Skip to main content

dsl_kit_parse/
example_gen.rs

1//! Example synthesis from a grammar (item Q-1).
2//!
3//! Walks a [`Grammar`]'s [`Peg`] — not the schema — and emits input
4//! strings that the grammar accepts **by construction**: every choice
5//! picks a concrete arm, every token contributes matching input text
6//! (`%int` → `1`, `%str` → `"example"`, keywords verbatim). Because
7//! synthesis reads the grammar itself, spellings supplied through
8//! `schema_gen::SyntaxOverrides` fall out automatically — no separate
9//! example registration.
10//!
11//! Two synthesis modes drive the output of [`examples_from_grammar`]:
12//!
13//! - **Minimal** (per-rule examples) — at every choice take the arm
14//!   with the cheapest finite derivation, at every repeat emit the
15//!   minimum count. Terminates by the shortest-derivation argument:
16//!   each step either emits a token or strictly reduces the remaining
17//!   derivation cost.
18//! - **Rich** (the composite program) — while a depth budget lasts,
19//!   choices take the *most expensive* finite arm and repeats emit up
20//!   to two iterations, showing nesting and list syntax; the budget
21//!   decrements per rule expansion and exhaustion falls back to
22//!   Minimal.
23//!
24//! The intended consumer is an AI writing the canonical text syntax:
25//! few-shot examples beat a formal grammar table for one-shot
26//! accuracy, and machine-derived examples cannot drift from the
27//! grammar the way hand-written documentation does.
28
29use std::cell::Cell;
30use std::collections::HashMap;
31
32use crate::peg::{Grammar, Peg};
33use crate::{BuildError, Diagnostic};
34
35/// Diagnostic codes emitted by example synthesis.
36pub mod codes {
37    /// A rule has no finite derivation (every path recurses forever),
38    /// so no example input exists.
39    pub const NO_FINITE_DERIVATION: &str = "dsl_kit::example_gen::no_finite_derivation";
40    /// A `RuleRef` names a rule the grammar does not define.
41    pub const UNKNOWN_RULE: &str = "dsl_kit::example_gen::unknown_rule";
42}
43
44/// Rich-mode depth budget used by [`examples_from_grammar`] for the
45/// composite program: rule expansions beyond this depth continue
46/// minimally.
47pub const COMPOSITE_DEPTH: u32 = 2;
48
49/// One rule's minimal example.
50#[derive(Debug, Clone)]
51pub struct RuleExample {
52    /// Rule name (for `schema_gen` grammars: the variant name).
53    pub rule: String,
54    /// Input text accepted by the grammar, entering at this rule.
55    pub text: String,
56}
57
58/// Everything [`examples_from_grammar`] synthesizes for one grammar.
59#[derive(Debug, Clone)]
60pub struct GrammarExamples {
61    /// Minimal example per non-start rule, in rule declaration order.
62    /// For `schema_gen` grammars this is exactly one example per
63    /// variant.
64    pub per_rule: Vec<RuleExample>,
65    /// One depth-capped rich expansion of the start rule, showing
66    /// nesting and repetition.
67    pub composite: String,
68}
69
70/// Synthesizes [`GrammarExamples`] for `grammar`.
71///
72/// Fails with one [`codes::NO_FINITE_DERIVATION`] diagnostic per
73/// underivable rule (collected, so the author sees the full list), or
74/// [`codes::UNKNOWN_RULE`] on a dangling reference.
75pub fn examples_from_grammar(grammar: &Grammar) -> Result<GrammarExamples, BuildError> {
76    let synth = Synth::prepare(grammar)?;
77
78    let mut underivable = Vec::new();
79    for (name, _) in &synth.rules_in_order {
80        if synth.rule_cost(name) == INFINITE {
81            underivable.push(Diagnostic::error(
82                codes::NO_FINITE_DERIVATION,
83                format!("rule `{name}` has no finite derivation — no example input exists"),
84            ));
85        }
86    }
87    if !underivable.is_empty() {
88        return Err(BuildError::new(underivable));
89    }
90
91    let mut per_rule = Vec::new();
92    for (name, body) in &synth.rules_in_order {
93        if *name == grammar.start {
94            continue;
95        }
96        // The reserved import rule (`$import`, injected by
97        // `crate::import::add_import_syntax`) is load-phase plumbing:
98        // examples exist to teach the DSL itself, so `@import "…"`
99        // never appears in them.
100        if name == crate::import::IMPORT_VARIANT {
101            continue;
102        }
103        let mut tokens = Vec::new();
104        synth.emit(body, 0, &mut tokens)?;
105        per_rule.push(RuleExample {
106            rule: name.clone(),
107            text: render(&tokens),
108        });
109    }
110
111    let start_body = synth.rule_body(&grammar.start)?;
112    let mut tokens = Vec::new();
113    synth.emit(start_body, COMPOSITE_DEPTH, &mut tokens)?;
114    let composite = render(&tokens);
115
116    Ok(GrammarExamples {
117        per_rule,
118        composite,
119    })
120}
121
122/// Sentinel cost for "no finite derivation".
123const INFINITE: u64 = u64::MAX;
124
125struct Synth<'g> {
126    /// Rule name → body, for `RuleRef` expansion.
127    by_name: HashMap<&'g str, &'g Peg>,
128    /// `(name, body)` in grammar declaration order.
129    rules_in_order: Vec<(String, &'g Peg)>,
130    /// Shortest-derivation token count per rule (fixpoint result).
131    costs: HashMap<String, u64>,
132    /// Running count of keyed entries emitted, so each one can be
133    /// given a distinct key. Interior mutability because emission
134    /// takes `&self` — the alternative, threading a counter through
135    /// every `emit` signature, would put keyed-slot bookkeeping in the
136    /// path of shapes that have nothing to do with it.
137    key_seq: Cell<u32>,
138}
139
140impl<'g> Synth<'g> {
141    fn prepare(grammar: &'g Grammar) -> Result<Self, BuildError> {
142        let mut by_name = HashMap::new();
143        let mut rules_in_order = Vec::new();
144        for r in &grammar.rules {
145            if let Peg::Rule { name, body, .. } = r {
146                by_name.insert(name.as_str(), body.as_ref());
147                rules_in_order.push((name.clone(), body.as_ref()));
148            }
149        }
150
151        // Shortest-derivation cost fixpoint: start every rule at
152        // INFINITE and relax until stable. Monotone non-increasing and
153        // bounded, so it terminates.
154        let mut costs: HashMap<String, u64> = rules_in_order
155            .iter()
156            .map(|(n, _)| (n.clone(), INFINITE))
157            .collect();
158        loop {
159            let mut changed = false;
160            for (name, body) in &rules_in_order {
161                let c = peg_cost(body, &costs);
162                if c < costs[name] {
163                    costs.insert(name.clone(), c);
164                    changed = true;
165                }
166            }
167            if !changed {
168                break;
169            }
170        }
171
172        Ok(Self {
173            by_name,
174            rules_in_order,
175            costs,
176            key_seq: Cell::new(0),
177        })
178    }
179
180    fn rule_cost(&self, name: &str) -> u64 {
181        self.costs.get(name).copied().unwrap_or(INFINITE)
182    }
183
184    fn rule_body(&self, name: &str) -> Result<&'g Peg, BuildError> {
185        self.by_name.get(name).copied().ok_or_else(|| {
186            BuildError::single(Diagnostic::error(
187                codes::UNKNOWN_RULE,
188                format!("reference to undefined rule `{name}`"),
189            ))
190        })
191    }
192
193    /// Appends the input tokens of one derivation of `peg`.
194    /// `rich_depth > 0` selects the expansive arm at choices and up to
195    /// two iterations at repeats; `0` is the minimal mode.
196    fn emit(&self, peg: &Peg, rich_depth: u32, out: &mut Vec<String>) -> Result<(), BuildError> {
197        match peg {
198            Peg::Token { pat, .. } => {
199                out.push(token_input(pat));
200                Ok(())
201            }
202            Peg::Seq { items, .. } => {
203                for item in items {
204                    self.emit(item, rich_depth, out)?;
205                }
206                Ok(())
207            }
208            Peg::Choice { alts, .. } => {
209                let arm = self.pick_arm(alts, rich_depth)?;
210                self.emit(arm, rich_depth, out)
211            }
212            Peg::Repeat { body, min, max, .. } => {
213                let count = if rich_depth > 0 {
214                    (*min).max(2.min(max.unwrap_or(2)))
215                } else {
216                    *min
217                };
218                for _ in 0..count {
219                    self.emit(body, rich_depth, out)?;
220                }
221                Ok(())
222            }
223            Peg::RuleRef { name, .. } => {
224                let body = self.rule_body(name)?;
225                self.emit(body, rich_depth.saturating_sub(1), out)
226            }
227            Peg::Rule { body, .. } | Peg::Node { body, .. } | Peg::Field { body, .. } => {
228                self.emit(body, rich_depth, out)
229            }
230            // A keyed entry emits its key then its value, in that
231            // order — the same shape a two-item `Seq` would, since the
232            // primitive adds no syntax of its own (the separator and
233            // brackets around it live in the enclosing grammar).
234            //
235            // The key goes through `emit_key` so that repeated entries
236            // get *distinct* keys. Emitting the plain token text twice
237            // would synthesize `{ "example": …, "example": … }` — text
238            // the grammar accepts but the schema rejects as a
239            // duplicate key, which is precisely the drift this module
240            // exists to prevent.
241            Peg::KeyedEntry { key, value, .. } => {
242                let n = self.key_seq.get() + 1;
243                self.key_seq.set(n);
244                self.emit_key(key, n, rich_depth, out)?;
245                self.emit(value, rich_depth, out)
246            }
247        }
248    }
249
250    /// Emits a keyed entry's key with occurrence number `n` woven in,
251    /// so sibling entries in one map get distinct keys.
252    ///
253    /// Handles the shapes a key production is made of (tokens, `Seq`,
254    /// `Choice`). Anything richer falls through to the generic
255    /// emitter: keys may then collide, but a collision surfaces as a
256    /// `DUPLICATE_KEY` conformance error on the synthesized example
257    /// rather than being papered over here.
258    fn emit_key(
259        &self,
260        peg: &Peg,
261        n: u32,
262        rich_depth: u32,
263        out: &mut Vec<String>,
264    ) -> Result<(), BuildError> {
265        match peg {
266            Peg::Token { pat, .. } => {
267                out.push(keyed_token_input(pat, n));
268                Ok(())
269            }
270            Peg::Seq { items, .. } => {
271                for item in items {
272                    self.emit_key(item, n, rich_depth, out)?;
273                }
274                Ok(())
275            }
276            Peg::Choice { alts, .. } => {
277                let arm = self.pick_arm(alts, rich_depth)?;
278                self.emit_key(arm, n, rich_depth, out)
279            }
280            other => self.emit(other, rich_depth, out),
281        }
282    }
283
284    /// Chooses a choice arm: cheapest finite derivation in minimal
285    /// mode, most expensive finite one in rich mode (ties: first).
286    ///
287    /// Arms reaching the reserved import rule are never picked —
288    /// `@import "…"` is load-phase plumbing, not the DSL the examples
289    /// teach (see `crate::import::add_import_syntax`).
290    fn pick_arm<'p>(&self, alts: &'p [Peg], rich_depth: u32) -> Result<&'p Peg, BuildError> {
291        let finite = alts
292            .iter()
293            .filter(|a| !is_import_arm(a))
294            .map(|a| (a, peg_cost(a, &self.costs)))
295            .filter(|(_, c)| *c != INFINITE);
296        let picked = if rich_depth > 0 {
297            finite.max_by_key(|(_, c)| *c)
298        } else {
299            finite.min_by_key(|(_, c)| *c)
300        };
301        picked.map(|(a, _)| a).ok_or_else(|| {
302            BuildError::single(Diagnostic::error(
303                codes::NO_FINITE_DERIVATION,
304                "choice has no finite alternative".to_string(),
305            ))
306        })
307    }
308}
309
310/// Whether a choice arm reaches the reserved `$import` rule / node
311/// (see `pick_arm`).
312fn is_import_arm(peg: &Peg) -> bool {
313    match peg {
314        Peg::RuleRef { name, .. } => name == crate::import::IMPORT_VARIANT,
315        Peg::Node { variant, .. } => variant == crate::import::IMPORT_VARIANT,
316        _ => false,
317    }
318}
319
320/// Shortest-derivation token count of `peg` under the current rule
321/// cost estimates ([`INFINITE`]-safe saturating arithmetic).
322fn peg_cost(peg: &Peg, costs: &HashMap<String, u64>) -> u64 {
323    match peg {
324        Peg::Token { .. } => 1,
325        Peg::Seq { items, .. } => items
326            .iter()
327            .try_fold(0u64, |acc, i| {
328                let c = peg_cost(i, costs);
329                if c == INFINITE {
330                    None
331                } else {
332                    Some(acc.saturating_add(c))
333                }
334            })
335            .unwrap_or(INFINITE),
336        Peg::Choice { alts, .. } => alts
337            .iter()
338            .map(|a| peg_cost(a, costs))
339            .min()
340            .unwrap_or(INFINITE),
341        Peg::Repeat { body, min, .. } => {
342            if *min == 0 {
343                0
344            } else {
345                let c = peg_cost(body, costs);
346                if c == INFINITE {
347                    INFINITE
348                } else {
349                    c.saturating_mul(u64::from(*min))
350                }
351            }
352        }
353        Peg::RuleRef { name, .. } => costs.get(name).copied().unwrap_or(INFINITE),
354        Peg::Rule { body, .. } | Peg::Node { body, .. } | Peg::Field { body, .. } => {
355            peg_cost(body, costs)
356        }
357        // Sum of both halves, `INFINITE`-poisoned like `Seq`: an entry
358        // whose value has no finite derivation has none either.
359        Peg::KeyedEntry { key, value, .. } => {
360            let (k, v) = (peg_cost(key, costs), peg_cost(value, costs));
361            if k == INFINITE || v == INFINITE {
362                INFINITE
363            } else {
364                k.saturating_add(v)
365            }
366        }
367    }
368}
369
370/// Input text for a keyed entry's key token, occurrence `n`.
371///
372/// Only the two key spellings `schema_gen` emits are disambiguated;
373/// every other pattern (a literal separator like `:`) renders as
374/// usual.
375fn keyed_token_input(pat: &str, n: u32) -> String {
376    match pat {
377        "%str" => format!("\"key{n}\""),
378        "%ident" => format!("key{n}"),
379        other => token_input(other),
380    }
381}
382
383/// Input text matching one token pattern.
384fn token_input(pat: &str) -> String {
385    if let Some(kw) = pat.strip_prefix("%kw:") {
386        return kw.to_string();
387    }
388    match pat {
389        "%int" => "1".to_string(),
390        "%str" => "\"example\"".to_string(),
391        "%ident" => "x".to_string(),
392        "%ws" => " ".to_string(),
393        literal => literal.to_string(),
394    }
395}
396
397/// Joins tokens with canonical-syntax spacing: no space before
398/// punctuation that closes or separates (`,` `)` `]` `}` `:` `(`), no
399/// space after an opener (`(` `[` `{`).
400fn render(tokens: &[String]) -> String {
401    let mut out = String::new();
402    for t in tokens {
403        let tight_before = matches!(t.as_str(), "," | ")" | "]" | "}" | ":" | "(");
404        let tight_after_prev = out.ends_with('(') || out.ends_with('[') || out.ends_with('{');
405        if !out.is_empty() && !tight_before && !tight_after_prev {
406            out.push(' ');
407        }
408        out.push_str(t);
409    }
410    out
411}
412
413#[cfg(test)]
414mod tests {
415    use super::*;
416    use crate::check_conformance;
417    use crate::schema_gen::checked_grammar_from_schema;
418    use dsl_kit_core::IdGen;
419    use dsl_kit_schema::{
420        ChildSchema, ChildValueShape, FieldSchema, Multiplicity, NodeSchema, VariantSchema,
421    };
422
423    /// Same shape matrix as the schema_gen demo: int / string / bool
424    /// fields, One / Optional / Many children, zero-argument variant.
425    fn demo_schema() -> NodeSchema {
426        NodeSchema {
427            name: "Expr".into(),
428            variants: vec![
429                VariantSchema {
430                    name: "Lit".into(),
431                    fields: vec![FieldSchema {
432                        name: "value".into(),
433                        ty: "i64".into(),
434                        optional: false,
435                    }],
436                    children: vec![],
437                },
438                VariantSchema {
439                    name: "Name".into(),
440                    fields: vec![
441                        FieldSchema {
442                            name: "text".into(),
443                            ty: "String".into(),
444                            optional: false,
445                        },
446                        FieldSchema {
447                            name: "quoted".into(),
448                            ty: "bool".into(),
449                            optional: false,
450                        },
451                    ],
452                    children: vec![],
453                },
454                VariantSchema {
455                    name: "Add".into(),
456                    fields: vec![],
457                    children: vec![
458                        ChildSchema {
459                            name: "lhs".into(),
460                            multiplicity: Multiplicity::One,
461                            value_shape: ChildValueShape::Recursive,
462                            scalar_shorthands: vec![],
463                        },
464                        ChildSchema {
465                            name: "rhs".into(),
466                            multiplicity: Multiplicity::One,
467                            value_shape: ChildValueShape::Recursive,
468                            scalar_shorthands: vec![],
469                        },
470                    ],
471                },
472                VariantSchema {
473                    name: "Neg".into(),
474                    fields: vec![],
475                    children: vec![ChildSchema {
476                        name: "body".into(),
477                        multiplicity: Multiplicity::Optional,
478                        value_shape: ChildValueShape::Recursive,
479                        scalar_shorthands: vec![],
480                    }],
481                },
482                VariantSchema {
483                    name: "List".into(),
484                    fields: vec![],
485                    children: vec![ChildSchema {
486                        name: "items".into(),
487                        multiplicity: Multiplicity::Many,
488                        value_shape: ChildValueShape::Recursive,
489                        scalar_shorthands: vec![],
490                    }],
491                },
492                VariantSchema {
493                    name: "Env".into(),
494                    fields: vec![],
495                    children: vec![ChildSchema {
496                        name: "entries".into(),
497                        multiplicity: Multiplicity::Map,
498                        value_shape: ChildValueShape::Recursive,
499                        scalar_shorthands: vec![],
500                    }],
501                },
502                VariantSchema {
503                    name: "Unit".into(),
504                    fields: vec![],
505                    children: vec![],
506                },
507            ],
508        }
509    }
510
511    fn demo_examples() -> (Grammar, GrammarExamples) {
512        let g = checked_grammar_from_schema(&demo_schema(), &IdGen::new())
513            .expect("demo schema generates");
514        let ex = examples_from_grammar(&g).expect("examples synthesize");
515        (g, ex)
516    }
517
518    #[test]
519    fn every_per_rule_example_parses_as_its_own_variant() {
520        let (g, ex) = demo_examples();
521        assert_eq!(ex.per_rule.len(), 7, "one example per variant");
522        for e in &ex.per_rule {
523            let tree = g.parse(&e.text).unwrap_or_else(|err| {
524                panic!(
525                    "example for `{}` failed to parse: {:?}\n  text: {}",
526                    e.rule, err.diagnostics, e.text
527                )
528            });
529            assert_eq!(tree.variant, e.rule, "example enters at its own variant");
530            let diags = check_conformance(&tree, &demo_schema());
531            assert!(
532                diags.is_empty(),
533                "conformance clean for {}: {diags:?}",
534                e.rule
535            );
536        }
537    }
538
539    #[test]
540    fn minimal_examples_have_the_expected_spellings() {
541        let (_, ex) = demo_examples();
542        let by_rule: HashMap<&str, &str> = ex
543            .per_rule
544            .iter()
545            .map(|e| (e.rule.as_str(), e.text.as_str()))
546            .collect();
547        assert_eq!(by_rule["Lit"], "Lit(value: 1)");
548        assert_eq!(by_rule["Name"], "Name(text: \"example\", quoted: true)");
549        assert_eq!(
550            by_rule["Add"], "Add(lhs: Unit(), rhs: Unit())",
551            "nested slots fill with the cheapest variant"
552        );
553        assert_eq!(
554            by_rule["Neg"], "Neg(body: none)",
555            "Optional minimal = absent"
556        );
557        assert_eq!(
558            by_rule["List"], "List(items: [])",
559            "Many minimal = empty list"
560        );
561        assert_eq!(
562            by_rule["Env"], "Env(entries: {})",
563            "Map minimal = empty map, braces tight like the empty list"
564        );
565        assert_eq!(by_rule["Unit"], "Unit()");
566    }
567
568    /// Rich mode expands a keyed slot to two entries; those entries
569    /// must carry *different* keys. Emitting the bare token text twice
570    /// would produce `{ "example": …, "example": … }` — accepted by the
571    /// grammar, rejected by the schema — which is exactly the
572    /// grammar/schema drift machine-derived examples exist to avoid.
573    #[test]
574    fn rich_keyed_map_example_uses_distinct_keys() {
575        let map_only = NodeSchema {
576            name: "Cfg".into(),
577            variants: vec![
578                VariantSchema {
579                    name: "Env".into(),
580                    fields: vec![],
581                    children: vec![ChildSchema {
582                        name: "entries".into(),
583                        multiplicity: Multiplicity::Map,
584                        value_shape: ChildValueShape::Recursive,
585                        scalar_shorthands: vec![],
586                    }],
587                },
588                VariantSchema {
589                    name: "Unit".into(),
590                    fields: vec![],
591                    children: vec![],
592                },
593            ],
594        };
595        let g = checked_grammar_from_schema(&map_only, &IdGen::new()).expect("generates");
596        let ex = examples_from_grammar(&g).expect("synthesizes");
597
598        let tree = g.parse(&ex.composite).unwrap_or_else(|err| {
599            panic!(
600                "composite failed to parse: {:?}\n  text: {}",
601                err.diagnostics, ex.composite
602            )
603        });
604        let entries = tree
605            .keyed_child_slot("entries")
606            .expect("rich mode fills the keyed slot");
607        assert!(
608            entries.len() >= 2,
609            "rich mode should expand the map: {}",
610            ex.composite
611        );
612        let diags = check_conformance(&tree, &map_only);
613        assert!(
614            diags.is_empty(),
615            "synthesized example must conform: {diags:?}\n  text: {}",
616            ex.composite
617        );
618    }
619
620    /// A keyed entry whose value has no finite derivation poisons the
621    /// entry's cost, so the rule it sits in is reported as underivable
622    /// instead of sending synthesis into an endless expansion.
623    #[test]
624    fn keyed_entry_inherits_an_underivable_value() {
625        let ids = IdGen::new();
626        // `s` can only be written by writing an `s` inside a keyed
627        // entry: no finite string enters the rule.
628        use crate::peg::{keyed_entry, node, rule, rule_ref, token};
629        let entry = keyed_entry(&ids, "entries", token(&ids, "%ident"), rule_ref(&ids, "s"));
630        let g = Grammar::new(vec![rule(&ids, "s", node(&ids, "N", entry))], "s");
631        let err = examples_from_grammar(&g).expect_err("no finite derivation exists");
632        assert!(
633            err.diagnostics
634                .iter()
635                .any(|d| d.code == codes::NO_FINITE_DERIVATION),
636            "expected NO_FINITE_DERIVATION; got {:?}",
637            err.diagnostics
638                .iter()
639                .map(|d| d.code.as_str())
640                .collect::<Vec<_>>()
641        );
642    }
643
644    #[test]
645    fn composite_parses_and_shows_nesting() {
646        let (g, ex) = demo_examples();
647        let tree = g.parse(&ex.composite).unwrap_or_else(|err| {
648            panic!(
649                "composite failed to parse: {:?}\n  text: {}",
650                err.diagnostics, ex.composite
651            )
652        });
653        assert!(check_conformance(&tree, &demo_schema()).is_empty());
654        // Rich mode picked an expansive variant and expanded at least
655        // one nested child — pin the property, not the exact string.
656        assert!(
657            !tree.children.is_empty(),
658            "composite has child structure: {}",
659            ex.composite
660        );
661    }
662
663    #[test]
664    fn underivable_rules_fail_loudly_with_the_full_list() {
665        // A single variant whose only child is mandatory and recursive:
666        // no finite tree exists.
667        let schema = NodeSchema {
668            name: "Loop".into(),
669            variants: vec![VariantSchema {
670                name: "Rec".into(),
671                fields: vec![],
672                children: vec![ChildSchema {
673                    name: "inner".into(),
674                    multiplicity: Multiplicity::One,
675                    value_shape: ChildValueShape::Recursive,
676                    scalar_shorthands: vec![],
677                }],
678            }],
679        };
680        let g = crate::schema_gen::grammar_from_schema(&schema, &IdGen::new())
681            .expect("generation itself succeeds");
682        let err = examples_from_grammar(&g).expect_err("no finite derivation");
683        assert!(
684            err.diagnostics
685                .iter()
686                .all(|d| d.code == codes::NO_FINITE_DERIVATION),
687            "{:?}",
688            err.diagnostics
689        );
690        // Both the start rule and the variant rule are underivable.
691        assert_eq!(err.diagnostics.len(), 2);
692    }
693}