_attempt_at,
            "review_loop must have actually retried the check, not left it exactly as found"
        );
        assert_ne!(
            runner.state.status,
            RunStatus::Blocked,
            "a resumed run must not read leftover contention as a verdict on the patch: {:?}",
            runner.state.status
        );

        held.release();
    }

    #[tokio::test]
    async fn a_run_resumed_mid_landing_reenters_land_instead_of_opening_a_second_pull_request() {
        crate::run::pin_test_home();
        let tmp = tempfile::tempdir().expect("tempdir");
        let repo = tmp.path().join("repo");
        std::fs::create_dir_all(&repo).unwrap();
        init_repo(&repo);

        let mut config = Config::default();
        config.merge.mode = MergeMode::Pr;
        config.graph.land = true;
        config.graph.land_approval = false;

        let mut state = RunState::new(
            repo.clone(),
            "main".to_owned(),
            "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            "task".to_owned(),
            config,
        );
        state.candidates = vec![Candidate {
            index: 0,
            label: 'A',
            agent: "alpha".to_owned(),
            branch: "does-not-exist".to_owned(),
            worktree: repo.clone(),
            summary: String::new(),
            stat: String::new(),
            files: 0,
            commits: 0,
            empty: false,
            failed: None,
            verified_noop: None,
            duration_ms: 0,
            folded: false,
        }];
        state.tally = Some(Tally {
            first_choice: BTreeMap::from([('A', 1)]),
            borda: BTreeMap::new(),
            winner: 'A',
            rankings: 1,
            unanimous_initial: true,
            deliberated: false,
            changed_votes: 0,
            unanimous_final: true,
            tie_break: None,
            judges: 0,
            present: 0,
            quorum: 0,
            met_quorum: true,
            uncontested: Some("only candidate A produced a change".to_owned()),
        });
        state.reviews = vec![ReviewRound {
            round: 1,
            head: "deadbeef".to_owned(),
            verified_head: None,
            verified_at: None,
            reviews: Vec::new(),
            e2e: Vec::new(),
            fix: None,
            blocking: 0,
            answered: 0,
            expected: 0,
            clean: true,
            verify_retried: false,
            e2e_deferred: false,
            e2e_defer_reason: None,
            progressed: false,
            vote_split: false,
            reconsideration: Vec::new(),
            verdict: None,
        }];
        state.gate = vec![CommandOutcome {
            command: "test".to_owned(),
            code: Some(0),
            output_tail: String::new(),
            duration_ms: 0,
            resource_blocked: false,
        }];
        state.gate_ran = true;
        // A first pass through `merge` already pushed and opened this pull
        // request; `status` is `Landing` because a previous call into `land`
        // parked or was interrupted before it reached a terminal outcome.
        state.status = RunStatus::Landing;
        state.merge = Some(MergeOutcome {
            mode: MergeMode::Pr,
            ok: true,
            detail: "https://example.invalid/x/y/pull/1".to_owned(),
            empty: false,
        });

        // The Landing-resume shortcut calls `run_land` directly rather than
        // through `merge`, which is exactly the call site that used to skip
        // `settle_questions` - see the fixture below.
        ask_test_home();
        let store = ask::Questions::open();
        let q = ask_open_question(&store, &state.id);

        let mut runner = Runner {
            state,
            roles: ResolvedRoles {
                implementers: Vec::new(),
                judges: Vec::new(),
                reviewers: Vec::new(),
                fixer: None,
                conductor: conductor(),
                implementer_roster: Vec::new(),
                judge_roster: Vec::new(),
                reviewer_roster: Vec::new(),
            },
            sem: Arc::new(Semaphore::new(1)),
            pause: Pause::new(),
            interrupt: Pause::new(),
        };

        // `execute`, not `merge` directly: the Landing-resume shortcut lives
        // at the top of `execute`, not inside `merge` (see `execute`'s doc)
        // exactly because `review_loop` would otherwise clobber the marker
        // first.
        runner.execute().await.expect("execute");

        assert_eq!(
            runner.state.merge.as_ref().map(|m| m.detail.as_str()),
            Some("https://example.invalid/x/y/pull/1"),
            "reentry must not push again or open a second pull request over the \
             one `land` is already watching"
        );
        assert_ne!(
            runner.state.status,
            RunStatus::Landing,
            "land could not actually reach the fake pull request, so it must \
             have given up rather than left the run silently parked forever"
        );
        // `land` could not reach the fake pull request, so it gave up into
        // `Blocked` - still resumable, so the question must not have been
        // swept just because this branch now also calls `settle_questions`.
        assert_eq!(runner.state.status, RunStatus::Blocked);
        assert!(
            store.get(&q.id).unwrap().status.open(),
            "Blocked is still alive; settle_questions must have been a no-op here"
        );
    }

    fn state_with_round(round: ReviewRound) -> RunState {
        let mut s = RunState::new(
            PathBuf::from("/repo"),
            "main".to_owned(),
            "abc1234".to_owned(),
            "add retries".to_owned(),
            Config::default(),
        );
        s.reviews = vec![round];
        s
    }

    fn finding(id: &str, severity: Severity, title: &str) -> crate::verdict::Finding {
        crate::verdict::Finding {
            id: id.to_owned(),
            severity,
            file: None,
            line: None,
            title: title.to_owned(),
            detail: String::new(),
        }
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_body_names_open_findings_and_declined_ones() {
        let round = ReviewRound {
            round: 2,
            head: "deadbee".to_owned(),
            verified_head: None,
            verified_at: None,
            reviews: vec![ReviewRecord {
                attempts: 0,
                reviewer: 1,
                agent: "alpha".to_owned(),
                summary: String::new(),
                findings: vec![finding("R2-1-1", Severity::Minor, "unused import")],
                vote: None,
                failed: None,
                duration_ms: 0,
            }],
            e2e: vec![CommandOutcome {
                command: "cargo test".to_owned(),
                code: Some(0),
                output_tail: String::new(),
                duration_ms: 0,
                resource_blocked: false,
            }],
            verify_retried: false,
            e2e_deferred: false,
            e2e_defer_reason: None,
            fix: Some(FixRecord {
                agent: "alpha".to_owned(),
                addressed: Vec::new(),
                rejected: vec![crate::verdict::Rejection {
                    id: "R1-1-1".to_owned(),
                    why: "not reachable from any caller".to_owned(),
                }],
                notes: String::new(),
                committed: true,
                failed: None,
                duration_ms: 0,
                continuation: None,
            }),
            blocking: 0,
            answered: 1,
            expected: 1,
            clean: false,
            progressed: true,
            vote_split: false,
            reconsideration: Vec::new(),
            verdict: None,
        };
        let state = state_with_round(round);
        let body = pr_message(&state, 'A').body;

        assert!(body.contains("add retries"), "the task must still be there");
        assert!(body.contains("R2-1-1"), "{body}");
        assert!(body.contains("unused import"), "{body}");
        assert!(body.contains("R1-1-1"), "the declined finding: {body}");
        assert!(
            body.contains("not reachable from any caller"),
            "the reason it was declined: {body}"
        );
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_body_says_nothing_extra_when_the_round_was_clean() {
        let round = ReviewRound {
            round: 1,
            head: "deadbee".to_owned(),
            verified_head: None,
            verified_at: None,
            reviews: vec![ReviewRecord {
                attempts: 0,
                reviewer: 1,
                agent: "alpha".to_owned(),
                summary: String::new(),
                findings: Vec::new(),
                vote: None,
                failed: None,
                duration_ms: 0,
            }],
            e2e: Vec::new(),
            verify_retried: false,
            e2e_deferred: false,
            e2e_defer_reason: None,
            fix: None,
            blocking: 0,
            answered: 1,
            expected: 1,
            clean: true,
            progressed: false,
            vote_split: false,
            reconsideration: Vec::new(),
            verdict: None,
        };
        let state = state_with_round(round);
        let body = pr_message(&state, 'A').body;
        assert!(!body.contains("Open review findings"), "{body}");
        assert!(!body.contains("Declined"), "{body}");
    }

    fn state_with_summary(instruction: &str, summary: &str) -> RunState {
        let mut state = RunState::new(
            PathBuf::from("/repo"),
            "main".to_owned(),
            "abc1234".to_owned(),
            instruction.to_owned(),
            Config::default(),
        );
        state.candidates.push(Candidate {
            index: 0,
            label: 'A',
            agent: "alpha".to_owned(),
            branch: "magi/x/A".to_owned(),
            worktree: PathBuf::from("/wt"),
            summary: summary.to_owned(),
            stat: String::new(),
            files: 1,
            commits: 1,
            empty: false,
            failed: None,
            verified_noop: None,
            folded: false,
            duration_ms: 0,
        });
        state
    }

    fn review_state(subjects: &[&str]) -> RunState {
        let mut state = state_with_summary(
            "Review the work already on branch `magi/x/A`. There is no task statement: what the change claims to do is whatever its commits say.\n\nfirst\nsecond",
            "",
        );
        state.candidates[0].agent = EXISTING_BRANCH.to_owned();
        state.reviewed_commits = Some(subjects.iter().map(|s| (*s).to_owned()).collect());
        state
    }

    /// A branch rebased onto a main that moved past the recorded
    /// `base_commit` is titled from its own first commit, never main's.
    #[tokio::test]
    async fn a_rebased_review_branch_is_titled_from_its_own_commits() {
        ask_test_home();
        let tmp = tempfile::tempdir().unwrap();
        let repo = tmp.path().join("repo");
        std::fs::create_dir_all(&repo).unwrap();
        init_repo(&repo);
        let origin = tmp.path().join("origin.git");
        let g = |dir: &Path, args: &[&str]| {
            let out = std::process::Command::new("git")
                .args(args)
                .current_dir(dir)
                .quiet()
                .output()
                .expect("spawn git");
            assert!(
                out.status.success(),
                "git {args:?}: {}",
                String::from_utf8_lossy(&out.stderr)
            );
        };
        g(
            tmp.path(),
            &[
                "clone",
                "--bare",
                "-q",
                repo.to_str().unwrap(),
                origin.to_str().unwrap(),
            ],
        );
        g(
            &repo,
            &["remote", "add", "origin", origin.to_str().unwrap()],
        );
        let c1 = git::rev_parse(&repo, "main").await.unwrap();

        // Main moves on; the branch is built on top of the new main.
        std::fs::write(repo.join("dep.txt"), "bump\n").unwrap();
        g(&repo, &["add", "-A"]);
        g(
            &repo,
            &["commit", "-q", "-m", "chore(deps): update a crate"],
        );
        g(&repo, &["push", "-q", "origin", "main"]);
        g(&repo, &["checkout", "-q", "-b", "feat/own"]);
        std::fs::write(repo.join("own.txt"), "own\n").unwrap();
        g(&repo, &["add", "-A"]);
        g(
            &repo,
            &["commit", "-q", "-m", "fix(daemon): apply a chosen action"],
        );
        g(&repo, &["checkout", "-q", "main"]);

        let start = review_base(&repo, "origin", "main", &c1, "feat/own").await;
        assert_eq!(start, git::rev_parse(&repo, "main").await.unwrap());
        // Without a readable tracking ref the recorded base's merge base is used.
        let fallback = review_base(&repo, "nowhere", "main", &c1, "feat/own").await;
        assert_eq!(fallback, c1);

        let mut state = review_state(&[
            "chore(deps): update a crate",
            "fix(daemon): apply a chosen action",
        ]);
        state.repo = repo.clone();
        state.base_branch = "main".to_owned();
        state.base_commit = c1;
        refresh_reviewed_commits(&mut state, "feat/own").await;
        assert_eq!(
            state.reviewed_commits,
            Some(vec!["fix(daemon): apply a chosen action".to_owned()])
        );
        assert_eq!(
            review_title(&state).as_deref(),
            Some("fix(daemon): apply a chosen action")
        );
        assert_eq!(
            leaked_subjects(&state, "feat/own").await,
            Some(vec!["chore(deps): update a crate".to_owned()])
        );
        // A stale tracking ref is still used when the fetch fails, but the
        // leak list is withheld.
        state.config.merge.remote = "nowhere".to_owned();
        assert_eq!(leaked_subjects(&state, "feat/own").await, None);
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_review_single_commit_uses_its_subject() {
        let state = review_state(&["feat(nats): per-role user"]);
        let m = pr_message(&state, 'A');
        assert_eq!(m.title, "feat(nats): per-role user");
        assert!(!m.body.contains("Review the work already"), "{}", m.body);
        assert!(m.body.contains("## Commits under review"), "{}", m.body);
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_review_multi_commit_takes_the_oldest() {
        let state = review_state(&["feat: the change", "fix: typo", "fix: again"]);
        let m = pr_message(&state, 'A');
        assert_eq!(m.title, "feat: the change");
        for s in ["feat: the change", "fix: typo", "fix: again"] {
            assert!(m.body.contains(&format!("- {s}\n")), "{}", m.body);
        }
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_review_without_a_usable_first_subject_is_neutral() {
        for first in ["日本語の件名", "", "magi: candidate A (uncommitted work)"] {
            let mut state = review_state(&[first, "fix: later fixup"]);
            state.candidates[0].branch = "機能/ログイン".to_owned();
            let m = pr_message(&state, 'A');
            assert!(
                m.title.starts_with("chore: land candidate A of run"),
                "{}",
                m.title
            );
        }
    }

    fn facts(commits: &[(&str, &str)], stat: &str) -> BranchFacts {
        BranchFacts {
            commits: commits
                .iter()
                .map(|(s, b)| ((*s).to_owned(), (*b).to_owned()))
                .collect(),
            stat: stat.to_owned(),
        }
    }

    fn round_with_notes(round: usize, notes: Option<&str>) -> ReviewRound {
        let mut r = review_round(true, 0, 1, 1, true, true);
        r.round = round;
        r.fix = notes.map(|n| FixRecord {
            agent: "fixer".to_owned(),
            addressed: Vec::new(),
            rejected: Vec::new(),
            notes: n.to_owned(),
            committed: true,
            failed: None,
            duration_ms: 0,
            continuation: None,
        });
        r
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_review_with_branch_facts_uses_commits_and_stat() {
        let state = review_state(&["ignored"]);
        let f = facts(
            &[
                (
                    "fix(login): resolve PATH on macOS",
                    "Login shells skip rc files.",
                ),
                ("fix: address review", ""),
            ],
            " src/a.rs | 2 +-\n 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-)",
        );
        let m = pr_message_with(&state, 'A', Some(&f));
        assert_eq!(m.title, "fix(login): resolve PATH on macOS");
        assert!(
            m.body
                .contains("- fix(login): resolve PATH on macOS\n  Login shells skip rc files.\n"),
            "{}",
            m.body
        );
        assert!(m.body.contains("- fix: address review\n"), "{}", m.body);
        assert!(m.body.contains("## Diff stat"), "{}", m.body);
        assert!(m.body.contains("src/a.rs | 2 +-"), "{}", m.body);
        for banned in [
            "Review the work already",
            "no task statement",
            "Original task",
        ] {
            assert!(!m.body.contains(banned), "{banned}: {}", m.body);
        }
        assert!(m.body.ends_with("magi:candidate-a\n"), "{}", m.body);
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_review_truncates_a_huge_first_commit_body() {
        let state = review_state(&["ignored"]);
        let f = facts(
            &[("feat: big", &"x".repeat(70_000)), ("fix: later", "")],
            "s",
        );
        let m = pr_message_with(&state, 'A', Some(&f));
        assert!(m.body.len() < 30_000, "{}", m.body.len());
        assert!(m.body.contains("(truncated)"), "{}", m.body.len());
        assert!(
            m.body.contains("- ... 1 more commit(s)"),
            "{}",
            m.body.len()
        );
        assert!(m.body.ends_with("magi:candidate-a\n"));
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_review_without_facts_falls_back_to_recorded_subjects() {
        let m = pr_message_with(&review_state(&["feat: x", "fix: y"]), 'A', None);
        assert_eq!(m.title, "feat: x");
        assert!(m.body.contains("- fix: y\n"), "{}", m.body);
        assert!(!m.body.contains("Diff stat"), "{}", m.body);
        assert!(!m.body.contains("no task statement"), "{}", m.body);
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_review_titles_from_the_branch_name_when_subjects_are_unusable() {
        let mut state = review_state(&["日本語の件名"]);
        state.candidates[0].branch = "fix/macos-login-path".to_owned();
        assert_eq!(pr_message(&state, 'A').title, "fix/macos-login-path");
        state.candidates[0].branch = "機能/ログイン".to_owned();
        assert!(
            pr_message(&state, 'A')
                .title
                .starts_with("chore: land candidate A")
        );
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_review_fixes_survive_a_clean_final_round() {
        let mut state = review_state(&["feat: x"]);
        state.reviews = vec![
            round_with_notes(1, Some("handled the PATH case")),
            round_with_notes(2, None),
        ];
        let body = pr_message(&state, 'A').body;
        assert!(
            body.contains("## Review fixes\n\nhandled the PATH case\n"),
            "{body}"
        );
        assert!(!body.contains("### Round"), "{body}");

        state.reviews = vec![
            round_with_notes(1, Some("first fix")),
            round_with_notes(2, Some("")),
            round_with_notes(3, Some("second fix")),
            round_with_notes(4, None),
        ];
        let body = pr_message(&state, 'A').body;
        assert!(body.contains("### Round 1\n\nfirst fix"), "{body}");
        assert!(body.contains("### Round 3\n\nsecond fix"), "{body}");
        assert!(!body.contains("### Round 2"), "{body}");
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_implementation_run_keeps_its_shape_and_marker() {
        let state = state_with_summary(
            "add retries to the client",
            "TITLE: feat: retries\n\nDid it.",
        );
        let m = pr_message_with(&state, 'A', Some(&facts(&[("x", "")], "s")));
        assert_eq!(m.title, "feat: retries");
        assert!(
            m.body.contains("<summary>Original task</summary>"),
            "{}",
            m.body
        );
        assert!(!m.body.contains("Commits under review"), "{}", m.body);
        assert!(
            m.body
                .ends_with(&format!("magi:run/{} magi:candidate-a\n", state.id)),
            "{}",
            m.body
        );
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_review_bounds_a_long_english_subject() {
        let long = format!("feat: {}", "word ".repeat(100));
        let m = pr_message(&review_state(&[&long]), 'A');
        assert!(m.title.starts_with("feat: word"), "{}", m.title);
        assert!(m.title.chars().count() <= PR_TITLE_MAX, "{}", m.title);
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_implementation_run_is_unchanged_by_review_support() {
        let state = state_with_summary("add retries\n\ndetails", "- did some things");
        let m = pr_message(&state, 'A');
        assert_eq!(m.title, "add retries");
        assert!(m.body.contains("<summary>Original task</summary>"));
        assert!(!m.body.contains("Commits under review"));
        assert_eq!(landing_subject_source(&state), state.instruction);
    }

    #[test]
    fn review_run_squash_subject_is_the_change_not_the_prompt() {
        let state = review_state(&["feat: the change", "fix: typo"]);
        let source = landing_subject_source(&state);
        assert_eq!(land::merge_subject("", &source), "feat: the change");
        assert_eq!(
            land::merge_subject("magi: candidate A (uncommitted work)", &source),
            "feat: the change"
        );
        // An operator's rename still wins.
        assert_eq!(
            land::merge_subject("feat: renamed by hand", &source),
            "feat: renamed by hand"
        );
        let blank = review_state(&["日本語"]);
        assert!(
            land::merge_subject("", &landing_subject_source(&blank)).starts_with("chore: land")
        );
    }

    #[test]
    fn review_run_drops_a_prompt_shaped_pr_title_at_landing() {
        let state = review_state(&["feat: the change"]);
        let source = landing_subject_source(&state);
        let old = "Review the work already on branch `magi/x/A`. There is no task statement";
        assert_eq!(
            land::merge_subject(landing_title(&state, old), &source),
            "feat: the change"
        );
        assert_eq!(landing_title(&state, "feat: renamed"), "feat: renamed");
        let task = state_with_summary("add retries", "");
        assert_eq!(landing_title(&task, old), old);
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_describes_the_change_not_the_task() {
        let state = state_with_summary(
            "今回やってほしいこと: results projector を直す",
            "TITLE: fix(web): batch the runs list reads\n- reads run.json once\n- risk: none",
        );
        let m = pr_message(&state, 'A');
        assert_eq!(m.title, "fix(web): batch the runs list reads");
        assert!(
            m.body.starts_with("## Summary\n\n- reads run.json once"),
            "{}",
            m.body
        );
        assert!(!m.body.contains("TITLE:"), "{}", m.body);
        let task_at = m.body.find("今回やってほしいこと").unwrap();
        let details_at = m.body.find("<details>").unwrap();
        assert!(
            details_at < task_at,
            "the task lives inside <details>: {}",
            m.body
        );
        assert!(m.body.contains(&format!("magi:run/{}", state.id)));
        assert!(m.body.contains("magi:candidate-a"));
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_falls_back_to_the_task_without_a_title_line() {
        let state = state_with_summary("\n\nadd retries\n\ndetails", "- did some things");
        let m = pr_message(&state, 'A');
        assert_eq!(m.title, "add retries");
        assert!(
            m.body.contains("## Summary\n\n- did some things"),
            "{}",
            m.body
        );

        let none = RunState::new(
            PathBuf::from("/repo"),
            "main".to_owned(),
            "abc1234".to_owned(),
            "add retries".to_owned(),
            Config::default(),
        );
        let m = pr_message(&none, 'A');
        assert_eq!(m.title, "add retries");
        assert!(!m.body.contains("## Summary"), "{}", m.body);
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_refuses_the_candidate_commit_subject() {
        for bad in [
            "TITLE: magi: candidate A (uncommitted work)",
            "TITLE: chore: stuff (uncommitted work)",
            "TITLE:   ",
        ] {
            let state = state_with_summary("add retries", bad);
            assert_eq!(pr_message(&state, 'A').title, "add retries", "{bad}");
        }
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_bounds_a_very_long_task_and_title() {
        let long = format!("fix the thing 🎉 {}", "x".repeat(5000));
        let state = state_with_summary(&long, "- nothing");
        let m = pr_message(&state, 'A');
        assert!(m.title.chars().count() <= PR_TITLE_MAX, "{}", m.title);
        assert!(!m.title.contains('\n'));

        let state = state_with_summary("task", &format!("TITLE: feat: {}", "y".repeat(5000)));
        let m = pr_message(&state, 'A');
        assert!(m.title.starts_with("feat: "));
        assert!(m.title.chars().count() <= PR_TITLE_MAX, "{}", m.title);
        assert_eq!(m.commit_message().lines().next(), Some(m.title.as_str()));
    }

    fn long_title_of(instruction: &str) -> String {
        pr_message(&state_with_summary(instruction, "- nothing"), 'A').title
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_cuts_a_long_english_line_at_its_first_sentence() {
        let first = "Make the landing path keep a readable title for long tasks";
        let line = format!(
            "{first}. {}",
            "And then keep going with more words ".repeat(20)
        );
        let t = long_title_of(&line);
        assert_eq!(t, first);
        assert!(!t.starts_with("chore: land"));
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_cuts_a_sentenceless_long_line_at_a_word() {
        let line = "word ".repeat(200);
        let t = long_title_of(&line);
        assert!(t.ends_with("word..."), "{t}");
        assert!(t.is_ascii() && t.chars().count() <= PR_TITLE_MAX, "{t}");
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_long_non_english_or_letterless_line_is_neutral() {
        for line in ["日本語のタスク ".repeat(80), "1234 ".repeat(100)] {
            assert!(long_title_of(&line).starts_with("chore: land"), "{line}");
        }
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_title_limit_is_exact() {
        let at = "a".repeat(PR_TITLE_MAX);
        assert_eq!(long_title_of(&at), at);
        let over = long_title_of(&"a".repeat(PR_TITLE_MAX + 1));
        assert!(over.ends_with("..."), "{over}");
        assert_eq!(over.chars().count(), PR_TITLE_MAX);
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_judges_the_kept_text_not_what_follows_the_cut() {
        let line = format!("{} \u{2014} tail", "alpha beta ".repeat(40));
        let t = long_title_of(&line);
        assert!(t.ends_with("..."), "{t}");
        assert!(t.is_ascii(), "{t}");
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_sentence_cut_skips_abbreviations_and_decimals() {
        let line = format!(
            "Support several shells, e.g. bash and zsh, at version 1.5 or newer when it matters {}",
            "plus more filler words ".repeat(20)
        );
        let t = long_title_of(&line);
        assert!(t.contains("e.g. bash") && t.contains("1.5 or newer"), "{t}");
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_long_title_survives_a_blank_first_line_and_the_squash_subject() {
        let line = format!("\n\n# {}", "title words ".repeat(40));
        let state = state_with_summary(&line, "- nothing");
        let m = pr_message(&state, 'A');
        assert!(m.title.starts_with("title words"), "{}", m.title);
        assert_eq!(
            land::merge_subject(&m.title, &landing_subject_source(&state)),
            m.title
        );
        // An operator's rename wins untouched.
        assert_eq!(
            land::merge_subject("feat: renamed by hand", &landing_subject_source(&state)),
            "feat: renamed by hand"
        );
    }

    #[tokio::test]
    async fn github_text_rewrite_is_bounded_and_falls_back() {
        crate::run::pin_test_home();
        for (reply, accepted) in [
            (
                "TITLE: fix: retries\nAdd retries for failed requests.",
                true,
            ),
            (
                "TITLE: fix: retries\n日本語の説明をもう一度書きます。",
                false,
            ),
            ("TITLE: fix: retries\nUse token=secret", false),
        ] {
            let dir = tempfile::tempdir().unwrap();
            let mut runner = runner_at(RunStatus::Gating);
            runner.state = state_with_summary(
                "add retries",
                "TITLE: fix: retries\n日本語の説明を書きます。",
            );
            runner.state.repo = dir.path().to_owned();
            runner.state.candidates[0].worktree = dir.path().to_owned();
            let mut author = spec("alpha");
            author.command = vec![
                "sh".into(),
                "-c".into(),
                "printf '%s' \"$REWRITE_REPLY\"".into(),
            ];
            author.env.insert("REWRITE_REPLY".into(), reply.into());
            runner.state.config.agents = vec![author];
            let winner = runner.state.candidates[0].clone();
            let message = runner.guarded_pr_message(&winner, None, true).await;
            assert!(crate::github_text::check(&message.title, &message.body).is_empty());
            assert_eq!(
                message.body.contains("Add retries for failed requests."),
                accepted
            );
            assert_eq!(
                runner.state.seats["impl-A"].turns, 1,
                "only one rewrite invocation"
            );
            assert!(runner.state.events.iter().any(|e| e.node == "github-text"));
            if !accepted {
                assert!(message.body.contains(crate::github_text::NEUTRAL_BODY));
                assert!(
                    message
                        .body
                        .contains(&format!("magi:run/{}", runner.state.id))
                );
            }
        }
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_magi_text_is_english_and_the_task_is_verbatim() {
        // What magi itself writes stays English under any configured language,
        // so a future localisation of these headings fails here. (The agents'
        // own text is also checked by the posting gate.)
        let mut state = state_with_summary(
            "add retries",
            "TITLE: fix(web): batch reads\n- reads run.json once",
        );
        state.config.graph.language = "ja".to_owned();
        let m = pr_message(&state, 'A');
        assert!(crate::github_text::check(&m.title, &m.body).is_empty());
        assert!(m.title.is_ascii() && m.body.is_ascii(), "{}", m.body);

        // The task is the operator's own text: it goes in untouched, and the
        // fallback title (no summary) may be in its language too.
        let task = "今回やってほしいこと: results projector を直す";
        let mut state = state_with_summary(task, "- no title line");
        state.config.graph.language = "ja".to_owned();
        let m = pr_message(&state, 'A');
        assert_eq!(
            m.title,
            format!("chore: land candidate A of run {}", state.id)
        );
        assert!(
            m.body.contains(&format!(
                "<summary>Original task</summary>\n\n{task}\n\n</details>"
            )),
            "{}",
            m.body
        );
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_scrubs_home_paths_and_addresses() {
        let state = state_with_summary(
            "fix it in /Users/someone/src/x",
            "TITLE: fix(x): y\n- edited /home/someone/repo/src/a.rs on 10.1.2.3",
        );
        let m = pr_message(&state, 'A');
        for leak in ["/Users/someone", "/home/someone", "10.1.2.3"] {
            assert!(!m.body.contains(leak), "{}", m.body);
        }
        assert!(m.body.contains("~/repo/src/a.rs"), "{}", m.body);
    }

    #[test]
    fn pr_message_survives_a_task_that_closes_details() {
        let state = state_with_summary("a </details> b", "TITLE: fix: x");
        let m = pr_message(&state, 'A');
        assert_eq!(m.body.matches("</details>").count(), 1, "{}", m.body);
    }

    #[test]
    fn manual_squash_subject_cannot_break_out_of_its_quotes() {
        let cmd = manual_merge_command(
            MergeStyle::Squash,
            Path::new("/repo"),
            "b",
            "fix: \"quoted\" $(x) `y`\n\nbody",
        );
        assert!(cmd.ends_with("commit -m \"fix: quoted (x) y\""), "{cmd}");
    }

    #[test]
    fn manual_merge_command_matches_the_configured_style() {
        let repo = Path::new("/repo");
        let message = "Merge magi run 0832 (candidate A)\n\nadd retries";

        let merge = manual_merge_command(MergeStyle::Merge, repo, "magi/0832/A", message);
        assert_eq!(merge, "git -C /repo merge --no-ff magi/0832/A");

        let squash = manual_merge_command(MergeStyle::Squash, repo, "magi/0832/A", message);
        assert_eq!(
            squash,
            "git -C /repo merge --squash magi/0832/A && git -C /repo commit -m \
             \"Merge magi run 0832 (candidate A)\""
        );

        let rebase = manual_merge_command(MergeStyle::Rebase, repo, "magi/0832/A", message);
        assert_eq!(rebase, "git -C /repo merge --ff-only magi/0832/A");
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_nudge_gets_a_quarter_of_the_budget() {
        // The judge and implement budgets magi ships with.
        assert_eq!(retry_budget(secs(1200), true), secs(300));
        assert_eq!(retry_budget(secs(3600), true), secs(900));
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_resent_prompt_keeps_the_whole_budget() {
        // The seat kept no context, so the retry is the original job again and
        // shortening it would only guarantee a second failure.
        assert_eq!(retry_budget(secs(1200), false), secs(1200));
        assert_eq!(retry_budget(secs(60), false), secs(60));
    }

    #[test]
    fn the_floor_never_exceeds_the_original_budget() {
        // A short configured timeout must not be *raised* by the floor: the
        // operator asked for a bound, and a retry may not outlast the attempt
        // it is retrying.
        assert_eq!(retry_budget(secs(60), true), secs(60));
        assert_eq!(retry_budget(secs(480), true), secs(120));
        assert_eq!(retry_budget(secs(0), true), secs(0));
    }

    fn evidence(exit_code: Option<i32>) -> agent::CommandEvidence {
        agent::CommandEvidence {
            id: "item1".to_owned(),
            description: "cargo test".to_owned(),
            exit_code,
            result_summary: String::new(),
            source: "codex".to_owned(),
        }
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_reply_with_no_commands_at_all_is_not_unconfirmed() {
        // No evidence is not the same fact as unconfirmed evidence: a
        // backend with no adapter, or a reply that ran no commands at all,
        // must not be misread as carrying a dangling job.
        assert!(!has_unconfirmed_command(&[]));
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_command_with_a_real_exit_code_is_confirmed_whatever_its_value() {
        // Deliberately not a check on the exit code's *value*: a fixer
        // legitimately runs something that fails mid-iteration before it
        // succeeds, and that must never by itself reopen a valid report.
        assert!(!has_unconfirmed_command(&[evidence(Some(0))]));
        assert!(!has_unconfirmed_command(&[evidence(Some(1))]));
        assert!(!has_unconfirmed_command(&[
            evidence(Some(0)),
            evidence(Some(101))
        ]));
    }

    #[test]
    fn one_command_with_no_readable_exit_code_is_enough_to_flag_the_reply() {
        assert!(has_unconfirmed_command(&[
            evidence(Some(0)),
            evidence(None)
        ]));
    }

    #[test]
    fn a_clean_usable_reply_with_the_marker_is_a_verified_claim() {
        let text = "NO CHANGE NEEDED: already fixed by b32cfc4, on main.";
        assert_eq!(
            verified_noop_claim(true, &[], text).as_deref(),
            Some("already fixed by b32cfc4, on main.")
        );
    }

    #[test]
    fn an_unusable_reply_never_earns_the_benefit_of_the_doubt() {
        // A timeout or a bad exit code reads as the ordinary loss it is,
        // whatever the reply's own prose claims.
        let text = "NO CHANGE NEEDED: already fixed by b32cfc4, on main.";
        assert!(verified_noop_claim(false, &[], text).is_none());
    }

    #[test]
    fn an_unconfirmed_command_disqualifies_the_claim_even_on_a_usable_reply() {
        let text = "NO CHANGE NEEDED: already fixed by b32cfc4, on main.";
        assert!(verified_noop_claim(true, &[evidence(None)], text).is_none());
        // A confirmed command alongside the marker is fine.
        assert!(verified_noop_claim(true, &[evidence(Some(0))], text).is_some());
    }

    #[test]
    fn an_ordinary_reply_with_no_marker_is_never_a_claim() {
        assert!(verified_noop_claim(true, &[], "- did the thing\n- tested it").is_none());
    }

    /// Sets `runner.state.candidates` to one candidate per `(empty, verified)`
    /// pair, in order, labelled A, B, C, ...
    fn set_candidates(runner: &mut Runner, shape: &[(bool, Option<&str>)]) {
        runner.state.candidates = shape
            .iter()
            .enumerate()
            .map(|(i, &(empty, verified))| Candidate {
                index: i,
                label: (b'A' + i as u8) as char,
                agent: "sonnet".to_owned(),
                branch: format!("magi/x/{}", (b'A' + i as u8) as char),
                worktree: PathBuf::from(format!("/wt/{i}")),
                summary: String::new(),
                stat: String::new(),
                files: 0,
                commits: 0,
                empty,
                failed: None,
                verified_noop: verified.map(str::to_owned),
                duration_ms: 0,
                folded: false,
            })
            .collect();
    }

    #[test]
    fn after_implement_reads_all_candidates_verified_as_a_noop_not_a_failure() {
        ask_test_home();
        let mut runner = runner_at(RunStatus::Implementing);
        set_candidates(
            &mut runner,
            &[
                (true, Some("already on main at b32cfc4")),
                (true, Some("same fix, see the existing test")),
            ],
        );

        runner
            .after_implement()
            .expect("a verified no-op is not an error");

        assert_eq!(runner.state.status, RunStatus::VerifiedNoop);
    }

    #[test]
    fn after_implement_does_not_accept_one_candidates_claim_next_to_an_ordinary_loss() {
        ask_test_home();
        let mut runner = runner_at(RunStatus::Implementing);
        // Candidate A declares a verified no-op; candidate B simply wrote
        // nothing and said nothing about why. One candidate's claim is not
        // the whole run's agreement.
        set_candidates(
            &mut runner,
            &[(true, Some("already on main at b32cfc4")), (true, None)],
        );

        let err = runner
            .after_implement()
            .expect_err("an unverified empty candidate must still fail the run");

        assert!(
            err.to_string().contains("no candidate produced a change"),
            "{err}"
        );
        assert_eq!(runner.state.status, RunStatus::Failed);
    }

    #[test]
    fn after_implement_still_fails_an_ordinary_all_empty_run() {
        ask_test_home();
        let mut runner = runner_at(RunStatus::Implementing);
        set_candidates(&mut runner, &[(true, None), (true, None)]);

        let err = runner
            .after_implement()
            .expect_err("no candidate declared anything; this is an ordinary failure");

        assert!(
            err.to_string().contains("no candidate produced a change"),
            "{err}"
        );
        assert_eq!(runner.state.status, RunStatus::Failed);
    }
}